Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2109.11742

Anomalous Loss Reduction Below Two-Level System Saturation in Aluminum Superconducting Resonators

Tamin Tai, Jingnan Cai, Steven M. Anlage

Published Sep 24, 2021• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Superconducting resonators are widely used in many applications such as qubit readout for quantum computing, and kinetic inductance detectors. These resonators are susceptible to numerous loss and noise mechanisms, especially the dissipation due to two-level systems (TLS) which become the dominant source of loss in the few-photon and low temperature regime. In this study, capacitively-coupled aluminum half-wavelength coplanar waveguide resonators are investigated. Surprisingly, the loss of the resonators is observed to decrease with a lowering temperature at low excitation powers and temperatures below the TLS saturation. This behavior is attributed to the reduction of the TLS resonant response bandwidth with decreasing temperature and power to below the detuning between the TLS and the resonant photon frequency in a discrete ensemble of TLS. When response bandwidths of TLS are smaller than their detunings from the resonance, the resonant response and thus the loss is reduced. At higher excitation powers, the loss follows a logarithmic power dependence, consistent with predictions from the generalized tunneling model (GTM). A model combining the discrete TLS ensemble with the GTM is proposed and matches the temperature and power dependence of the measured internal loss of the resonator with reasonable parameters.

DOI
10.13016/o2xz-wnvm

Related papers

Anomalous Loss Reduction Below Two‐Level System Saturation in Aluminum Superconducting Resonators

Tamin Tai, Jingnan Cai, Steven M. Anlage

Abstract Superconducting resonators are widely used in many applications such as qubit readout for quantum computing, and kinetic inductance detectors. These resonators are susceptible to numerous loss and noise mechanisms, especially the dissipation due to two‐level systems (TLS) which become the dominant source of loss in the few‐photon and low temperature regime. In this study, capacitively‐coupled aluminum half‐wavelength coplanar waveguide resonators are investigated. Surprisingly, the loss of the resonators is observed to decrease with a lowering temperature at low excitation powers and temperatures below the TLS saturation. This behavior is attributed to the reduction of the TLS resonant response bandwidth with decreasing temperature and power to below the detuning between the TLS and the resonant photon frequency in a discrete ensemble of TLS. When response bandwidths of TLS are smaller than their detunings from the resonance, the resonant response and thus the loss is reduced. At higher excitation powers, the loss follows a logarithmic power dependence, consistent with predictions from the generalized tunneling model (GTM). A model combining the discrete TLS ensemble with the GTM is proposed and matches the temperature and power dependence of the measured internal loss of the resonator with reasonable parameters.

Advanced Quantum Technologies•Nov 28, 2023•3 citations

Coherence Time Enhancement of Interacting Two-Level Systems in Aluminum Superconducting Resonators

Tamin Tai, Jingnan Cai, Steven M. Anlage

Superconducting resonators are widely used in many applications such as qubit readout for quantum computing applications, and kinetic inductance detectors. These resonators are susceptible to numerous loss and noise mechanisms under microwave excitation, especially the dissipation due to non-equilibrium quasi-particles and two-level systems (TLS), which can result in a decrease of the superconducting intrinsic quality factor ($Q_i$) in high quality superconducting resonators. Particularly in the few-photon and low temperature (T) regime, TLS losses can become a dominant loss mechanism. In this study, novel aluminum half-wavelength resonators are investigated, focusing on the loss properties at extra-low power and low temperature. An unusual increase of $Q_i(T)$ with deceasing temperature is observed. This behavior is attributed to the increase of TLS coherence time ($T_2$) at ultra-low temperatures and powers. This $T_2$ increase is consistent with other work on resonant frequency noise in resonators and measurements of individual TLS, and likely arises from interacting TLS in the aluminum half-wavelength resonators.

•Sep 24, 2021•1 citation

TLS and Quasiparticle Loss in Thin-Film Aluminum CPW Resonators: A Modified Model and Design Implications

Carolyn G. Volpert, Emily M. Barrentine, Alberto D. Bolatto +7 more

As superconducting kinetic inductance detectors (KIDs) continue to grow in popularity for sensitive submillimeter detection and other applications, there is a drive to advance toward lower-loss devices. We present measurements of diagnostic thin-film aluminum coplanar waveguide (CPW) resonators designed to inform ongoing KID development at NASA Goddard Space Flight Center. The resonance frequencies span $f_0$ = 3.5-4 GHz and include quarter-wave and half-wave resonators with varying coupling capacitor designs. We present measurements of the device film properties and an analysis of the dominant mechanisms of loss in the resonators measured in a dark environment, demonstrating quality factors of $Q_i^{-1} \approx 3.64-8.57\ \times 10^{-8}$. We observe an enhanced level of suppression in the loss contributions from two-level systems (TLS) at intermediate-to-high read powers, and a regime at these powers and low temperatures where contributions from intrinsic processes $Q_i^{-1}$,other dominate the total loss. We also observe deviations from the standard TLS loss model at low powers and temperatures below 60 mK, and use a modified model to describe this behavior.

arXiv:2412.08811•Dec 11, 2024•0 citations

Anomalous Frequency Shift in Low-Loss Superconducting Granular Aluminum Resonators

Patrick Winkel, Daniil S. Antonenko, Vishakha Gupta +5 more

Superconducting high-kinetic inductance materials like granular aluminum (grAl) are a versatile part of the circuit quantum electrodynamics (cQED) toolbox, provided their losses at microwave frequencies are low enough. To further advance the use of grAl in quantum devices, it is indispensable to identify the dominant loss mechanisms. The standard approach pairs electromagnetic simulations of resonator geometry with measured temperature and power dependence of resonance frequency and loss rate. Most materials follow the phenomenological theory of two-level systems (TLSs) at low temperatures, resulting in an initial decrease of the resonance frequency with increasing temperature. In our work, we observe an opposite behavior at the lowest temperatures: The resonance frequency initially increases with both temperature and readout power, contradicting the standard TLS model predictions. We are able to explain a part of the data by an alternative mechanism associated with the effect of superconducting quasiparticles in a granular system with spatially-nonuniform gap. Yet, the observed change in the resonance frequency with temperature is not matched by a proportional change in the loss rate. We also observe anomalous positive frequency responses following high-energy events, characterized by several time scales. While anomalous behavior has been reported previously in grAl, the disagreement with standard models is particularly visible in our devices thanks to their exceptionally low loss rates.

quant-pharXiv:2608.29282•Sep 1, 2026•0 citations

Power and temperature dependent model for high Q superconductor resonators

Ashish Alexander, Christopher Weddle, Christopher J. K. Richardson

Measuring the internal quality factor of coplanar waveguide superconducting resonators is an established method of determining small losses in superconducting devices. Often, resonator losses are attributed to two-level system (TLS) defects using a power dependent model for the quality factor. However, excess non-equilibrium quasiparticles can also limit the quality factor of superconducting resonators. Here, a two-temperature, power and temperature dependent model is used to evaluate resonator losses for titanium nitride and aluminum coplanar waveguide resonators with loss tangents of 10−5–10−6. This model enables a set of parameters to describe both the internal quality factor and fractional frequency shift of the resonator across a broad range of average cavity photon numbers, from 1 to 106, and temperatures between those limited by the experimental apparatus near 50 mK and thermal quasiparticle dominated. The presented model also offers potential insight into observing the temperature and power dependence of TLS–TLS interactions in these resonators.

arXiv:2205.06291•APL Quantum•Jul 23, 2025•4 citations

Two Level System Loss in Superconducting Microwave Resonators

David P. Pappas, Michael R. Vissers, David Wisbey +2 more

High quality factor, i.e. low loss, microwave resonators are important for quantum information storage and addressing. In this work we study the resonance frequency and loss in superconducting coplanar waveguide resonators as a function of power and temperature. We find that there is increased loss at low power and low temperature. The increased loss is attributed to the existence of two-level systems (TLS) at the surfaces, interfaces, and in the bulk of insulators deposited on the structures. We show that both the temperature dependence of the resonant frequency and the power dependence of the loss can be used to find the TLS contribution to the loss. The TLS intrinsic loss tangent derived from the frequency shift data at high power is shown to agree well with the direct loss measurement at low power. The former allows for a relatively fast measurement of the TLS loss. As an example, we measure the properties of amorphous AlOXdeposited on the resonators and find a TLS loss tangent of 1 × 10-3.

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Jan 13, 2011•175 citations
Superconducting resonators are widely used in many applications such as qubit readout for quantum computing, and kinetic inductance detectors. These resonators are susceptible to numerous loss and noise mechanisms, especially the dissipation due to two-level systems (TLS) which become the dominant source of loss in the few-photon and low temperature regime. In this study, capacitively-coupled aluminum half-wavelength coplanar waveguide resonators are investigated. Surprisingly, the loss of the resonators is observed to decrease with a lowering temperature at low excitation powers and temperatures below the TLS saturation. This behavior is attributed to the reduction of the TLS resonant response bandwidth with decreasing temperature and power to below the detuning between the TLS and the resonant photon frequency in a discrete ensemble of TLS. When response bandwidths of TLS are smaller than their detunings from the resonance, the resonant response and thus the loss is reduced. At higher excitation powers, the loss follows a logarithmic power dependence, consistent with predictions from the generalized tunneling model (GTM). A model combining the discrete TLS ensemble with the GTM is proposed and matches the temperature and power dependence of the measured internal loss of the resonator with reasonable parameters.
Abstract Superconducting resonators are widely used in many applications such as qubit readout for quantum computing, and kinetic inductance detectors. These resonators are susceptible to numerous loss and noise mechanisms, especially the dissipation due to two‐level systems (TLS) which become the dominant source of loss in the few‐photon and low temperature regime. In this study, capacitively‐coupled aluminum half‐wavelength coplanar waveguide resonators are investigated. Surprisingly, the loss of the resonators is observed to decrease with a lowering temperature at low excitation powers and temperatures below the TLS saturation. This behavior is attributed to the reduction of the TLS resonant response bandwidth with decreasing temperature and power to below the detuning between the TLS and the resonant photon frequency in a discrete ensemble of TLS. When response bandwidths of TLS are smaller than their detunings from the resonance, the resonant response and thus the loss is reduced. At higher excitation powers, the loss follows a logarithmic power dependence, consistent with predictions from the generalized tunneling model (GTM). A model combining the discrete TLS ensemble with the GTM is proposed and matches the temperature and power dependence of the measured internal loss of the resonator with reasonable parameters.
Superconducting resonators are widely used in many applications such as qubit readout for quantum computing applications, and kinetic inductance detectors. These resonators are susceptible to numerous loss and noise mechanisms under microwave excitation, especially the dissipation due to non-equilibrium quasi-particles and two-level systems (TLS), which can result in a decrease of the superconducting intrinsic quality factor (QiQ_iQi​) in high quality superconducting resonators. Particularly in the few-photon and low temperature (T) regime, TLS losses can become a dominant loss mechanism. In this study, novel aluminum half-wavelength resonators are investigated, focusing on the loss properties at extra-low power and low temperature. An unusual increase of Qi(T)Q_i(T)Qi​(T) with deceasing temperature is observed. This behavior is attributed to the increase of TLS coherence time (T2T_2T2​) at ultra-low temperatures and powers. This T2T_2T2​ increase is consistent with other work on resonant frequency noise in resonators and measurements of individual TLS, and likely arises from interacting TLS in the aluminum half-wavelength resonators.
As superconducting kinetic inductance detectors (KIDs) continue to grow in popularity for sensitive submillimeter detection and other applications, there is a drive to advance toward lower-loss devices. We present measurements of diagnostic thin-film aluminum coplanar waveguide (CPW) resonators designed to inform ongoing KID development at NASA Goddard Space Flight Center. The resonance frequencies span f0f_0f0​ = 3.5-4 GHz and include quarter-wave and half-wave resonators with varying coupling capacitor designs. We present measurements of the device film properties and an analysis of the dominant mechanisms of loss in the resonators measured in a dark environment, demonstrating quality factors of Qi−1≈3.64−8.57 ×10−8Q_i^{-1} \approx 3.64-8.57\ \times 10^{-8}Qi−1​≈3.64−8.57 ×10−8. We observe an enhanced level of suppression in the loss contributions from two-level systems (TLS) at intermediate-to-high read powers, and a regime at these powers and low temperatures where contributions from intrinsic processes Qi−1Q_i^{-1}Qi−1​,other dominate the total loss. We also observe deviations from the standard TLS loss model at low powers and temperatures below 60 mK, and use a modified model to describe this behavior.
Superconducting high-kinetic inductance materials like granular aluminum (grAl) are a versatile part of the circuit quantum electrodynamics (cQED) toolbox, provided their losses at microwave frequencies are low enough. To further advance the use of grAl in quantum devices, it is indispensable to identify the dominant loss mechanisms. The standard approach pairs electromagnetic simulations of resonator geometry with measured temperature and power dependence of resonance frequency and loss rate. Most materials follow the phenomenological theory of two-level systems (TLSs) at low temperatures, resulting in an initial decrease of the resonance frequency with increasing temperature. In our work, we observe an opposite behavior at the lowest temperatures: The resonance frequency initially increases with both temperature and readout power, contradicting the standard TLS model predictions. We are able to explain a part of the data by an alternative mechanism associated with the effect of superconducting quasiparticles in a granular system with spatially-nonuniform gap. Yet, the observed change in the resonance frequency with temperature is not matched by a proportional change in the loss rate. We also observe anomalous positive frequency responses following high-energy events, characterized by several time scales. While anomalous behavior has been reported previously in grAl, the disagreement with standard models is particularly visible in our devices thanks to their exceptionally low loss rates.
Measuring the internal quality factor of coplanar waveguide superconducting resonators is an established method of determining small losses in superconducting devices. Often, resonator losses are attributed to two-level system (TLS) defects using a power dependent model for the quality factor. However, excess non-equilibrium quasiparticles can also limit the quality factor of superconducting resonators. Here, a two-temperature, power and temperature dependent model is used to evaluate resonator losses for titanium nitride and aluminum coplanar waveguide resonators with loss tangents of 10−5–10−6. This model enables a set of parameters to describe both the internal quality factor and fractional frequency shift of the resonator across a broad range of average cavity photon numbers, from 1 to 106, and temperatures between those limited by the experimental apparatus near 50 mK and thermal quasiparticle dominated. The presented model also offers potential insight into observing the temperature and power dependence of TLS–TLS interactions in these resonators.
High quality factor, i.e. low loss, microwave resonators are important for quantum information storage and addressing. In this work we study the resonance frequency and loss in superconducting coplanar waveguide resonators as a function of power and temperature. We find that there is increased loss at low power and low temperature. The increased loss is attributed to the existence of two-level systems (TLS) at the surfaces, interfaces, and in the bulk of insulators deposited on the structures. We show that both the temperature dependence of the resonant frequency and the power dependence of the loss can be used to find the TLS contribution to the loss. The TLS intrinsic loss tangent derived from the frequency shift data at high power is shown to agree well with the direct loss measurement at low power. The former allows for a relatively fast measurement of the TLS loss. As an example, we measure the properties of amorphous AlOXdeposited on the resonators and find a TLS loss tangent of 1 × 10-3.