Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2306.17235 · Physical Review Research

Modeling the performance of early fault-tolerant quantum algorithms

Qiyao Liang, Yiqing Zhou, Archismita Dalal, Peter D. Johnson

Published May 2, 2024• 13 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Progress in fault-tolerant quantum computation (FTQC) has driven the pursuit of practical applications with (EFTQC). These devices, limited in their qubit counts and fault-tolerance capabilities, require algorithms that can accommodate some degrees of error, which are known as EFTQC algorithms. To predict the onset of early quantum advantage, a comprehensive methodology is needed to develop and analyze EFTQC algorithms, drawing insights from both the methodologies of noisy intermediate-scale quantum and traditional FTQC. To address this need, we propose such a methodology for modeling algorithm performance on EFTQC devices under varying degrees of error. As a case study, we apply our methodology to analyze the performance of randomized Fourier estimation (RFE) [Kshirsagar, Katabarwa, and Johnson, ], an EFTQC algorithm for phase estimation. We investigate the runtime performance and the fault-tolerant overhead of RFE in comparison to the traditional quantum phase estimation algorithm. Our analysis reveals that RFE achieves significant savings in physical qubit counts while having a much higher runtime upper bound. We anticipate even greater physical qubit savings when considering more realistic assumptions about the performance of EFTQC devices. By providing insights into the performance trade-offs and resource requirements of EFTQC algorithms, our work contributes to the development of practical and efficient quantum computing solutions on the path to quantum advantage. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.6.023118

Related papers

Early Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computing

Amara Katabarwa, Katerina Gratsea, Athena Caesura +1 more

In recent years, research in quantum computing has largely focused on two approaches: near-term intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computing and future fault-tolerant quantum computing (FTQC). A growing body of research into early fault-tolerant quantum computing (EFTQC) is exploring how to utilize quantum computers during the transition between these two eras. However, without agreed-upon characterizations of this transition, it is unclear how best to utilize EFTQC architectures. We argue for the perspective that this transition period will be characterized by a law of diminishing returns in quantum error correction (QEC), where the ability of the architecture to maintain quality operations at scale determines the point of diminishing returns. Two challenges emerge from this picture: how to model this phenomenon of diminishing return of QEC as the performance of devices is continually improving and how to design algorithms to make the most use of these devices. To address these challenges, we present models for the performance of EFTQC architectures, capturing the diminishing returns of QEC. We then use these models to elucidate the regimes in which algorithms suited to such architectures are advantageous. As a concrete example, we show that for the canonical task of phase estimation, in a regime of moderate scalability and using just over one million physical qubits, the “reach” of the quantum computer can be extended (compared to the standard approach) from 90-qubit instances to over 130-qubit instances using a simple early fault-tolerant quantum algorithm, which reduces the number of operations per circuit by a factor of 100 and increases the number of circuit repetitions by a factor of 10 000. This clarifies the role that such algorithms might play in the era of limited-scalability quantum computing. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2311.14814•PRX Quantum•Jun 17, 2024•103 citations

Robust Quantum Algorithms for Early Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computing

Rutuja Kshirsagar

Current quantum computing research is divided into two eras: near-term intermediate scaling quantum (NISQ) and fault-tolerant quantum computing (FTQC). There is a significant gap in these both in terms of hardware and algorithms. An important question is “how to transition from NISQ to FTQC”? Some research looks at an intermediate third era of quantum computing, sometimes referred to as “early” fault-tolerant quantum computing (EFTQC). The idea is to establish a trade-off between hardware and algorithmic parameters such that we have limited size circuits, albeit large enough to allow some amount of error-correction at the cost of more number of samples and increased run-time. This also requires adjustment to algorithms for various tasks. One way to do this is to allow the algorithm to tolerate some level of noise in the input. These algorithms are called “robust” quantum algorithms. In this chapter, we will understand what EFTQC means and how we can distinguish between the three eras of quantum computing. Furthermore, we will look at the ideas behind algorithms suitable for EFTQC devices. Lastly, we will look at two examples of robust quantum algorithms for the task of quantum phase estimation.

IntechOpen eBooks•Apr 9, 2024•1 citation

Practical Quantum Advantage on Partially Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computer

Riki Toshio, Yutaro Akahoshi, Jun Fujisaki +3 more

Achieving quantum speedups in practical tasks remains challenging for current noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. These devices always encounter significant obstacles such as inevitable physical errors and the limited scalability of current near-term algorithms. Meanwhile, assuming a typical architecture for fault-tolerant quantum computing (FTQC), realistic applications inevitably require a vast number of qubits, typically exceeding 10 6 , which seems far beyond near-term realization. In this work, to bridge the gap between the NISQ and FTQC eras, we propose an alternative approach to achieve practical quantum advantages on early-FTQC devices. Our framework is based on partially fault-tolerant logical operations to minimize spatial overhead and avoids the costly distillation techniques typically required for executing non-Clifford gates. To this end, we develop a space-time efficient state preparation protocol to generate an ancillary non-Clifford state consumed for implementing an analog rotation gate with an arbitrary small angle θ and a remarkably low worst-case error rate below O ( | θ | p ph ) , where p ph is the physical error rate. Furthermore, we propose several error suppression schemes tailored to our preparation protocol, which are essential to minimize the overhead for mitigating errors. Based on this framework, we present several promising applications that leverage the potential of our framework, including the Trotter simulation and quantum phase estimation (QPE). Notably, we demonstrate that our framework allows us to perform the QPE for an ( 8 × 8 ) -site Hubbard model with fewer than 6.8 × 10 4 qubits and an execution time of 10.6 days (or 14 min with full parallelization) under p ph = 10 − 4 , which is significantly faster than recent classical estimation with tensor network techniques (density matrix renormalization group and projected entangled pair states).

arXiv:2408.14848•Physical Review X•May 16, 2025•21 citations

Assessing Finite Scalability in Early Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computing for Homogeneous Catalysts

Yanbing Zhou, Athena Caesura, Corneliu Buda +3 more

As quantum hardware advances toward fault-tolerant operation, an intermediate stage known as early fault-tolerant quantum computing (EFTQC) is emerging, where partial error correction enables meaningful computation. In this regime, the ability of quantum processors to scale in size and depth has become a crucial factor shaping their achievable performance. This study investigates how finite scalability influences resource requirements for simulating open-shell catalytic systems using Quantum Phase Estimation (QPE). The analysis compares hardware archetypes distinguished by fidelity or operation speed under two representative scalability models. Finite scalability increases qubit and runtime demands yet leaves overall scaling behavior intact, with high-fidelity architectures requiring lower minimum scalability to solve equally sized problems. These effects are largely independent of the chosen scalability model. Extending this framework, we examine runtime competitiveness across hardware and code configurations, incorporating surface-code and quantum Low-Density Parity-Check (LDPC)-based fault tolerance under finite scalability. The results identify operating regimes where high-fidelity architectures remain competitive despite slower gate speeds and show that LDPC codes further expand this regime by reducing space-time overhead. Together, these findings highlight the central role of scalability in quantifying performance and guiding the design of next-generation quantum hardware. Continued progress in scalable architectures will be essential for extending quantum computing to increasingly complex scientific and industrial applications.

quant-pharXiv:2511.10388•Nov 14, 2025•0 citations

Error Mitigation and Circuit Division for Early Fault-Tolerant Quantum Phase Estimation

Alicja Dutkiewicz, Stefano Polla, Maximilian Scheurer +3 more

As fully fault-tolerant quantum computers capable of solving useful problems remain a distant goal, we anticipate an era of during which limited error correction is available. We propose a framework for designing early fault-tolerant algorithms by trading between error-correction overhead and residual logical noise, and apply it to quantum phase estimation (QPE). We develop a quantum-Fourier-transform- (QFT) based QPE technique that is robust to global depolarizing noise and outperforms the previous state of the art at low and moderate noise rates. We further introduce the explicitly unbiased maximum-likelihood estimator (EUMLE), a data-processing technique that mitigates errors in QFT-based QPE schemes. EUMLE provides consistent asymptotically normal error-mitigated estimates, addressing the open problem of extending error mitigation beyond expectation-value estimation. Applying this scheme to the ground-state problem of the two-dimensional Hubbard model and various molecular Hamiltonians, we find that we can roughly halve the number of physical qubits with a ∼ 10 times wall-clock time overhead, but that further reduction causes a steep run-time increase. This work provides an end-to-end analysis of early fault-tolerance cost reductions and space-time trade-offs, and identifies which areas can be improved in the future.

arXiv:2410.05369•PRX Quantum•Sep 11, 2025•5 citations

Enabling Chemically Accurate Quantum Phase Estimation in the Early Fault-Tolerant Regime

Shota Kanasugi, Riki Toshio, Kazunori Maruyama +1 more

Quantum simulation of molecular electronic structure is one of the most promising applications of quantum computing. However, achieving chemically accurate predictions for strongly correlated systems requires quantum phase estimation (QPE) on fault-tolerant quantum computing (FTQC) devices. Existing resource estimates for typical FTQC architectures suggest that such calculations demand millions of physical qubits, thereby placing them beyond the reach of near-term devices. Here, we investigate the feasibility of performing QPE for chemically relevant molecular systems in an early-FTQC regime, characterized by partial fault tolerance, constrained qubit budgets, and limited circuit depth. Our framework is based on single-ancilla, Trotter-based QPE implementations combined with partially randomized time evolution. Within this framework, we develop a novel Hamiltonian optimization strategy, termed unitary weight concentration, that reduces algorithmic cost by reshaping linear-combination-of-unitaries representations. Applying this framework to active-space models of iron-sulfur clusters, cytochrome P450 active sites, and CO$_2$-utilization catalysts, we perform end-to-end resource estimation using the latest version of the space-time efficient analog rotation (STAR) architecture. Our results indicate that ground-state energy estimation for active spaces of approximately 20 to 50 spatial orbitals, well beyond the reach of classical full configuration interaction, is achievable using $\sim 10^5$ physical qubits, with runtimes on the order of days to weeks. These findings demonstrate that while full-fledged fault-tolerant quantum computers will be required for even larger molecular simulations, chemically meaningful quantum chemistry problems are already within reach in an experimentally relevant, early-FTQC regime.

quant-pharXiv:2603.22778•PRX Quantum•Mar 25, 2026•0 citations
Progress in fault-tolerant quantum computation (FTQC) has driven the pursuit of practical applications with (EFTQC). These devices, limited in their qubit counts and fault-tolerance capabilities, require algorithms that can accommodate some degrees of error, which are known as EFTQC algorithms. To predict the onset of early quantum advantage, a comprehensive methodology is needed to develop and analyze EFTQC algorithms, drawing insights from both the methodologies of noisy intermediate-scale quantum and traditional FTQC. To address this need, we propose such a methodology for modeling algorithm performance on EFTQC devices under varying degrees of error. As a case study, we apply our methodology to analyze the performance of randomized Fourier estimation (RFE) [Kshirsagar, Katabarwa, and Johnson, ], an EFTQC algorithm for phase estimation. We investigate the runtime performance and the fault-tolerant overhead of RFE in comparison to the traditional quantum phase estimation algorithm. Our analysis reveals that RFE achieves significant savings in physical qubit counts while having a much higher runtime upper bound. We anticipate even greater physical qubit savings when considering more realistic assumptions about the performance of EFTQC devices. By providing insights into the performance trade-offs and resource requirements of EFTQC algorithms, our work contributes to the development of practical and efficient quantum computing solutions on the path to quantum advantage. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
In recent years, research in quantum computing has largely focused on two approaches: near-term intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computing and future fault-tolerant quantum computing (FTQC). A growing body of research into early fault-tolerant quantum computing (EFTQC) is exploring how to utilize quantum computers during the transition between these two eras. However, without agreed-upon characterizations of this transition, it is unclear how best to utilize EFTQC architectures. We argue for the perspective that this transition period will be characterized by a law of diminishing returns in quantum error correction (QEC), where the ability of the architecture to maintain quality operations at scale determines the point of diminishing returns. Two challenges emerge from this picture: how to model this phenomenon of diminishing return of QEC as the performance of devices is continually improving and how to design algorithms to make the most use of these devices. To address these challenges, we present models for the performance of EFTQC architectures, capturing the diminishing returns of QEC. We then use these models to elucidate the regimes in which algorithms suited to such architectures are advantageous. As a concrete example, we show that for the canonical task of phase estimation, in a regime of moderate scalability and using just over one million physical qubits, the “reach” of the quantum computer can be extended (compared to the standard approach) from 90-qubit instances to over 130-qubit instances using a simple early fault-tolerant quantum algorithm, which reduces the number of operations per circuit by a factor of 100 and increases the number of circuit repetitions by a factor of 10 000. This clarifies the role that such algorithms might play in the era of limited-scalability quantum computing. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Current quantum computing research is divided into two eras: near-term intermediate scaling quantum (NISQ) and fault-tolerant quantum computing (FTQC). There is a significant gap in these both in terms of hardware and algorithms. An important question is “how to transition from NISQ to FTQC”? Some research looks at an intermediate third era of quantum computing, sometimes referred to as “early” fault-tolerant quantum computing (EFTQC). The idea is to establish a trade-off between hardware and algorithmic parameters such that we have limited size circuits, albeit large enough to allow some amount of error-correction at the cost of more number of samples and increased run-time. This also requires adjustment to algorithms for various tasks. One way to do this is to allow the algorithm to tolerate some level of noise in the input. These algorithms are called “robust” quantum algorithms. In this chapter, we will understand what EFTQC means and how we can distinguish between the three eras of quantum computing. Furthermore, we will look at the ideas behind algorithms suitable for EFTQC devices. Lastly, we will look at two examples of robust quantum algorithms for the task of quantum phase estimation.
Achieving quantum speedups in practical tasks remains challenging for current noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. These devices always encounter significant obstacles such as inevitable physical errors and the limited scalability of current near-term algorithms. Meanwhile, assuming a typical architecture for fault-tolerant quantum computing (FTQC), realistic applications inevitably require a vast number of qubits, typically exceeding 10 6 , which seems far beyond near-term realization. In this work, to bridge the gap between the NISQ and FTQC eras, we propose an alternative approach to achieve practical quantum advantages on early-FTQC devices. Our framework is based on partially fault-tolerant logical operations to minimize spatial overhead and avoids the costly distillation techniques typically required for executing non-Clifford gates. To this end, we develop a space-time efficient state preparation protocol to generate an ancillary non-Clifford state consumed for implementing an analog rotation gate with an arbitrary small angle θ and a remarkably low worst-case error rate below O ( | θ | p ph ) , where p ph is the physical error rate. Furthermore, we propose several error suppression schemes tailored to our preparation protocol, which are essential to minimize the overhead for mitigating errors. Based on this framework, we present several promising applications that leverage the potential of our framework, including the Trotter simulation and quantum phase estimation (QPE). Notably, we demonstrate that our framework allows us to perform the QPE for an ( 8 × 8 ) -site Hubbard model with fewer than 6.8 × 10 4 qubits and an execution time of 10.6 days (or 14 min with full parallelization) under p ph = 10 − 4 , which is significantly faster than recent classical estimation with tensor network techniques (density matrix renormalization group and projected entangled pair states).
As quantum hardware advances toward fault-tolerant operation, an intermediate stage known as early fault-tolerant quantum computing (EFTQC) is emerging, where partial error correction enables meaningful computation. In this regime, the ability of quantum processors to scale in size and depth has become a crucial factor shaping their achievable performance. This study investigates how finite scalability influences resource requirements for simulating open-shell catalytic systems using Quantum Phase Estimation (QPE). The analysis compares hardware archetypes distinguished by fidelity or operation speed under two representative scalability models. Finite scalability increases qubit and runtime demands yet leaves overall scaling behavior intact, with high-fidelity architectures requiring lower minimum scalability to solve equally sized problems. These effects are largely independent of the chosen scalability model. Extending this framework, we examine runtime competitiveness across hardware and code configurations, incorporating surface-code and quantum Low-Density Parity-Check (LDPC)-based fault tolerance under finite scalability. The results identify operating regimes where high-fidelity architectures remain competitive despite slower gate speeds and show that LDPC codes further expand this regime by reducing space-time overhead. Together, these findings highlight the central role of scalability in quantifying performance and guiding the design of next-generation quantum hardware. Continued progress in scalable architectures will be essential for extending quantum computing to increasingly complex scientific and industrial applications.
As fully fault-tolerant quantum computers capable of solving useful problems remain a distant goal, we anticipate an era of during which limited error correction is available. We propose a framework for designing early fault-tolerant algorithms by trading between error-correction overhead and residual logical noise, and apply it to quantum phase estimation (QPE). We develop a quantum-Fourier-transform- (QFT) based QPE technique that is robust to global depolarizing noise and outperforms the previous state of the art at low and moderate noise rates. We further introduce the explicitly unbiased maximum-likelihood estimator (EUMLE), a data-processing technique that mitigates errors in QFT-based QPE schemes. EUMLE provides consistent asymptotically normal error-mitigated estimates, addressing the open problem of extending error mitigation beyond expectation-value estimation. Applying this scheme to the ground-state problem of the two-dimensional Hubbard model and various molecular Hamiltonians, we find that we can roughly halve the number of physical qubits with a ∼ 10 times wall-clock time overhead, but that further reduction causes a steep run-time increase. This work provides an end-to-end analysis of early fault-tolerance cost reductions and space-time trade-offs, and identifies which areas can be improved in the future.
Quantum simulation of molecular electronic structure is one of the most promising applications of quantum computing. However, achieving chemically accurate predictions for strongly correlated systems requires quantum phase estimation (QPE) on fault-tolerant quantum computing (FTQC) devices. Existing resource estimates for typical FTQC architectures suggest that such calculations demand millions of physical qubits, thereby placing them beyond the reach of near-term devices. Here, we investigate the feasibility of performing QPE for chemically relevant molecular systems in an early-FTQC regime, characterized by partial fault tolerance, constrained qubit budgets, and limited circuit depth. Our framework is based on single-ancilla, Trotter-based QPE implementations combined with partially randomized time evolution. Within this framework, we develop a novel Hamiltonian optimization strategy, termed unitary weight concentration, that reduces algorithmic cost by reshaping linear-combination-of-unitaries representations. Applying this framework to active-space models of iron-sulfur clusters, cytochrome P450 active sites, and CO2_22​-utilization catalysts, we perform end-to-end resource estimation using the latest version of the space-time efficient analog rotation (STAR) architecture. Our results indicate that ground-state energy estimation for active spaces of approximately 20 to 50 spatial orbitals, well beyond the reach of classical full configuration interaction, is achievable using ∼105\sim 10^5∼105 physical qubits, with runtimes on the order of days to weeks. These findings demonstrate that while full-fledged fault-tolerant quantum computers will be required for even larger molecular simulations, chemically meaningful quantum chemistry problems are already within reach in an experimentally relevant, early-FTQC regime.