Abstract Materials simulations involving strongly correlated electrons pose fundamental challenges to state‐of‐the‐art electronic structure methods but are hypothesized to be the ideal use case for quantum computing algorithms. To date, no quantum computer has simulated a molecule of a size and complexity relevant to real‐world applications, despite the fact that the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) algorithm can predict chemically accurate total energies. Nevertheless, because of the many applications of moderately sized, strongly correlated systems, such as molecular catalysts, the successful use of the VQE stands as an important waypoint in the advancement toward useful chemical modeling on near‐term quantum processors. In this paper, we take a significant step in this direction. We lay out the steps, write, and run parallel code for an (emulated) quantum computer to compute the bond dissociation curves of the TiH, LiH, NaH, and KH diatomic hydride molecules using the VQE. TiH was chosen as a relatively simple chemical system that incorporates d orbitals and strong electron correlation. Because current VQE implementations on existing quantum hardware are limited by qubit error rates, the number of qubits available, and the allowable gate depth, recent studies using it have focused on chemical systems involving s and p block elements. Through VQE + UCCSD calculations of TiH, we evaluate the near‐term feasibility of modeling a molecule with d‐orbitals on real quantum hardware. We demonstrate that the inclusion of d‐orbitals and the use of the UCCSD ansatz, which are both necessary to capture the correct TiH physics, dramatically increase the cost of this problem. We estimate the approximate error rates necessary to model TiH on current quantum computing hardware using VQE + UCCSD and show them to likely be prohibitive until significant improvements in hardware and error correction algorithms are available.
Abstract Materials simulations involving strongly correlated electrons pose fundamental challenges to state‐of‐the‐art electronic structure methods but are hypothesized to be the ideal use case for quantum computing algorithms. To date, no quantum computer has simulated a molecule of a size and complexity relevant to real‐world applications, despite the fact that the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) algorithm can predict chemically accurate total energies. Nevertheless, because of the many applications of moderately sized, strongly correlated systems, such as molecular catalysts, the successful use of the VQE stands as an important waypoint in the advancement toward useful chemical modeling on near‐term quantum processors. In this paper, we take a significant step in this direction. We lay out the steps, write, and run parallel code for an (emulated) quantum computer to compute the bond dissociation curves of the TiH, LiH, NaH, and KH diatomic hydride molecules using the VQE. TiH was chosen as a relatively simple chemical system that incorporates d orbitals and strong electron correlation. Because current VQE implementations on existing quantum hardware are limited by qubit error rates, the number of qubits available, and the allowable gate depth, recent studies using it have focused on chemical systems involving s and p block elements. Through VQE + UCCSD calculations of TiH, we evaluate the near‐term feasibility of modeling a molecule with d‐orbitals on real quantum hardware. We demonstrate that the inclusion of d‐orbitals and the use of the UCCSD ansatz, which are both necessary to capture the correct TiH physics, dramatically increase the cost of this problem. We estimate the approximate error rates necessary to model TiH on current quantum computing hardware using VQE + UCCSD and show them to likely be prohibitive until significant improvements in hardware and error correction algorithms are available.
This software supports the paper, "Exploring the scaling limitations of the variational quantum eigensolver with the bond dissociation of hydride diatomic molecules," published in the International Journal of Quantum Chemistry, whose abstract is as follows: Materials simulations involving strongly correlated electrons pose fundamental challenges to state-of-the-art electronic structure methods but are hypothesized to be the ideal use case for quantum computing. To date, no quantum computer has simulated a molecule of a size and complexity relevant to real-world applications, despite the fact that the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) algorithm can predict chemically accurate total energies. Nevertheless, because of the many applications of moderately-sized, strongly correlated systems, such as molecular catalysts, the successful use of the VQE stands as an important waypoint in the advancement toward useful chemical modeling on near-term quantum processors. In this paper, we take a significant step in this direction. We lay out the steps, write, and run parallel code for an (emulated) quantum computer to compute the bond dissociation curves of the TiH, LiH, NaH, and KH diatomic hydride molecules using VQE. TiH was chosen as a relatively simple chemical system that incorporates d orbitals and strong electron correlation. Because current VQE implementations on existing quantum hardware are limited by qubit error rates, the number of qubits available, and the allowable gate depth, recent studies have focused on chemical systems involving s and p block elements. Through VQE + UCCSD calculations of TiH, we evaluate the near-term feasibility of modeling a molecule with d-orbitals on real quantum hardware. We demonstrate that the inclusion of d-orbitals and the use of the UCCSD ansatz, which are both necessary to capture the correct TiH physics, dramatically increase the cost of this problem. We estimate the approximate error rates necessary to model TiH on current quantum computing hardware using VQE+UCCSD and show them to likely be prohibitive until significant improvements in hardware and error correction algorithms are available.
Abstract Variational quantum eigensolvers (VQE) are among the most promising approaches for solving electronic structure problems on near-term quantum computers. A critical challenge for VQE in practice is that one needs to strike a balance between the expressivity of the VQE ansatz versus the number of quantum gates required to implement the ansatz, given the reality of noisy quantum operations on near-term quantum computers. In this work, we consider an orbital-optimized pair-correlated approximation to the unitary coupled cluster with singles and doubles (uCCSD) ansatz and report a highly efficient quantum circuit implementation for trapped-ion architectures. We show that orbital optimization can recover significant additional electron correlation energy without sacrificing efficiency through measurements of low-order reduced density matrices (RDMs). In the dissociation of small molecules, the method gives qualitatively accurate predictions in the strongly-correlated regime when running on noise-free quantum simulators. On IonQ’s Harmony and Aria trapped-ion quantum computers, we run end-to-end VQE algorithms with up to 12 qubits and 72 variational parameters—the largest full VQE simulation with a correlated wave function on quantum hardware. We find that even without error mitigation techniques, the predicted relative energies across different molecular geometries are in excellent agreement with noise-free simulators.
One of the most important application areas of molecular quantum chemistry is the study and prediction of chemical reactivity. Large-scale, fully error-tolerant quantum computers could provide exact or near-exact solutions to the underlying electronic structure problem with exponentially less effort than a classical computer thus enabling highly accurate predictions for comparably large molecular systems. In the nearer future, however, only “noisy” devices with a limited number of qubits that are subject to decoherence will be available. For such near-term quantum computers the hybrid quantum-classical variational quantum eigensolver algorithm in combination with the unitary coupled-cluster ansatz (UCCSD-VQE) [Peruzzo et al. Nat. Commun. 2014, 5, 4213 and McClean et al. New J. Phys. 2016, 18, 023023] has become an intensively discussed approach that could provide accurate results before the dawn of error-tolerant quantum computing. In this work we present an implementation of UCCSD-VQE that allows for the first time to treat both open- and closed-shell molecules. We study the accuracy of the obtained energies for nine small molecular systems as well as for four exemplary chemical reactions by comparing to well-established electronic structure methods like (nonunitary) coupled-cluster and density functional theory. Finally, we roughly estimate the required quantum hardware resources to obtain “useful” results for practical purposes.
The accurate prediction and understanding of molecular energy and chemical reactivity are fundamental pursuits in the field of molecular quantum chemistry. With the limitations of the current noisy intermediate scale quantum computer (NISQ) era, the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) algorithm offers a promising approach to efficiently estimate the stable energy state of a given molecule. This study is focused on predicting the ground state and single electron detachment energy of the hydride ion because of its high electron electron correlation and numerous applications in astrophysics and quantum chemistry. The hydride ion is the first three body quantum problem for which the ground state energy has been calculated theoretically using the Chandrasekhar Wavefunction, which takes high electron-electron correlation into account. For the calculation of hydride ion, we used the VQE algorithm with two types of quantum computational ansatz, (i) chemistry inspired ansatz based on unitary CC (UCC) and (ii) hardware efficient based ansatz (HEA). To check the versatility of the algorithm, we analyzed two proton transfer reactions involving the hydride ion and finds the energy to be exothermic with a much improved result compared to previous studies. Overall, the VQE algorithm with a quantum computational approach is found to be reliable in calculating stable state energy, single electron detachment energy, and reaction energy for proton transfer reactions involving a highly correlated molecule with a low relative percentage error.
High Resolution Image Download MS PowerPoint Slide Quantum computers have the potential to efficiently solve the electronic structure problem but are currently limited by noise and shallow circuits. We present an enhanced Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) ansatz based on the Qubit Coupled Cluster (QCC) approach that requires optimization of only n parameters, where n is the number of Pauli string generators, rather than the typical n + 2 m parameters, where m is the number of qubits. We evaluate the ground state energies and molecular dissociation curves of strongly correlated molecules, namely O 3 and Li 4, using active spaces of varying sizes in conjunction with our enhanced QCC ansatz, Unitary Coupled Cluster Single–Double (UCCSD) ansatz, and the classical Coupled Cluster Singles and Doubles (CCSD) method. Compared to UCCSD, our approach significantly reduces the number of parameters while maintaining high accuracy. Numerical simulations demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach, and experiments on superconducting and trapped-ion quantum computers showcase its practicality on real hardware. By eliminating the need for symmetry-restoring gates and reducing the number of parameters, our enhanced QCC ansatz enables accurate quantum chemistry calculations on near-term quantum devices for strongly correlated systems.
Assessment of the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) for bond dissociation of H2, H3+, and CH5+
Abstract Context The variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) is a quantum-classical algorithm for estimating molecular ground-state energies. However, the accuracy depends on the choice of ansatz , active space, and initial variational parameters. Hence, it is relevant to perform assessments of VQE. The dissociation profiles of H 2 2 , H 3+ 3 + , and CH 5+ 5 + were chosen for these assessments. For H 2 2 and H 3+ 3 + , the UCCSD, GateFabric, and k -UpCCGSD ansätze reproduced the dissociation profiles with high accuracy. For CH 5+ 5 + , GateFabric and k -UpCCGSD provided the best compromise between accuracy and scalability. Hardware-efficient ansätze (HEA), particularly HEA-A and HEA-B, produced significant deviations from the reference energies. The results also demonstrate that larger numbers of parameters or logic gates do not necessarily improve VQE performance. Furthermore, some ansätze , especially GRSD and EHA, showed sensitivity to the initialization of the parameters. Methods Reference geometries and energies were obtained at the CISD/STO-3 G level using Gaussian 09. VQE simulations were performed with the PennyLane library employing the Jordan-Wigner mapping. The ansätze evaluated were UCCSD, k -UpCCGSD, GateFabric, GRSD, HEA-A, HEA-B, HEA-C, and Entanglement-variational Hardware-efficient Ansatz (EHA). Dissociation profiles were generated by varying interatomic distances and angular coordinates for H 2 2 and H 3+ 3 + , as well as the C-H 2 2 dissociation coordinate for CH 5+ 5 + . Active-space ranging from 2/2 to 8/8 electrons/orbitals was employed for CH 5+ 5 + . Variational parameters were optimized using stochastic gradient descent with a convergence threshold of 1×10−6 1 × 10