arXiv:2304.03716 · Nature Communications

Quantum noise and its evasion in feedback oscillators

Hudson A. Loughlin, Vivishek Sudhir

Published Nov 4, 2023• 7 citations

Abstract

Feedback oscillators, consisting of an amplifier whose output is partially fed back to its input, provide stable references for standardization and synchronization. Notably, the laser is such an oscillator whose performance can be limited by quantum fluctuations. The resulting frequency instability, quantified by the Schawlow-Townes formula, sets a limit to laser linewidth. Here, we show that the Schawlow-Townes formula applies universally to feedback oscillators beyond lasers. This is because it arises from quantum noise added by the amplifier and out-coupler in the feedback loop. Tracing the precise origin of quantum noise in an oscillator informs techniques to systematically evade it: we show how squeezing and entanglement can enable sub-Schawlow-Townes linewidth feedback oscillators. Our analysis clarifies the quantum limits to the stability of feedback oscillators in general, derives a standard quantum limit (SQL) for all such devices, and quantifies the efficacy of quantum strategies in realizing sub-SQL oscillators.

DOI: 10.1038/s41467-023-42739-9

Related papers

Evading the Schawlow-Townes limit in feedback oscillators

Hudson A. Loughlin, Vivishek Sudhir

We develop a general quantum theory of feedback oscillators and use it to study the origin of quantum noise in such systems, the limitations posed by quantum noise, and systematic techniques to evade these limitations. For a laser, the quantum noise limit is the Schawlow-Townes limit, which can be evaded using squeezing or entanglement.

Frontiers in OpticsJan 1, 20230 citations

A Quantum-Enhanced Feedback Oscillator

Hudson A. Loughlin, Daniel M. DeSantis, Nergis Mavalvala +1 more

Feedback oscillators, such as lasers and masers, serve as time references in modern computing, communication, and measurement. Quantum fluctuations ultimately limit their phase stability and ability to keep time precisely; in the absence of quantum engineering, their phase stability is bounded by a standard quantum limit (SQL). Techniques to improve the frequency stability of feedback oscillators beyond the SQL have been theorized, but have not yet been demonstrated. We demonstrate an opto-electronic oscillator (OEO), a type of feedback oscillator, with phase stability approaching the SQL. We then engineer the OEO's quantum state to improve its phase stability, thereby demonstrating the essential principle quantum-enhancement of feedback oscillators. Similar techniques may be employed to evade the SQL in other feedback oscillators such as masers and lasers.

quant-pharXiv:2608.07753Aug 11, 20260 citations

Generalized Schawlow-Townes limit

Hudson A. Loughlin, Vivishek Sudhir

We study a class of feedback oscillators realized by a phase-insensitive amplifier in positive feedback, where either the amplifier or the feedback element may determine the oscillator's linewidth. The spectral purity of the output of such a device originates from basic demands of quantum mechanics and causality. The resulting expression generalizes the Schawlow-Townes limit, which is itself one component of a standard quantum limit for feedback oscillators. Recently realized bad-cavity oscillators, such as superradiant lasers and solid-state masers, can saturate this generalized Schawlow-Townes limit. This limit can be surpassed through appropriate quantum engineering, for example, by atomic spin squeezing in a superradiant laser.

arXiv:2501.11861Physical Review AMar 16, 20261 citation

Quantum noise reduction in semiconductor lasers using dispersive optical feedback

John Edward Kitching

This thesis describes the phase and amplitude noise properties of semiconductor lasers subjected to weak, dispersive optical feedback. In the first half, experiments demonstrating reductions in the laser frequency noise power spectrum and spectral linewidth by several orders of magnitude are presented. Weak optical feedback is applied to the laser by an external cavity containing an atomic vapor. The presence of the vapor adds to the dispersion of the cavity and simultaneously locks the laser to a fixed frequency reference. The role of 1/f frequency noise in limiting the effectiveness of this linewidth reduction technique is investigated and 1/f noise is found to be the dominant contribution to the linewidth under strong optical feedback conditions. An electronic feedback scheme utilizing FM sideband locking is then implemented alongside the optical feedback, and an additional reduction in the low frequency 1/f frequency noise power spectrum by over two orders of magnitude is obtained. With both systems operating simultaneously, the spectral linewidth is narrowed from its free-running value of about 20 MHz to 1.4 kHz. Excellent absolute frequency stability is also achieved. In the second half, the effects of optical feedback on the quantum mechanical amplitude noise properties of the laser are examined. A fully quantum mechanical theory of amplitude and phase noise for a semiconductor laser with weak optical feedback is developed, and the nature and limits of the noise reduction using this technique are established. Particular attention is given to the feedback-induced enhancement of the amplitude squeezing which can be obtained in a pump-suppressed semiconductor laser: an improvement in the squeezing by 3 dB is predicted under moderate pumping. Somewhat larger noise reductions are expected when the laser is operating closer to threshold. Measurements performed on a laser biased close to threshold are then described and a reduction in the low frequency amplitude noise power spectrum by 7 dB is obtained. An experimental investigation of the effects of optical feedback on the amplitude squeezing in a semiconductor laser is then discussed. The low frequency squeezing in a room temperature device is increased from 3% below the standard quantum limit (SQL) under free-running conditions to 19% below the SQL with optimal feedback. The experimental results are found to agree poorly with the single-mode model and a multi-mode model including the effects of asymmetrical cross-mode non-linear gain is developed to explain the discrepancy. Finally, further experimental investigation into the generation of amplitude squeezed light is presented using a commercial laser with no intentional external modifications. Squeezing as large as 29% below the SQL is measured using a balanced homodyne detector with the laser operating near room temperature, corresponding to 41% below the SQL at the output facet of the laser.

Jan 1, 19951 citation

Quantum nondemotion tracking of a resonator’s phase

Bernard Yurke, D. S. Creywall, Paul Busch +1 more

Resonators driven to self-oscillation by active feedback play an important role in technology. The laser is an example of such a device. Generally, the feedback that sustains self-oscillation is contaminated with amplifier noise, which leads to phase diffusion. Here we show that under suitable conditions phase noise from the feedback amplifier can be evaded, allowing one to track the resonator's phase in a quantum nondemolition manner. In particular, we consider a resonator with a Kerr nonlinearity. The output of the resonator is fed into a linear amplifier, phase shifted, fed through an amplitude limiter, and then fed back into the resonator. Stable operation is achieved, even on portions of the resonance curve for which the resonator would exhibit optical bistability under open-loop conditions. By operating the system at a point on the resonance curve for which the slope of the phase versus frequency is infinite, the long-term phase stability of the oscillator becomes insensitive to the amplifier's output noise. In addition, the amplifier's input-port noise can be evaded by making the coupling between the resonator and the amplifier sufficiently weak.

May 8, 19940 citations

Amplitude squeezing in a pump-noise-suppressed laser oscillator

Y. Yamamoto, S. Machida, OLLE NILSSON

This paper clarifies the origins of the standard quantum limit for the amplitude noise of a laser-oscillator outgoing field. The amplitude noise within the cavity bandwidth, \ensuremath{\Omega}\ensuremath{\le}\ensuremath{\omega}/Q, is ultimately caused by the pump amplitude fluctuation, while that above the cavity bandwidth, \ensuremath{\Omega}\ensuremath{\ge}\ensuremath{\omega}/Q, is due to the field zero-point fluctuation. The uncertainty product of the amplitude- and phase-noise spectra at an extremely high pumping level is still larger than the Heisenberg minimum-uncertainty product because of the presence of nonstationary phase-diffusion noise. In this sense, an ordinary laser oscillator is not a quantum-limited device. This paper suggests that a laser oscillator can produce an amplitude-squeezed state in itself if the pump amplitude fluctuation is suppressed below the ordinary shot-noise level. The paper discusses possible schemes for suppressing pump fluctuation, commutator bracket preservation without pump fluctuation, and resulting amplitude and phase spectra. The similarity of and difference between a pump-noise-suppressed laser and a cavity degenerate parametric amplifier are delineated.

Physical Review ANov 1, 1986387 citations