Developments over the last two decades have opened the path towards quantum technologies in many quantum systems, such as cold atoms, trapped ions, cavity-quantum electrodynamics (QED), and circuit-QED. However, the fragility of quantum states to the effects of measurement and decoherence still poses one of the greatest challenges in quantum technology. An imperative capability in this path is quantum feedback, as it enhances the control possibilities and allows for prolonging coherence times through quantum error correction. While changing parameters from shot to shot of an experiment or procedure can be considered feedback, quantum mechanics also allows for the intriguing possibility of performing feedback operations during the measurement process itself. This broader approach to measurements leads to the concepts of weak measurement, quantum trajectories, and numerous types of feedback with no classical analogs. These types of processes are the primary focus of this review. We introduce the concept of quantum feedback in the context of circuit-QED, an experimental platform with significant potential in quantum feedback and technology. We then discuss several experiments and see how they elucidate the concepts of continuous measurements and feedback. We conclude with an overview of coherent feedback, with application to fault-tolerant error correction.
Developments over the last two decades have opened the path towards quantum technologies in many quantum systems, such as cold atoms, trapped ions, cavity-quantum electrodynamics (QED), and circuit-QED. However, the fragility of quantum states to the effects of measurement and decoherence still poses one of the greatest challenges in quantum technology. An imperative capability in this path is quantum feedback, as it enhances the control possibilities and allows for prolonging coherence times through quantum error correction. While changing parameters from shot to shot of an experiment or procedure can be considered feedback, quantum mechanics also allows for the intriguing possibility of performing feedback operations during the measurement process itself. This broader approach to measurements leads to the concepts of weak measurement, quantum trajectories, and numerous types of feedback with no classical analogs. These types of processes are the primary focus of this review. We introduce the concept of quantum feedback in the context of circuit-QED, an experimental platform with significant potential in quantum feedback and technology. We then discuss several experiments and see how they elucidate the concepts of continuous measurements and feedback. We conclude with an overview of coherent feedback, with application to fault-tolerant error correction.
Abstract Quantum measurement has always been thought of as a formal, sudden projection that changes the system state instantly. However, in real life, the process of measurement involves a physical interaction that takes time to gather the information. The paper discusses the continuous quantum measurement that challenges the traditional instant measurement idea with the detector’s accumulated data continuously uninterruptedly. The paper starts by laying down the basic mathematics, which gradually leads to the modern Stochastic master equations and quantum trajectories through generalized measurements positive operator-valued measures and quantum instruments. The crucial experimental setups like circuit QED, trapped ions, and optomechanics are delineated where these notions have been put into practice. The significant ramifications of ongoing observation are then discussed, starting with the fundamental Zeno effect, measurement backaction, and continuing through the active steering of quantum states and the emergence of measurement-induced phase transitions in many-body systems. One of the main ideas of the paper is the attribute of measurement as a powerful control method which enables real-time feedback, state stabilization, and continuous quantum error correction. Finally, the paper points out the open problems that remain in the areas of many-body systems’ scalability and the coupling of machine learning with real-time quantum control.
The advance of experimental techniques in circuit quantum electrodynamics over last decadehas made it possible to monitor the evolution of qubits under continuous measurements in\nreal time . This kind of measurements, as compared to the discrete ones, provides a stream\nof information for feedback to alter the system's quantum dynamics continuously in a desired\nmanner, thus allowing broader possibilities. We obtain the information at a cost, the backaction on the states. However, the back-action turns out not to be just something disturbing \nand harmful to the control but instead can be harnessed, together with the control, to steer the system to our targets. \nThis thesis discusses one such application, namely to use measurements to create entanglement from remote qubits under locally optimal control. It is illustrated that by carefully designing symmetric measurement and feedback operators, we can construct efficient Markovian or non-Markovian protocols which generate N-qubit W,\ngeneral Dicke and Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states with high fidelity above 94% up to\nN = 100. In some cases, the fidelity even approaches unity. Following that, we describe how\nto take advantages of the continuous stream of information to protect the unitary dynamics of\na quantum system subject to noises. We develop a practical protocol for continuous operation\nof a quantum error correcting code for protection of coherent evolution due to an encoded\nHamiltonian against environmental errors, using the three qubit bit-flip code and bit-flip\nerrors as a canonical example. We demonstrate, for both quantum memory and adiabatic\nHamiltonians, that the protocol, once optimized, can significantly reduce logical errors with\na performance which is close to the theoretical limit of the bit-flip code's capability. In the\nadiabatic Hamiltonian case, we also propose some novel correction operators instead of the\nconventional ones to further reduce the logical errors.
The standard quantum formalism introduced at the undergraduate level treats measurement as an instantaneous collapse. In reality however, no physical process can occur over a truly infinitesimal time interval. A more subtle investigation of open quantum systems lead to the theory of continuous measurement and quantum trajectories, in which wave function collapse occurs over a finite time scale associated with an interaction. Within this formalism, it becomes possible to ask many new questions that would be trivial or even ill-defined in the context of the more basic measurement model. In this thesis, we investigate both theoretically and experimentally what fundamentally new capabilities arise when an experimental apparatus can resolve the continuous dynamics of a measurement. Theoretically, we show that when one can perform feedback operations on the timescale of the measurement process, the resulting tools provide significantly more control over entanglement generation, and in some settings can generate it optimally. We derive these results using a novel formalism which encompasses most known quantum feedback protocols. Experimentally, we show that continuous measurement allows one to observe the dynamics of a system undergoing simultaneous non-commuting measurements, which provides a reinterpretation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. Finally, we combine the theoretical focus on quantum feedback with the experimental capabilities of superconducting circuits to implement a feedback controlled quantum amplifier. The resulting system is capable of adaptive measurement, which we use to perform the first canonical phase measurement.
Quantum computers hold immense promise for solving problems intractable for classical machines, yet their practical realization is hindered by the fragility of quantum states. Quantum Error Correction (QEC) is indispensable for protecting quantum information from environmental noise and operational imperfections. Traditional QEC schemes often rely on measurement-based feedback, which involves performing measurements, processing the classical outcomes, and then applying corrective operations. This process introduces latency, consumes significant resources, and can itself be a source of errors due to the invasive nature of quantum measurement and the classical-quantum interface. Coherent feedback control offers a compelling alternative by allowing the controller to directly interact with the quantum system using quantum fields, without intermediate measurement and classical processing. This maintains the coherence of the quantum information throughout the feedback loop, potentially leading to more robust and faster error correction. This paper explores the theoretical framework and potential advantages of employing coherent feedback control for autonomous QEC. We review existing QEC paradigms, delve into the principles of coherent feedback, and propose how this approach can be integrated into autonomous QEC architectures. Specifically, we investigate its application to bosonic codes and stabilizer codes, discussing the engineering challenges and the prospects for achieving truly fault-tolerant quantum computation by minimizing the classical overhead and enhancing real-time error suppression.
Quantum systems exhibit unique behaviors governed by principles distinct from classical physics, notably in the realms of measurement and control. This paper explores the fundamental concepts and applications of quantum measurement and feedback control in quantum systems. Measurement in quantum mechanics disrupts the state of a system due to the inherent probabilistic nature of quantum states. This disruption, often described by the collapse of the wave function, presents challenges and opportunities for understanding and manipulating quantum states. Quantum measurement theory addresses how observations affect quantum states and the role of measurement devices in this process. Feedback control mechanisms offer a pathway to mitigate the disruptive effects of measurement and harness them for coherent quantum operations. By continuously monitoring and adjusting quantum systems based on measurement outcomes, feedback control enables stabilization, state preparation, and enhanced coherence times. Examples include quantum error correction, quantum state tomography, and real-time manipulation of quantum bits (qubits).
Circuit quantum electrodynamics (cQED), exemplified by a coupled system of a superconducting qubit and a microwave cavity, is a powerful framework for the quantum control and measurement of macroscopic quantum states in solid-state circuits. Quantum circuits based on superconducting qubits have emerged as one of the leading platforms in the pursuit of fault-tolerant quantum computing. Despite significant progress in extending qubit lifetimes, refining experimental protocols, and scaling up quantum processors, errors arising from the control and measurement of superconducting qubits continue to hinder the realization of a universal quantum computer. To investigate the error mechanisms for state-of-the-art qubits, we realize long-lived superconducting transmon qubits that exhibit fluctuating lifetimes, with an average of 0.2 ms and a maximum exceeding 0.4 ms. We then investigate their dominant error mechanism. By introducing novel time-resolved error measurements that are synchronized with the operation of the pulse tube cooler in a dilution refrigerator, we find that mechanical vibrations from the pulse tube induce nonequilibrium dynamics in highly coherent qubits, leading to their correlated bit-flip errors. Our findings not only deepen our understanding of qubit error mechanisms but also provide valuable insights into potential error-mitigation strategies for achieving fault tolerance by decoupling superconducting qubits from their mechanical environments. We also present a novel scheme for operating a cQED system in a regime where the cavity is largely displaced. We find that a qubit drive at the bare cavity frequency can effectively displace the cavity field while minimizing the cavity-drive-induced dephasing and the ac Stark shift. Furthermore, we demonstrate that standard cQED protocols, such as qubit control, readout, and cavity single-photon generation, remain compatible with largely displaced cavity fields, even beyond the critical photon number. These findings open new pathways for exploring cQED dynamics in large-photon-number regimes, including the study of nonlinear phenomena in microwave cavities, the saturation of two-level system baths for extending the coherence of microwave quantum states, and the acceleration of the dispersive readout. Finally, mechanical resonators have emerged as integral components in quantum computing for storing and transducing quantum information. Low-frequency mechanical resonators, with extremely low energy dissipation rates, are particularly interesting for extending the lifetimes of stored quantum information. However, integrating low-frequency mechanical resonators with qubits is challenging because their small energy gaps make coherent energy exchange and ground-state preparation difficult. In this thesis, we report the first steps towards the characterization of a hybrid quantum device, consisting of a Transmon qubit and a circuit optomechanical system, both coupled to a 3D microwave cavity.