Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2004.09560 · Physical Review X

Entanglement Phase Transitions in Measurement-Only Dynamics

Matteo Ippoliti, Michael J. Gullans, Sarang Gopalakrishnan, David A. Huse, Vedika Khemani

Published Feb 15, 2021• 277 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Unitary circuits subject to repeated projective measurements can undergo an entanglement phase transition (EPT) as a function of the measurement rate.This transition is generally understood in terms of a competition between the scrambling effects of unitary dynamics and the disentangling effects of measurements.We find that, surprisingly, EPTs are possible even in the absence of scrambling unitary dynamics, where they are best understood as arising from measurements alone.This finding motivates us to introduce measurement-only models, in which the "scrambling" and "unscrambling" effects driving the EPT are fundamentally intertwined and cannot be attributed to physically distinct processes.These models represent a novel form of an EPT, conceptually distinct from that in hybrid unitary-projective circuits.We explore the entanglement phase diagrams, critical points, and quantum code properties of some of these measurement-only models.We find that the principle driving the EPTs in these models is frustration, or mutual incompatibility, of the measurements.Surprisingly, an entangling (volume-law) phase is the generic outcome when measuring sufficiently long but still local (≳3-body) operators.We identify a class of exceptions to this behavior ("bipartite ensembles") which cannot sustain an entangling phase but display dual area-law phases, possibly with different kinds of quantum order, separated by self-dual critical points.Finally, we introduce a measure of information spreading in dynamics with measurements and use it to demonstrate the emergence of a statistical light cone, despite the nonlocality inherent to quantum measurements.

DOI
10.1103/physrevx.11.011030

Related papers

Phase transition and evidence of fast-scrambling phase in measurement-only quantum circuits

Yoshihito Kuno, Takahiro Orito, Ikuo Ichinose

Information scrambling is nowadays one of the most important topics in various fields of research. Measurement-only circuits (MoCs) exhibit specific information scrambling dynamics, depending on the types of projective measurements and their mutual anticommutativity. The spatial range of the projective measurements in MoCs gives significant influences on circuit dynamics. In this work, we introduce and study long-range MoCs, which exhibit an interesting behavior in their dynamics. In particular, the long-range measurements can induce volume-law phases in MoCs without unitary time evolution, which come from anticommutative frustration of measurements specific to the long-range MoCs. This phenomenon occurs even in MoCs composed of solely two-body measurements, and it accompanies an entanglement phase transition. Crucially, our numerics find evidences that MoCs can be a fast scrambler. Interplay of high anticommutativity among measurements and their long-range properties generates fast entanglement growth in the whole system beyond linear-light-cone spreading.

arXiv:2307.07170•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 11, 2023•10 citations

Unitary-projective entanglement dynamics

Amos Chan, Rahul Nandkishore, Michael Pretko +1 more

Starting from a state of low quantum entanglement, local unitary time evolution increases the entanglement of a quantum many-body system. In contrast, local projective measurements disentangle degrees of freedom and decrease entanglement. We study the interplay of these competing tendencies by considering time evolution combining both unitary and projective dynamics. We begin by constructing a toy model of Bell pair dynamics which demonstrates that measurements can keep a system in a state of low, i.e., area-law, entanglement, in contrast with the volume-law entanglement produced by generic pure unitary time evolution. While the simplest Bell pair model has area-law entanglement for any measurement rate, as seen in certain noninteracting systems, we show that more generic models of entanglement can feature an area-to-volume law transition at a critical value of the measurement rate, in agreement with recent numerical investigations. As a concrete example of these ideas, we analytically investigate Clifford evolution in qubit systems which can exhibit an entanglement transition. We are able to identify stabilizer size distributions characterizing the area law, volume law, and critical ``fixed points.'' We also discuss a Floquet random unitary circuit, where the answers depend on the order of limits---one order of limits yields area-law entanglement for any nonzero measurement rate, whereas a different order of limits allows for an arealaw--volumelaw transition. Finally, we provide a rigorous argument that a system subjected to projective measurements can only exhibit a volume-law entanglement entropy if it also features a subleading correction term, which provides a universal signature of projective dynamics in the high-entanglement phase.

arXiv:1808.05949•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 24, 2019•474 citations

Non-commutative Index of Measurement-only Entanglement Phase Transition

Zhichen Huang, Chunxiao Du, Yang Zhou +1 more

Measurement-only models offer an ideal platform for exploring entanglement dynamics in the absence of unitary evolution. Despite extensive numerical evidence for entanglement phase transitions in measurement-only dynamics, the underlying mechanism attributed to non-commutativity among multi-site projective measurements has remained qualitative and coarse-grained. In this work, we identify a quantitative non-commutative index for spatially and temporally homogeneous Pauli stabilizer measurement-only circuits. By applying this index to three representative measurement-only models, we find that the emergence of a volume-law phase is governed by the non-commutative structure of the measurement ensemble, while the transition point is quantitatively determined by the amount of critical non-commutativity. More strikingly, the critical non-commutativity exhibits a linear scaling with the measurement range, independent of the microscopic details of the measurement ensembles. Our findings deepen the understanding of the fundamental mechanism behind the measurement-only entanglement phase transition.

quant-pharXiv:2602.23868•Physical Review A•Mar 2, 2026•0 citations

Measurement-driven entanglement transition in hybrid quantum circuits

Yaodong Li, Xiao Chen, Matthew P. A. Fisher

Quantum information tends to spread out in interacting systems, leading to thermalization as characterized by the volume-law entropy of entanglement, while local measurements that extract classical information of the state tend to interrupt the propagation of information and reduce the entanglement entropy. Can entanglement sustain repeated measurements? The authors address this question in a toy hybrid-circuit model, where qubits undergo both unitary time evolution and sporadic local measurements. The phase diagram features a stable volume-law phase of entanglement for weak measurements and an area-law phase for strong measurements. The two domains in the diagram are separated by a single second-order phase transition. Characterization of both phases as well as of the critical point are presented.

arXiv:1901.08092•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 15, 2019•596 citations

Quantum Error Correction in Scrambling Dynamics and Measurement-Induced Phase Transition

Soonwon Choi, Yimu Bao, Xiao-Liang Qi +1 more

We analyze the dynamics of entanglement entropy in a generic quantum many-body open system from the perspective of quantum information and error corrections. We introduce a random unitary circuit model with intermittent projective measurements, in which the degree of information scrambling by the unitary and the rate of projective measurements are independently controlled. This model displays two stable phases, characterized by the volume-law and area-law scaling entanglement entropy in steady states. The transition between the two phases is understood from the point of view of quantum error correction: the chaotic unitary evolution protects quantum information from projective measurements that act as errors. A phase transition occurs when the rate of errors exceeds a threshold that depends on the degree of information scrambling. We confirm these results using numerical simulations and obtain the phase diagram of our model. Our work shows that information scrambling plays a crucial role in understanding the dynamics of entanglement in an open quantum system and relates the entanglement phase transition to changes in quantum channel capacity.

arXiv:1903.05124•Physical Review Letters•Jul 15, 2020•436 citations

Measurement-Induced Phase Transitions in the Dynamics of Entanglement

Brian J. Skinner, Jonathan Ruhman, Adam Nahum

© 2019 authors. Published by the American Physical Society. We define dynamical universality classes for many-body systems whose unitary evolution is punctuated by projective measurements. In cases where such measurements occur randomly at a finite rate p for each degree of freedom, we show that the system has two dynamical phases: "entangling" and "disentangling." The former occurs for p smaller than a critical rate pc and is characterized by volume-law entanglement in the steady state and "ballistic" entanglement growth after a quench. By contrast, for p>pc the system can sustain only area-law entanglement. At p=pc the steady state is scale invariant, and in 1+1D, the entanglement grows logarithmically after a quench. To obtain a simple heuristic picture for the entangling-disentangling transition, we first construct a toy model that describes the zeroth Rényi entropy in discrete time. We solve this model exactly by mapping it to an optimization problem in classical percolation. The generic entangling-disentangling transition can be diagnosed using the von Neumann entropy and higher Rényi entropies, and it shares many qualitative features with the toy problem. We study the generic transition numerically in quantum spin chains and show that the phenomenology of the two phases is similar to that of the toy model but with distinct "quantum" critical exponents, which we calculate numerically in 1+1D. We examine two different cases for the unitary dynamics: Floquet dynamics for a nonintegrable Ising model, and random circuit dynamics. We obtain compatible universal properties in each case, indicating that the entangling-disentangling phase transition is generic for projectively measured many-body systems. We discuss the significance of this transition for numerical calculations of quantum observables in many-body systems.

•Jan 1, 2019•619 citations
Unitary circuits subject to repeated projective measurements can undergo an entanglement phase transition (EPT) as a function of the measurement rate.This transition is generally understood in terms of a competition between the scrambling effects of unitary dynamics and the disentangling effects of measurements.We find that, surprisingly, EPTs are possible even in the absence of scrambling unitary dynamics, where they are best understood as arising from measurements alone.This finding motivates us to introduce measurement-only models, in which the "scrambling" and "unscrambling" effects driving the EPT are fundamentally intertwined and cannot be attributed to physically distinct processes.These models represent a novel form of an EPT, conceptually distinct from that in hybrid unitary-projective circuits.We explore the entanglement phase diagrams, critical points, and quantum code properties of some of these measurement-only models.We find that the principle driving the EPTs in these models is frustration, or mutual incompatibility, of the measurements.Surprisingly, an entangling (volume-law) phase is the generic outcome when measuring sufficiently long but still local (≳3-body) operators.We identify a class of exceptions to this behavior ("bipartite ensembles") which cannot sustain an entangling phase but display dual area-law phases, possibly with different kinds of quantum order, separated by self-dual critical points.Finally, we introduce a measure of information spreading in dynamics with measurements and use it to demonstrate the emergence of a statistical light cone, despite the nonlocality inherent to quantum measurements.
Information scrambling is nowadays one of the most important topics in various fields of research. Measurement-only circuits (MoCs) exhibit specific information scrambling dynamics, depending on the types of projective measurements and their mutual anticommutativity. The spatial range of the projective measurements in MoCs gives significant influences on circuit dynamics. In this work, we introduce and study long-range MoCs, which exhibit an interesting behavior in their dynamics. In particular, the long-range measurements can induce volume-law phases in MoCs without unitary time evolution, which come from anticommutative frustration of measurements specific to the long-range MoCs. This phenomenon occurs even in MoCs composed of solely two-body measurements, and it accompanies an entanglement phase transition. Crucially, our numerics find evidences that MoCs can be a fast scrambler. Interplay of high anticommutativity among measurements and their long-range properties generates fast entanglement growth in the whole system beyond linear-light-cone spreading.
Starting from a state of low quantum entanglement, local unitary time evolution increases the entanglement of a quantum many-body system. In contrast, local projective measurements disentangle degrees of freedom and decrease entanglement. We study the interplay of these competing tendencies by considering time evolution combining both unitary and projective dynamics. We begin by constructing a toy model of Bell pair dynamics which demonstrates that measurements can keep a system in a state of low, i.e., area-law, entanglement, in contrast with the volume-law entanglement produced by generic pure unitary time evolution. While the simplest Bell pair model has area-law entanglement for any measurement rate, as seen in certain noninteracting systems, we show that more generic models of entanglement can feature an area-to-volume law transition at a critical value of the measurement rate, in agreement with recent numerical investigations. As a concrete example of these ideas, we analytically investigate Clifford evolution in qubit systems which can exhibit an entanglement transition. We are able to identify stabilizer size distributions characterizing the area law, volume law, and critical ``fixed points.'' We also discuss a Floquet random unitary circuit, where the answers depend on the order of limits---one order of limits yields area-law entanglement for any nonzero measurement rate, whereas a different order of limits allows for an arealaw--volumelaw transition. Finally, we provide a rigorous argument that a system subjected to projective measurements can only exhibit a volume-law entanglement entropy if it also features a subleading correction term, which provides a universal signature of projective dynamics in the high-entanglement phase.
Measurement-only models offer an ideal platform for exploring entanglement dynamics in the absence of unitary evolution. Despite extensive numerical evidence for entanglement phase transitions in measurement-only dynamics, the underlying mechanism attributed to non-commutativity among multi-site projective measurements has remained qualitative and coarse-grained. In this work, we identify a quantitative non-commutative index for spatially and temporally homogeneous Pauli stabilizer measurement-only circuits. By applying this index to three representative measurement-only models, we find that the emergence of a volume-law phase is governed by the non-commutative structure of the measurement ensemble, while the transition point is quantitatively determined by the amount of critical non-commutativity. More strikingly, the critical non-commutativity exhibits a linear scaling with the measurement range, independent of the microscopic details of the measurement ensembles. Our findings deepen the understanding of the fundamental mechanism behind the measurement-only entanglement phase transition.
Quantum information tends to spread out in interacting systems, leading to thermalization as characterized by the volume-law entropy of entanglement, while local measurements that extract classical information of the state tend to interrupt the propagation of information and reduce the entanglement entropy. Can entanglement sustain repeated measurements? The authors address this question in a toy hybrid-circuit model, where qubits undergo both unitary time evolution and sporadic local measurements. The phase diagram features a stable volume-law phase of entanglement for weak measurements and an area-law phase for strong measurements. The two domains in the diagram are separated by a single second-order phase transition. Characterization of both phases as well as of the critical point are presented.
We analyze the dynamics of entanglement entropy in a generic quantum many-body open system from the perspective of quantum information and error corrections. We introduce a random unitary circuit model with intermittent projective measurements, in which the degree of information scrambling by the unitary and the rate of projective measurements are independently controlled. This model displays two stable phases, characterized by the volume-law and area-law scaling entanglement entropy in steady states. The transition between the two phases is understood from the point of view of quantum error correction: the chaotic unitary evolution protects quantum information from projective measurements that act as errors. A phase transition occurs when the rate of errors exceeds a threshold that depends on the degree of information scrambling. We confirm these results using numerical simulations and obtain the phase diagram of our model. Our work shows that information scrambling plays a crucial role in understanding the dynamics of entanglement in an open quantum system and relates the entanglement phase transition to changes in quantum channel capacity.
© 2019 authors. Published by the American Physical Society. We define dynamical universality classes for many-body systems whose unitary evolution is punctuated by projective measurements. In cases where such measurements occur randomly at a finite rate p for each degree of freedom, we show that the system has two dynamical phases: "entangling" and "disentangling." The former occurs for p smaller than a critical rate pc and is characterized by volume-law entanglement in the steady state and "ballistic" entanglement growth after a quench. By contrast, for p>pc the system can sustain only area-law entanglement. At p=pc the steady state is scale invariant, and in 1+1D, the entanglement grows logarithmically after a quench. To obtain a simple heuristic picture for the entangling-disentangling transition, we first construct a toy model that describes the zeroth Rényi entropy in discrete time. We solve this model exactly by mapping it to an optimization problem in classical percolation. The generic entangling-disentangling transition can be diagnosed using the von Neumann entropy and higher Rényi entropies, and it shares many qualitative features with the toy problem. We study the generic transition numerically in quantum spin chains and show that the phenomenology of the two phases is similar to that of the toy model but with distinct "quantum" critical exponents, which we calculate numerically in 1+1D. We examine two different cases for the unitary dynamics: Floquet dynamics for a nonintegrable Ising model, and random circuit dynamics. We obtain compatible universal properties in each case, indicating that the entangling-disentangling phase transition is generic for projectively measured many-body systems. We discuss the significance of this transition for numerical calculations of quantum observables in many-body systems.