Natural orbitals, defined in electronic structure and quantum chemistry as the molecular orbitals diagonalizing the one-particle reduced density matrix of the ground state, have been conjectured for decades to be the perfect reference orbitals to describe electron correlation. In the present work we applied the Wave function-Adapted Hamiltonian Through Orbital Rotation (WAHTOR) method to study correlated empirical ansätze for quantum computing. In all representative molecules considered, we show that the converged orbitals are coinciding with natural orbitals. Interestingly, the resulting quantum mutual information matrix built on such orbitals is also maximally sparse, providing a clear picture that such orbital choice is indeed able to provide the optimal basis to describe electron correlation. The correlation is therefore encoded in a smaller number of qubit pairs contributing to the quantum mutual information matrix.
Natural orbitals, defined in electronic structure and quantum chemistry as the molecular orbitals diagonalizing the one-particle reduced density matrix of the ground state, have been conjectured for decades to be the perfect reference orbitals to describe electron correlation. In the present work we applied the Wave function-Adapted Hamiltonian Through Orbital Rotation (WAHTOR) method to study correlated empirical ansätze for quantum computing. In all representative molecules considered, we show that the converged orbitals are coinciding with natural orbitals. Interestingly, the resulting quantum mutual information matrix built on such orbitals is also maximally sparse, providing a clear picture that such orbital choice is indeed able to provide the optimal basis to describe electron correlation. The correlation is therefore encoded in a smaller number of qubit pairs contributing to the quantum mutual information matrix.
The use of the mutual information (MI) as a measure of the entanglement in quantum systems has gained a consensus in recent years, even if there is an ongoing effort to distinguish the classical and quantum contributions contained therein. This quantity has been first introduced in condensed matter physics, in particular, in studies based on the density matrix renormalization group method. This method has been successfully adapted to quantum chemistry problems, opening the way to compute MI also in molecular systems. A key aspect of this quantity is its dependence on the one-electron (orbital) basis set, even for wave functions that are invariant under unitary transformation of the orbitals. In this work, we investigate the role of the orbital basis set (delocalized or localized, following different strategies) for wave functions expressed as linear combinations of Slater determinants and we give the analytic expression for the MI for a few special cases. This study aims to improve the knowledge of the relationship between the characteristics of the chemical bond (considering a few paradigmatic molecules, H 2, F 2, N 2, and short linear polyenes) and the properties of interest in the field of quantum information theory.
Hardware-efficient empirical variational ansätze for Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) simulations of quantum chemistry often lack a direct connection to classical quantum chemistry methods. In this work, we propose a method to bridge this gap by introducing a novel approach to constructing a starting point for variational quantum circuits, leveraging quantum mutual information from classical quantum chemistry states to design simple yet effective heuristic ansätze with a topology reflecting the molecular system’s correlations. As a first step, we make use of quantum chemistry calculations, such as Mo̷ller–Plesset (MP2) perturbation theory, to initially provide approximate Natural Orbitals, which have been shown to be the best candidate one-electron basis for developing compact empirical wave functions. 1 Second, we evaluate the quantum mutual information matrix, which provides insights about the main correlations between qubits of the quantum circuit, and enables a direct design of entangling blocks for the circuit. The resulting ansatz is then used with a VQE to obtain a short-depth variational ground state of the electronic Hamiltonian. To validate our approach, we perform a comprehensive statistical analysis through simulations of various molecular systems ( H 2, LiH, H 2 O ) and apply it to the more complex NH 3 molecule. The reported results demonstrate that the proposed methodology gives rise to highly effective ansätze, outperforming the standard empirical ladder-entangler ansatz. Overall, our approach can be used as an effective state preparation, providing a promising route for designing efficient variational quantum circuits for large molecular systems.
Quantum chemistry provides a target for quantum simulation of considerable scientific interest and industrial importance. The majority of algorithms to date have been based on a second-quantized representation of the electronic structure Hamiltonian - necessitating qubit requirements that scale linearly with the number of orbitals. The scaling of the number of gates for such methods, while polynomial, presents some serious experimental challenges. However, because the number of electrons is a good quantum number for the electronic structure problem it is unnecessary to store the full Fock space of the orbitals. Representation of the wave function in a basis of Slater determinants for fixed electron number suffices. However, to date techniques for the quantum simulation of the Hamiltonian represented in this basis - the CI-matrix - have been lacking. We show how to apply techniques developed for the simulation of sparse Hamiltonians to the CI-matrix. We prove a number of results exploiting the structure of the CI-matrix, arising from the Slater rules which define it, to improve the application of sparse Hamiltonian simulation techniques in this case. We show that it is possible to use the minimal number of qubits to represent the wavefunction, and that these methods can offer improved scaling in the number of gates required in the limit of fixed electron number and increasing basis set size relevant for high-accuracy calculations. We hope these results open the door to further investigation of sparse Hamiltonian simulation techniques in the context of the quantum simulation of quantum chemistry.
It is the ultimate goal of this work to foster synergy between quantum chemistry and the flourishing field of quantum information theory. For this, we first translate quantum information concepts, such as entanglement and correlation, into the context of quantum chemical systems. In particular, we establish two conceptually distinct perspectives on 'electron correlation', leading to a notion of orbital and particle correlation. We then demonstrate that particle correlation equals total orbital correlation minimized over all orbital bases. Accordingly, particle correlation resembles the minimal, thus intrinsic, complexity of many-electron wave functions, while orbital correlation quantifies their complexity relative to a basis. We illustrate these concepts of intrinsic and extrinsic correlation complexity in molecular systems, which also manifests the crucial link between the two correlation pictures. Our results provide theoretical justification for the long-favored natural orbitals for simplifying electronic structures, and open new pathways for developing more efficient approaches towards the electron correlation problem.
The use of the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) for quantum chemistry is one of the most promising applications for noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. A major limitation is represented by the need to build compact and shallow circuit ansatzes having the variational flexibility to catch the complexity of the electronic structure problem. To alleviate this drawback, we introduce a modified VQE scheme in which the form of the molecular Hamiltonian is adapted to the circuit ansatz through an optimization procedure. Exploiting the invariance of the Hamiltonian by molecular orbital rotations, we can optimize it using gradients that can be calculated without significant computational overload. The proposed method, named Wavefunction Adapted Hamiltonian Through Orbital Rotation (WAHTOR), has been applied to small molecules in numerical state vector simulations. The results demonstrate that, at variance with standard VQE, the method is less dependent on circuit topology and less prone to be trapped into high-energy local minima. It is able to recover a significant amount of electron correlation even with only empirical ansatzes with shallow circuit depth. Noisy calculations demonstrate the robustness and feasibility of the proposed methodology and indicate the hardware requirements to effectively apply the procedure using forthcoming NISQ devices.
Wave functions constructed from electron-pair states can accurately model strong electron correlation effects and are promising approaches especially for larger many-body systems. In this article, we analyze the nature and the type of electron correlation effects that can be captured by wave functions restricted to electron-pair states. We focus on the pair-coupled-cluster doubles (pCCD) ansatz also called the antisymmetric product of the 1-reference orbital geminal (AP1roG) method, combined with an orbital optimization protocol presented in Boguslawski et al. [Phys. Rev. B 89, 201106(R) (2014)], whose performance is assessed against electronic structures obtained form density-matrix renormalization-group reference data. Our numerical analysis covers model systems for strong correlation: the one-dimensional Hubbard model with a periodic boundary condition as well as metallic and molecular hydrogen rings. Specifically, the accuracy of pCCD/AP1roG is benchmarked using the single-orbital entropy, the orbital-pair mutual information, as well as the eigenvalue spectrum of the one-orbital and two-orbital reduced density matrices. Our study indicates that contributions from singly occupied states become important in the strong correlation regime which highlights the limitations of the pCCD/AP1roG method. Furthermore, we examine the effect of orbital rotations within the pCCD/AP1roG model on correlations between orbital pairs.