Entanglement phase transitions in hybrid quantum circuits describe individual quantum trajectories rather than the measurement-averaged ensemble, despite the fact that results of measurements are not conventionally used for feedback. Here, we numerically demonstrate that a class of generalized measurements with identical measurement-averaged dynamics give different phases and phase transitions. We show that measurement-averaged destruction of Bell state entanglement is a useful proxy for determining which hybrid circuit yields the lowest-entanglement dynamics. We use this to argue that no unfolding of our model can avoid a volume law phase, which has implications for simulation of open quantum systems.
Entanglement phase transitions in hybrid quantum circuits describe individual quantum trajectories rather than the measurement-averaged ensemble, despite the fact that results of measurements are not conventionally used for feedback. Here, we numerically demonstrate that a class of generalized measurements with identical measurement-averaged dynamics give different phases and phase transitions. We show that measurement-averaged destruction of Bell state entanglement is a useful proxy for determining which hybrid circuit yields the lowest-entanglement dynamics. We use this to argue that no unfolding of our model can avoid a volume law phase, which has implications for simulation of open quantum systems.
Entanglement phase transitions in hybrid quantum circuits are generally argued to be properties of the individual trajectories rather than measurement-averaged dynamics, despite the fact that results of measurements are not used for feedback in the steady state. Here, we explicitly demonstrate this difference by constructing a family of hybrid quantum circuits with identical measurement-averaged dynamics that give different phases and phase transitions. We propose measurement-averaged destruction of Bell state entanglement as a proxy for determining which hybrid circuit yields the lowest-entanglement dynamics and show that it holds numerically for the measurements we consider. We comment on implications for quantum computing and noisy quantum circuits.
The intensely studied measurement-induced entanglement phase transition has become a hallmark of nonunitary quantum many-body dynamics. Usually, such a transition only appears at the level of each individual quantum trajectory, and is absent for the density matrix averaged over measurement outcomes. In this work, we introduce a class of adaptive random circuit models with feedback that exhibit transitions in both settings. After each measurement, a unitary operation is either applied or not depending on the measurement outcome, which steers the averaged density matrix towards a unique state above a certain measurement threshold. Interestingly, the transition for the density matrix and the entanglement transition in the individual quantum trajectory in general happen at different critical measurement rates. We demonstrate that the former transition belongs to the parity-conserving universality class by explicitly mapping to a classical branching-annihilating random-walk process.
Unitary circuits subject to repeated projective measurements can undergo an entanglement phase transition (EPT) as a function of the measurement rate.This transition is generally understood in terms of a competition between the scrambling effects of unitary dynamics and the disentangling effects of measurements.We find that, surprisingly, EPTs are possible even in the absence of scrambling unitary dynamics, where they are best understood as arising from measurements alone.This finding motivates us to introduce measurement-only models, in which the "scrambling" and "unscrambling" effects driving the EPT are fundamentally intertwined and cannot be attributed to physically distinct processes.These models represent a novel form of an EPT, conceptually distinct from that in hybrid unitary-projective circuits.We explore the entanglement phase diagrams, critical points, and quantum code properties of some of these measurement-only models.We find that the principle driving the EPTs in these models is frustration, or mutual incompatibility, of the measurements.Surprisingly, an entangling (volume-law) phase is the generic outcome when measuring sufficiently long but still local (≳3-body) operators.We identify a class of exceptions to this behavior ("bipartite ensembles") which cannot sustain an entangling phase but display dual area-law phases, possibly with different kinds of quantum order, separated by self-dual critical points.Finally, we introduce a measure of information spreading in dynamics with measurements and use it to demonstrate the emergence of a statistical light cone, despite the nonlocality inherent to quantum measurements.
Measurement-induced entanglement transitions arise in quantum circuits of unitary gates and measurements, referred to as hybrid circuits. On average, unitary dynamics generate entanglement, and measurements suppress entanglement. In one-dimensional hybrid circuits, this competition leads to a transition between an area-law phase when the probability of measurements is higher, and a volume-law entangled phase when the probability is lower. In this thesis, the phase transition is studied using two different approaches. First, state vector simulations are performed for hybrid circuits composed of Haar-random unitary gates and random Clifford gates. This allows for direct access to the state vectors and entanglement entropy, but is only feasible for smaller size systems (up to 12 qubits). Second, a traffic flow model is implemented as an approximation to stabiliser dynamics of Clifford circuits, which is studied for larger systems (up to 2048 qubits). Scaling analyses are carried out for both approaches to investigate the dependence of the steady-state entropy on system size and measurement probability. Data collapses of simulation data for different circuit sizes are obtained using both a logarithmic form S−αlnN and by also including an additional correction S−αlnN+βN^(−ω) where ω = 1, leading to a more accurate collapse for smaller sizes. Both the state vector model and traffic flow model lead to a phase transition in entanglement entropy, but with different critical parameters. This indicates that the traffic flow model and the quantum circuit models do not belong to the same universality class. The results clarify the efficiency but also limitations of classical models for describing measurement-induced entanglement transitions.
When subject to a nonlocal unitary evolution, qubits in a quantum circuit become increasingly entangled. Conversely, measurements applied to individual qubits lead to their disentanglement from the collective system. The extent of entanglement reduction depends on the frequency of local projective measurements. A delicate balance emerges between unitary evolution, which enhances entanglement, and measurements which diminish it. In the thermodynamic limit, there is a phase transition from volume law entanglement to area law entanglement at a critical value of measurement frequency. This phenomenon, occurring in hybrid quantum circuits with both unitary gates and measurements, is termed as measurement-induced phase transition (MIPT). We study the behavior of MIPT in circuits comprising of two-qubit unitary gates parameterized by Cartan decomposition. We show that the entangling power and gate typicality of the two-qubit local unitaries employed in the circuit can be used to explain the behavior of global bipartite entanglement the circuit can sustain. When the two-qubit gate throughout the circuit is the identity and measurements are the sole driver of the entanglement behavior, we obtain an analytical estimate for the entanglement entropy that shows remarkable agreement with numerical simulations. We also find that the entangling power and gate typicality enable the classification of the two-qubit unitaries by different universality classes of phase transitions that can occur in the hybrid circuit. For all unitaries in a particular universality class, the transition from volume to area law of entanglement occurs with the same exponent that characterizes the phase transition.
We investigate the distribution of entanglement entropy in hybrid quantum circuits consisting of random unitary gates and local measurements applied at a finite rate. We demonstrate that higher moments of the entanglement entropy distribution, such as the ratio between the variance and the mean and the skewness, capture nontrivial features of the measurement-induced dynamics that are invisible to the mean entropy alone. We demonstrate that these quantities exhibit distinct and robust behaviors across the volume-law and area-law phases, and can serve as effective diagnostics of measurement-induced entanglement transitions. We propose a phenomenological model describing the effect of measurements in the area-law regime, which, when combined with the directed polymer in a random environment description of the volume-law phase, well matches numerical simulations across the entire phase diagram.