Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2110.14772 · International Journal of Geometric Methods in Modern Physics

On Penrose’s theory of objective gravitationally induced wave function reduction

Ricardo Gallego Torromé

Published Nov 27, 2021• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper, the formal structure of Penrose’s gravitationally induced reduction of the wave function mechanism is analyzed. It is shown that pushing Penrose’s argument forward leads to the interpretation of quantum coherence in microscopic systems as an observable signature violation of general covariance. We discuss potential avenues to avoid this conclusion, among them emergent quantum mechanics and super-determinism.

DOI
10.1142/s0219887822500207

Related papers

Why the quantum must yield to gravity

Joy Christian

After providing an extensive overview of the conceptual elements -- such as Einstein's `hole argument' -- that underpin Penrose's proposal for gravitationally induced quantum state reduction, the proposal is constructively criticised. Penrose has suggested a mechanism for objective reduction of quantum states with postulated collapse time T = h/E, where E is an ill-definedness in the gravitational self-energy stemming from the profound conflict between the principles of superposition and general covariance. Here it is argued that, even if Penrose's overall conceptual scheme for the breakdown of quantum mechanics is unreservedly accepted, his formula for the collapse time of superpositions reduces to T --> oo (E --> 0) in the strictly Newtonian regime, which is the domain of his proposed experiment to corroborate the effect. A suggestion is made to rectify this situation. In particular, recognising the cogency of Penrose's reasoning in the domain of full `quantum gravity', it is demonstrated that an appropriate experiment which could in principle corroborate his argued `macroscopic' breakdown of superpositions is not the one involving non-rotating mass distributions as he has suggested, but a Leggett-type SQUID or BEC experiment involving superposed mass distributions in relative rotation. The demonstration thereby brings out one of the distinctive characteristics of Penrose's scheme, rendering it empirically distinguishable from other state reduction theories involving gravity. As an aside, a new geometrical measure of gravity-induced deviation from quantum mechanics in the manner of Penrose is proposed, but now for the canonical commutation relations [Q, P] = ih.

arXiv:gr-qc/9810078•Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 29, 2001•13 citations

Collapse of neutrino wave functions under Penrose gravitational reduction

B. J. P. Jones, Olivia Seidel

Models of spontaneous wave function collapse have been postulated to address the measurement problem in quantum mechanics. Their primary function is to convert coherent quantum superpositions into incoherent ones, with the result that macroscopic objects cannot be placed into widely separated superpositions for observably prolonged times. Many of these processes will also lead to loss of coherence in neutrino oscillations, producing observable signatures in the flavor profile of neutrinos at long travel distances. The majority of studies of neutrino oscillation coherence to date have focused on variants of the continuous state localization model, whereby an effective decoherence strength parameter is used to model the rate of coherence loss with an assumed energy dependence. Another class of collapse models that have been proposed posit connections to the configuration of gravitational field accompanying the mass distribution associated with each wave function that is in the superposition. A particularly interesting and prescriptive model is Penrose’s description of gravitational collapse which proposes a decoherence time τ determined through E g τ ∼ ℏ , where E g is a calculable function of the Newtonian gravitational potential. Here we explore application of the Penrose collapse model to neutrino oscillations, reinterpreting previous experimental limits on neutrino decoherence in terms of this model. We identify effects associated with both spatial collapse and momentum diffusion, finding that the latter is ruled out in data from the IceCube South Pole Neutrino Observatory so long as the neutrino wave packet width at production is σ ν , x ≤ 2 × 10 − 12 m . Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2405.03954•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jul 26, 2024•2 citations

Gravitationally Induced Quantum Decoherence via Anisotropic Phase Distribution in 4-Dimensional Incompressible Wave Packets: A Mechanical Bridge to the Penrose Objective Reduction and the Measurement Illusion

Güven Yarkadaş

The objective reduction (collapse) of quantum superpositions under gravitational influence remains one of the most deep-seated dilemmas of modern physics. Within the Di´osi–Penrose (DP) framework, Roger Penrose correctly identified that the linear superposition of distinct spacetime metrics generates an ill-defined timelike Killing vector field, necessitating an inevitable decay of the superposition into a single stationary state with a lifetime of τ ≈ ℏ/∆E G . However, because standard formulations treat the quantum particle as an idealized 3-dimensional mass distribution evolving against a classical, external clock, the primary dynamic physical agency destabilizing the state has remained an ontological mystery. Consequently, laboratory-scale gravitational decoherence models have traditionally assumed that the terrestrial gravitational gradient (∼ 10 −16 ) is far too weak to bend null geodesics or scatter phases within an experimental wave packet. Within the framework of the Black Hole–White Wall (BH-WW) model, this work resolves the impasse by restoring the particle’s intrinsic 4-dimensional temporal depth to the system. When quantum particles are treated as incompressible 4-volume packets governed by the principle Ω 4 = ∆V 3 · c∆τ = constant, it is demonstrated that even a weak ambient gravitational potential gradient (∆Φ = g∆h) induces an internal metric shear across the particle’s own temporal thickness (c∆τ). The lower section of the wave packet resides in an axially elongated corridor where the time fiber is stretched, whereas the upper section occupies a less contracted geometry. This gradient breaks the internal phase symmetry, inducing an instantaneous anisotropic geodesic bias along internal photon and virtual-mode scattering trajectories toward the center of gravity. The resulting internal phase torque rapidly destabilizes the 4-dimensional envelope, triggering an irreversible phase discharge (collapse) into a single geodesic trajectory. Furthermore, this mechanism decodes the Copenhagen interpretation’s illusion of the “neutral observer” by revealing that measurement apparatuses reside in the exact same gravitational curvature reservoir: macroscopic detectors are already permanently locked into a single geodesic due to their own massive 4-volumes, and the moment of measurement is merely the geometric entrainment (phase-locking) of the microscopic particle to this macroscopic phase vise. Thus, it is shown that macroscopic core heating in celestial bodies and microscopic wave packet collapse in the laboratory are dual manifestations of the identical opto-geometric phase anisotropy operating across two different scales.

•Nov 2, 2026•0 citations

Superposing spacetimes: lessons from analogue gravity

Carlos Barceló, Luis J. Garay, Gerardo García-Moreno

We analyze Penrose's ideas concerning the role of gravity in the quantum-mechanical state reduction from the perspective of analogue-gravity models. We first review a line of work which argues that it is not enough to find a satisfactory quantization scheme for gravity in the description of a matter-gravity system. Instead of that; the standard rules of quantum mechanics as they are actually applied to matter systems need to be modified when the gravitational interaction is relevant. Among these ideas we focus on Penrose's argument for the absence of macroscopic quantum superpositions. He argues that such phenomenon has its roots in the idiosyncratic aspects of gravity, which become relevant just when the system is macroscopic and hence able to generate a sufficiently strong gravitational field, and not in the environmental decoherence. We then present an analogue model consisting of a Bose-Einstein condensate in a double well potential, where it is possible to build states that would correspond to putative superpositions of spacetimes. Such configurations are unstable and the source of instability from a microscopic point of view can be related to the abscence of a well-defined causal structure in the effective geometric description. We also discuss some additional lessons that can be taken from these instabilities.

•Apr 30, 2021•1 citation

Gravitational Modulation of Quantum Decoherence: A Proposed Microgravity Double-Slit Experiment

Anthony James Donnelly

We propose a double-slit photon interference experiment conducted across three gravitational conditions (1g, ~0g, 0.16g) to test whether gravitational field strength modulates wave function collapse behaviour. This proposal does not assume wave function collapse is ontologically real; it tests whether effective collapse behaviour—operationalised as interference fringe visibility and decoherence rate—varies with gravitational context. A secondary experiment introduces information accessibility as a variable, testing whether the causal availability of which-path information affects collapse statistics differently across gravitational conditions. Null results would place strong upper bounds on gravitationally induced collapse models, constraining Penrose-type theories. Positive results would provide the first direct experimental evidence for a gravitational component in quantum state reduction. Keywords: wave function collapse, quantum decoherence, gravity, Penrose objective reduction, measurement problem, double-slit experiment, microgravity

•Dec 24, 2025•0 citations

Foundations for a theory of emergent quantum mechanics and emergent classical gravity

Ricardo Gallego Torromé

Quantum systems are viewed as emergent systems from the fundamental degrees of freedom. The laws and rules of quantum mechanics are understood as an effective description, valid for the emergent systems and specially useful to handle probabilistic predictions of observables. After introducing the geometric theory of Hamilton-Randers spaces and reformulating it using Hilbert space theory, a Hilbert space structure is constructed from the Hilbert space formulation of the underlying Hamilton-Randers model and associated with the space of wave functions of quantum mechanical systems. We can prove the emergence of the Born rule from ergodic considerations. A geometric mechanism for a natural spontaneous collapse of the quantum states based on the concentration of measure phenomena as it appears in metric geometry is discussed.We show the existence of stable vacua states for the quantized matter Hamiltonian. Another consequence of the concentration of measure is the emergence of a weak equivalence principle for one of the dynamics of the fundamental degrees of freedom. We suggest that the reduction of the quantum state is driven by a gravitational type interaction. Such interaction appears only in the dynamical domain when localization of quantum observables happens, it must be a classical interaction. We discuss the double slit experiment in the context of the framework proposed, the interference phenomena associated with a quantum system in an external gravitational potential, a mechanism explaining non-quantum locality and also provide an argument in favour of an emergent interpretation of every macroscopic time parameter. Entanglement is partially described in the context of Hamilton-Randers theory and how naturally Bell's inequalities should be violated.

arXiv:1402.5070•Feb 20, 2014•21 citations
In this paper, the formal structure of Penrose’s gravitationally induced reduction of the wave function mechanism is analyzed. It is shown that pushing Penrose’s argument forward leads to the interpretation of quantum coherence in microscopic systems as an observable signature violation of general covariance. We discuss potential avenues to avoid this conclusion, among them emergent quantum mechanics and super-determinism.
After providing an extensive overview of the conceptual elements -- such as Einstein's `hole argument' -- that underpin Penrose's proposal for gravitationally induced quantum state reduction, the proposal is constructively criticised. Penrose has suggested a mechanism for objective reduction of quantum states with postulated collapse time T = h/E, where E is an ill-definedness in the gravitational self-energy stemming from the profound conflict between the principles of superposition and general covariance. Here it is argued that, even if Penrose's overall conceptual scheme for the breakdown of quantum mechanics is unreservedly accepted, his formula for the collapse time of superpositions reduces to T --> oo (E --> 0) in the strictly Newtonian regime, which is the domain of his proposed experiment to corroborate the effect. A suggestion is made to rectify this situation. In particular, recognising the cogency of Penrose's reasoning in the domain of full `quantum gravity', it is demonstrated that an appropriate experiment which could in principle corroborate his argued `macroscopic' breakdown of superpositions is not the one involving non-rotating mass distributions as he has suggested, but a Leggett-type SQUID or BEC experiment involving superposed mass distributions in relative rotation. The demonstration thereby brings out one of the distinctive characteristics of Penrose's scheme, rendering it empirically distinguishable from other state reduction theories involving gravity. As an aside, a new geometrical measure of gravity-induced deviation from quantum mechanics in the manner of Penrose is proposed, but now for the canonical commutation relations [Q, P] = ih.
Models of spontaneous wave function collapse have been postulated to address the measurement problem in quantum mechanics. Their primary function is to convert coherent quantum superpositions into incoherent ones, with the result that macroscopic objects cannot be placed into widely separated superpositions for observably prolonged times. Many of these processes will also lead to loss of coherence in neutrino oscillations, producing observable signatures in the flavor profile of neutrinos at long travel distances. The majority of studies of neutrino oscillation coherence to date have focused on variants of the continuous state localization model, whereby an effective decoherence strength parameter is used to model the rate of coherence loss with an assumed energy dependence. Another class of collapse models that have been proposed posit connections to the configuration of gravitational field accompanying the mass distribution associated with each wave function that is in the superposition. A particularly interesting and prescriptive model is Penrose’s description of gravitational collapse which proposes a decoherence time τ determined through E g τ ∼ ℏ , where E g is a calculable function of the Newtonian gravitational potential. Here we explore application of the Penrose collapse model to neutrino oscillations, reinterpreting previous experimental limits on neutrino decoherence in terms of this model. We identify effects associated with both spatial collapse and momentum diffusion, finding that the latter is ruled out in data from the IceCube South Pole Neutrino Observatory so long as the neutrino wave packet width at production is σ ν , x ≤ 2 × 10 − 12 m . Published by the American Physical Society 2024
The objective reduction (collapse) of quantum superpositions under gravitational influence remains one of the most deep-seated dilemmas of modern physics. Within the Di´osi–Penrose (DP) framework, Roger Penrose correctly identified that the linear superposition of distinct spacetime metrics generates an ill-defined timelike Killing vector field, necessitating an inevitable decay of the superposition into a single stationary state with a lifetime of τ ≈ ℏ/∆E G . However, because standard formulations treat the quantum particle as an idealized 3-dimensional mass distribution evolving against a classical, external clock, the primary dynamic physical agency destabilizing the state has remained an ontological mystery. Consequently, laboratory-scale gravitational decoherence models have traditionally assumed that the terrestrial gravitational gradient (∼ 10 −16 ) is far too weak to bend null geodesics or scatter phases within an experimental wave packet. Within the framework of the Black Hole–White Wall (BH-WW) model, this work resolves the impasse by restoring the particle’s intrinsic 4-dimensional temporal depth to the system. When quantum particles are treated as incompressible 4-volume packets governed by the principle Ω 4 = ∆V 3 · c∆τ = constant, it is demonstrated that even a weak ambient gravitational potential gradient (∆Φ = g∆h) induces an internal metric shear across the particle’s own temporal thickness (c∆τ). The lower section of the wave packet resides in an axially elongated corridor where the time fiber is stretched, whereas the upper section occupies a less contracted geometry. This gradient breaks the internal phase symmetry, inducing an instantaneous anisotropic geodesic bias along internal photon and virtual-mode scattering trajectories toward the center of gravity. The resulting internal phase torque rapidly destabilizes the 4-dimensional envelope, triggering an irreversible phase discharge (collapse) into a single geodesic trajectory. Furthermore, this mechanism decodes the Copenhagen interpretation’s illusion of the “neutral observer” by revealing that measurement apparatuses reside in the exact same gravitational curvature reservoir: macroscopic detectors are already permanently locked into a single geodesic due to their own massive 4-volumes, and the moment of measurement is merely the geometric entrainment (phase-locking) of the microscopic particle to this macroscopic phase vise. Thus, it is shown that macroscopic core heating in celestial bodies and microscopic wave packet collapse in the laboratory are dual manifestations of the identical opto-geometric phase anisotropy operating across two different scales.
We analyze Penrose's ideas concerning the role of gravity in the quantum-mechanical state reduction from the perspective of analogue-gravity models. We first review a line of work which argues that it is not enough to find a satisfactory quantization scheme for gravity in the description of a matter-gravity system. Instead of that; the standard rules of quantum mechanics as they are actually applied to matter systems need to be modified when the gravitational interaction is relevant. Among these ideas we focus on Penrose's argument for the absence of macroscopic quantum superpositions. He argues that such phenomenon has its roots in the idiosyncratic aspects of gravity, which become relevant just when the system is macroscopic and hence able to generate a sufficiently strong gravitational field, and not in the environmental decoherence. We then present an analogue model consisting of a Bose-Einstein condensate in a double well potential, where it is possible to build states that would correspond to putative superpositions of spacetimes. Such configurations are unstable and the source of instability from a microscopic point of view can be related to the abscence of a well-defined causal structure in the effective geometric description. We also discuss some additional lessons that can be taken from these instabilities.
We propose a double-slit photon interference experiment conducted across three gravitational conditions (1g, ~0g, 0.16g) to test whether gravitational field strength modulates wave function collapse behaviour. This proposal does not assume wave function collapse is ontologically real; it tests whether effective collapse behaviour—operationalised as interference fringe visibility and decoherence rate—varies with gravitational context. A secondary experiment introduces information accessibility as a variable, testing whether the causal availability of which-path information affects collapse statistics differently across gravitational conditions. Null results would place strong upper bounds on gravitationally induced collapse models, constraining Penrose-type theories. Positive results would provide the first direct experimental evidence for a gravitational component in quantum state reduction. Keywords: wave function collapse, quantum decoherence, gravity, Penrose objective reduction, measurement problem, double-slit experiment, microgravity
Quantum systems are viewed as emergent systems from the fundamental degrees of freedom. The laws and rules of quantum mechanics are understood as an effective description, valid for the emergent systems and specially useful to handle probabilistic predictions of observables. After introducing the geometric theory of Hamilton-Randers spaces and reformulating it using Hilbert space theory, a Hilbert space structure is constructed from the Hilbert space formulation of the underlying Hamilton-Randers model and associated with the space of wave functions of quantum mechanical systems. We can prove the emergence of the Born rule from ergodic considerations. A geometric mechanism for a natural spontaneous collapse of the quantum states based on the concentration of measure phenomena as it appears in metric geometry is discussed.We show the existence of stable vacua states for the quantized matter Hamiltonian. Another consequence of the concentration of measure is the emergence of a weak equivalence principle for one of the dynamics of the fundamental degrees of freedom. We suggest that the reduction of the quantum state is driven by a gravitational type interaction. Such interaction appears only in the dynamical domain when localization of quantum observables happens, it must be a classical interaction. We discuss the double slit experiment in the context of the framework proposed, the interference phenomena associated with a quantum system in an external gravitational potential, a mechanism explaining non-quantum locality and also provide an argument in favour of an emergent interpretation of every macroscopic time parameter. Entanglement is partially described in the context of Hamilton-Randers theory and how naturally Bell's inequalities should be violated.