Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2106.15993 · Physical Review A

Correlation energy and quantum correlations in a solvable model

Javier Faba, Vicente Martín, Luis Miguel Robledo

Published Sep 30, 2021• 31 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Typically in many-body systems the correlation energy, which is defined as the difference between the exact ground-state energy and the mean-field solution, has been a measure of the system's total correlations. However, under the quantum information context, it is possible to define some quantities in terms of the system's constituents that measure the classical and quantum correlations, such as the entanglement entropy, mutual information, quantum discord, one-body entropy, etc. In this work we apply concepts of quantum information in fermionic systems in order to study traditional correlation measures (the relative correlation energy). Concretely, we analyze the two- and three-level Lipkin models, which are exactly solvable (but nontrivial) models commonly used in the context of the many-body problem. We conclude that the correlation energy is not a good estimator of the total correlation of the system, and information theoretic measures should be considered.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.104.032428

Related papers

Analysis of quantum correlations within the ground state of a three-level Lipkin model

Javier Faba, Vicente Martín, Robledo Martín, Luis Miguel

The performance of beyond mean-field methods in solving the quantum many-body problem for fermions is usually characterized by the correlation energy measured with respect to the underlying mean-field value. In this paper we address the issue of characterizing the amount of correlations associated to different approximations from a quantum information perspective. With this goal in mind, we analyze the traditional Hartree-Fock (HF) method with spontaneous symmetry breaking, the HF with symmetry restoration and the generator coordinate method in an exactly solvable fermion model known as the three-level Lipkin model. To characterize correlations including entanglement and beyond we use the quantum discord between different partition orbitals. We find that for physically motivated partitions, the quantum discord of the exact ground state is reasonably well reproduced by the different approximations. However, other partitions create "fake quantum correlations" in order to capture quantum correlations corresponding to partitions for which the Hartree-Fock solution fails. Those are removed and redistributed through a symmetry restoration process

•Jun 27, 2022•17 citations

Analysis of quantum correlations within the ground state of a three-level Lipkin model

Javier Faba, Vicente Martín, Luis Miguel Robledo

The performance of beyond mean-field methods in solving the quantum many-body problem for fermions is usually characterized by the correlation energy measured with respect to the underlying mean-field value. In this paper we address the issue of characterizing the amount of correlations associated to different approximations from a quantum information perspective. With this goal in mind, we analyze the traditional Hartree-Fock (HF) method with spontaneous symmetry breaking, the HF with symmetry restoration and the generator coordinate method in an exactly solvable fermion model known as the three-level Lipkin model. To characterize correlations including entanglement and beyond we use the quantum discord between different partition orbitals. We find that for physically motivated partitions, the quantum discord of the exact ground state is reasonably well reproduced by the different approximations. However, other partitions create ``fake quantum correlations'' in order to capture quantum correlations corresponding to partitions for which the Hartree-Fock solution fails. Those are removed and redistributed through a symmetry restoration process.

arXiv:2203.09400•Physical Review A•Jun 27, 2022•0 citations

Mutual information sums and relations with interaction energies in N -particle quantum systems

Saúl J. C. Salazar, Humberto G. Laguna, Robin P. Sagar

The sums of position- and momentum-space mutual information measures are used to examine the pairwise and higher-order statistical correlation in the ground states of N-particle coupled oscillators. Analytical expressions for these measures are shown to be related to the logarithmic interaction energies of these states, plus those of mirror states where the intensities of the one- and two-body potentials are interchanged, and the nature of the attractive or repulsive interaction is opposite to that in the original state. The measures separate the contributions from the interactions and those from the effective interactions due to marginalization into different terms. The pairwise mutual information sum is linearly related to the Shannon entropy sum in two particle systems, while the total correlation sum exhibits a similar relationship in three particle ones. In the latter instance, the interaction information sum can be related to entropy differences. This illustrates how entropy sums are connected to correlation measure sums in these systems. All measures approach zero with large N, when the magnitudes of the one- and two-body potentials are fixed. The pair mutual information and total correlation sums decay monotonically with N in the presence of an attractive potential and monotonically increase with a repulsive potential. On the other hand, the interaction information sum exhibits a minimum at small N, with an attractive potential. This is a consequence of the higher-order correlations governing behavior at smaller N while the pairwise ones dominate at larger N. Results are presented when the magnitude of the one-body potential is set to N.

Physical review. E•Sep 26, 2024•4 citations

Information-Theoretic Features of Many Fermion Systems: An Exploration Based on Exactly Solvable Models

Angel Ricardo Plastino, Diana Monteoliva, Angelo Plastino

Finite quantum many fermion systems are essential for our current understanding of Nature. They are at the core of molecular, atomic, and nuclear physics. In recent years, the application of information and complexity measures to the study of diverse types of many-fermion systems has opened a line of research that elucidates new aspects of the structure and behavior of this class of physical systems. In this work we explore the main features of information and information-based complexity indicators in exactly soluble many-fermion models of the Lipkin kind. Models of this kind have been extremely useful in shedding light on the intricacies of quantum many body physics. Models of the Lipkin kind play, for finite systems, a role similar to the one played by the celebrated Hubbard model of solid state physics. We consider two many fermion systems and show how their differences can be best appreciated by recourse to information theoretic tools. We appeal to information measures as tools to compare the structural details of different fermion systems. We will discover that few fermion systems are endowed by a much larger complexity-degree than many fermion ones. The same happens with the coupling-constants strengths. Complexity augments as they decrease, without reaching zero. Also, the behavior of the two lowest lying energy states are crucial in evaluating the system's complexity.

Entropy•Nov 10, 2021•7 citations

Unreliability of mutual information as a measure for variations in total correlations

S. Alipour, Sasu Tuohino, A. T. Rezakhani +1 more

Correlations disguised in various forms underlie a host of important phenomena in classical and quantum systems, such as information and energy exchanges. The quantum mutual information and the norm of the correlation matrix are both considered as proper measures of total correlations. We demonstrate that, when applied to the same system, these two measures can actually show significantly different behavior except at least in two limiting cases: when there are no correlations and when there is maximal quantum entanglement. We further quantify the discrepancy by providing analytic formulas for time derivatives of the measures for an interacting bipartite system evolving unitarily. We argue that to properly account for correlations one should consider the full information provided by the correlation matrix (and reduced states of the subsystems). Scalar quantities such as the norm of the correlation matrix or the quantum mutual information can only capture a part of the complex features of correlations. As a concrete example, we show that in describing heat exchange associated with correlations neither of these quantities can fully capture the underlying physics. As a byproduct, we also prove an area law for quantum mutual information in systems with local and short-range interactions, without need to assume Markovianity or final thermal equilibrium.

arXiv:1909.06661•Physical Review A•Apr 7, 2020•9 citations

Genuine Quantum and Classical Correlations in Multipartite Systems

Gian Luca Giorgi, Bruno Bellomo, Fernando Galve +1 more

Generalizing the quantifiers used to classify correlations in bipartite systems, we define genuine total, quantum, and classical correlations in multipartite systems. The measure we give is based on the use of relative entropy to quantify the distance between two density matrices. Moreover, we show that, for pure states of three qubits, both quantum and classical bipartite correlations obey a ladder ordering law fixed by two-body mutual informations, or, equivalently, by one-qubit entropies.

arXiv:1108.0434•Physical Review Letters•Nov 3, 2011•123 citations
Typically in many-body systems the correlation energy, which is defined as the difference between the exact ground-state energy and the mean-field solution, has been a measure of the system's total correlations. However, under the quantum information context, it is possible to define some quantities in terms of the system's constituents that measure the classical and quantum correlations, such as the entanglement entropy, mutual information, quantum discord, one-body entropy, etc. In this work we apply concepts of quantum information in fermionic systems in order to study traditional correlation measures (the relative correlation energy). Concretely, we analyze the two- and three-level Lipkin models, which are exactly solvable (but nontrivial) models commonly used in the context of the many-body problem. We conclude that the correlation energy is not a good estimator of the total correlation of the system, and information theoretic measures should be considered.
The performance of beyond mean-field methods in solving the quantum many-body problem for fermions is usually characterized by the correlation energy measured with respect to the underlying mean-field value. In this paper we address the issue of characterizing the amount of correlations associated to different approximations from a quantum information perspective. With this goal in mind, we analyze the traditional Hartree-Fock (HF) method with spontaneous symmetry breaking, the HF with symmetry restoration and the generator coordinate method in an exactly solvable fermion model known as the three-level Lipkin model. To characterize correlations including entanglement and beyond we use the quantum discord between different partition orbitals. We find that for physically motivated partitions, the quantum discord of the exact ground state is reasonably well reproduced by the different approximations. However, other partitions create "fake quantum correlations" in order to capture quantum correlations corresponding to partitions for which the Hartree-Fock solution fails. Those are removed and redistributed through a symmetry restoration process
The performance of beyond mean-field methods in solving the quantum many-body problem for fermions is usually characterized by the correlation energy measured with respect to the underlying mean-field value. In this paper we address the issue of characterizing the amount of correlations associated to different approximations from a quantum information perspective. With this goal in mind, we analyze the traditional Hartree-Fock (HF) method with spontaneous symmetry breaking, the HF with symmetry restoration and the generator coordinate method in an exactly solvable fermion model known as the three-level Lipkin model. To characterize correlations including entanglement and beyond we use the quantum discord between different partition orbitals. We find that for physically motivated partitions, the quantum discord of the exact ground state is reasonably well reproduced by the different approximations. However, other partitions create ``fake quantum correlations'' in order to capture quantum correlations corresponding to partitions for which the Hartree-Fock solution fails. Those are removed and redistributed through a symmetry restoration process.
The sums of position- and momentum-space mutual information measures are used to examine the pairwise and higher-order statistical correlation in the ground states of N-particle coupled oscillators. Analytical expressions for these measures are shown to be related to the logarithmic interaction energies of these states, plus those of mirror states where the intensities of the one- and two-body potentials are interchanged, and the nature of the attractive or repulsive interaction is opposite to that in the original state. The measures separate the contributions from the interactions and those from the effective interactions due to marginalization into different terms. The pairwise mutual information sum is linearly related to the Shannon entropy sum in two particle systems, while the total correlation sum exhibits a similar relationship in three particle ones. In the latter instance, the interaction information sum can be related to entropy differences. This illustrates how entropy sums are connected to correlation measure sums in these systems. All measures approach zero with large N, when the magnitudes of the one- and two-body potentials are fixed. The pair mutual information and total correlation sums decay monotonically with N in the presence of an attractive potential and monotonically increase with a repulsive potential. On the other hand, the interaction information sum exhibits a minimum at small N, with an attractive potential. This is a consequence of the higher-order correlations governing behavior at smaller N while the pairwise ones dominate at larger N. Results are presented when the magnitude of the one-body potential is set to N.
Finite quantum many fermion systems are essential for our current understanding of Nature. They are at the core of molecular, atomic, and nuclear physics. In recent years, the application of information and complexity measures to the study of diverse types of many-fermion systems has opened a line of research that elucidates new aspects of the structure and behavior of this class of physical systems. In this work we explore the main features of information and information-based complexity indicators in exactly soluble many-fermion models of the Lipkin kind. Models of this kind have been extremely useful in shedding light on the intricacies of quantum many body physics. Models of the Lipkin kind play, for finite systems, a role similar to the one played by the celebrated Hubbard model of solid state physics. We consider two many fermion systems and show how their differences can be best appreciated by recourse to information theoretic tools. We appeal to information measures as tools to compare the structural details of different fermion systems. We will discover that few fermion systems are endowed by a much larger complexity-degree than many fermion ones. The same happens with the coupling-constants strengths. Complexity augments as they decrease, without reaching zero. Also, the behavior of the two lowest lying energy states are crucial in evaluating the system's complexity.
Correlations disguised in various forms underlie a host of important phenomena in classical and quantum systems, such as information and energy exchanges. The quantum mutual information and the norm of the correlation matrix are both considered as proper measures of total correlations. We demonstrate that, when applied to the same system, these two measures can actually show significantly different behavior except at least in two limiting cases: when there are no correlations and when there is maximal quantum entanglement. We further quantify the discrepancy by providing analytic formulas for time derivatives of the measures for an interacting bipartite system evolving unitarily. We argue that to properly account for correlations one should consider the full information provided by the correlation matrix (and reduced states of the subsystems). Scalar quantities such as the norm of the correlation matrix or the quantum mutual information can only capture a part of the complex features of correlations. As a concrete example, we show that in describing heat exchange associated with correlations neither of these quantities can fully capture the underlying physics. As a byproduct, we also prove an area law for quantum mutual information in systems with local and short-range interactions, without need to assume Markovianity or final thermal equilibrium.