Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2206.07716 · Physical Review Research

Implementing two-qubit gates at the quantum speed limit

J.E. Howard, Alexander Lidiak, Casey Jameson, Bora Basyildiz, Kyle Clark, Tongyu Zhao, Mustafa Bal, Junling Long, David P. Pappas, Meenakshi Singh, Zhexuan Gong

Published Dec 1, 2023• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The speed of elementary quantum gates, particularly two-qubit gates, ultimately sets the limit on the speed at which quantum circuits can operate. In this work, we experimentally demonstrate commonly used two-qubit gates at nearly the fastest possible speed allowed by the physical interaction strength between two superconducting transmon qubits. We achieve this quantum speed limit by implementing experimental gates designed using a machine-learning-inspired optimal control method. Importantly, our method only requires the single-qubit drive strength to be moderately larger than the interaction strength to achieve an arbitrary two-qubit gate close to its analytical speed limit with high fidelity. Thus the method is applicable to a variety of platforms, including those with comparable single-qubit and two-qubit gate speeds, or those with always-on interactions. We expect our method to offer significant speedups for non-native two-qubit gates that are typically achieved with a long sequence of single-qubit and native two-qubit gates.

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.5.043194

Related papers

Speed limits of two-qubit gates with qudits

Bora Basyildiz, Casey Jameson, Zhexuan Gong

The speed of elementary quantum gates ultimately sets the limit on the speed at which quantum circuits can operate. For a fixed physical interaction strength between two qubits, the speed of any two-qubit gate is limited even with arbitrarily fast single-qubit gates. In this work, we explore the possibilities of speeding up two-qubit gates beyond such a limit by expanding our computational space outside the qubit subspace, which is experimentally relevant for qubits encoded in multi-level atoms or anharmonic oscillators. We identify an optimal theoretical bound for the speed limit of a two-qubit gate achieved using two qudits with a bounded interaction strength and arbitrarily fast single-qudit gates. In addition, we find an experimentally feasible protocol using two parametrically coupled superconducting transmons that achieves this theoretical speed limit in a non-trivial way. We also consider practical scenarios with limited single-qudit drive strengths and off-resonant transitions. For such scenarios, we develop an open-source, machine learning assisted, quantum optimal control algorithm that can achieve a speedup close to the theoretical limit with near-perfect gate fidelity. This work opens up a new avenue to speed up two-qubit gates when the physical interaction strength between qubits cannot be easily increased while extra states outside the qubit subspace can be well controlled.

arXiv:2312.09218•Dec 14, 2023•1 citation

Speed limits for quantum gates in multiqubit systems

Sahel Ashhab, P. C. de Groot, Franco Nori

We use analytical and numerical calculations to obtain speed limits for various unitary quantum operations in multiqubit systems under typical experimental conditions. The operations that we consider include single-, two-, and three-qubit gates, as well as quantum-state transfer in a chain of qubits. We find in particular that simple methods for implementing two-qubit gates generally provide the fastest possible implementations of these gates. We also find that the three-qubit Toffoli gate time varies greatly depending on the type of interactions and the system's geometry, taking only slightly longer than a two-qubit controlled-not (cnot) gate for a triangle geometry. The speed limit for quantum-state transfer across a qubit chain is set by the maximum spin-wave speed in the chain.

arXiv:1202.5872•Physical Review A•May 29, 2012•89 citations

Quantum Computing with Superconducting Circuits in the Picosecond Regime

Daoquan Zhu, Tuomas Jaako, Qiongyi He +1 more

We discuss the realization of a universal set of ultrafast single- and two-qubit operations with superconducting quantum circuits and investigate the most relevant physical and technical limitations that arise when pushing for faster and faster gates. With the help of numerical optimization techniques, we establish a fundamental bound on the minimal gate time, which is determined independently of the qubit design solely by its nonlinearity. In addition, important practical restrictions arise from the finite qubit transition frequency and the limited bandwidth of the control pulses. We show that, for highly anharmonic flux qubits and commercially available control electronics, elementary single- and two-qubit operations can be implemented in about 100 ps with residual gate errors below ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}4}$. Under the same conditions, we simulate the complete execution of a compressed version of Shor's algorithm for factoring the number 15 in about 1 ns. These results demonstrate that, compared to state-of-the-art implementations with transmon qubits, a hundredfold increase in the speed of gate operations with superconducting circuits is still feasible.

arXiv:2101.05810•Physical Review Applied•Jul 9, 2021•18 citations

Efficient implementation of arbitrary two-qubit gates using unified control

Zhen Chen, Weiyang Liu, Yanjun Ma +16 more

The set of quantum logic gates that can be easily implemented is fundamental to the performance of quantum computers, as it governs the accuracy of basic quantum operations and dictates the complexity of implementing quantum algorithms. Traditional approaches to extending gate sets often require operating devices outside the ideal parameter regimes used to realize qubits, leading to increased control complexity while offering only a limited set of gates. Here we experimentally demonstrate a unified and versatile gate scheme capable of generating arbitrary two-qubit gates using only an exchange interaction and qubit driving on a superconducting quantum processor. We achieve high fidelities averaging 99.38% across a wide range of commonly used two-qubit unitaries, enabling precise multipartite entangled state preparation. Furthermore, we successfully produce a B gate, which efficiently synthesizes the entire family of two-qubit gates. Our results establish that fully exploiting the capabilities of the exchange interaction can yield a comprehensive and highly accurate gate set. With maximum expressivity, optimal gate time, demonstrated high fidelity and easy adaption to other quantum platforms, our unified control scheme offers the prospect of improved performance in quantum hardware and algorithm development. The efficiency of a quantum computer depends on which basic operations it can implement. Now a scheme that can implement any two-qubit logic gate has been demonstrated on a superconducting architecture.

Nature Physics•Aug 15, 2025•18 citations

Quantum optimal control of superconducting qubits based on machine-learning characterization

Élie Genois, Noah Stevenson, Noah Goss +2 more

Implementing fast and high-fidelity quantum operations using open-loop quantum optimal control relies on having an accurate model of the quantum dynamics. Any deviations between this model and the complete dynamics of the device, such as the presence of spurious modes or pulse distortions, can degrade the performance of optimal controls in practice. Here, we propose an experimentally simple approach to realize optimal quantum controls tailored to the device parameters and environment while specifically characterizing this quantum system. Concretely, we use physics-inspired machine learning to infer an accurate model of the dynamics from experimentally available data and then optimize our experimental controls on this trained model. We show the power and feasibility of this approach by optimizing arbitrary single-qubit operations on a superconducting transmon qubit, using detailed numerical simulations. We demonstrate that this framework produces an accurate description of the device dynamics under arbitrary controls, together with the precise pulses achieving arbitrary single-qubit gates with a high fidelity of about 99.99%.

arXiv:2410.22603•Physical Review Applied•Aug 19, 2025•3 citations

Speed limits of two-qutrit gates

Bora Basyildiz, Zhexuan Gong, Sahel Ashhab

The speed of elementary quantum gates sets a limit on the speed at which quantum circuits can be applied and, as a result, the size of the computations that can be performed on a quantum computer. This limitation stems from the fact that present-day quantum hardware systems have finite coherence times that limit the total computation time. The speeds of qubit gates in various hardware settings have been well studied over the past few decades. The recent interest in multi-level quantum systems naturally creates a need for similar investigations of the speeds of multi-level or qudit gates. In this work, we perform an empirical study of the speed limit for the three-level or qutrit CZ gate. Our analysis focuses on a theoretical model for capacitively coupled superconducting transmons but can be extended to other systems. We generate CZ gate protocols using optimal control theory techniques and observe when the fidelity crosses certain thresholds. In addition to the empirical approach, we derive an analytical speed limit for the qutrit CZ gate using traditional quantum speed limit techniques. We compare the speed limits derived using these two different approaches and discuss the gap that remains between them. We also compare the time needed to implement the qutrit CZ gate with its qubit counterpart.

arXiv:2510.07742•Oct 9, 2025•0 citations
The speed of elementary quantum gates, particularly two-qubit gates, ultimately sets the limit on the speed at which quantum circuits can operate. In this work, we experimentally demonstrate commonly used two-qubit gates at nearly the fastest possible speed allowed by the physical interaction strength between two superconducting transmon qubits. We achieve this quantum speed limit by implementing experimental gates designed using a machine-learning-inspired optimal control method. Importantly, our method only requires the single-qubit drive strength to be moderately larger than the interaction strength to achieve an arbitrary two-qubit gate close to its analytical speed limit with high fidelity. Thus the method is applicable to a variety of platforms, including those with comparable single-qubit and two-qubit gate speeds, or those with always-on interactions. We expect our method to offer significant speedups for non-native two-qubit gates that are typically achieved with a long sequence of single-qubit and native two-qubit gates.
The speed of elementary quantum gates ultimately sets the limit on the speed at which quantum circuits can operate. For a fixed physical interaction strength between two qubits, the speed of any two-qubit gate is limited even with arbitrarily fast single-qubit gates. In this work, we explore the possibilities of speeding up two-qubit gates beyond such a limit by expanding our computational space outside the qubit subspace, which is experimentally relevant for qubits encoded in multi-level atoms or anharmonic oscillators. We identify an optimal theoretical bound for the speed limit of a two-qubit gate achieved using two qudits with a bounded interaction strength and arbitrarily fast single-qudit gates. In addition, we find an experimentally feasible protocol using two parametrically coupled superconducting transmons that achieves this theoretical speed limit in a non-trivial way. We also consider practical scenarios with limited single-qudit drive strengths and off-resonant transitions. For such scenarios, we develop an open-source, machine learning assisted, quantum optimal control algorithm that can achieve a speedup close to the theoretical limit with near-perfect gate fidelity. This work opens up a new avenue to speed up two-qubit gates when the physical interaction strength between qubits cannot be easily increased while extra states outside the qubit subspace can be well controlled.
We use analytical and numerical calculations to obtain speed limits for various unitary quantum operations in multiqubit systems under typical experimental conditions. The operations that we consider include single-, two-, and three-qubit gates, as well as quantum-state transfer in a chain of qubits. We find in particular that simple methods for implementing two-qubit gates generally provide the fastest possible implementations of these gates. We also find that the three-qubit Toffoli gate time varies greatly depending on the type of interactions and the system's geometry, taking only slightly longer than a two-qubit controlled-not (cnot) gate for a triangle geometry. The speed limit for quantum-state transfer across a qubit chain is set by the maximum spin-wave speed in the chain.
We discuss the realization of a universal set of ultrafast single- and two-qubit operations with superconducting quantum circuits and investigate the most relevant physical and technical limitations that arise when pushing for faster and faster gates. With the help of numerical optimization techniques, we establish a fundamental bound on the minimal gate time, which is determined independently of the qubit design solely by its nonlinearity. In addition, important practical restrictions arise from the finite qubit transition frequency and the limited bandwidth of the control pulses. We show that, for highly anharmonic flux qubits and commercially available control electronics, elementary single- and two-qubit operations can be implemented in about 100 ps with residual gate errors below ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}4}$. Under the same conditions, we simulate the complete execution of a compressed version of Shor's algorithm for factoring the number 15 in about 1 ns. These results demonstrate that, compared to state-of-the-art implementations with transmon qubits, a hundredfold increase in the speed of gate operations with superconducting circuits is still feasible.
The set of quantum logic gates that can be easily implemented is fundamental to the performance of quantum computers, as it governs the accuracy of basic quantum operations and dictates the complexity of implementing quantum algorithms. Traditional approaches to extending gate sets often require operating devices outside the ideal parameter regimes used to realize qubits, leading to increased control complexity while offering only a limited set of gates. Here we experimentally demonstrate a unified and versatile gate scheme capable of generating arbitrary two-qubit gates using only an exchange interaction and qubit driving on a superconducting quantum processor. We achieve high fidelities averaging 99.38% across a wide range of commonly used two-qubit unitaries, enabling precise multipartite entangled state preparation. Furthermore, we successfully produce a B gate, which efficiently synthesizes the entire family of two-qubit gates. Our results establish that fully exploiting the capabilities of the exchange interaction can yield a comprehensive and highly accurate gate set. With maximum expressivity, optimal gate time, demonstrated high fidelity and easy adaption to other quantum platforms, our unified control scheme offers the prospect of improved performance in quantum hardware and algorithm development. The efficiency of a quantum computer depends on which basic operations it can implement. Now a scheme that can implement any two-qubit logic gate has been demonstrated on a superconducting architecture.
Implementing fast and high-fidelity quantum operations using open-loop quantum optimal control relies on having an accurate model of the quantum dynamics. Any deviations between this model and the complete dynamics of the device, such as the presence of spurious modes or pulse distortions, can degrade the performance of optimal controls in practice. Here, we propose an experimentally simple approach to realize optimal quantum controls tailored to the device parameters and environment while specifically characterizing this quantum system. Concretely, we use physics-inspired machine learning to infer an accurate model of the dynamics from experimentally available data and then optimize our experimental controls on this trained model. We show the power and feasibility of this approach by optimizing arbitrary single-qubit operations on a superconducting transmon qubit, using detailed numerical simulations. We demonstrate that this framework produces an accurate description of the device dynamics under arbitrary controls, together with the precise pulses achieving arbitrary single-qubit gates with a high fidelity of about 99.99%.
The speed of elementary quantum gates sets a limit on the speed at which quantum circuits can be applied and, as a result, the size of the computations that can be performed on a quantum computer. This limitation stems from the fact that present-day quantum hardware systems have finite coherence times that limit the total computation time. The speeds of qubit gates in various hardware settings have been well studied over the past few decades. The recent interest in multi-level quantum systems naturally creates a need for similar investigations of the speeds of multi-level or qudit gates. In this work, we perform an empirical study of the speed limit for the three-level or qutrit CZ gate. Our analysis focuses on a theoretical model for capacitively coupled superconducting transmons but can be extended to other systems. We generate CZ gate protocols using optimal control theory techniques and observe when the fidelity crosses certain thresholds. In addition to the empirical approach, we derive an analytical speed limit for the qutrit CZ gate using traditional quantum speed limit techniques. We compare the speed limits derived using these two different approaches and discuss the gap that remains between them. We also compare the time needed to implement the qutrit CZ gate with its qubit counterpart.