Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2305.11822 · Discover Quantum Science

Explicit attacks on differential phase shift quantum key distribution

Valliamai Ramanathan, Anil Prabhakar, Prabha Mandayam

Published Aug 24, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In the well-established framework of quantum key distribution (QKD), differential phase shift (DPS) protocols have known information-theoretic security bounds defining tolerable error rates under optimal adversaries. In this work, we revisit the security of 3- and $$n$$ -pulse DPS QKD by explicitly analyzing two specific, physically implementable individual attacks: minimum error discrimination (MED) and quantum cloning. Using semidefinite programming, we characterize these attacks in detail and quantify their induced quantum bit error rates (QBER) and resulting secure key rates under realistic system assumptions. The critical QBER thresholds for these attacks are approximately 20%, significantly higher than the theoretical lower bounds of 6% for individual and 4% for coherent attacks, indicating these are suboptimal adversarial strategies. This study primarily serves as a practical exercise to benchmark known attacks, providing explicit measures that aid experimental validation, protocol calibration, and risk assessment within current technological capabilities. Additionally, we explore finite-size effects and the effectiveness of phase randomization in weak coherent source-based protocols as protection against unambiguous state discrimination attacks.

DOI
10.1007/s44464-026-00036-6

Related papers

Upper bounds on the performance of differential-phase-shift quantum key distribution

Hipólito Gómez-Sousa, Marcos Curty

In this paper, we investigate limitations imposed by sequential attacks on the performance of a differential-phase-shift (DPS) quantum key distribution (QKD) protocol with weak coherent pulses. Specifically, we analyze a sequential attack based on optimal unambiguous discrimination of the relative phases between consecutive signal states emitted by the source. We show that this attack can provide tighter upper bounds for the security of a DPS QKD scheme than those derived from sequential attacks where the eavesdropper aims to identify the state of each signal emitted by the source unambiguously.

arXiv:0806.0858•Quantum Information and Computation•Jan 1, 2009•11 citations

An efficient modeling and simulation of differential phase shift-quantum key distribution (DPS-QKD) system using optisystem

Mu'azu Dauda

Differential phase-shift (DPS) quantum key distribution (QKD) is a unique QKD protocol that is different from traditional ones, featuring simplicity and practicality. In this work, we simulated the DPS-QKD experiment conducted by (Liu et al., 2013), using OptiSystem 7. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first simulation work on DPS-QKD using a single photon source.We used a random number generator to get the phase modulation pattern of N=5, 7,9,11 and 13, while for the 3 and 15 pulse cases, the pattern adopted in the experiment was used. When the number of pulse (N) was 3, a quantum bit error rate (QBER) of 3.0%, which is lower than the minimum QBER of 4.12% required for unconditional security, was obtained. The key creation efficiency increases with the increase in the number of pulse up to 15, as it reaches 93.4% but at the expense of the increment in QBER. The result of our simulation is, on some aspect, in agreement with the experimental result. However, we were able to extend the transmission distance from 3 meter, as in the experiment, to 10 meter. The coincidence count obtained was also in total agreement with the one obtained from the experiment. The result of the average QBER indicated that increase in the pulse number N causes the QBER to raise up due to longer rise and fall time of phase modulation step which affect the MZ inference. Therefore, we suggest using a faster waveform generator with shorter rise and fall times will remarkably lower the QBER. Extending the transmission coverage to a longer distance while, at the same time reducing the QBER with full unconditional security will part of the future research.

•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations

Finite-key security analysis of differential-phase-shift quantum key distribution

Akihiro Mizutani, Yuki Takeuchi, Kiyoshi Tamaki

Differential-phase-shift (DPS) quantum key distribution (QKD) is one of the major QKD protocols that can be implemented with a simple setup using a laser source and a passive detection unit. Recently, an information-theoretic security proof of this protocol was established by Mizutani et al. [npj Quantum Inf. 5, 87 (2019)], assuming an infinitely large number of emitted pulses. To implement the DPS protocol in a real-life world, it is indispensable to analyze the security with the finite number of emitted pulses. The extension of the security proof to the finite-size regime requires the accommodation of the statistical fluctuations to determine the amount of privacy amplification. In doing so, Azuma's inequality is often employed, but unfortunately we show that in the case of the DPS protocol, this results in a substantially low key rate. This low key rate is due to a loose estimation of the sum of probabilities regarding three-photon emission whose probability of occurrence is very small. The main contribution of our work is to show that this obstacle can be overcome by exploiting the recently found novel concentration inequality, Kato's inequality. As a result, the key rate of the DPS protocol is drastically improved. For instance, assuming typical experimental parameters, a 3-Mbit secret key can be generated over 77 km for 8.3 hours, which shows the feasibility of DPS QKD under a realistic setup.

arXiv:2301.09844•Physical Review Research•May 30, 2023•18 citations

Security of differential phase shift QKD from relativistic principles

Martin Sandfuchs, Michael Haberland, V. Vilasini +1 more

The design of quantum protocols for secure key generation poses many challenges: On the one hand, they need to be practical concerning experimental realisations. On the other hand, their theoretical description must be simple enough to allow for a security proof against all possible attacks. Often, these two requirements are in conflict with each other, and the differential phase shift (DPS) QKD protocol exemplifies these difficulties: It is designed to be implementable with current optical telecommunication technology, which, for this protocol, comes at the cost that many standard security proof techniques do not apply to it. After about 20 years since its invention, this work presents the first full security proof of DPS QKD against general attacks, including finite-size effects. The proof combines techniques from quantum information theory, quantum optics, and relativity. We first give a security proof of a QKD protocol whose security stems from relativistic constraints. We then show that security of DPS QKD can be reduced to security of the relativistic protocol. In addition, we show that coherent attacks on the DPS protocol are, in fact, stronger than collective attacks. Our results have broad implications for the development of secure and reliable quantum communication technologies, as they shed light on the range of applicability of state-of-the-art security proof techniques.

arXiv:2301.11340•Quantum•Jan 27, 2025•15 citations

Effect of detector dead times on the security evaluation of differential-phase-shift quantum key distribution against sequential attacks

Marcos Curty, Kiyoshi Tamaki, Tobias Moroder

We investigate limitations imposed by detector dead times on the performance of sequential attacks against a differential-phase-shift (DPS) quantum key distribution (QKD) protocol with weak coherent pulses. In particular, we analyze sequential attacks based on unambiguous state discrimination of the signal states emitted by the source and we obtain ultimate upper bounds on the maximal distance achievable by a DPS QKD scheme both for the case of calibrated and uncalibrated devices, respectively.

arXiv:0803.1473•Physical Review A•May 19, 2008•24 citations

Sequential attacks against differential-phase-shift quantum key distribution with weak coherent states

Marcos Curty, Lucy Liuxuan Zhang, Hoi‐Kwong Lo +1 more

We investigate limitations imposed by sequential attacks on the performance of differential-phase-shift quantum key distribution protocols that use pulsed coherent light. In particular, we analyze two sequential attacks based on unambiguous state discrimination and minimum error discrimination, respectively, of the signal states emitted by the source. Sequential attacks represent;I special type of intercept-resend attacks and, therefore, they provide ultimate upper bounds on the maximal distance achievable by quantum key distribution schemes.

•Sep 1, 2007•30 citations
In the well-established framework of quantum key distribution (QKD), differential phase shift (DPS) protocols have known information-theoretic security bounds defining tolerable error rates under optimal adversaries. In this work, we revisit the security of 3- and nnn -pulse DPS QKD by explicitly analyzing two specific, physically implementable individual attacks: minimum error discrimination (MED) and quantum cloning. Using semidefinite programming, we characterize these attacks in detail and quantify their induced quantum bit error rates (QBER) and resulting secure key rates under realistic system assumptions. The critical QBER thresholds for these attacks are approximately 20%, significantly higher than the theoretical lower bounds of 6% for individual and 4% for coherent attacks, indicating these are suboptimal adversarial strategies. This study primarily serves as a practical exercise to benchmark known attacks, providing explicit measures that aid experimental validation, protocol calibration, and risk assessment within current technological capabilities. Additionally, we explore finite-size effects and the effectiveness of phase randomization in weak coherent source-based protocols as protection against unambiguous state discrimination attacks.
In this paper, we investigate limitations imposed by sequential attacks on the performance of a differential-phase-shift (DPS) quantum key distribution (QKD) protocol with weak coherent pulses. Specifically, we analyze a sequential attack based on optimal unambiguous discrimination of the relative phases between consecutive signal states emitted by the source. We show that this attack can provide tighter upper bounds for the security of a DPS QKD scheme than those derived from sequential attacks where the eavesdropper aims to identify the state of each signal emitted by the source unambiguously.
Differential phase-shift (DPS) quantum key distribution (QKD) is a unique QKD protocol that is different from traditional ones, featuring simplicity and practicality. In this work, we simulated the DPS-QKD experiment conducted by (Liu et al., 2013), using OptiSystem 7. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first simulation work on DPS-QKD using a single photon source.We used a random number generator to get the phase modulation pattern of N=5, 7,9,11 and 13, while for the 3 and 15 pulse cases, the pattern adopted in the experiment was used. When the number of pulse (N) was 3, a quantum bit error rate (QBER) of 3.0%, which is lower than the minimum QBER of 4.12% required for unconditional security, was obtained. The key creation efficiency increases with the increase in the number of pulse up to 15, as it reaches 93.4% but at the expense of the increment in QBER. The result of our simulation is, on some aspect, in agreement with the experimental result. However, we were able to extend the transmission distance from 3 meter, as in the experiment, to 10 meter. The coincidence count obtained was also in total agreement with the one obtained from the experiment. The result of the average QBER indicated that increase in the pulse number N causes the QBER to raise up due to longer rise and fall time of phase modulation step which affect the MZ inference. Therefore, we suggest using a faster waveform generator with shorter rise and fall times will remarkably lower the QBER. Extending the transmission coverage to a longer distance while, at the same time reducing the QBER with full unconditional security will part of the future research.
Differential-phase-shift (DPS) quantum key distribution (QKD) is one of the major QKD protocols that can be implemented with a simple setup using a laser source and a passive detection unit. Recently, an information-theoretic security proof of this protocol was established by Mizutani et al. [npj Quantum Inf. 5, 87 (2019)], assuming an infinitely large number of emitted pulses. To implement the DPS protocol in a real-life world, it is indispensable to analyze the security with the finite number of emitted pulses. The extension of the security proof to the finite-size regime requires the accommodation of the statistical fluctuations to determine the amount of privacy amplification. In doing so, Azuma's inequality is often employed, but unfortunately we show that in the case of the DPS protocol, this results in a substantially low key rate. This low key rate is due to a loose estimation of the sum of probabilities regarding three-photon emission whose probability of occurrence is very small. The main contribution of our work is to show that this obstacle can be overcome by exploiting the recently found novel concentration inequality, Kato's inequality. As a result, the key rate of the DPS protocol is drastically improved. For instance, assuming typical experimental parameters, a 3-Mbit secret key can be generated over 77 km for 8.3 hours, which shows the feasibility of DPS QKD under a realistic setup.
The design of quantum protocols for secure key generation poses many challenges: On the one hand, they need to be practical concerning experimental realisations. On the other hand, their theoretical description must be simple enough to allow for a security proof against all possible attacks. Often, these two requirements are in conflict with each other, and the differential phase shift (DPS) QKD protocol exemplifies these difficulties: It is designed to be implementable with current optical telecommunication technology, which, for this protocol, comes at the cost that many standard security proof techniques do not apply to it. After about 20 years since its invention, this work presents the first full security proof of DPS QKD against general attacks, including finite-size effects. The proof combines techniques from quantum information theory, quantum optics, and relativity. We first give a security proof of a QKD protocol whose security stems from relativistic constraints. We then show that security of DPS QKD can be reduced to security of the relativistic protocol. In addition, we show that coherent attacks on the DPS protocol are, in fact, stronger than collective attacks. Our results have broad implications for the development of secure and reliable quantum communication technologies, as they shed light on the range of applicability of state-of-the-art security proof techniques.
We investigate limitations imposed by sequential attacks on the performance of differential-phase-shift quantum key distribution protocols that use pulsed coherent light. In particular, we analyze two sequential attacks based on unambiguous state discrimination and minimum error discrimination, respectively, of the signal states emitted by the source. Sequential attacks represent;I special type of intercept-resend attacks and, therefore, they provide ultimate upper bounds on the maximal distance achievable by quantum key distribution schemes.