Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2006.02788 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Diffusion and operator entanglement spreading

Vincenzo Alba

Published Sep 7, 2021• 40 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Understanding the spreading of the operator space entanglement entropy (OSEE) is key in order to explore out-of-equilibrium quantum many-body systems. Here we argue that for integrable models the dynamics of the OSEE is related to the diffusion of the operator front. We derive the logarithmic bound $1/2ln(t)$ for the OSEE of some simple, i.e., low-rank, diagonal local operators. We numerically check that the bound is saturated in the rule 54 chain, which is representative of interacting integrable systems. Remarkably, the same bound is saturated in the spin-1/2 Heisenberg $XXZ$ chain. Away from the isotropic point and from the free-fermion point, the OSEE grows as $1/2ln(t)$, irrespective of the chain anisotropy, suggesting universality. Finally, we discuss the effect of integrability breaking. We show that strong finite-time effects are present, which prevent us from probing the asymptotic behavior of the OSEE.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.104.094410

Related papers

Operator Entanglement in Interacting Integrable Quantum Systems: The Case of the Rule 54 Chain

Vincenzo Alba, Jérôme Dubail, Marko Medenjak

In a many-body quantum system, local operators in the Heisenberg picture O(t)=e^{iHt}Oe^{-iHt} spread as time increases. Recent studies have attempted to find features of that spreading which could distinguish between chaotic and integrable dynamics. The operator entanglement-the entanglement entropy in operator space-is a natural candidate to provide such a distinction. Indeed, while it is believed that the operator entanglement grows linearly with time t in chaotic systems, we present evidence that it grows only logarithmically in generic interacting integrable systems. Although this logarithmic growth has been previously established for noninteracting fermions, there has been no progress on interacting integrable systems to date. In this Letter we provide an analytical upper bound on operator entanglement for all local operators in the "Rule 54" qubit chain, a cellular automaton model introduced in the 1990s [Bobenko et al., CMP 158, 127 (1993)CMPHAY0010-361610.1007/BF02097234], and recently advertised as the simplest representative of interacting integrable systems. Physically, the logarithmic bound originates from the fact that the dynamics of the models is mapped onto the one of stable quasiparticles that scatter elastically. The possibility of generalizing this scenario to other interacting integrable systems is briefly discussed.

arXiv:1901.04521•Physical Review Letters•Jun 28, 2019•156 citations

Operator spreading in quantum hardcore gases

Marko Medenjak

Abstract In this article we study a set of integrable quantum cellular automata, the quantum hardcore gases (QHCG), with an arbitrary local Hilbert space dimension, and discuss the matrix product ansatz based approach for solving the dynamics of local operators analytically. Subsequently, we focus on the dynamics of operator spreading, in particular on the out-of-time ordered correlation functions (OTOCs), operator weight spreading and operators space entanglement entropy (OSEE). All of the quantities were conjectured to provide signifying features of integrable systems and quantum chaos. We show that in QHCG OTOCs spread diffusively and that in the limit of the large local Hilbert space dimension they increase linearly with time, despite their integrability. On the other hand, it was recently conjectured that operator weight front, which is associated with the extent of operators, spreads diffusively in both, integrable and generic systems, but its decay seems to differ in these two cases (Lopez-Piqueres et al 2021 Phys. Rev. B 104 104307). We observe that the spreading of the operator weight front in QHCG is markedly different from chaotic, generic integrable and free systems, as the front freezes in the long time limit. Finally, we discuss the OSEE in QHCG and show that it grows at most logarithmically with time in accordance with the conjectured behaviour for interacting integrable systems (Alba et al 2019 Phys. Rev. Lett. 122 250603).

arXiv:2201.00395•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Sep 6, 2022•6 citations

Operator-Space Entanglement Entropy in Random Fermionic Gaussian Dynamics

Pablo Bayona-Pena, Elena Gramellini, Lorenzo Piroli

We study the von Neumann operator-space entanglement entropy (OSEE) of initial product operators evolved under random gaussian dynamics, as modeled by a Brownian SYK$_2$ model. By exploiting a mapping to a domain-wall melting problem, we derive an exact expression for the time-dependent bipartite OSEE in the thermodynamic limit, and obtain an analytic characterization of the corresponding gaussian Page curve emerging at late times. Our results build on recent work on the entanglement dynamics in the all-to-all quantum simple exclusion process, leveraging tools from RMT, including the Coulomb-gas approach and a mapping to the free Jacobi process. Finally, based on our results, we discuss the possibility of relating the OSEE with non-gaussianity measures in the Heisenberg picture.

quant-pharXiv:2610.21723•Oct 16, 2026•0 citations

More on the operator space entanglement (OSE): Rényi OSE, revivals, and integrability breaking*

Vincenzo Alba

Abstract We investigate the dynamics of the Rényi Operator Space Entanglement (OSE) entropies Sn across several one-dimensional integrable and chaotic models. As a paradigmatic integrable system, we first consider the so-called rule 54 chain. Our numerical results reveal that the Rényi OSE entropies of diagonal operators with nonzero trace saturate at long times, in contrast with the behavior of von Neumann entropy. Oppositely, the Rényi entropies of traceless operators exhibit logarithmic growth with time, with the prefactor of this growth depending in a nontrivial manner on n. Notably, at long times, the complete operator entanglement spectrum of an operator can be reconstructed from the spectrum of its traceless part. We observe a similar pattern in the XXZ chain, suggesting Universal behavior. Additionally, we consider dynamics in nonintegrable deformations of the XXZ chain. Finite-time corrections do not allow to access the long-time behavior of the von Neumann entropy. On the other hand, for n > 1 the growth of the entropies is milder, and it is compatible with a sublinear growth, at least for operators associated with global conserved quantities. Finally, we show that in finite-size integrable systems, Sn exhibit strong revivals, which are washed out when integrability is broken.

arXiv:2410.18930•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Apr 7, 2025•4 citations

Free fermion models with an operator entanglement growing as $O(\sqrt{t})$

Federico Tonetto, Jérôme Dubail

We study the time evolution of the Operator Space Entanglement Entropy (OSEE) of one-dimensional number-conserving free fermions subject to a random space- and time-dependent evolution. It is known that, in free-fermion systems without randomness, the OSEE of \emph{local} operators grows at most \emph{logarithmically} in time. Here we show that, in the presence of randomness, the OSEE of local spin operators involving a Jordan-Wigner string grows as $\mathcal O(\sqrt t)$, for all values of the Rényi index. We establish this in two models: a Brownian Hamiltonian and a brick-wall matchgate circuit. We also consider the OSEE of the evolution operator, and we show that it also grows as $\mathcal O(\sqrt{t})$, in contrast with the linear growth generically expected without randomness. We analytically compute the average entropies of the two operators by mapping the quantum models to the symmetric simple exclusion process, relying on an assumption of self-averaging which we support numerically. We also consider two other types of randomness: random evolution in time that keeps spatial translation invariance, and quenched disorder. In the former case, we find that the OSEE also grows as $\sqrt{t}$. In the latter case, we find that the entropy grows as $\mathcal O( \log \log t)$ for Hamiltonian evolution both for local operators with a Jordan-Wigner string and for the evolution operator, whereas it remains bounded at all times in the brick-wall matchgate circuit.

quant-pharXiv:2610.05995•Oct 6, 2026•0 citations

Long-time limits of local operator entanglement in interacting integrable models

J. Alexander Jacoby, Sarang Gopalakrishnan

We explore the long-time behavior of Local Operator Entanglement entropy (LOE) in finite-size interacting integrable systems. For certain operators in the Rule 54 automaton, we prove that the LOE saturates to a value that is at most logarithmic in system size. This bound extends previous work [Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 250603 (2019); Commun. Math. Phys. 371, 651 (2019)] showing LOE grows logarithmically in the early time regime, t\ll L t ≪ L , to the late time regime, $tL $. However, the late-time logarithmic bound relies on a feature of Rule 54 that does not generalize to other interacting integrable systems: namely, that there are only two types of quasiparticles, and therefore only two possible values of the phase shift between quasiparticles. We present a heuristic argument, supported by numerical evidence, that for generic interacting integrable systems (such as the Heisenberg spin chain) the saturated value of the LOE is volume-law in system size.

arXiv:2503.09578•SciPost Physics•Jun 11, 2026•0 citations
Understanding the spreading of the operator space entanglement entropy (OSEE) is key in order to explore out-of-equilibrium quantum many-body systems. Here we argue that for integrable models the dynamics of the OSEE is related to the diffusion of the operator front. We derive the logarithmic bound 1/2ln(t)1/2ln(t)1/2ln(t) for the OSEE of some simple, i.e., low-rank, diagonal local operators. We numerically check that the bound is saturated in the rule 54 chain, which is representative of interacting integrable systems. Remarkably, the same bound is saturated in the spin-1/2 Heisenberg XXZXXZXXZ chain. Away from the isotropic point and from the free-fermion point, the OSEE grows as 1/2ln(t)1/2ln(t)1/2ln(t), irrespective of the chain anisotropy, suggesting universality. Finally, we discuss the effect of integrability breaking. We show that strong finite-time effects are present, which prevent us from probing the asymptotic behavior of the OSEE.
In a many-body quantum system, local operators in the Heisenberg picture O(t)=e^{iHt}Oe^{-iHt} spread as time increases. Recent studies have attempted to find features of that spreading which could distinguish between chaotic and integrable dynamics. The operator entanglement-the entanglement entropy in operator space-is a natural candidate to provide such a distinction. Indeed, while it is believed that the operator entanglement grows linearly with time t in chaotic systems, we present evidence that it grows only logarithmically in generic interacting integrable systems. Although this logarithmic growth has been previously established for noninteracting fermions, there has been no progress on interacting integrable systems to date. In this Letter we provide an analytical upper bound on operator entanglement for all local operators in the "Rule 54" qubit chain, a cellular automaton model introduced in the 1990s [Bobenko et al., CMP 158, 127 (1993)CMPHAY0010-361610.1007/BF02097234], and recently advertised as the simplest representative of interacting integrable systems. Physically, the logarithmic bound originates from the fact that the dynamics of the models is mapped onto the one of stable quasiparticles that scatter elastically. The possibility of generalizing this scenario to other interacting integrable systems is briefly discussed.
Abstract In this article we study a set of integrable quantum cellular automata, the quantum hardcore gases (QHCG), with an arbitrary local Hilbert space dimension, and discuss the matrix product ansatz based approach for solving the dynamics of local operators analytically. Subsequently, we focus on the dynamics of operator spreading, in particular on the out-of-time ordered correlation functions (OTOCs), operator weight spreading and operators space entanglement entropy (OSEE). All of the quantities were conjectured to provide signifying features of integrable systems and quantum chaos. We show that in QHCG OTOCs spread diffusively and that in the limit of the large local Hilbert space dimension they increase linearly with time, despite their integrability. On the other hand, it was recently conjectured that operator weight front, which is associated with the extent of operators, spreads diffusively in both, integrable and generic systems, but its decay seems to differ in these two cases (Lopez-Piqueres et al 2021 Phys. Rev. B 104 104307). We observe that the spreading of the operator weight front in QHCG is markedly different from chaotic, generic integrable and free systems, as the front freezes in the long time limit. Finally, we discuss the OSEE in QHCG and show that it grows at most logarithmically with time in accordance with the conjectured behaviour for interacting integrable systems (Alba et al 2019 Phys. Rev. Lett. 122 250603).
We study the von Neumann operator-space entanglement entropy (OSEE) of initial product operators evolved under random gaussian dynamics, as modeled by a Brownian SYK2_22​ model. By exploiting a mapping to a domain-wall melting problem, we derive an exact expression for the time-dependent bipartite OSEE in the thermodynamic limit, and obtain an analytic characterization of the corresponding gaussian Page curve emerging at late times. Our results build on recent work on the entanglement dynamics in the all-to-all quantum simple exclusion process, leveraging tools from RMT, including the Coulomb-gas approach and a mapping to the free Jacobi process. Finally, based on our results, we discuss the possibility of relating the OSEE with non-gaussianity measures in the Heisenberg picture.
Abstract We investigate the dynamics of the Rényi Operator Space Entanglement (OSE) entropies Sn across several one-dimensional integrable and chaotic models. As a paradigmatic integrable system, we first consider the so-called rule 54 chain. Our numerical results reveal that the Rényi OSE entropies of diagonal operators with nonzero trace saturate at long times, in contrast with the behavior of von Neumann entropy. Oppositely, the Rényi entropies of traceless operators exhibit logarithmic growth with time, with the prefactor of this growth depending in a nontrivial manner on n. Notably, at long times, the complete operator entanglement spectrum of an operator can be reconstructed from the spectrum of its traceless part. We observe a similar pattern in the XXZ chain, suggesting Universal behavior. Additionally, we consider dynamics in nonintegrable deformations of the XXZ chain. Finite-time corrections do not allow to access the long-time behavior of the von Neumann entropy. On the other hand, for n > 1 the growth of the entropies is milder, and it is compatible with a sublinear growth, at least for operators associated with global conserved quantities. Finally, we show that in finite-size integrable systems, Sn exhibit strong revivals, which are washed out when integrability is broken.
Free fermion models with an operator entanglement growing as O(t)O(\sqrt{t})O(t​)
We study the time evolution of the Operator Space Entanglement Entropy (OSEE) of one-dimensional number-conserving free fermions subject to a random space- and time-dependent evolution. It is known that, in free-fermion systems without randomness, the OSEE of \emph{local} operators grows at most \emph{logarithmically} in time. Here we show that, in the presence of randomness, the OSEE of local spin operators involving a Jordan-Wigner string grows as O(t)\mathcal O(\sqrt t)O(t​), for all values of the Rényi index. We establish this in two models: a Brownian Hamiltonian and a brick-wall matchgate circuit. We also consider the OSEE of the evolution operator, and we show that it also grows as O(t)\mathcal O(\sqrt{t})O(t​), in contrast with the linear growth generically expected without randomness. We analytically compute the average entropies of the two operators by mapping the quantum models to the symmetric simple exclusion process, relying on an assumption of self-averaging which we support numerically. We also consider two other types of randomness: random evolution in time that keeps spatial translation invariance, and quenched disorder. In the former case, we find that the OSEE also grows as t\sqrt{t}t​. In the latter case, we find that the entropy grows as O(log⁡log⁡t)\mathcal O( \log \log t)O(loglogt) for Hamiltonian evolution both for local operators with a Jordan-Wigner string and for the evolution operator, whereas it remains bounded at all times in the brick-wall matchgate circuit.
We explore the long-time behavior of Local Operator Entanglement entropy (LOE) in finite-size interacting integrable systems. For certain operators in the Rule 54 automaton, we prove that the LOE saturates to a value that is at most logarithmic in system size. This bound extends previous work [Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 250603 (2019); Commun. Math. Phys. 371, 651 (2019)] showing LOE grows logarithmically in the early time regime, t\ll L t ≪ L , to the late time regime, $tL $. However, the late-time logarithmic bound relies on a feature of Rule 54 that does not generalize to other interacting integrable systems: namely, that there are only two types of quasiparticles, and therefore only two possible values of the phase shift between quasiparticles. We present a heuristic argument, supported by numerical evidence, that for generic interacting integrable systems (such as the Heisenberg spin chain) the saturated value of the LOE is volume-law in system size.