We construct topological defects in two-dimensional classical lattice models and quantum chains. The defects satisfy local commutation relations guaranteeing that the partition function is independent of their path. These relations and their solutions are extended to allow defect lines to fuse, branch and satisfy all the properties of a fusion category. We show how the two-dimensional classical lattice models and their topological defects are naturally described by boundary conditions of a Turaev-Viro-Barrett-Westbury partition function. These defects allow Kramers-Wannier duality to be generalized to a large class of models, explaining exact degeneracies between non-symmetry-related ground states as well as in the low-energy spectrum. They give a precise and general notion of twisted boundary conditions and the universal behaviour under Dehn twists. Gluing a topological defect to a boundary yields linear identities between partition functions with different boundary conditions, allowing ratios of the universal g-factor to be computed exactly on the lattice. We develop this construction in detail in a variety of examples, including the Potts, parafermion and height models.
Abstract In this paper and its sequel, we construct topologically invariant defects in two-dimensional classical lattice models and quantum spin chains. We show how defect lines commute with the transfer matrix/Hamiltonian when they obey the defect commutation relations , cousins of the Yang–Baxter equation. These relations and their solutions can be extended to allow defect lines to branch and fuse, again with properties depending only on topology. In this part I, we focus on the simplest example, the Ising model. We define lattice spin-flip and duality defects and their branching, and prove they are topological. One useful consequence is a simple implementation of Kramers–Wannier duality on the torus and higher genus surfaces by using the fusion of duality defects. We use these topological defects to do simple calculations that yield exact properties of the conformal field theory describing the continuum limit. For example, the shift in momentum quantization with duality-twisted boundary conditions yields the conformal spin 1/16 of the chiral spin field. Even more strikingly, we derive the modular transformation matrices explicitly and exactly.
The critical two-dimensional classical Ising model on the square lattice has two topological conformal defects: the
Z2 symmetry defect ${D}_{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}$ and the Kramers-Wannier duality defect ${D}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}}$. These two defects implement antiperiodic boundary conditions and a more exotic form of twisted boundary conditions, respectively. On the torus, the partition function
ZD of the critical Ising model in the presence of a topological conformal defect
D is expressed in terms of the scaling dimensions ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ and conformal spins ${s}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ of a distinct set of primary fields (and their descendants, or conformal towers) of the Ising conformal field theory. This characteristic conformal data ${{{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}},{s}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}}_{D}$ can be extracted from the eigenvalue spectrum of a transfer matrix
MD for the partition function
ZD. In this paper, we investigate the use of tensor network techniques to both represent and coarse grain the partition functions ${Z}_{{D}_{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}}$ and ${Z}_{{D}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}$ of the critical Ising model with either a symmetry defect ${D}_{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}$ or a duality defect ${D}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}}$. We also explain how to coarse grain the corresponding transfer matrices ${M}_{{D}_{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}}$ and ${M}_{{D}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}$, from which we can extract accurate numerical estimates of ${{{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}},{s}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}}_{{D}_{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}}$ and ${{{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}},{s}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}}_{{D}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}$. Two key ingredients of our approach are (i) coarse graining of the defect
D, which applies to any (i.e., not just topological) conformal defect and yields a set of associated scaling dimensions ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$, and (ii) construction and coarse graining of a generalized translation operator using a local unitary transformation that moves the defect, which only exist for topological conformal defects and yields the corresponding conformal spins ${s}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$.
Defects associated with non-invertible symmetries have attracted significant attention in recent years. Among them, Kramers-Wannier (KW) duality defects have been investigated in both classical statistical systems and quantum Hamiltonian models. Aasen et al. analyzed duality defects in the 2D Ising model and in statistical models built from fusion categories, while Koide et al. later constructed a duality defect in 4D lattice gauge theory. In this work, we extend these developments by providing a systematic construction of KW duality defects/KW defects for a broad class of models formulated within the chain complex framework. Our construction employs the strange correlator, an overlap between a topologically ordered state and a product state, to realize these KW defects.
We relate two classical dualities in low-dimensional quantum field theory: Kramers-Wannier duality of the Ising and related lattice models in
2 dimensions, with electromagnetic duality for finite gauge theories in
3 dimensions. The relation is mediated by the notion of boundary field theory: Ising models are boundary theories for pure gauge theory in one dimension higher. Thus the Ising order/disorder operators are endpoints of Wilson/'t Hooft defects of gauge theory. Symmetry breaking on low-energy states reflects the multiplicity of topological boundary states. In the process we describe lattice theories as (extended) topological field theories with boundaries and domain walls. This allows us to generalize the duality to non-abelian groups; finite, semi-simple Hopf algebras; and, in a different direction, to finite homotopy theories in arbitrary dimension.
The twofold twist defects in the
D(Zk) quantum double model (Abelian topological phase) carry non-Abelian fractional Majorana-like characteristics. We align these twist defects in a line and construct a one-dimensional Hamiltonian which only includes the pairwise interaction. For the defect chain with an even number of twist defects, it is equivalent to the
Zk clock model with a periodic boundary condition (up to some phase factor for the boundary term), while for the odd number case, it maps to the
Zk clock model with a duality twisted boundary condition. At the critical point, for both cases, the twist defect chain enjoys an additional translation symmetry, which corresponds to the Kramers-Wannier duality symmetry in the
Zk clock model and can be generated by a series of braiding operators for twist defects. We further numerically investigate the low energy excitation spectrum for
k=3,4,5, and 6. For the even-defect chain, the critical points are the same as the
Zk clock conformal field theories (CFTs), while for the odd-defect chain, when $k\ensuremath{\ne}4$, the critical points correspond to orbifolding a
Z2 symmetry of CFTs of the even-defect chain. For
k=4 case, we numerically observe some similarity to the
Z4 twist fields in the
SU(2)1/D4 orbifold CFT.
It has been a long-standing open problem to construct a general framework for relating the spectra of dual theories to each other. Here, we solve this problem for the case of one-dimensional quantum lattice models with symmetry-twisted boundary conditions. In Ref. [PRX Quantum 4, 020357], dualities are defined between (categorically) symmetric models that only differ in a choice of module category. Using matrix product operators, we construct from the data of module functors explicit symmetry operators preserving boundary conditions as well as intertwiners mapping topological sectors of dual models onto one another. We illustrate our construction with a family of examples that are in the duality class of the spin- 12 Heisenberg XXZ model. One model has symmetry operators forming the fusion category Rep(S3) of representations of the group S3 . We find that the mapping between its topological sectors and those of the XXZ model is associated with the nontrivial braided autoequivalence of the Drinfel’d center of Rep(S3) . Published by the American Physical Society 2024