arXiv:2102.00960 · SciPost Physics Lecture Notes

Magnetisation and Mean Field Theory in the Ising Model

Dalton A R Sakthivadivel

Published Jan 19, 2022• 18 citations

Abstract

In this set of notes, a complete, pedagogical tutorial for applying mean field theory to the two-dimensional Ising model is presented. Beginning with the motivation and basis for mean field theory, we formally derive the Bogoliubov inequality and discuss mean field theory itself. We proceed with the use of mean field theory to determine a magnetisation function, and the results of the derivation are interpreted graphically, physically, and mathematically. We give a new interpretation of the self-consistency condition in terms of intersecting surfaces and constrained solution sets. We also include some more general comments on the thermodynamics of the phase transition. We end by evaluating symmetry considerations in magnetisation, and some more subtle features of the Ising model. Together, a self-contained overview of the mean field Ising model is given, with some novel presentation of important results.

DOI: 10.21468/scipostphyslectnotes.35

Related papers

A mean field approach to the Ising chain in a transverse magnetic field

Carlos Osácar, Amalio F. Pacheco

Abstract We evaluate a mean field method to describe the properties of the ground state of the Ising chain in a transverse magnetic field. Specifically, a method of the Bethe–Peierls type is used by solving spin blocks with a self-consistency condition at the borders. The computations include the critical point for the phase transition, exponent of magnetisation and energy density. All results are obtained using basic quantum mechanics at an undergraduate level. The advantages and the limitations of the approach are emphasised.

European Journal of PhysicsApr 12, 20171 citation

Discontinuous magnetisation in mean-field theory

Manuel Berrondo, S. Y. Larsen

The authors calculate the classical partition function for a mean-field effective Hamiltonian with a finite number of spins. They find a single-valued magnetisation as a function of the external magnetic field, with a sharp transition at zero magnetic field, below the Curie point. The authors then calculate the thermodynamic limit for the same system (equivalent to the infinite-dimensional Ising model) in a straightforward fashion, and find the corresponding discontinuous behaviour at the phase transition point, with no van der Waals loop.

European Journal of PhysicsJul 1, 19892 citations

Mean field theory I: Ising model, equilibrium theory

K. H. Fischer, John Hertz

In this chapter we will put the concepts we have developed in Chapter 2 to work in constructing the mean field theory for an Ising spin glass. The term ‘mean field theory’ (henceforth frequently abbreviated ‘MFT’) can be interpreted in many ways. Here we will take it to mean the exact solution of a model in which the forces are of infinitely long range, so that each spin interacts equally strongly with every other one. For spin glasses, this is the Sherrington–Kirkpatrick (SK) model (1975), which we solve heuristically (though unfortunately incorrectly) in Section 3.1. The error is a somewhat subtle one, as is evident from the fact that we obtain exactly the same result in the more systematic calculations of Sections 3.2 (a direct summation of the leading terms in N −1 in high-temperature perturbation theory) and 3.3 (which uses the replica formalism). In both these approaches, we can also see how the theory itself reveals that it is wrong, since they lead to negative values of quantities which are necessarily positive. We then study the correct mean field theory, with replica symmetry breaking, in Section 3.4, including the remarkable nature of the broken ergodicity it implies and an examination of its stability. Further physical insight into the problem is obtained in Section 3.5 from the mean field equations first introduced by Thouless, Anderson and Palmer (TAP) (1977).

Cambridge University Press eBooksMay 2, 19910 citations

Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena: Renormalisation Group Method

Deepak Kumar

These lectures describe the physics of phase transitions and critical phenomena. After introducing the thermodynamics of phase transitions, these general considerations are made explicit by presenting statistical mechanical calculations on a lattice gas model in the mean-field approximation. Then the Landau theory of phase transitions is presented. The form of free energy in the Landau theory is motivated by an explicit mean field calculation for the Ising model. This is followed by a discussion of spatial correlations and the breakdown of the mean field theory due to increase of spatial fluctuations near the critical point. This calculation also brings out the role of dimension of the system for the critical behaviour. The basic ideas of Renormalization Group (RG) are then introduced and illustrated by a simple RG calculation for the one-dimensional Ising model. Real-space RG calculations are then applied to the two-dimensional Ising model on the triangular lattice, which, in fact, brings forth several key features of the RG technique. A discussion of more general aspects of the RG formalism, such as scaling for spatial correlation functions, relevant and irrelevant couplings, universality, upper critical dimension, etc. are introduced.

Texts and readings in physical sciencesJan 1, 20010 citations

Mean-field theory

Paul M. Chaikin, T. C. Lubensky

In the preceding two chapters, we have discussed various types of order that can occur in nature and how the ordering process can be quantified by the introduction of order parameters. We also developed a formalism for dealing with the thermodynamics of ordered states. In this chapter, we will use mean-field theory to study phase transitions and the properties of various ordered phases. Mean-field theory is an approximation for the thermodynamic properties of a system based on treating the order parameter as spatially constant. It is a useful description if spatial fluctuations are not important. It becomes an exact theory only when the range of interactions becomes infinite. It, nevertheless, makes quantitatively correct predictions about some aspects of phase transitions (e.g. critical exponents) in high spatial dimensions where each particle or spin has many nearest neighbors, and it makes qualitatively correct predictions in physical dimensions. Mean-field theory has the enormous advantage of being mathematically simple, and it is almost invariably the first approach taken to predict phase diagrams and properties of new experimental systems. Before proceeding, let us review some simple facts about phase transitions. At high temperatures, there is no order, and the order parameter 〈φ〉 is zero. At a critical temperature, T c , order sets in so that, for temperatures below T c , 〈φ〉 is nonzero. If 〈φ〉 rises continuously from zero, as shown in Fig. 4.0.1a, the transition is second order .

Cambridge University Press eBooksJun 22, 199540 citations

How Phase Transitions Occur in Practice

Nigel D. Goldenfeld

This chapter explores the basic notions of phase transitions, and the manner in which non-analytic thermodynamic behaviour may occur in principle. It presents some concrete calculations of phase transition behaviour in magnetic systems. The chapter is concerned with the transfer matrix method, first introduced by Hendrik Kramers, which reduces the problem of calculating the partition function to the problem of finding the eigenvalues of a certain matrix. It describes the low temperature expansion and Weiss’ mean field theory for magnets. Mean field theory is the simplest treatment of an interacting statistical mechanical system, apart from the approximation of ignoring the interactions all together. The chapter provides a simple, non-systematic derivation of mean field theory for the Ising model. This mean field theory can be easily improved by applying it to clusters of spins rather than individual spins.

CRC Press eBooksMar 8, 20181 citation