We develop analytical gradients of ground- and excited-state energies with respect to system parameters including the nuclear coordinates for the hybrid quantum/classical multistate contracted variational quantum eigensolver (MC-VQE) applied to fermionic systems. We show how the resulting response contributions to the gradient can be evaluated with a quantum effort similar to that of obtaining the VQE energy and independent of the total number of derivative parameters (e.g. number of nuclear coordinates) by adopting a Lagrangian formalism for the evaluation of the total derivative. We also demonstrate that large-step-size finite-difference treatment of directional derivatives in concert with the parameter shift rule can significantly mitigate the complexity of dealing with the quantum parameter Hessian when solving the quantum response equations. This enables the computation of analytical derivative properties of systems with hundreds of atoms, while solving an active space of their most strongly correlated orbitals on a quantum computer. We numerically demonstrate the exactness the analytical gradients and discuss the magnitude of the quantum response contributions.
We develop analytical gradients of ground- and excited-state energies with respect to system parameters including the nuclear coordinates for the hybrid quantum/classical multistate contracted variational quantum eigensolver (MC-VQE) applied to fermionic systems. We show how the resulting response contributions to the gradient can be evaluated with a quantum effort similar to that of obtaining the VQE energy and independent of the total number of derivative parameters (e.g. number of nuclear coordinates) by adopting a Lagrangian formalism for the evaluation of the total derivative. We also demonstrate that large-step-size finite-difference treatment of directional derivatives in concert with the parameter shift rule can significantly mitigate the complexity of dealing with the quantum parameter Hessian when solving the quantum response equations. This enables the computation of analytical derivative properties of systems with hundreds of atoms, while solving an active space of their most strongly correlated orbitals on a quantum computer. We numerically demonstrate the exactness the analytical gradients and discuss the magnitude of the quantum response contributions.
The maturation of analytical derivative theory over the past few decades has enabled classical electronic structure theory to provide accurate and efficient predictions of a wide variety of observable properties. However, classical implementations of analytical derivative theory take advantage of explicit computational access to the approximate electronic wavefunctions in question, which is not possible for the emerging case of hybrid quantum/classical methods. Here, we develop an efficient Lagrangian-based approach for analytical first derivatives of hybrid quantum/classical methods using only observable quantities from the quantum portion of the algorithm. Specifically, we construct the key first-derivative property of the nuclear energy gradient for the recently-developed multistate, contracted variant of the variational quantum eigensolver (MC-VQE) within the context of the ab initio exciton model (AIEM). We show that a clean separation between the quantum and classical parts of the problem is enabled by the definition of an appropriate set of relaxed density matrices, and show how the wavefunction response equations in the quantum part of the algorithm (coupled-perturbed MC-VQE or CP-MC-VQE equations) are decoupled from the wavefunction response equations and and gradient perturbations in the classical part of the algorithm. We explore the magnitudes of the Hellmann-Feynman and response contributions to the gradients in quantum circuit simulations of MC-VQE+AIEM and demonstrate a quantum circuit simulator implementation of adiabatic excited state dynamics with MC-VQE+AIEM.
Nuclear gradients and Hessians are fundamental quantities in computational chemistry, essential for a wide range of applications including geometry optimization, vibrational spectroscopy, and molecular property calculations. In this work, we present their analytical implementation on quantum hardware. The methodology is formulated within an active-space framework combining orbital optimization and linear-response theory.
On the quantum-computing side, the approach employs the tiled unitary product state (tUPS) ansatz to directly evaluate the tensor elements required for solving the response equations. Moreover, the expectation values are corrected using an adapted confusion-matrix error-mitigation scheme in combination with post-selection criteria. The resulting workflow is assessed on molecular hydrogen and on water through the calculation of potential energy surfaces, nuclear gradients, Hessians, and vibrational frequencies, enabling the evaluation of both its capabilities and current limitations.
The results demonstrate good performance for the hydrogen molecule, whereas the water molecule provides a more demanding test of quantum-hardware resources and highlights the trade-offs associated with error-mitigation strategies. The quantified analysis of the results identify the main sources of errors, suggesting improvement directions for more accurate quantum computer applications.
The maturation of analytical derivative theory over the past few decades has enabled classical electronic structure theory to provide accurate and efficient predictions of a wide variety of observable properties. However, classical implementations of analytical derivative theory take advantage of explicit computational access to the approximate electronic wavefunctions in question, which is not possible for the emerging case of hybrid quantum/classical methods. Here, we develop an efficient Lagrangian-based approach for analytical first derivatives of hybrid quantum/classical methods using only observable quantities from the quantum portion of the algorithm. Specifically, we construct the key first-derivative property of the nuclear energy gradient for the recently-developed multistate, contracted variant of the variational quantum eigensolver (MC-VQE) within the context of the ab initio exciton model (AIEM). We show that a clean separation between the quantum and classical parts of the problem is enabled by the definition of an appropriate set of relaxed density matrices, and show how the wavefunction response equations in the quantum part of the algorithm (coupled-perturbed MC-VQE or CP-MC-VQE equations) are decoupled from the wavefunction response equations and and gradient perturbations in the classical part of the algorithm. We explore the magnitudes of the Hellmann-Feynman and response contributions to the gradients in quantum circuit simulations of MC-VQE+AIEM and demonstrate a quantum circuit simulator implementation of adiabatic excited state dynamics with MC-VQE+AIEM.
Efficient representations of the Hamiltonian, such as double factorization, drastically reduce the circuit depth or the number of repetitions in error corrected and noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) algorithms for chemistry. We report a Lagrangian-based approach for evaluating relaxed one- and two-particle reduced density matrices from double factorized Hamiltonians, unlocking efficiency improvements in computing the nuclear gradient and related derivative properties. We demonstrate the accuracy and feasibility of our Lagrangian-based approach to recover all off-diagonal density matrix elements in classically simulated examples with up to 327 quantum and 18 470 total atoms in QM/MM simulations with modest-sized quantum active spaces. We show this in the context of the variational quantum eigensolver in case studies, such as transition state optimization, ab initio molecular dynamics simulation, and energy minimization of large molecular systems.
Quantum computing has emerged as a promising paradigm for tackling electronic structure problems, with most efforts to date focused on molecular energies and, more recently, first-order derivatives. However, the extension to second-order energy derivatives with respect to nuclear coordinates─essential for predicting vibrational spectra and identifying transition states─has remained relatively limited. Here, we present an analytic implementation for computing nuclear Hessians within the variational quantum eigensolver framework. Our approach produces harmonic vibrational frequencies and normal modes in excellent agreement with full configuration interaction (FCI) benchmarks, even for systems with challenging cases of orbital degeneracy or involving weak intermolecular interactions. We further assess the quantum measurement cost of these second-order derivative calculations and compare it with that of variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) energy calculations. Additionally, we demonstrate how point group symmetry can be incorporated to reduce measurement cost without loss of accuracy. This work extends quantum computing capabilities toward advanced quantum chemical simulations, such as the characterization of noncovalent interactions via low-frequency vibrational signatures and the identification of transition states.
The variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) typically optimizes variational parameters in a quantum circuit to prepare eigenstates for a quantum system. Its application to many problems may involve a group of Hamiltonians, e.g., a Hamiltonian of a molecule is a function of the nuclear configurations. In this paper we incorporate derivatives of the Hamiltonian into the VQE and develop some hybrid quantum-classical algorithms, which explore both Hamiltonian and wave-function spaces for solving quantum chemistry problems more efficiently. For geometry optimization, we propose a mutual gradient-descent algorithm that updates the parameters of the Hamiltonian and wave function alternately, which can give a rapid convergence towards equilibrium structures of molecules as demonstrated in numerical simulations. Moreover, to speed up the calculation of the energy potential surface, we establish differential equations that govern how the optimized variational parameters of the wave function change with the intrinsic parameters of the Hamiltonian. Our study suggests a direction for a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm for solving quantum systems more efficiently by considering spaces of both the Hamiltonian and the wave function.