© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

arXiv:2301.10782 · SciPost Physics

Multipole groups and fracton phenomena on arbitrary crystalline lattices

Daniel Bulmash, Oliver Hart, Rahul Nandkishore

Published Dec 12, 2023• 11 citations

Abstract

Multipole symmetries are of interest in multiple contexts, from the study of fracton phases, to nonergodic quantum dynamics, to the exploration of new hydrodynamic universality classes. However, prior explorations have focused on continuum systems or hypercubic lattices. In this work, we systematically explore multipole symmetries on arbitrary crystal lattices. We explain how, given a crystal structure (specified by a space group and the occupied Wyckoff positions), one may systematically construct all consistent multipole groups. We focus on two-dimensional crystal structures for simplicity, although our methods are general and extend straightforwardly to three dimensions. We classify the possible multipole groups on all two-dimensional Bravais lattices, and on the Kagome and breathing Kagome crystal structures to illustrate the procedure on general crystal lattices. Using Wyckoff positions, we provide an in-principle classification of all possible multipole groups in any space group. We explain how, given a valid multipole group, one may construct a consistent lattice Hamiltonian and a low-energy field theory. We then explore the physical consequences, beginning by generalizing certain results originally obtained on hypercubic lattices to arbitrary crystal structures. Next, we identify two apparently novel phenomena: an emergent, robust subsystem symmetry on the triangular lattice, and an exact multipolar symmetry on the breathing Kagome lattice that does not include conservation of charge (monopole), but instead conserves a vector charge. This makes clear that there is new physics to be found by exploring the consequences of multipolar symmetries on arbitrary lattices, and this work provides the map for the exploration thereof, as well as guiding the search for emergent multipolar symmetries and the attendant exotic phenomena in real materials based on nonhypercubic lattices.

DOI: 10.21468/scipostphys.15.6.235

Related papers

Towards Classification of Fracton Phases: The Multipole Algebra

Andrey Gromov

We present an effective field theory approach to the fracton phases. The approach is based on the notion of a multipole algebra. It is an extension of space(time) symmetries of a charge-conserving matter that includes global symmetries responsible for the conservation of various components of the multipole moments of the charge density. We explain how to construct field theories invariant under the action of the algebra. These field theories generally break rotational invariance and exhibit anisotropic scaling. We further explain how to partially gauge the multipole algebra. Such gauging makes the symmetries responsible for the conservation of multipole moments local, while keeping rotation and translations symmetries global. It is shown that upon such gauging one finds the symmetric tensor gauge theories, as well as the generalized gauge theories discussed recently in the literature. We refer to all such theories as multipole gauge theories. The outcome of the gauging procedure depends on the choice of the multipole algebra. In particular, we show how to construct an effective theory for the U(1) version of the Haah code based on the principles of symmetry and provide a two-dimensional example with operators supported on a Sierpinski triangle. We show that upon condensation of charged excitations, fracton phases of both types as well as various Symmetry-protected topological phases emerge. Finally, the relation between the present approach and the formalism based on polynomials over finite fields is discussed.

•Jul 1, 2019•183 citations

Spontaneous breaking of multipole symmetries

Charles Stahl, Ethan Lake, Rahul Nandkishore

Multipole symmetries are of interest both as a window on fracton physics and as a crucial ingredient in realizing new universality classes for quantum dynamics. Here we address the question of whether and when multipole symmetries can be spontaneously broken, both in thermal equilibrium and at zero temperature. We derive generalized Mermin-Wagner arguments for the total or partial breaking of multipolar symmetry groups and generalized Imry-Ma arguments for the robustness of such multipolar symmetry breaking to disorder. We present both general results and explicit examples. Our results should be directly applicable to quantum dynamics with multipolar symmetries and also provide a useful stepping stone to understanding the robustness of fracton phases to thermal fluctuations, quantum fluctuations, and disorder.

arXiv:2111.08041•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 5, 2022•64 citations

Fracton Matter

Andrey Gromov, Leo Radzihovsky

We review a burgeoning field of "fractons" -- a class of models where quasi-particles are strictly immobile or display restricted mobility that can be understood through generalized multipolar symmetries and associated conservation laws. Focusing on just a corner of this fast-growing subject, we will demonstrate how one class of such theories -- symmetric tensor and coupled-vector gauge theories surprisingly emerge from familiar elasticity of a two-dimensional quantum crystal. The disclination and dislocation crystal defects respectively map onto charges and dipoles of the fracton gauge theory. This fracton-elasticity duality leads to predictions of fractonic phases and quantum phase transitions to their descendants, that are duals of the commensurate crystal, supersolid, smectic, hexatic liquid crystals, as well as amorphous solids, quasi-crystals and elastic membranes. We show how these dual gauge theories provide a field theoretic description of quantum melting transitions through a generalized Higgs mechanism. We demonstrate how they can be equivalently constructed as gauged models with global multipole symmetries. We expect extensions of such gauge-elasticity dualities to generalized elasticity theories provide a route to discovery of new fractonic models and their potential experimental realizations.

arXiv:2211.05130•Nov 9, 2022•12 citations

Systematic Constructions of Fracton Theories

Djordje Radicevic

Fracton theories possess exponentially degenerate ground states, excitations with restricted mobility, and nontopological higher-form symmetries. This paper shows that such theories can be defined on arbitrary spatial lattices in three dimensions. The key element of this construction is a generalization of higher-form gauge theories to so-called $\mathfrak{F}_p$ gauge theories, in which gauge transformations of rank-$k$ fields are specified by rank-$(k - p)$ gauge parameters. The $\mathbb{Z}_2$ rank-two theory of type $\mathfrak{F}_2$, placed on a cubic lattice and coupled to scalar matter, is shown to have a topological phase exactly dual to the well-known X-cube model. Generalizations of this example yield novel fracton theories. In the continuum, the $\mathrm{U}(1)$ rank-two theory of type $\mathfrak{F}_2$ is shown to have a perturbatively gapless fracton regime that cannot be consistently interpreted as a tensor gauge theory of any kind. The compact scalar fields that naturally couple to this $\mathfrak{F}_2$ theory also show gapless fracton behavior; on a cubic lattice they have a conserved $\mathrm{U}(1)$ charge and dipole moment, but these particular charges are not necessarily conserved on more general lattices. The construction straightforwardly generalizes to $\mathfrak{F}_2$ theories of nonabelian rank-two gauge fields, giving first examples of pure nonabelian higher-rank theories.

arXiv:1910.06336•Oct 14, 2019•29 citations

Quantum Liquids: Emergent higher-rank gauge theory and fractons

Yizhi You

Fracton emerges from strongly interacting many-body systems whose excitations, referred to as sub-dimensional particles, have restricted mobility or kinetic motions. These entities have garnered significant interest due to their interdisciplinary implications spanning topological quantum codes, quantum field theory, emergent gravity, quantum information, and more, revealing unique nonequilibrium behaviors such as nonergodicity and glassy dynamics. This review presents a structured and educational overview of fracton phenomena, specifically focusing on gapless fracton liquids. Noteworthy for their compressibility and gapless excitations, fracton liquids facilitate collective modes reminiscent of those gauge fluctuations found in Maxwell's electromagnetic framework. However, they are distinct due to an additional higher-moment conservation law that restricts the mobility of individual charges and monopoles. Our exploration begins with the theoretical foundation of 3D fracton liquids, presenting a variety of emergent symmetric tensor gauge theories and reviewing their equilibrium and dynamic properties. Following this theoretical groundwork, we discuss the material realization of various fracton liquids in Yb-based breathing pyrochlore lattices, close-packed tiling structures and other synthetic quantum matter platforms. Additionally, we introduce a general protocol to foster and manipulate emergent fracton spin liquids in the realm of frustrated magnetism.

arXiv:2403.17074•Mar 25, 2024•1 citation

Unified Theory of Quantum Crystalline Symmetries

Y. X. Zhao, Shao, L. B.

Symmetry groups are projectively represented in quantum mechanics, and crystalline symmetries are fundamental in condensed matter physics. Here, we systematically present a unified theory of quantum mechanical space groups from two complementary aspects. First, we provide a decomposition form for the space-group factor systems to characterize all quantum space groups. It consists of three factors, the factor system for the translation subgroup $L$, an in-homogeneous factor system for the point group $P$, and a factor connecting $L$ and $P$. The three factors satisfy three consistency equations, which are exactly solvable and can completely exhaust all factor systems for space groups. Second, since factors systems are classified by the second cohomology group, we show the (co)homology groups for space groups can be derived from Borel's equivariant (co)homology theory, which leads to an algorithm that can compute all (co)homology groups for space groups. To demonstrate the general theory, we explicitly present quantum wallpaper groups with the $\mathbb{Z}_2$ gauge group. Furthermore, as a primitive application, we find the time-reversal invariant quantum space groups with inversion symmetry can lead to a novel clifford band theory, where each band is fourfold degenerate to represent certain real Clifford algebras with topologically nontrivial pinor structures over the Brillouin zone. Our work serves as a foundation for exploring quantum mechanical space groups, and can find applications in spin liquids, unconventional superconductors, and artificial lattice systems, including cold atoms, photonic and phononic crystals, and even LC electric circuit networks.

arXiv:2009.07483•Sep 16, 2020•0 citations

Multipole symmetries are of interest in multiple contexts, from the study of fracton phases, to nonergodic quantum dynamics, to the exploration of new hydrodynamic universality classes. However, prior explorations have focused on continuum systems or hypercubic lattices. In this work, we systematically explore multipole symmetries on arbitrary crystal lattices. We explain how, given a crystal structure (specified by a space group and the occupied Wyckoff positions), one may systematically construct all consistent multipole groups. We focus on two-dimensional crystal structures for simplicity, although our methods are general and extend straightforwardly to three dimensions. We classify the possible multipole groups on all two-dimensional Bravais lattices, and on the Kagome and breathing Kagome crystal structures to illustrate the procedure on general crystal lattices. Using Wyckoff positions, we provide an in-principle classification of all possible multipole groups in any space group. We explain how, given a valid multipole group, one may construct a consistent lattice Hamiltonian and a low-energy field theory. We then explore the physical consequences, beginning by generalizing certain results originally obtained on hypercubic lattices to arbitrary crystal structures. Next, we identify two apparently novel phenomena: an emergent, robust subsystem symmetry on the triangular lattice, and an exact multipolar symmetry on the breathing Kagome lattice that does not include conservation of charge (monopole), but instead conserves a vector charge. This makes clear that there is new physics to be found by exploring the consequences of multipolar symmetries on arbitrary lattices, and this work provides the map for the exploration thereof, as well as guiding the search for emergent multipolar symmetries and the attendant exotic phenomena in real materials based on nonhypercubic lattices.

We present an effective field theory approach to the fracton phases. The approach is based on the notion of a multipole algebra. It is an extension of space(time) symmetries of a charge-conserving matter that includes global symmetries responsible for the conservation of various components of the multipole moments of the charge density. We explain how to construct field theories invariant under the action of the algebra. These field theories generally break rotational invariance and exhibit anisotropic scaling. We further explain how to partially gauge the multipole algebra. Such gauging makes the symmetries responsible for the conservation of multipole moments local, while keeping rotation and translations symmetries global. It is shown that upon such gauging one finds the symmetric tensor gauge theories, as well as the generalized gauge theories discussed recently in the literature. We refer to all such theories as multipole gauge theories. The outcome of the gauging procedure depends on the choice of the multipole algebra. In particular, we show how to construct an effective theory for the U(1) version of the Haah code based on the principles of symmetry and provide a two-dimensional example with operators supported on a Sierpinski triangle. We show that upon condensation of charged excitations, fracton phases of both types as well as various Symmetry-protected topological phases emerge. Finally, the relation between the present approach and the formalism based on polynomials over finite fields is discussed.

Multipole symmetries are of interest both as a window on fracton physics and as a crucial ingredient in realizing new universality classes for quantum dynamics. Here we address the question of whether and when multipole symmetries can be spontaneously broken, both in thermal equilibrium and at zero temperature. We derive generalized Mermin-Wagner arguments for the total or partial breaking of multipolar symmetry groups and generalized Imry-Ma arguments for the robustness of such multipolar symmetry breaking to disorder. We present both general results and explicit examples. Our results should be directly applicable to quantum dynamics with multipolar symmetries and also provide a useful stepping stone to understanding the robustness of fracton phases to thermal fluctuations, quantum fluctuations, and disorder.

We review a burgeoning field of "fractons" -- a class of models where quasi-particles are strictly immobile or display restricted mobility that can be understood through generalized multipolar symmetries and associated conservation laws. Focusing on just a corner of this fast-growing subject, we will demonstrate how one class of such theories -- symmetric tensor and coupled-vector gauge theories surprisingly emerge from familiar elasticity of a two-dimensional quantum crystal. The disclination and dislocation crystal defects respectively map onto charges and dipoles of the fracton gauge theory. This fracton-elasticity duality leads to predictions of fractonic phases and quantum phase transitions to their descendants, that are duals of the commensurate crystal, supersolid, smectic, hexatic liquid crystals, as well as amorphous solids, quasi-crystals and elastic membranes. We show how these dual gauge theories provide a field theoretic description of quantum melting transitions through a generalized Higgs mechanism. We demonstrate how they can be equivalently constructed as gauged models with global multipole symmetries. We expect extensions of such gauge-elasticity dualities to generalized elasticity theories provide a route to discovery of new fractonic models and their potential experimental realizations.

Fracton theories possess exponentially degenerate ground states, excitations with restricted mobility, and nontopological higher-form symmetries. This paper shows that such theories can be defined on arbitrary spatial lattices in three dimensions. The key element of this construction is a generalization of higher-form gauge theories to so-called

\mathfrak{F}_p

gauge theories, in which gauge transformations of rank-

k

fields are specified by rank-

(k - p)

gauge parameters. The

\mathbb{Z}_2

rank-two theory of type

\mathfrak{F}_2

, placed on a cubic lattice and coupled to scalar matter, is shown to have a topological phase exactly dual to the well-known X-cube model. Generalizations of this example yield novel fracton theories. In the continuum, the

\mathrm{U}(1)

rank-two theory of type

\mathfrak{F}_2

is shown to have a perturbatively gapless fracton regime that cannot be consistently interpreted as a tensor gauge theory of any kind. The compact scalar fields that naturally couple to this

\mathbb{Z}_2

theory also show gapless fracton behavior; on a cubic lattice they have a conserved

\mathfrak{F}_2

charge and dipole moment, but these particular charges are not necessarily conserved on more general lattices. The construction straightforwardly generalizes to

\mathfrak{F}_2

theories of nonabelian rank-two gauge fields, giving first examples of pure nonabelian higher-rank theories.

Fracton emerges from strongly interacting many-body systems whose excitations, referred to as sub-dimensional particles, have restricted mobility or kinetic motions. These entities have garnered significant interest due to their interdisciplinary implications spanning topological quantum codes, quantum field theory, emergent gravity, quantum information, and more, revealing unique nonequilibrium behaviors such as nonergodicity and glassy dynamics. This review presents a structured and educational overview of fracton phenomena, specifically focusing on gapless fracton liquids. Noteworthy for their compressibility and gapless excitations, fracton liquids facilitate collective modes reminiscent of those gauge fluctuations found in Maxwell's electromagnetic framework. However, they are distinct due to an additional higher-moment conservation law that restricts the mobility of individual charges and monopoles. Our exploration begins with the theoretical foundation of 3D fracton liquids, presenting a variety of emergent symmetric tensor gauge theories and reviewing their equilibrium and dynamic properties. Following this theoretical groundwork, we discuss the material realization of various fracton liquids in Yb-based breathing pyrochlore lattices, close-packed tiling structures and other synthetic quantum matter platforms. Additionally, we introduce a general protocol to foster and manipulate emergent fracton spin liquids in the realm of frustrated magnetism.

Symmetry groups are projectively represented in quantum mechanics, and crystalline symmetries are fundamental in condensed matter physics. Here, we systematically present a unified theory of quantum mechanical space groups from two complementary aspects. First, we provide a decomposition form for the space-group factor systems to characterize all quantum space groups. It consists of three factors, the factor system for the translation subgroup

L

, an in-homogeneous factor system for the point group

P

, and a factor connecting

L

and

P

. The three factors satisfy three consistency equations, which are exactly solvable and can completely exhaust all factor systems for space groups. Second, since factors systems are classified by the second cohomology group, we show the (co)homology groups for space groups can be derived from Borel's equivariant (co)homology theory, which leads to an algorithm that can compute all (co)homology groups for space groups. To demonstrate the general theory, we explicitly present quantum wallpaper groups with the

\mathbb{Z}_2

gauge group. Furthermore, as a primitive application, we find the time-reversal invariant quantum space groups with inversion symmetry can lead to a novel clifford band theory, where each band is fourfold degenerate to represent certain real Clifford algebras with topologically nontrivial pinor structures over the Brillouin zone. Our work serves as a foundation for exploring quantum mechanical space groups, and can find applications in spin liquids, unconventional superconductors, and artificial lattice systems, including cold atoms, photonic and phononic crystals, and even LC electric circuit networks.