Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2209.12925 · Physical Review A

Quantum superposition of causal structures as a universal resource for local implementation of nonlocal quantum operations

Pratik Ghosal, Arkaprabha Ghosal, Debarshi Das, Ananda G. Maity

Published Feb 15, 2023• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Spatial separation restricts the set of locally implementable quantum operations on distributed multipartite quantum systems. We propose that indefinite causal structure arising due to quantum superposition of different space-time geometries can be used as an independent universal resource for local implementation of any quantum operation on spatially distributed quantum systems. Consequently, all such quantum tasks that are not accomplishable by local operations and classical communication (LOCC) only also become locally accomplishable. We show that exploiting indefinite causal structure as the sole resource, it is possible to perfectly teleport the state of one agent's subsystem to the other distant laboratory in such a way that the agent at the distant laboratory can have access to the whole initially shared state in his or her laboratory and can perform any global quantum operation on the joint state locally. We further find that, after the teleportation process, the resource---indefinite causal structure of the space-time does not get consumed. Hence, after implementing the desired quantum operation the state of the first agent's subsystem can be teleported back to its previous laboratory using the same resource. We show that this two-way teleportation is not always necessary for locally executing all nonlocal quantum tasks that are not realizable by LOCC only. Without invoking any kind of teleportation, we present a protocol for perfect local discrimination of the set of four Bell states that exploits indefinite causal structure as the sole resource. As immediate upshots, we present some more examples of such nonlocal tasks as local discrimination of the set of states exhibiting ``quantum nonlocality without entanglement'' and activation of bound entangled states that are also achievable by our proposed protocol incorporating indefinite causal structure as a resource.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.107.022613

Related papers

Trading Causal Order for Locality

Ravi Kunjwal, Ämin Baumeler

Quantum theory admits ensembles of quantum nonlocality without entanglement (QNLWE). These ensembles consist of seemingly classical states (they are perfectly distinguishable and nonentangled) that cannot be perfectly discriminated with local operations and classical communication (LOCC). Here, we analyze QNLWE from a causal perspective, and show how to perfectly discriminate some of these ensembles using local operations and classical communication without definite causal order. Specifically, three parties with access to an instance of indefinite causal order-the Araújo-Feix-Baumeler-Wolf process-can perfectly discriminate the states in a QNLWE ensemble-the SHIFT ensemble-with local operations. Hence, this type of quantum nonlocality disappears at the expense of definite causal order while retaining classical communication. Our results thereby leverage the fact that LOCC is a conjunction of three constraints: local operations, classical communication, and definite causal order. Moreover, we show how multipartite generalizations of the Araújo-Feix-Baumeler-Wolf process are transformed into multiqubit ensembles that exhibit QNLWE. Such ensembles are of independent interest for cryptographic protocols and for the study of separable quantum operations unachievable with LOCC.

arXiv:2202.00440•Physical Review Letters•Sep 18, 2023•3 citations

Quantum teleportation of quantum causal structures

Marius Krumm, Philippe Allard Guérin, Thomas Zauner +1 more

Quantum teleportation is a very helpful information-theoretic protocol that allows to transfer an unknown arbitrary quantum state from one location to another without having to transmit the quantum system through the intermediate region. Quantum states, quantum channels, and indefinite causal structures are all examples of quantum causal structures that not only enable advanced quantum information processing functions, but can also model causal structures in nonclassical spacetimes. In this letter, we develop quantum teleportation of arbitrary quantum causal structures, as formalized by the process matrix framework. Instead of teleporting all the physical degrees of freedom that implement the causal structure, the central idea is to just teleport the inputs to and outputs from the operations of agents. The communication of outcomes of Bell state measurements, which is necessary for deterministic quantum teleportation, is not possible for all causal structures that one might wish to investigate. To avoid this problem, we propose partially and fully post-selected teleportation protocols. We prove that our partially post-selected teleportation protocol is compatible with all quantum causal structures, including those that involve indefinite causal order.

arXiv:2203.00433•Mar 1, 2022•1 citation

Indefinite causal order with output-signalling instruments

Ricardo Silveira, Patrick Andriolo, Davide Poderini +2 more

Quantum processes can exhibit indefinite causal order, allowing coherent superpositions of distinct orderings of events. Whether such processes generate genuinely noncausal statistics, however, depends not only on their global causal structure but also on the local operations available to the parties. Here, we restrict communication to the classical outcomes of local operations, yielding a causal polytope with new causal inequalities that can be violated using measure-and-reprepare, entanglement-breaking instruments requiring no coherent transmission through the laboratories. Using a semidefinite-programming framework, we bound the achievable violations and reveal noncausal correlations that satisfy all conventional input-signalling inequalities, demonstrating that restricting the information available for communication can uncover forms of indefinite causal order inaccessible under less restrictive operational assumptions.

quant-pharXiv:2609.31863•Sep 29, 2026•0 citations

Achieving Maximal Causal Indefiniteness in a Maximally Nonlocal Theory

Kuntal Sengupta

Quantum theory allows for the superposition of causal orders between operations, i.e., for an indefinite causal order; an implication of the principle of quantum superposition. Since a higher theory might also admit this feature, an understanding of superposition and indefinite causal order in a generalised probabilistic framework is needed. We present a possible notion of superposition for such a framework and show that in maximal theories, respecting non-signalling relations, single system state-spaces do not admit superposition; however, composite systems do. Additionally, we show that superposition does not imply entanglement. Next, we provide a concrete example of a maximally Bell-nonlocal theory, which not only admits the presented notion of superposition, but also allows for post-quantum violations of theory-independent inequalities that certify indefinite causal order; even up to an algebraic bound. These findings might point towards potential connections between a theory's ability to admit indefinite causal order, Bell-nonlocal correlations and the structure of its state spaces.

arXiv:2411.04201•Nov 6, 2024•0 citations

Entanglement as a resource for local state discrimination in multipartite systems

Somshubhro Bandyopadhyay, Saronath Halder, Michael Nathanson

We explore the question of using an entangled state as a universal resource for implementing quantum measurements by local operations and classical communication (LOCC). We show that for most systems consisting of three or more subsystems, there is no entangled state from the same space that can enable all measurements by LOCC. This is in direct contrast to the bipartite case, where a maximally entangled state is a universal resource. Our results are obtained showing an equivalence between the problem of local state transformation and that of entanglement-assisted local unambiguous state discrimination.

arXiv:1510.02443•Physical Review A•Aug 11, 2016•62 citations

Practical implementation of arbitrary nonlocal controlled-unitary gate via indefinite causal order

Wen-Qiang Liu, Zi-Han Zheng, Zhang-Qi Yin +1 more

Quantum gate teleportation enables the implementation of nonlocal quantum operations without direct interactions between distant nodes. We propose an efficient protocol for implementing arbitrary controlled-unitary (CU) gates acting on two spatially separated parties via indefinite causal order (ICO). By establishing a maximally entanglement between two remote nodes and coherently superposing orders of single-qubit gates, our protocol circumvents the drawback of complex local two-qubit operations. This ICO-based approach enables full programmability of CU gates by adjusting the inherent single-qubit operations, offering advantages over conventional fixed causal-order methods in terms of reduced circuit complexity and improved experimental flexibility. Furthermore, we develop an optical construction to implement the polarization CU gate using a stable and reciprocal Sagnac interferometer. Our work establishes a practical framework for scalable distributed quantum computation with flexible operations.

quant-pharXiv:2603.08073•New Journal of Physics•Mar 10, 2026•2 citations
Spatial separation restricts the set of locally implementable quantum operations on distributed multipartite quantum systems. We propose that indefinite causal structure arising due to quantum superposition of different space-time geometries can be used as an independent universal resource for local implementation of any quantum operation on spatially distributed quantum systems. Consequently, all such quantum tasks that are not accomplishable by local operations and classical communication (LOCC) only also become locally accomplishable. We show that exploiting indefinite causal structure as the sole resource, it is possible to perfectly teleport the state of one agent's subsystem to the other distant laboratory in such a way that the agent at the distant laboratory can have access to the whole initially shared state in his or her laboratory and can perform any global quantum operation on the joint state locally. We further find that, after the teleportation process, the resource---indefinite causal structure of the space-time does not get consumed. Hence, after implementing the desired quantum operation the state of the first agent's subsystem can be teleported back to its previous laboratory using the same resource. We show that this two-way teleportation is not always necessary for locally executing all nonlocal quantum tasks that are not realizable by LOCC only. Without invoking any kind of teleportation, we present a protocol for perfect local discrimination of the set of four Bell states that exploits indefinite causal structure as the sole resource. As immediate upshots, we present some more examples of such nonlocal tasks as local discrimination of the set of states exhibiting ``quantum nonlocality without entanglement'' and activation of bound entangled states that are also achievable by our proposed protocol incorporating indefinite causal structure as a resource.
Quantum theory admits ensembles of quantum nonlocality without entanglement (QNLWE). These ensembles consist of seemingly classical states (they are perfectly distinguishable and nonentangled) that cannot be perfectly discriminated with local operations and classical communication (LOCC). Here, we analyze QNLWE from a causal perspective, and show how to perfectly discriminate some of these ensembles using local operations and classical communication without definite causal order. Specifically, three parties with access to an instance of indefinite causal order-the Araújo-Feix-Baumeler-Wolf process-can perfectly discriminate the states in a QNLWE ensemble-the SHIFT ensemble-with local operations. Hence, this type of quantum nonlocality disappears at the expense of definite causal order while retaining classical communication. Our results thereby leverage the fact that LOCC is a conjunction of three constraints: local operations, classical communication, and definite causal order. Moreover, we show how multipartite generalizations of the Araújo-Feix-Baumeler-Wolf process are transformed into multiqubit ensembles that exhibit QNLWE. Such ensembles are of independent interest for cryptographic protocols and for the study of separable quantum operations unachievable with LOCC.
Quantum teleportation is a very helpful information-theoretic protocol that allows to transfer an unknown arbitrary quantum state from one location to another without having to transmit the quantum system through the intermediate region. Quantum states, quantum channels, and indefinite causal structures are all examples of quantum causal structures that not only enable advanced quantum information processing functions, but can also model causal structures in nonclassical spacetimes. In this letter, we develop quantum teleportation of arbitrary quantum causal structures, as formalized by the process matrix framework. Instead of teleporting all the physical degrees of freedom that implement the causal structure, the central idea is to just teleport the inputs to and outputs from the operations of agents. The communication of outcomes of Bell state measurements, which is necessary for deterministic quantum teleportation, is not possible for all causal structures that one might wish to investigate. To avoid this problem, we propose partially and fully post-selected teleportation protocols. We prove that our partially post-selected teleportation protocol is compatible with all quantum causal structures, including those that involve indefinite causal order.
Quantum processes can exhibit indefinite causal order, allowing coherent superpositions of distinct orderings of events. Whether such processes generate genuinely noncausal statistics, however, depends not only on their global causal structure but also on the local operations available to the parties. Here, we restrict communication to the classical outcomes of local operations, yielding a causal polytope with new causal inequalities that can be violated using measure-and-reprepare, entanglement-breaking instruments requiring no coherent transmission through the laboratories. Using a semidefinite-programming framework, we bound the achievable violations and reveal noncausal correlations that satisfy all conventional input-signalling inequalities, demonstrating that restricting the information available for communication can uncover forms of indefinite causal order inaccessible under less restrictive operational assumptions.
Quantum theory allows for the superposition of causal orders between operations, i.e., for an indefinite causal order; an implication of the principle of quantum superposition. Since a higher theory might also admit this feature, an understanding of superposition and indefinite causal order in a generalised probabilistic framework is needed. We present a possible notion of superposition for such a framework and show that in maximal theories, respecting non-signalling relations, single system state-spaces do not admit superposition; however, composite systems do. Additionally, we show that superposition does not imply entanglement. Next, we provide a concrete example of a maximally Bell-nonlocal theory, which not only admits the presented notion of superposition, but also allows for post-quantum violations of theory-independent inequalities that certify indefinite causal order; even up to an algebraic bound. These findings might point towards potential connections between a theory's ability to admit indefinite causal order, Bell-nonlocal correlations and the structure of its state spaces.
We explore the question of using an entangled state as a universal resource for implementing quantum measurements by local operations and classical communication (LOCC). We show that for most systems consisting of three or more subsystems, there is no entangled state from the same space that can enable all measurements by LOCC. This is in direct contrast to the bipartite case, where a maximally entangled state is a universal resource. Our results are obtained showing an equivalence between the problem of local state transformation and that of entanglement-assisted local unambiguous state discrimination.
Quantum gate teleportation enables the implementation of nonlocal quantum operations without direct interactions between distant nodes. We propose an efficient protocol for implementing arbitrary controlled-unitary (CU) gates acting on two spatially separated parties via indefinite causal order (ICO). By establishing a maximally entanglement between two remote nodes and coherently superposing orders of single-qubit gates, our protocol circumvents the drawback of complex local two-qubit operations. This ICO-based approach enables full programmability of CU gates by adjusting the inherent single-qubit operations, offering advantages over conventional fixed causal-order methods in terms of reduced circuit complexity and improved experimental flexibility. Furthermore, we develop an optical construction to implement the polarization CU gate using a stable and reciprocal Sagnac interferometer. Our work establishes a practical framework for scalable distributed quantum computation with flexible operations.