Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2210.03716

The quantum commuting model (Ia): The CHSH game and other examples: Uniqueness of optimal states

Alexander Frei

Published Oct 7, 2022• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present in this paper that the CHSH game admits one and only one optimal state and so remove all ambiguity of representations. More precisely, we use the well-known universal description of quantum commuting correlations as state space on the universal algebra for two player games, and so allows us to unambigiously compare quantum strategies as states on this common algebra. As such we find that the CHSH game leaves a single optimal state on this common algebra. In turn passing to any non-minimal Stinespring dilation for this unique optimal state is the only source of ambiguity (including self-testing): More precisely, any state on some operator algebra may be uniquely broken up into its minimal Stinespring dilation as an honest representation for the operator algebra followed by its vector state. Any other Stinespring dilation however arises simply as an extension of the minimal Stinespring dilation (i.e., as an embedding of the minimal Hilbert space into some random ambient one). As such this manifests the only source of ambiguity appearing in most (but not all!) traditional self-testing results such as for the CHSH game as well as in plenty of similar examples. We then further demonstrate the simplicity of our arguments on the Mermin--Peres magic square and magic pentagram game. Most importantly however, we present this article as an illustration of operator algebraic techniques on optimal states and their quotients, and we further pick up the results of the current article in another following one (currently under preparation) to derive a first robust self-testing result in the quantum commuting model.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2210.03716

Related papers

A generalization of CHSH and the algebraic structure of optimal strategies

David Cui, Arthur Mehta, Hamoon Mousavi +1 more

Self-testing has been a rich area of study in quantum information theory. It allows an experimenter to interact classically with a black box quantum system and to test that a specific entangled state was present and a specific set of measurements were performed. Recently, self-testing has been central to high-profile results in complexity theory as seen in the work on entangled games PCP of Natarajan and Vidick (FOCS 2018), iterated compression by Fitzsimons et al.\ (STOC 2019), and NEEXP in MIP* due to Natarajan and Wright (FOCS 2019). The most studied self-test is the CHSH game which features a bipartite system with two isolated devices. This game certifies the presence of a single EPR entangled state and the use of anti-commuting Pauli measurements. Most of the self-testing literature has focused on extending these results to self-test for tensor products of EPR states and tensor products of Pauli measurements.In this work, we introduce an algebraic generalization of CHSH by viewing it as a linear constraint system (LCS) game, exhibiting self-testing properties that are qualitatively different. These provide the first example of LCS games that self-test non-Pauli operators resolving an open question posed by Coladangelo and Stark (QIP 2017). Our games also provide a self-test for states other than the maximally entangled state, and hence resolves the open question posed by Cleve and Mittal (ICALP 2012). Additionally, our games have 1 bit question and log⁡n bit answer lengths making them suitable candidates for complexity theoretic application. This work is the first step towards a general theory of self-testing arbitrary groups. In order to obtain our results, we exploit connections between sum of squares proofs, non-commutative ring theory, and the Gowers-Hatami theorem from approximate representation theory. A crucial part of our analysis is to introduce a sum of squares framework that generalizes the solution group of Cleve, Liu, and Slofstra (Journal of Mathematical Physics 2017) to the non-pseudo-telepathic regime. Finally, we give a game that is not a self-test by "gluing" together two copies of the magic square game. Our results suggest a richer landscape of self-testing phenomena than previously considered.

arXiv:1911.01593•Quantum•Oct 21, 2020•11 citations

A commuting operator self-test for exact entanglement embezzlement

Connor Paddock, Simon Schmidt

We show that the optimal commuting operator correlation for a variant of Coladangelo's two-player generalized nonlocal game, based on the embezzlement of entanglement, is a commuting operator self-test. Our result gives the first correlation self-test for an exact entanglement embezzlement protocol in the commuting operator framework. Because the unique optimal correlation necessitates the exact embezzlement of entanglement, the correlation is unrealizable using quantum tensor-product models, even if the local spaces are allowed to be infinite dimensional. As such, our result provides an example of a commuting operator self-test where the Hilbert space shared by the two parties cannot be factored into a tensor-product of local spaces that is compatible with the local measurement operators. Our main proof technique relies on Harris' unique abstract state characterization of exact embezzlement of entanglement involving Cuntz algebras.

quant-pharXiv:2609.38083•Sep 30, 2026•0 citations

The tilted CHSH games: an operator algebraic classification

Alexander Frei, Azin Shahiri

We introduce a general systematic procedure for solving any binary-input binary-output game using operator algebraic techniques on the representation theory for the underlying group, which we then illustrate on the prominent class of tilted CHSH games: We derive for those an entire characterisation on the region exhibiting some quantum advantage and in particular derive a greatly simplified description for the required amount of anticommutation on observables (as being an essential ingredient in several adjacent articles). We further derive an abstract algebraic representation--free classification on the unique operator algebraic state maximising above quantum value. In particular the resulting operator algebraic state entails uniqueness for its corresponding correlation, including all higher and mixed moments. Finally the main purpose of this article is to provide above simplified description for the required amount of anticommutation and an abstract algebraic characterisation for their corresponding unique optimal state, both defining a key ingredient in upcoming work by the authors.

arXiv:2302.08475•Feb 16, 2023•0 citations

A non-robust quantum correlation self-test

Ranyiliu Chen, Yuming Zhao

We show that exact self-testing of a quantum correlation does not imply robust self-testing. Mančinska and Schmidt previously established such a separation for non-local games, but their obstruction to robustness arises from two distinct optimal correlations, with the self-tested one remaining robust. We establish the separation for a single correlation. Our proof is operator-algebraic. The main technical contribution is a general construction that associates a synchronous binary correlation to any finitely presented C*-algebra with unitary generators and real-coefficient relations. The implementing states of the correlation correspond exactly to the tracial states on the algebra. We apply this construction to an algebra with a unique finite-dimensional tracial state and a distinct amenable tracial state. By a characterization established by Zhao and independently by Kar, the resulting correlation is a self-test but not a robust self-test.

quant-pharXiv:2609.25117•Sep 22, 2026•0 citations

The structure of optimal and nearly-optimal quantum strategies for non-local XOR games

Dimiter Ostrev

We study optimal and nearly-optimal quantum strategies for non-local XOR games. First, we prove the following general result: for every non-local XOR game, there exists a set of relations with the properties: (1) a quantum strategy is optimal for the game if and only if it satisfies the relations, and (2) a quantum strategy is nearly optimal for the game if and only if it approximately satisfies the relations. Next, we focus attention on a specific infinite family of XOR games: the CHSH(n) games. This family generalizes the well-known CHSH game. We describe the general form of CHSH(n) optimal strategies. Then, we adapt the concept of intertwining operator from representation theory and use that to characterize nearly-optimal CHSH(n) strategies.

arXiv:1506.00607•Jun 1, 2015•0 citations

Glued magic games self-test maximally entangled states

Laura Mančinska, Thor Gabelgaard Nielsen, Jitendra Prakash

Self-testing results allow us to infer the underlying quantum mechanical description of states and measurements from classical outputs produced by non-communicating parties. The standard definition of self-testing does not apply in situations when there are two or more inequivalent optimal strategies. To address this, we introduce the notion of self-testing convex combinations of reference strategies, which is a generalisation of self-testing to multiple strategies. We show that the Glued Magic Square game [Quantum 4 (2020), p. 346] self-tests a convex combination of two inequivalent strategies. As a corollary, we obtain that the Glued Magic square game self-tests two EPR pairs thus answering an open question from [Quantum 4 (2020), p. 346]. Our self-test is robust and extends to natural generalisations of the Glued Magic Square game.

arXiv:2105.10658•May 22, 2021•3 citations
We present in this paper that the CHSH game admits one and only one optimal state and so remove all ambiguity of representations. More precisely, we use the well-known universal description of quantum commuting correlations as state space on the universal algebra for two player games, and so allows us to unambigiously compare quantum strategies as states on this common algebra. As such we find that the CHSH game leaves a single optimal state on this common algebra. In turn passing to any non-minimal Stinespring dilation for this unique optimal state is the only source of ambiguity (including self-testing): More precisely, any state on some operator algebra may be uniquely broken up into its minimal Stinespring dilation as an honest representation for the operator algebra followed by its vector state. Any other Stinespring dilation however arises simply as an extension of the minimal Stinespring dilation (i.e., as an embedding of the minimal Hilbert space into some random ambient one). As such this manifests the only source of ambiguity appearing in most (but not all!) traditional self-testing results such as for the CHSH game as well as in plenty of similar examples. We then further demonstrate the simplicity of our arguments on the Mermin--Peres magic square and magic pentagram game. Most importantly however, we present this article as an illustration of operator algebraic techniques on optimal states and their quotients, and we further pick up the results of the current article in another following one (currently under preparation) to derive a first robust self-testing result in the quantum commuting model.
Self-testing has been a rich area of study in quantum information theory. It allows an experimenter to interact classically with a black box quantum system and to test that a specific entangled state was present and a specific set of measurements were performed. Recently, self-testing has been central to high-profile results in complexity theory as seen in the work on entangled games PCP of Natarajan and Vidick (FOCS 2018), iterated compression by Fitzsimons et al.\ (STOC 2019), and NEEXP in MIP* due to Natarajan and Wright (FOCS 2019). The most studied self-test is the CHSH game which features a bipartite system with two isolated devices. This game certifies the presence of a single EPR entangled state and the use of anti-commuting Pauli measurements. Most of the self-testing literature has focused on extending these results to self-test for tensor products of EPR states and tensor products of Pauli measurements.In this work, we introduce an algebraic generalization of CHSH by viewing it as a linear constraint system (LCS) game, exhibiting self-testing properties that are qualitatively different. These provide the first example of LCS games that self-test non-Pauli operators resolving an open question posed by Coladangelo and Stark (QIP 2017). Our games also provide a self-test for states other than the maximally entangled state, and hence resolves the open question posed by Cleve and Mittal (ICALP 2012). Additionally, our games have 1 bit question and log⁡n bit answer lengths making them suitable candidates for complexity theoretic application. This work is the first step towards a general theory of self-testing arbitrary groups. In order to obtain our results, we exploit connections between sum of squares proofs, non-commutative ring theory, and the Gowers-Hatami theorem from approximate representation theory. A crucial part of our analysis is to introduce a sum of squares framework that generalizes the solution group of Cleve, Liu, and Slofstra (Journal of Mathematical Physics 2017) to the non-pseudo-telepathic regime. Finally, we give a game that is not a self-test by "gluing" together two copies of the magic square game. Our results suggest a richer landscape of self-testing phenomena than previously considered.
We show that the optimal commuting operator correlation for a variant of Coladangelo's two-player generalized nonlocal game, based on the embezzlement of entanglement, is a commuting operator self-test. Our result gives the first correlation self-test for an exact entanglement embezzlement protocol in the commuting operator framework. Because the unique optimal correlation necessitates the exact embezzlement of entanglement, the correlation is unrealizable using quantum tensor-product models, even if the local spaces are allowed to be infinite dimensional. As such, our result provides an example of a commuting operator self-test where the Hilbert space shared by the two parties cannot be factored into a tensor-product of local spaces that is compatible with the local measurement operators. Our main proof technique relies on Harris' unique abstract state characterization of exact embezzlement of entanglement involving Cuntz algebras.
We introduce a general systematic procedure for solving any binary-input binary-output game using operator algebraic techniques on the representation theory for the underlying group, which we then illustrate on the prominent class of tilted CHSH games: We derive for those an entire characterisation on the region exhibiting some quantum advantage and in particular derive a greatly simplified description for the required amount of anticommutation on observables (as being an essential ingredient in several adjacent articles). We further derive an abstract algebraic representation--free classification on the unique operator algebraic state maximising above quantum value. In particular the resulting operator algebraic state entails uniqueness for its corresponding correlation, including all higher and mixed moments. Finally the main purpose of this article is to provide above simplified description for the required amount of anticommutation and an abstract algebraic characterisation for their corresponding unique optimal state, both defining a key ingredient in upcoming work by the authors.
We show that exact self-testing of a quantum correlation does not imply robust self-testing. Mančinska and Schmidt previously established such a separation for non-local games, but their obstruction to robustness arises from two distinct optimal correlations, with the self-tested one remaining robust. We establish the separation for a single correlation. Our proof is operator-algebraic. The main technical contribution is a general construction that associates a synchronous binary correlation to any finitely presented C*-algebra with unitary generators and real-coefficient relations. The implementing states of the correlation correspond exactly to the tracial states on the algebra. We apply this construction to an algebra with a unique finite-dimensional tracial state and a distinct amenable tracial state. By a characterization established by Zhao and independently by Kar, the resulting correlation is a self-test but not a robust self-test.
We study optimal and nearly-optimal quantum strategies for non-local XOR games. First, we prove the following general result: for every non-local XOR game, there exists a set of relations with the properties: (1) a quantum strategy is optimal for the game if and only if it satisfies the relations, and (2) a quantum strategy is nearly optimal for the game if and only if it approximately satisfies the relations. Next, we focus attention on a specific infinite family of XOR games: the CHSH(n) games. This family generalizes the well-known CHSH game. We describe the general form of CHSH(n) optimal strategies. Then, we adapt the concept of intertwining operator from representation theory and use that to characterize nearly-optimal CHSH(n) strategies.
Self-testing results allow us to infer the underlying quantum mechanical description of states and measurements from classical outputs produced by non-communicating parties. The standard definition of self-testing does not apply in situations when there are two or more inequivalent optimal strategies. To address this, we introduce the notion of self-testing convex combinations of reference strategies, which is a generalisation of self-testing to multiple strategies. We show that the Glued Magic Square game [Quantum 4 (2020), p. 346] self-tests a convex combination of two inequivalent strategies. As a corollary, we obtain that the Glued Magic square game self-tests two EPR pairs thus answering an open question from [Quantum 4 (2020), p. 346]. Our self-test is robust and extends to natural generalisations of the Glued Magic Square game.