In a many-body quantum system, local operators in the Heisenberg picture O(t)=e^{iHt}Oe^{-iHt} spread as time increases. Recent studies have attempted to find features of that spreading which could distinguish between chaotic and integrable dynamics. The operator entanglement-the entanglement entropy in operator space-is a natural candidate to provide such a distinction. Indeed, while it is believed that the operator entanglement grows linearly with time t in chaotic systems, we present evidence that it grows only logarithmically in generic interacting integrable systems. Although this logarithmic growth has been previously established for noninteracting fermions, there has been no progress on interacting integrable systems to date. In this Letter we provide an analytical upper bound on operator entanglement for all local operators in the "Rule 54" qubit chain, a cellular automaton model introduced in the 1990s [Bobenko et al., CMP 158, 127 (1993)CMPHAY0010-361610.1007/BF02097234], and recently advertised as the simplest representative of interacting integrable systems. Physically, the logarithmic bound originates from the fact that the dynamics of the models is mapped onto the one of stable quasiparticles that scatter elastically. The possibility of generalizing this scenario to other interacting integrable systems is briefly discussed.
In a many-body quantum system, local operators in the Heisenberg picture O(t)=e^{iHt}Oe^{-iHt} spread as time increases. Recent studies have attempted to find features of that spreading which could distinguish between chaotic and integrable dynamics. The operator entanglement-the entanglement entropy in operator space-is a natural candidate to provide such a distinction. Indeed, while it is believed that the operator entanglement grows linearly with time t in chaotic systems, we present evidence that it grows only logarithmically in generic interacting integrable systems. Although this logarithmic growth has been previously established for noninteracting fermions, there has been no progress on interacting integrable systems to date. In this Letter we provide an analytical upper bound on operator entanglement for all local operators in the "Rule 54" qubit chain, a cellular automaton model introduced in the 1990s [Bobenko et al., CMP 158, 127 (1993)CMPHAY0010-361610.1007/BF02097234], and recently advertised as the simplest representative of interacting integrable systems. Physically, the logarithmic bound originates from the fact that the dynamics of the models is mapped onto the one of stable quasiparticles that scatter elastically. The possibility of generalizing this scenario to other interacting integrable systems is briefly discussed.
We explore the long-time behavior of Local Operator Entanglement entropy (LOE) in finite-size interacting integrable systems. For certain operators in the Rule 54 automaton, we prove that the LOE saturates to a value that is at most logarithmic in system size. This bound extends previous work [Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 250603 (2019); Commun. Math. Phys. 371, 651 (2019)] showing LOE grows logarithmically in the early time regime, t\ll L t ≪ L , to the late time regime, $tL $. However, the late-time logarithmic bound relies on a feature of Rule 54 that does not generalize to other interacting integrable systems: namely, that there are only two types of quasiparticles, and therefore only two possible values of the phase shift between quasiparticles. We present a heuristic argument, supported by numerical evidence, that for generic interacting integrable systems (such as the Heisenberg spin chain) the saturated value of the LOE is volume-law in system size.
Understanding the spreading of the operator space entanglement entropy (OSEE) is key in order to explore out-of-equilibrium quantum many-body systems. Here we argue that for integrable models the dynamics of the OSEE is related to the diffusion of the operator front. We derive the logarithmic bound 1/2ln(t) for the OSEE of some simple, i.e., low-rank, diagonal local operators. We numerically check that the bound is saturated in the rule 54 chain, which is representative of interacting integrable systems. Remarkably, the same bound is saturated in the spin-1/2 Heisenberg XXZ chain. Away from the isotropic point and from the free-fermion point, the OSEE grows as 1/2ln(t), irrespective of the chain anisotropy, suggesting universality. Finally, we discuss the effect of integrability breaking. We show that strong finite-time effects are present, which prevent us from probing the asymptotic behavior of the OSEE.
We give a detailed theory for the leading coarse-grained dynamics of entanglement entropy of states and of operators in generic short-range interacting quantum many-body systems. This includes operators spreading under Heisenberg time evolution, which we find are much less entangled than "typical" operators of the same spatial support. Extending previous conjectures based on random circuit dynamics, we provide evidence that the leading-order entanglement dynamics of a given chaotic system are determined by a function E(v), which is model-dependent, but which we argue satisfies certain general constraints. In a minimal membrane picture, E(v) is the "surface tension" of the membrane and is a function of the membrane's orientation v in spacetime. For one-dimensional (1D) systems this surface tension is related by a Legendre transformation to an entanglement entropy growth rate Γ(∂S/∂x) which depends on the spatial "gradient" of the entanglement entropy S(x,t) across the cut at position x. We show how to extract the entanglement growth functions numerically in 1D at infinite temperature using the concept of the operator entanglement of the time evolution operator, and we discuss possible universality of E at low temperatures. Our theoretical ideas are tested against and informed by numerical results for a quantum-chaotic 1D spin Hamiltonian. These results are relevant to the broad class of chaotic many-particle systems or field theories with spatially local interactions, both in 1D and above.
The entanglement in operator space is a well established measure for the complexity of quantum many-body dynamics. In particular, that of local operators has recently been proposed as dynamical chaos indicator, i.e. as a quantity able to discriminate between quantum systems with integrable and chaotic dynamics. For chaotic systems the local-operator entanglement is expected to grow linearly in time, while it is expected to grow at most logarithmically in the integrable case. Here we study the dynamics of local-operator entanglement in dual-unitary quantum circuits, a class of "statistically solvable" quantum circuits that we recently introduced. We identify a class of ``completely chaotic" dual-unitary circuits where the local-operator entanglement grows linearly and we provide a conjecture for its asymptotic behaviour which is in excellent agreement with the numerical results. Interestingly, our conjecture also predicts a ``phase transition" in the slope of the local-operator entanglement when varying the parameters of the circuits.
The entanglement in operator space is a well established measure for the complexity of quantum many-body dynamics. In particular, that of local operators has recently been proposed as dynamical chaos indicator, i.e. as a quantity able to discriminate between quantum systems with integrable and chaotic dynamics. For chaotic systems the local-operator entanglement is expected to grow linearly in time, while it is expected to grow at most logarithmically in the integrable case. Here we study the dynamics of local-operator entanglement in dual-unitary quantum circuits, a class of "statistically solvable" quantum circuits that we recently introduced. We identify a class of ``completely chaotic" dual-unitary circuits where the local-operator entanglement grows linearly and we provide a conjecture for its asymptotic behaviour which is in excellent agreement with the numerical results. Interestingly, our conjecture also predicts a ``phase transition" in the slope of the local-operator entanglement when varying the parameters of the circuits.
Entanglement and magic are resources that reveal complementary aspects of quantum many-body systems. Their interplay is captured by nonlocal magic, the magic that survives arbitrary local changes of basis. Yet their markedly different dynamical behavior leaves open how this irreducible component of magic spreads. Here we connect nonlocal magic to the capacity of entanglement, a tractable quantity measuring fluctuations of the entanglement Hamiltonian. This connection enables analytically controlled predictions across a wide range of many-body dynamics, from chaotic to integrable systems, which we investigate also using large-scale numerical simulations. In chaotic systems, nonlocal magic exhibits a transient buildup, with logarithmic growth in time followed by decay to a size-independent value. For integrable systems, we develop a quasiparticle picture in quantitative agreement with numerics, showing that the same initial growth instead leads to saturation at a value logarithmic in subsystem size. These contrasting behaviors have an operational consequence for entanglement embezzlement: the strongest scramblers embezzle only transiently, whereas free-fermionic dynamics can sustain universal embezzlement in the steady state.