Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2108.02794 · Physical review. D/Physical review. D.

Measurements in QFT: Weakly coupled local particle detectors and entanglement harvesting

Daniel Grimmer, Bruno de S. L. Torres, Eduardo Martín-Martínez

Published Oct 11, 2021• 20 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present a comparison of the AQFT-based Fewster-Verch framework with the Unruh-DeWitt particle detector models commonly employed in relativistic quantum information and QFT in curved space. We use this comparison to respond to a recent paper [M. H. Ruep, Weakly coupled local particle detectors cannot harvest entanglement, arXiv:2103.13400.] in which it was argued that the Reeh-Schlieder theorem prevents weakly coupled local particle detectors from harvesting vacuum entanglement from a quantum field. Their claim can be traced back to the mixedness that a local particle detector cannot escape from because of the entanglement that it must have with the quantum fields outside of the localization area. We argue that for any realistic scale of localization for physical particle detectors, the effect of that mixedness is negligible, and that weakly coupled, localized particle detectors are not impeded from harvesting vacuum entanglement.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.104.085014

Related papers

A Tale of Two Detector Models: Weakly coupled local particle detectors and entanglement harvesting

Daniel Grimmer, Bruno de S. L. Torres, Eduardo Martín-Martínez

We present a comparison of the AQFT-based Fewster-Verch framework with the Unruh-DeWitt particle detector models commonly employed in relativistic quantum information and QFT in curved space. We use this comparison to respond to a recent paper [arXiv:2103.13400] in which it was argued that the Reeh-Schlieder theorem prevents weakly coupled local particle detectors from harvesting vacuum entanglement from a quantum field. Their claim can be traced back to the mixedness that a local particle detector cannot escape from because of the entanglement that it must have with the quantum fields outside of the localization area. We argue that for any realistic scale of localization for physical particle detectors the effect of that mixedness is negligible, and that weakly coupled localized particle detectors are not impeded from harvesting vacuum entanglement.

•Aug 9, 2021•0 citations

Weakly coupled local particle detectors cannot harvest entanglement

Maximilian H. Ruep

Abstract Many states of linear real scalar quantum fields (in particular Reeh–Schlieder states) on flat as well as curved spacetime are entangled on spacelike separated local algebras of observables. It has been argued that this entanglement can be ‘harvested’ by a pair of so-called particle detectors, for example singularly or non-locally coupled quantum mechanical harmonic oscillator Unruh detectors. In an attempt to avoid such imperfect coupling, we analyse a model-independent local and covariant entanglement harvesting protocol based on the local probes of a recently proposed measurement theory of quantum fields. We then introduce the notion of a local particle detector concretely given by a local mode of a linear real scalar probe field on possibly curved spacetime and possibly under the influence of external fields. In a non-perturbative analysis we find that local particle detectors cannot harvest entanglement below a critical coupling strength when the corresponding probe fields are initially prepared in quasi-free Reeh–Schlieder states and are coupled to a system field prepared in a quasi-free state. This is a consequence of the fact that Reeh–Schlieder states restrict to truly mixed states on any local mode.

arXiv:2103.13400•Classical and Quantum Gravity•Aug 5, 2021•22 citations

Quantum information and relativity: harvesting entanglement in different setups

Iara Naomi Nobre Ota

The aim of this work is present the phenomenon denoted entanglement harvesting.We begin by introducing entanglement historically.Following, we go beyond the one particle theory in flat spacetime and introduce Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime, showing two famous consequences: the Unruh effect and the Hawking radiation.Finally, we analyze entanglement harvesting for two Unruh-deWitt detectors.In the fisrt example, we see that there is a "sudden death" point of entanglement harvesting when the detectors are near the BTZ black hole event horizon, due to redshift effect and Hawking radiation.Then, we compare the phenomenon for different scenarios, and find out that it is sensitive to the structure of spacetime.Finally, we see how detectors' parameters affect it and find out that the smoothness of the switching of the detectors' coupling to the field is extremely relevant.We also see how the parameters can be used to optimize entanglement harvested.

•Oct 4, 2018•0 citations

Entanglement harvesting and divergences in quadratic Unruh-DeWitt detector pairs

Allison Sachs, Robert B. Mann, Eduardo Martín-Martínez

We analyze correlations between pairs of particle detectors quadratically coupled to a real scalar field. We find that, while a single quadratically coupled detector presents no divergences, when one considers pairs of detectors, there emerge unanticipated persistent divergences (not regularizable via smooth switching or smearing) in the entanglement they acquire from the field. We have characterized such divergences, discussed whether a suitable regularization can allow for fair comparison of the entanglement harvesting ability of the quadratic and the linear couplings, and finally found a UV-safe quantifier of harvested correlations. Our results are relevant to future studies of the entanglement structure of the fermionic vacuum.

arXiv:1704.08263•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Oct 30, 2017•53 citations

Entanglement Harvesting and Divergences in Unruh-DeWitt Detector Pairs

Allison Sachs

We analyze correlations between pairs of detectors quadratically coupled to real and complex scalar bosonic fields in 3+1 dimensions. This is a first step toward studying the entanglement structure of the fermionic vacuum through the entanglement harvesting protocol. We find that, while a single quadratically coupled Unruh-DeWitt presents no divergences, when one considers pairs of detectors there emerge persistent divergences (not regularizable via smooth switching or smearing) in the entanglement they acquire \nfrom the field. These divergences were not anticipated in previous studies. We characterize the divergences, discuss whether a suitable regularization can allow for fair comparison of the entanglement harvesting ability of the quadratic and the linear couplings, and finally find a UV-safe quantifier of harvested correlations.

•Aug 28, 2017•0 citations

Entanglement Harvesting Landscapes: A Common Computational Framework

Rahul Nigam, Ujjwala Vadrevu, Akshay Kulkarni

Entanglement harvesting provides an operational means of probing the nonlocal correlation structure of quantum fields through localized detector-field interactions. Although harvesting has been investigated in a wide variety of spacetime backgrounds and quantum field states, existing studies largely focus on individual detector configurations or specific physical settings. In this work, we develop a unified perturbative framework for entanglement harvesting with localized Unruh-DeWitt detectors that is applicable to arbitrary detector trajectories and quantum field states through the corresponding Wightman function. By expressing the detector response in terms of dimensionless variables and analytically reducing the perturbative integrals to numerically efficient representations, the framework enables a systematic exploration of multidimensional harvesting landscapes, phase boundaries, and harvesting robustness. As representative applications, we investigate inertial detectors in the Minkowski vacuum, thermal field states, and uniformly accelerated observers. We show that finite temperature enhances both the local detector response and the nonlocal exchange amplitude, leading, within the perturbative Gaussian-switching framework considered here, to an enlargement of the harvesting region in parameter space. The resulting harvesting landscapes provide a global characterization of detector-field interactions and demonstrate how temperature and observer motion reshape the competition between local detector noise and nonlocal field correlations. The framework developed here provides a unified and readily extensible methodology for investigating entanglement harvesting across a broad class of relativistic quantum systems.

arXiv:2609.14401•Sep 13, 2026•0 citations
We present a comparison of the AQFT-based Fewster-Verch framework with the Unruh-DeWitt particle detector models commonly employed in relativistic quantum information and QFT in curved space. We use this comparison to respond to a recent paper [M. H. Ruep, Weakly coupled local particle detectors cannot harvest entanglement, arXiv:2103.13400.] in which it was argued that the Reeh-Schlieder theorem prevents weakly coupled local particle detectors from harvesting vacuum entanglement from a quantum field. Their claim can be traced back to the mixedness that a local particle detector cannot escape from because of the entanglement that it must have with the quantum fields outside of the localization area. We argue that for any realistic scale of localization for physical particle detectors, the effect of that mixedness is negligible, and that weakly coupled, localized particle detectors are not impeded from harvesting vacuum entanglement.
We present a comparison of the AQFT-based Fewster-Verch framework with the Unruh-DeWitt particle detector models commonly employed in relativistic quantum information and QFT in curved space. We use this comparison to respond to a recent paper [arXiv:2103.13400] in which it was argued that the Reeh-Schlieder theorem prevents weakly coupled local particle detectors from harvesting vacuum entanglement from a quantum field. Their claim can be traced back to the mixedness that a local particle detector cannot escape from because of the entanglement that it must have with the quantum fields outside of the localization area. We argue that for any realistic scale of localization for physical particle detectors the effect of that mixedness is negligible, and that weakly coupled localized particle detectors are not impeded from harvesting vacuum entanglement.
Abstract Many states of linear real scalar quantum fields (in particular Reeh–Schlieder states) on flat as well as curved spacetime are entangled on spacelike separated local algebras of observables. It has been argued that this entanglement can be ‘harvested’ by a pair of so-called particle detectors, for example singularly or non-locally coupled quantum mechanical harmonic oscillator Unruh detectors. In an attempt to avoid such imperfect coupling, we analyse a model-independent local and covariant entanglement harvesting protocol based on the local probes of a recently proposed measurement theory of quantum fields. We then introduce the notion of a local particle detector concretely given by a local mode of a linear real scalar probe field on possibly curved spacetime and possibly under the influence of external fields. In a non-perturbative analysis we find that local particle detectors cannot harvest entanglement below a critical coupling strength when the corresponding probe fields are initially prepared in quasi-free Reeh–Schlieder states and are coupled to a system field prepared in a quasi-free state. This is a consequence of the fact that Reeh–Schlieder states restrict to truly mixed states on any local mode.
The aim of this work is present the phenomenon denoted entanglement harvesting.We begin by introducing entanglement historically.Following, we go beyond the one particle theory in flat spacetime and introduce Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime, showing two famous consequences: the Unruh effect and the Hawking radiation.Finally, we analyze entanglement harvesting for two Unruh-deWitt detectors.In the fisrt example, we see that there is a "sudden death" point of entanglement harvesting when the detectors are near the BTZ black hole event horizon, due to redshift effect and Hawking radiation.Then, we compare the phenomenon for different scenarios, and find out that it is sensitive to the structure of spacetime.Finally, we see how detectors' parameters affect it and find out that the smoothness of the switching of the detectors' coupling to the field is extremely relevant.We also see how the parameters can be used to optimize entanglement harvested.
We analyze correlations between pairs of particle detectors quadratically coupled to a real scalar field. We find that, while a single quadratically coupled detector presents no divergences, when one considers pairs of detectors, there emerge unanticipated persistent divergences (not regularizable via smooth switching or smearing) in the entanglement they acquire from the field. We have characterized such divergences, discussed whether a suitable regularization can allow for fair comparison of the entanglement harvesting ability of the quadratic and the linear couplings, and finally found a UV-safe quantifier of harvested correlations. Our results are relevant to future studies of the entanglement structure of the fermionic vacuum.
We analyze correlations between pairs of detectors quadratically coupled to real and complex scalar bosonic fields in 3+1 dimensions. This is a first step toward studying the entanglement structure of the fermionic vacuum through the entanglement harvesting protocol. We find that, while a single quadratically coupled Unruh-DeWitt presents no divergences, when one considers pairs of detectors there emerge persistent divergences (not regularizable via smooth switching or smearing) in the entanglement they acquire \nfrom the field. These divergences were not anticipated in previous studies. We characterize the divergences, discuss whether a suitable regularization can allow for fair comparison of the entanglement harvesting ability of the quadratic and the linear couplings, and finally find a UV-safe quantifier of harvested correlations.
Entanglement harvesting provides an operational means of probing the nonlocal correlation structure of quantum fields through localized detector-field interactions. Although harvesting has been investigated in a wide variety of spacetime backgrounds and quantum field states, existing studies largely focus on individual detector configurations or specific physical settings. In this work, we develop a unified perturbative framework for entanglement harvesting with localized Unruh-DeWitt detectors that is applicable to arbitrary detector trajectories and quantum field states through the corresponding Wightman function. By expressing the detector response in terms of dimensionless variables and analytically reducing the perturbative integrals to numerically efficient representations, the framework enables a systematic exploration of multidimensional harvesting landscapes, phase boundaries, and harvesting robustness. As representative applications, we investigate inertial detectors in the Minkowski vacuum, thermal field states, and uniformly accelerated observers. We show that finite temperature enhances both the local detector response and the nonlocal exchange amplitude, leading, within the perturbative Gaussian-switching framework considered here, to an enlargement of the harvesting region in parameter space. The resulting harvesting landscapes provide a global characterization of detector-field interactions and demonstrate how temperature and observer motion reshape the competition between local detector noise and nonlocal field correlations. The framework developed here provides a unified and readily extensible methodology for investigating entanglement harvesting across a broad class of relativistic quantum systems.