Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2108.08281 · Quantum Communications and Quantum Imaging

Theoretical comparison of quantum and classical illumination for simple detection-based LIDAR

Richard Murchie, Jonathan Pritchard, John Jeffers

Published Jul 30, 2021• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Use of non-classical light in a quantum illumination scheme provides an advantage over classical illumination when used for LIDAR with a simple and realistic detection scheme based on Geiger-mode single photon detectors. Here we provide an analysis that accounts for the additional information gained when detectors do not fire that is typically neglected and show an improvement in performance of quantum illumination. Moreover, we provide a theoretical framework quantifying performance of both quantum and classical illumination for simple target detection, showing parameters for which a quantum advantage exists. Knowledge of the regimes that demonstrate a quantum advantage will inform where possible practical quantum LIDAR utilising non-classical light could be realised.

DOI
10.1117/12.2597042

Related papers

Theoretical comparison of quantum and classical illumination for simple detection-based LIDAR

Richard J. Murchie, Jonathan D. Pritchard, John Jeffers

Use of non-classical light in a quantum illumination scheme provides an advantage over classical illumination when used for LIDAR with a simple and realistic detection scheme based on Geiger-mode single photon detectors. Here we provide an analysis that accounts for the additional information gained when detectors do not fire that is typically neglected and show an improvement in performance of quantum illumination. Moreover, we provide a theoretical framework quantifying performance of both quantum and classical illumination for simple target detection, showing parameters for which a quantum advantage exists. Knowledge of the regimes that demonstrate a quantum advantage will inform where possible practical quantum LIDAR utilising non-classical light could be realised.

•Aug 1, 2021•3 citations

Object detection and range finding with quantum states using simple detection

Richard J. Murchie, Jonathan D. Pritchard, John Jeffers

The task of sensing the presence of a target object using a weak light source is challenging when the object is embedded in a noisy environment. One possibility is to use quantum illumination to do this, as it can outperform classical illumination in determining the object presence and range. This advantage persists even when both classical and quantum illumination are restricted to identical suboptimal object-detection measurements based on nonsimultaneous, phase-insensitive coincidence counts. Motivated by realistic experimental protocols, we present a theoretical framework for analyzing coincident multishot data with simple detectors. This approach allows for the often-overlooked noncoincidence data to be included, as well as providing a calibration-free threshold for inferring an object’s presence and range, enabling a fair comparison between different detection regimes. Our results quantify the advantage of quantum over classical illumination when performing target discrimination in a noisy thermal environment, including estimating the number of shots required to detect a target with a given confidence level. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2307.10785•Physical Review Applied•Jun 5, 2024•5 citations

Quantum lidar scenario with simple detection

John Jeffers

Quantum Lidar is a future technology that can mean different things to different people. To some it means detection and identification of classical-type lidar signals reflected from an illuminated target at or near the single photon level. This is facilitated by advances in semiconductor detector technology that allow highly efficient photocounting. To others it is more stringent, requiring exploitation of covertness associated with being essentially undetectable by the target in a thermal background, whilst allowing the lidar operator to filter her own signal from this noise. Again there is nothing specifically quantum about this. Any source that mimics of the energy rate per bandwidth seen by the illuminated object in the direction of the source can appear covert. In order to exploit quantum optics one can use inherent correlations, whether entangled or otherwise between light beams. Simple correlated optical beams can do this in two ways, perhaps by storing one beam as a reference and later performing correlated detection with the return signal in a phase sensitive manner. This is the “gold standard” for quantum lidar, but will be difficult outside of laboratory situations. In microscopy such phase control might be possible, or perhaps in the radio or microwave region for a quantum radar. Less challenging is a scenario in which an immediate local measurement of one beam conditions the beam sent to the target, allowing the return signal to be sifted from noise more easily. Here we will consider such a simple system, providing a range equation for a basic quantum lidar if it is to be operated covertly or openly. Open operation allows increased quantum signal brightness but also provides a quantum advantage, unspoofability – the lidar operator can in principle recognise their own return signal. We will also provide an analysis of quantum lidar detection based on quantum hypothesis testing and use this to perform Monte Carlo simulation of both target detections and false positive avoidance in a noisy background. The theory will be applied to experimental data.

Emerging Imaging and Sensing Technologies for Security and Defence; and Advanced Manufacturing Technologies for Micro- and Nanosystems in Security and Defence•Sep 18, 2020•1 citation

Optimisation of simple quantum illumination

Thomas Brougham, John Jeffers

We investigate the optimization of direct measurement twin beam (signal-idler) quantum illumination. We focus on each of the three main components of such a system in turn: the detectors, the light beam parameters and the information processing protocol. Surprisingly, there can be an advantage to having a signal detector whose quantum efficiency is significantly less than perfect. This advantage does not vanish in the quantum lidar limits of low object reflectivities or signal strengths. We show that decreasing the pulse separation, while keeping the photon flux fixed to retain the same degree of covertness, can improve target detection performance dramatically. Finally, we show that post-selecting on the idler detector firing is sub-optimal for target detection.

SPIE Quantum Technologies•Jun 10, 2024•0 citations

Design and Performance Analysis of a Quantum-Illumination LiDAR System

Hawraa Slaiman, Sara Abou Chakra, Hassanein Rabah

Modern optical sensing systems, particularly LiDAR, play a central role in remote sensing and precision measurement. However, they face fundamental limits when operating in noisy and highly lossy environments. Quantum illumination has emerged as a promising approach to overcome these challenges by exploiting quantum correlations. This work presents the system design and performance analysis of a quantum illumination based LiDAR architecture operating at optical frequencies. The proposed system exploits entangled photon pairs generated through spontaneous parametric down conversion to enhance detection sensitivity and robustness under weak return conditions. A complete hardware oriented framework is developed, including the entanglement source, nonlinear crystal configuration, pump laser requirements, optical propagation path, quantum memory implementation, and a detection architecture based on quantum erasure Hong-Ou-Mandel interference. Practical realization using superconducting nanowire single photon detectors is discussed to enable high efficiency and low noise photon measurement. In addition, a system level link budget and noise analysis evaluates the impact of optical losses, atmospheric attenuation, turbulence, and detector imperfections on overall performance. The study highlights how quantum correlations can improve signal to noise performance compared with classical illumination strategies, particularly in low reflectivity and high background scenarios. The presented architecture provides a realistic framework for implementing quantum LiDAR systems and supports the development of next generation long range sensing technologies.

IEEE Middle East and North Africa Communications Conference (MENACOMM)•May 12, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Illumination: A Laboratory Investigation

Bhashyam Balaji, Duncan G. England

Quantum illumination is an idea for detection of targets in the presence of a noisy background using a photon pair that is entangled in some degree of freedom, such as frequency. This paper provides a simple and illustrative proof-of-concept setup of a quantum illumination investigation. Detection and imaging is investigated in the optical regime using a correlated source and the performance of classical illumination and quantum illumination are compared for detection and imaging experiments. The quantum advantage is demonstrated in the acquired data and possible application spaces and technological requirements are identified for developing practical systems.

IEEE International Carnahan Conference on Security Technology (ICCST)•Oct 1, 2018•18 citations
Use of non-classical light in a quantum illumination scheme provides an advantage over classical illumination when used for LIDAR with a simple and realistic detection scheme based on Geiger-mode single photon detectors. Here we provide an analysis that accounts for the additional information gained when detectors do not fire that is typically neglected and show an improvement in performance of quantum illumination. Moreover, we provide a theoretical framework quantifying performance of both quantum and classical illumination for simple target detection, showing parameters for which a quantum advantage exists. Knowledge of the regimes that demonstrate a quantum advantage will inform where possible practical quantum LIDAR utilising non-classical light could be realised.
Use of non-classical light in a quantum illumination scheme provides an advantage over classical illumination when used for LIDAR with a simple and realistic detection scheme based on Geiger-mode single photon detectors. Here we provide an analysis that accounts for the additional information gained when detectors do not fire that is typically neglected and show an improvement in performance of quantum illumination. Moreover, we provide a theoretical framework quantifying performance of both quantum and classical illumination for simple target detection, showing parameters for which a quantum advantage exists. Knowledge of the regimes that demonstrate a quantum advantage will inform where possible practical quantum LIDAR utilising non-classical light could be realised.
The task of sensing the presence of a target object using a weak light source is challenging when the object is embedded in a noisy environment. One possibility is to use quantum illumination to do this, as it can outperform classical illumination in determining the object presence and range. This advantage persists even when both classical and quantum illumination are restricted to identical suboptimal object-detection measurements based on nonsimultaneous, phase-insensitive coincidence counts. Motivated by realistic experimental protocols, we present a theoretical framework for analyzing coincident multishot data with simple detectors. This approach allows for the often-overlooked noncoincidence data to be included, as well as providing a calibration-free threshold for inferring an object’s presence and range, enabling a fair comparison between different detection regimes. Our results quantify the advantage of quantum over classical illumination when performing target discrimination in a noisy thermal environment, including estimating the number of shots required to detect a target with a given confidence level. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Quantum Lidar is a future technology that can mean different things to different people. To some it means detection and identification of classical-type lidar signals reflected from an illuminated target at or near the single photon level. This is facilitated by advances in semiconductor detector technology that allow highly efficient photocounting. To others it is more stringent, requiring exploitation of covertness associated with being essentially undetectable by the target in a thermal background, whilst allowing the lidar operator to filter her own signal from this noise. Again there is nothing specifically quantum about this. Any source that mimics of the energy rate per bandwidth seen by the illuminated object in the direction of the source can appear covert. In order to exploit quantum optics one can use inherent correlations, whether entangled or otherwise between light beams. Simple correlated optical beams can do this in two ways, perhaps by storing one beam as a reference and later performing correlated detection with the return signal in a phase sensitive manner. This is the “gold standard” for quantum lidar, but will be difficult outside of laboratory situations. In microscopy such phase control might be possible, or perhaps in the radio or microwave region for a quantum radar. Less challenging is a scenario in which an immediate local measurement of one beam conditions the beam sent to the target, allowing the return signal to be sifted from noise more easily. Here we will consider such a simple system, providing a range equation for a basic quantum lidar if it is to be operated covertly or openly. Open operation allows increased quantum signal brightness but also provides a quantum advantage, unspoofability – the lidar operator can in principle recognise their own return signal. We will also provide an analysis of quantum lidar detection based on quantum hypothesis testing and use this to perform Monte Carlo simulation of both target detections and false positive avoidance in a noisy background. The theory will be applied to experimental data.
We investigate the optimization of direct measurement twin beam (signal-idler) quantum illumination. We focus on each of the three main components of such a system in turn: the detectors, the light beam parameters and the information processing protocol. Surprisingly, there can be an advantage to having a signal detector whose quantum efficiency is significantly less than perfect. This advantage does not vanish in the quantum lidar limits of low object reflectivities or signal strengths. We show that decreasing the pulse separation, while keeping the photon flux fixed to retain the same degree of covertness, can improve target detection performance dramatically. Finally, we show that post-selecting on the idler detector firing is sub-optimal for target detection.
Modern optical sensing systems, particularly LiDAR, play a central role in remote sensing and precision measurement. However, they face fundamental limits when operating in noisy and highly lossy environments. Quantum illumination has emerged as a promising approach to overcome these challenges by exploiting quantum correlations. This work presents the system design and performance analysis of a quantum illumination based LiDAR architecture operating at optical frequencies. The proposed system exploits entangled photon pairs generated through spontaneous parametric down conversion to enhance detection sensitivity and robustness under weak return conditions. A complete hardware oriented framework is developed, including the entanglement source, nonlinear crystal configuration, pump laser requirements, optical propagation path, quantum memory implementation, and a detection architecture based on quantum erasure Hong-Ou-Mandel interference. Practical realization using superconducting nanowire single photon detectors is discussed to enable high efficiency and low noise photon measurement. In addition, a system level link budget and noise analysis evaluates the impact of optical losses, atmospheric attenuation, turbulence, and detector imperfections on overall performance. The study highlights how quantum correlations can improve signal to noise performance compared with classical illumination strategies, particularly in low reflectivity and high background scenarios. The presented architecture provides a realistic framework for implementing quantum LiDAR systems and supports the development of next generation long range sensing technologies.
Quantum illumination is an idea for detection of targets in the presence of a noisy background using a photon pair that is entangled in some degree of freedom, such as frequency. This paper provides a simple and illustrative proof-of-concept setup of a quantum illumination investigation. Detection and imaging is investigated in the optical regime using a correlated source and the performance of classical illumination and quantum illumination are compared for detection and imaging experiments. The quantum advantage is demonstrated in the acquired data and possible application spaces and technological requirements are identified for developing practical systems.