arXiv:2108.07744

An Iterative Improvement Method for HHL algorithm for Solving Linear System of Equations

Yoshiyuki Saito, Xinwei Lee, Dongsheng Cai, Nobuyoshi Asai

Published Aug 17, 2021• 3 citations

Abstract

We propose an iterative improvement method for the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) algorithm to solve a linear system of equations. This is a quantum-classical hybrid algorithm. The accuracy is essential to solve the linear system of equations. However, the accuracy of the HHL algorithm is limited by the number of quantum bits used to express the eigenvalues of the matrix. Our iterative method improves the accuracy of the HHL solutions, and gives higher accuracy which surpasses the accuracy limited by the number of quantum bits. In practical HHL algorithm, a huge number of measurements is required to obtain good accuracy, even if we provide a sufficient number of quantum bits for the eigenvalue expression, since the solution is statistically processed from the measurements. Our improved iterative method can reduce the number of measurements. Moreover, the sign information for each eigenstate of the solution is lost once the measurement is made, although the sign is significant. Therefore, the naïve iterative method of the HHL algorithm may slow down, especially, when the solution includes wrong signs. In this paper, we propose and evaluate an improved iterative method for the HHL algorithm that is robust against the sign information loss, in terms of the number of iterations and the computational accuracy.

DOI: 10.48550/arxiv.2108.07744

Related papers

An Enhanced Hybrid HHL Algorithm

Jack Morgan, Éric Ghysels, Hamed Mohammadbagherpoor

We present a classical enhancement to improve the accuracy of the Hybrid variant (Hybrid HHL) of the quantum algorithm for solving linear systems of equations proposed by Harrow, Hassidim, and Lloyd (HHL). We achieve this by using higher precision quantum estimates of the eigenvalues relevant to the linear system, and a new classical step to guide the eigenvalue inversion part of Hybrid HHL. We show that eigenvalue estimates with just two extra bits of precision result in tighter error bounds for our Enhanced Hybrid HHL compared to HHL. Our enhancement reduces the error of Hybrid HHL by an average of 57 percent on an ideal quantum processor for a representative sample of 2x2 systems. On IBM Torino and IonQ Aria-1 hardware, we see that the error of Enhanced Hybrid HHL is on average 13 percent and 20 percent (respectively) less than that of HHL for the same set of systems.

arXiv:2404.10103Apr 15, 20240 citations

Hybrid quantum linear equation algorithm and its experimental test on IBM Quantum Experience

Yonghae Lee, Jaewoo Joo, Soojoon Lee

We propose a hybrid quantum algorithm based on the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) algorithm for solving a system of linear equations. In this paper, we show that our hybrid algorithm can reduce a circuit depth from the original HHL algorithm by means of a classical information feed-forward after the quantum phase estimation algorithm, and the results of the hybrid algorithm are identical to those of the HHL algorithm. In addition, it is experimentally examined with four qubits in the IBM Quantum Experience setups, and the experimental results of our algorithm show higher accurate performance on specific systems of linear equations than that of the HHL algorithm.

arXiv:1807.10651Scientific ReportsMar 18, 201977 citations

Benchmarking Highly Precise Quantum Linear Systems Algorithms

Adrian Harkness, Kate Saltovets, Mohammadhossein Mohammadisiahroudi +1 more

Systems of linear equations are ubiquitous across science, engineering, machine learning, and even finance. While classical methods can be prohibitively slow for large-scale problems, quantum linear systems algorithms offer the potential for exponential speedup in certain parameter regimes. However, a significant gap persists between this theoretical promise and practical implementation, as the advantages are often obscured by the substantial quantum resources and high sensitivity to noise inherent in current quantum hardware. One way to bridge this gap is through the use of Iterative Refinement, a classical post-processing scheme that can exponentially improve the accuracy to which a linear system of equations can be solved using low-precision arithmetic. In the context of quantum linear systems algorithms, such as the HHL algorithm proposed by Harrow, Hassidim, and Loyd, Iterative Refinement can greatly reduce the quantum resources required to calculate an accurate solution in terms of tomography cost, circuit volume, and fault-tolerant overhead. Here, we compute and benchmark highly precise solutions to linear systems of equations of up to eight variables by running HHL with Iterative Refinement on NISQ quantum computers. We also present our open-source implementation, emphasizing that our circuit is not tailored to specific problem instances, as most available implementations are.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)Aug 30, 20250 citations

The HHL algorithm: Implementation and research directions

Varsha Sambhaje, Anju Chaurasia

Linear systems of equations lie at the heart of numerous scientific and engineering challenges. In cutting-edge arena like artificial intelligence, machine learning and neuro-computation, these systems serve as a fundamental tool for mathematical modeling. Classical algorithms for solving linear systems have been extensively developed and forms the backbone of diverse applications across various scientific disciplines. While classical algorithms exist for solving linear systems, they often encounter limitations termed “NP-completeness” as data complexity increases. The emerging field of quantum computing offers a revolutionary approach to deal with these kinds of problems. The Harrow–Hassidim–Lloyd (HHL) algorithm tackles these challenges and opens new avenues for research. This study delves into the contemporary effectiveness of the HHL algorithm to address systems of linear equations. By examining recent research in quantum machine learning, we aim to assess the HHL algorithm’s potential to revolutionize the process of optimizing hyperparameters for machine learning models, resulting in increased efficiency and cost savings. This paper meticulously analyzes the HHL algorithm and explores its evolution from conception to the latest advancements. A comprehensive examination of the HHL algorithm, including its evolution over time, is thoroughly explored. The investigation delves into the potential challenges and limitations that might hinder the practical deployment of the HHL algorithm. Identifying these roadblocks will pave the way for future research and development efforts.

International Journal of Quantum InformationMay 31, 20242 citations

Theory and Methodology for Information Security: Solving Linear Systems with the HHL Algorithm

Mikhail Pavlov

Abstract This study explores the application of the Harrow–Hassidim–Lloyd (HHL) algorithm for solving linear systems within the context of information security and quantum computing. Linear systems are fundamental in scientific, engineering, financial, and economic applications, impacting tasks such as differential equation solving, regression analysis, and Fourier transforms. In the quantum domain, effective implementation of the HHL algorithm relies on proper utilization of Pauli matrices and the choice of computational bases, including the computational basis and Hadamard basis. This work highlights how basis selection influences algorithmic efficiency and solution accuracy, offering insights for optimizing quantum computation workflows. By examining the HHL algorithm, we demonstrate its potential for accelerating linear system solutions and enhancing information processing capabilities, which may contribute to more secure and efficient computational methodologies in diverse application areas.

Mar 4, 20260 citations

Optimization of the HHL Algorithm

Dhruv Sood, Nilmani Mathur, Vikram Tripathi

The Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) algorithm is a quantum algorithm for solving systems of linear equations that, in principle, offers an exponential improvement in scaling with the system size compared to classical approaches. In this work, we investigate the practical implementation and optimisation of the HHL algorithm with a focus on improving its performance on near-term quantum simulators. After outlining the algorithm, we examine two optimisation strategies aimed at improving fidelity and scalability: Suzuki-Trotter decomposition of the Hamiltonian evolution operator and a block-encoding approach that embeds the problem matrix into a larger unitary operator. The performance of these methods is evaluated through simulations on matrices with varying sparsity, including diagonal, tridiagonal, moderately dense, and fully dense cases. Our results show that while HHL achieves near-ideal fidelity for highly structured matrices, performance degrades as sparsity decreases due to the increasing cost of Hamiltonian simulation and reduced post-selection probability due to higher condition number. Block encoding is found to provide improved fidelity for moderately dense matrices, whereas Trotterisation offers a qubit-efficient approach for sparse systems. These results highlight the importance of matrix structure in determining the practical efficiency of HHL and inform future implementations that combine algorithmic optimisation with hardware-aware design.

quant-pharXiv:2603.15756Mar 18, 20260 citations