Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2110.02908 · npj Quantum Information

Experimental metrology beyond the standard quantum limit for a wide resources range

Valeria Cimini, Emanuele Polino, Federico Belliardo, Francesco Hoch, Bruno Piccirillo, Nicolò Spagnolo, Vittorio Giovannetti, Fabio Sciarrino

Published Mar 2, 2023• 18 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Adopting quantum resources for parameter estimation discloses the possibility to realize quantum sensors operating at a sensitivity beyond the standard quantum limit. Such an approach promises to reach the fundamental Heisenberg scaling as a function of the employed resources N in the estimation process. Although previous experiments demonstrated precision scaling approaching Heisenberg-limited performances, reaching such a regime for a wide range of N remains hard to accomplish. Here, we show a method that suitably allocates the available resources permitting them to reach the same power law of Heisenberg scaling without any prior information on the parameter. We demonstrate experimentally such an advantage in measuring a rotation angle. We quantitatively verify sub-standard quantum limit performances for a considerable range of N (O(30,000)) by using single-photon states with high-order orbital angular momentum, achieving an error reduction, in terms of the obtained variance, >10 dB below the standard quantum limit. Such results can be applied to different scenarios, opening the way to the optimization of resources in quantum sensing.

DOI
10.1038/s41534-023-00691-y

Related papers

Optimal quantum metrology under resource constraints

Qiushi Liu, 刘秋实

Nature imposes fundamental limits on how precisely we can probe the physical world. Quantum metrology is the study of achieving higher precision and accuracy in estimating the physical parameters by harnessing quantum resources. It is considered one of the most promising quantum technologies, offering significant advantages over classical ones in both near‑term and long‑term applications. However, existing theoretical research in quantum metrology often falls short of providing a unified and rigorous understanding of the ultimate precision under realistic experimental limitations on available quantum resources. In this thesis, we conduct a systematic investigation of the optimal precision limits in quantum metrology and identify the metrological strategies that achieve optimality under specified resource constraints. We primarily focus on the single-parameter estimation of quantum processes, a cornerstone task in quantum metrology. We first establish a general framework of strictly optimal quantum metrology using semidefinite programming within the formalism of higher-order quantum operations. This framework reveals a strict hierarchy for the performance of different families of strategies---parallel, sequential, and indefinite-causal-order ones---each subject to specific causal constraints. Our results rigorously demonstrate a quantum metrological advantage of indefinite causal order in finite-dimensional systems, which has recently aroused rapidly growing interest. In realistic scenarios, a fully optimized quantum metrology protocol may be experimentally demanding due to the complexity of state preparation and control. Tailored to practical constraints on the allowed ancilla and control operations, we propose a highly efficient tensor network algorithm to optimize the probe state and a long sequence of control for quantum metrology. When the number of control steps tends to infinity, we develop an asymptotic theory of quantum metrology for achieving the ultimate precision limit---Heisenberg limit---without ancilla. This contrasts with the traditional approach using quantum error correction for metrology that typically requires noiseless and controllable ancilla. Our results pave the way for exploiting the full potential of quantum resources in metrology. In the near term, our methods enable high-precision estimation with limited interaction with the unknown process using experimentally feasible control techniques. In the long term, they lay the foundation for scalable and fault-tolerant quantum metrology.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Beyond Heisenberg Limit Quantum Metrology through Quantum Signal Processing

Yulong Dong, Jonathan A. Gross, Murphy Yuezhen Niu

Leveraging quantum effects in metrology such as entanglement and coherence allows one to measure parameters with enhanced sensitivity. However, time-dependent noise can disrupt such Heisenberg-limited amplification. We propose a quantum-metrology method based on the quantum-signal-processing framework to overcome these realistic noise-induced limitations in practical quantum metrology. Our algorithm separates the gate parameter $φ$~(single-qubit Z phase) that is susceptible to time-dependent error from the target gate parameter $θ$~(swap-angle between |10> and |01> states) that is largely free of time-dependent error. Our method achieves an accuracy of $10^{-4}$ radians in standard deviation for learning $θ$ in superconducting-qubit experiments, outperforming existing alternative schemes by two orders of magnitude. We also demonstrate the increased robustness in learning time-dependent gate parameters through fast Fourier transformation and sequential phase difference. We show both theoretically and numerically that there is an interesting transition of the optimal metrology variance scaling as a function of circuit depth $d$ from the pre-asymptotic regime $d \ll 1/θ$ to Heisenberg limit $d \to \infty$. Remarkably, in the pre-asymptotic regime our method's estimation variance on time-sensitive parameter $φ$ scales faster than the asymptotic Heisenberg limit as a function of depth, $\text{Var}(\hatφ)\approx 1/d^4$. Our work is the first quantum-signal-processing algorithm that demonstrates practical application in laboratory quantum computers.

arXiv:2209.11207•Sep 22, 2022•1 citation

Quantum Speed Limits and the Ultimate Scaling of the Quantum Sensors

Yusef Maleki

Quantum metrology promises sensitivity beyond classical strategies, yet it remains unsettled how quantum-enabled precision should scale with physical resources and how to interpret quantum advantage. We provide a physically grounded resource accounting that clarifies the true Heisenberg limit and resolves apparent super-Heisenberg paradoxes. We demonstrate that the Heisenberg limit is best viewed as an information-theoretic manifestation of the quantum speed limit. We illustrate these ideas with a simple, super-resolving phase-estimation protocol based on Rabi oscillations in two-level atoms driven on an $m$-photon resonance. In this setting, the phase error scales as $n^{-m/2}$, where $n$ is the average photon number. Recasting metrological sensitivity through quantum dynamical speed limits yields operational bounds that reconcile such super-resolution strategies with the standard Heisenberg interpretation and identify the relevant resources in the norm of the generator. We also revisit the common attribution of the NOON state's $1/n$ scaling to quantum entanglement. We show that such an attribution is not generic and the Heisenberg $1/n$ scaling does not, by itself, certify entanglement as the enabling resource.

quant-pharXiv:2607.23573•Entropy•Jul 28, 2026•1 citation

Nonlinear enhancement of measurement precision via a hybrid quantum switch

Anonymous, Yuxiang Yang, Gongchu Li +9 more

Quantum metrology promises measurement precision beyond the classical limit by using suitably tailored quantum states and detection strategies. However, scaling up this advantage is experimentally challenging, due to the difficulty of generating high-quality large-scale probes. Here, we build a photonic setup that achieves enhanced precision scaling by manipulating the probe's dynamics through operations performed in a coherently controlled order. Our setup applies an unknown rotation and a known orbital angular momentum increase in a coherently controlled order, in a way that reproduces a hybrid quantum SWITCH involving gates generated by both discrete and continuous variables. The unknown rotation angle $θ$ is measured with precision scaling as $1/4ml$ when a photon undergoes a rotation of $2mθ$ and an angular momentum shift of $2l \hbar$. With a practical enhancement factor as high as 2317, the ultimate precision in our experiment is $0.0105^{\prime \prime}$ when using $7.16\times10^7$ photons, corresponding to a normalized precision of $\approx 10^{-4}$rad per photon. No photon interaction occurs in our experiment, and the precision enhancement consumes only a linearly increasing amount of physical resources while achieving a nonlinear scaling of the precision. We further indicate that this nonlinear enhancement roots in an in-depth exploration of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle (HUP), and our findings not only deepen the understanding of the HUP but also pave a pathway for advancements in quantum metrology.

arXiv:2506.20632•Physical Review Applied•Jun 29, 2026•1 citation

Quantum metrology at the limit with extremal Majorana constellations

F. Bouchard, P. de la Hoz, Gunnar G. Bjork +8 more

Quantum metrology allows for a tremendous boost in the accuracy of measurement of diverse physical parameters. The estimation of a rotation constitutes a remarkable example of this quantum-enhanced precision. The recently introduced Kings of Quantumness are especially germane for this task when the rotation axis is unknown, as they have a sensitivity independent of that axis and they achieve a Heisenberg-limit scaling. Here, we report the experimental realization of these states by generating up to 21-dimensional orbital angular momentum states of single photons, and confirm their high metrological abilities.

arXiv:1612.06804•Optica•Nov 16, 2017•52 citations

Optimal Multiparameter Metrology: The Quantum Compass Solution

Denis V. Vasilyev, Athreya Shankar, Raphael Kaubruegger +1 more

We study optimal quantum sensing of multiple physical parameters using repeated measurements. In this scenario, the Fisher information framework sets the fundamental limits on sensing performance, yet the optimal states and corresponding measurements that attain these limits remain to be discovered. To address this, we extend the Fisher information approach with a second optimality requirement for a sensor to provide unambiguous estimation of unknown parameters. We propose a systematic method integrating Fisher information and Bayesian approaches to quantum metrology to identify the combination of input states and measurements that satisfies both optimality criteria. Specifically, we frame the optimal sensing problem as an optimization of an asymptotic Bayesian cost function that can be efficiently solved numerically and, in many cases, analytically. We refer to the resulting optimal sensor as a `quantum compass' solution, which serves as a direct multiparameter counterpart to the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state-based interferometer, renowned for achieving the Heisenberg limit in single-parameter metrology. We provide exact quantum compass solutions for paradigmatic multiparameter problem of sensing two and three parameters using an SU(2) sensor. Our metrological cost function opens avenues for quantum variational techniques to design low-depth quantum circuits approaching the optimal sensing performance in the many-repetition scenario. We demonstrate this by constructing simple quantum circuits that achieve the Heisenberg limit for vector field and 3D rotations estimation using a limited set of gates available on a trapped-ion platform. Our work introduces and optimizes sensors for a practical notion of optimality, keeping in mind the ultimate goal of quantum sensors to precisely estimate unknown parameters.

arXiv:2404.14194•Apr 22, 2024•1 citation
Abstract Adopting quantum resources for parameter estimation discloses the possibility to realize quantum sensors operating at a sensitivity beyond the standard quantum limit. Such an approach promises to reach the fundamental Heisenberg scaling as a function of the employed resources N in the estimation process. Although previous experiments demonstrated precision scaling approaching Heisenberg-limited performances, reaching such a regime for a wide range of N remains hard to accomplish. Here, we show a method that suitably allocates the available resources permitting them to reach the same power law of Heisenberg scaling without any prior information on the parameter. We demonstrate experimentally such an advantage in measuring a rotation angle. We quantitatively verify sub-standard quantum limit performances for a considerable range of N (O(30,000)) by using single-photon states with high-order orbital angular momentum, achieving an error reduction, in terms of the obtained variance, >10 dB below the standard quantum limit. Such results can be applied to different scenarios, opening the way to the optimization of resources in quantum sensing.
Nature imposes fundamental limits on how precisely we can probe the physical world. Quantum metrology is the study of achieving higher precision and accuracy in estimating the physical parameters by harnessing quantum resources. It is considered one of the most promising quantum technologies, offering significant advantages over classical ones in both near‑term and long‑term applications. However, existing theoretical research in quantum metrology often falls short of providing a unified and rigorous understanding of the ultimate precision under realistic experimental limitations on available quantum resources. In this thesis, we conduct a systematic investigation of the optimal precision limits in quantum metrology and identify the metrological strategies that achieve optimality under specified resource constraints. We primarily focus on the single-parameter estimation of quantum processes, a cornerstone task in quantum metrology. We first establish a general framework of strictly optimal quantum metrology using semidefinite programming within the formalism of higher-order quantum operations. This framework reveals a strict hierarchy for the performance of different families of strategies---parallel, sequential, and indefinite-causal-order ones---each subject to specific causal constraints. Our results rigorously demonstrate a quantum metrological advantage of indefinite causal order in finite-dimensional systems, which has recently aroused rapidly growing interest. In realistic scenarios, a fully optimized quantum metrology protocol may be experimentally demanding due to the complexity of state preparation and control. Tailored to practical constraints on the allowed ancilla and control operations, we propose a highly efficient tensor network algorithm to optimize the probe state and a long sequence of control for quantum metrology. When the number of control steps tends to infinity, we develop an asymptotic theory of quantum metrology for achieving the ultimate precision limit---Heisenberg limit---without ancilla. This contrasts with the traditional approach using quantum error correction for metrology that typically requires noiseless and controllable ancilla. Our results pave the way for exploiting the full potential of quantum resources in metrology. In the near term, our methods enable high-precision estimation with limited interaction with the unknown process using experimentally feasible control techniques. In the long term, they lay the foundation for scalable and fault-tolerant quantum metrology.
Leveraging quantum effects in metrology such as entanglement and coherence allows one to measure parameters with enhanced sensitivity. However, time-dependent noise can disrupt such Heisenberg-limited amplification. We propose a quantum-metrology method based on the quantum-signal-processing framework to overcome these realistic noise-induced limitations in practical quantum metrology. Our algorithm separates the gate parameter φφφ~(single-qubit Z phase) that is susceptible to time-dependent error from the target gate parameter θθθ~(swap-angle between |10> and |01> states) that is largely free of time-dependent error. Our method achieves an accuracy of 10−410^{-4}10−4 radians in standard deviation for learning θθθ in superconducting-qubit experiments, outperforming existing alternative schemes by two orders of magnitude. We also demonstrate the increased robustness in learning time-dependent gate parameters through fast Fourier transformation and sequential phase difference. We show both theoretically and numerically that there is an interesting transition of the optimal metrology variance scaling as a function of circuit depth ddd from the pre-asymptotic regime d≪1/θd \ll 1/θd≪1/θ to Heisenberg limit d→∞d \to \inftyd→∞. Remarkably, in the pre-asymptotic regime our method's estimation variance on time-sensitive parameter φφφ scales faster than the asymptotic Heisenberg limit as a function of depth, Var(φ^)≈1/d4\text{Var}(\hatφ)\approx 1/d^4Var(φ^​)≈1/d4. Our work is the first quantum-signal-processing algorithm that demonstrates practical application in laboratory quantum computers.
Quantum metrology promises sensitivity beyond classical strategies, yet it remains unsettled how quantum-enabled precision should scale with physical resources and how to interpret quantum advantage. We provide a physically grounded resource accounting that clarifies the true Heisenberg limit and resolves apparent super-Heisenberg paradoxes. We demonstrate that the Heisenberg limit is best viewed as an information-theoretic manifestation of the quantum speed limit. We illustrate these ideas with a simple, super-resolving phase-estimation protocol based on Rabi oscillations in two-level atoms driven on an mmm-photon resonance. In this setting, the phase error scales as n−m/2n^{-m/2}n−m/2, where nnn is the average photon number. Recasting metrological sensitivity through quantum dynamical speed limits yields operational bounds that reconcile such super-resolution strategies with the standard Heisenberg interpretation and identify the relevant resources in the norm of the generator. We also revisit the common attribution of the NOON state's 1/n1/n1/n scaling to quantum entanglement. We show that such an attribution is not generic and the Heisenberg 1/n1/n1/n scaling does not, by itself, certify entanglement as the enabling resource.
Quantum metrology promises measurement precision beyond the classical limit by using suitably tailored quantum states and detection strategies. However, scaling up this advantage is experimentally challenging, due to the difficulty of generating high-quality large-scale probes. Here, we build a photonic setup that achieves enhanced precision scaling by manipulating the probe's dynamics through operations performed in a coherently controlled order. Our setup applies an unknown rotation and a known orbital angular momentum increase in a coherently controlled order, in a way that reproduces a hybrid quantum SWITCH involving gates generated by both discrete and continuous variables. The unknown rotation angle θθθ is measured with precision scaling as 1/4ml1/4ml1/4ml when a photon undergoes a rotation of 2mθ2mθ2mθ and an angular momentum shift of 2lℏ2l \hbar2lℏ. With a practical enhancement factor as high as 2317, the ultimate precision in our experiment is 0.0105′′0.0105^{\prime \prime}0.0105′′ when using 7.16×1077.16\times10^77.16×107 photons, corresponding to a normalized precision of ≈10−4\approx 10^{-4}≈10−4rad per photon. No photon interaction occurs in our experiment, and the precision enhancement consumes only a linearly increasing amount of physical resources while achieving a nonlinear scaling of the precision. We further indicate that this nonlinear enhancement roots in an in-depth exploration of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle (HUP), and our findings not only deepen the understanding of the HUP but also pave a pathway for advancements in quantum metrology.
Quantum metrology allows for a tremendous boost in the accuracy of measurement of diverse physical parameters. The estimation of a rotation constitutes a remarkable example of this quantum-enhanced precision. The recently introduced Kings of Quantumness are especially germane for this task when the rotation axis is unknown, as they have a sensitivity independent of that axis and they achieve a Heisenberg-limit scaling. Here, we report the experimental realization of these states by generating up to 21-dimensional orbital angular momentum states of single photons, and confirm their high metrological abilities.
We study optimal quantum sensing of multiple physical parameters using repeated measurements. In this scenario, the Fisher information framework sets the fundamental limits on sensing performance, yet the optimal states and corresponding measurements that attain these limits remain to be discovered. To address this, we extend the Fisher information approach with a second optimality requirement for a sensor to provide unambiguous estimation of unknown parameters. We propose a systematic method integrating Fisher information and Bayesian approaches to quantum metrology to identify the combination of input states and measurements that satisfies both optimality criteria. Specifically, we frame the optimal sensing problem as an optimization of an asymptotic Bayesian cost function that can be efficiently solved numerically and, in many cases, analytically. We refer to the resulting optimal sensor as a `quantum compass' solution, which serves as a direct multiparameter counterpart to the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state-based interferometer, renowned for achieving the Heisenberg limit in single-parameter metrology. We provide exact quantum compass solutions for paradigmatic multiparameter problem of sensing two and three parameters using an SU(2) sensor. Our metrological cost function opens avenues for quantum variational techniques to design low-depth quantum circuits approaching the optimal sensing performance in the many-repetition scenario. We demonstrate this by constructing simple quantum circuits that achieve the Heisenberg limit for vector field and 3D rotations estimation using a limited set of gates available on a trapped-ion platform. Our work introduces and optimizes sensors for a practical notion of optimality, keeping in mind the ultimate goal of quantum sensors to precisely estimate unknown parameters.