Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2006.02445 · Physical Review A

Density-matrix formalism for PT -symmetric non-Hermitian Hamiltonians with the Lindblad equation

Tommy Ohlsson B, Shun Zhou C

Published Feb 22, 2021• 28 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In the presence of Lindblad decoherence, i.e., dissipative effects in an open quantum system due to interaction with an environment, we examine the transition probabilities between the eigenstates in the two-level quantum system described by non-Hermitian Hamiltonians with the Lindblad equation, for which the parity-time-reversal (PT) symmetry is conserved. First, the density matrix formalism for $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetric non-Hermitian Hamiltonian systems is developed. It is shown that the Lindblad operators ${L}_{j}^{}$ are pseudo-Hermitian, namely, $\ensuremath{\eta}{L}_{j}^{}{\ensuremath{\eta}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}={L}_{j}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}$ with $\ensuremath{\eta}$ being a linear and positive-definite metric, and respect the $\mathcal{PT}$ symmetry as well. We demonstrate that the generalized density matrix ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{\mathrm{G}}^{}(t)\ensuremath{\equiv}\ensuremath{\rho}(t)\ensuremath{\eta}$, instead of the normalized density matrix ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{\mathrm{N}}^{}(t)\ensuremath{\equiv}\ensuremath{\rho}(t)/\mathrm{tr}\left[\ensuremath{\rho}(t)\right]$, should be implemented for the calculation of the transition probabilities in accordance with the linearity requirement. Second, the density matrix formalism is used to derive the transition probabilities in general cases of $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetric non-Hermitian Hamiltonians. In some concrete examples, we calculate compact analytical formulas for the transition probabilities and explore their main features with numerical illustrations. We also make a comparison between our present results and our previous ones using state vectors in the absence of Lindblad decoherence.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.103.022218

Related papers

Conserved quantities in non-hermitian systems via vectorization method

Kaustubh S. Agarwal, Jacob Muldoon, Yogesh N. Joglekar

Open classical and quantum systems have attracted great interest in the past two decades. These include systems described by non-Hermitian Hamiltonians with parity-time (PT) symmetry that are best understood as systems with balanced, separated gain and loss. Here, we present an alternative way to characterize and derive conserved quantities, or intertwining operators, in such open systems. As a consequence, we also obtain non-Hermitian or Hermitian operators whose expectations values show single exponential time dependence. By using a simple example of a PT-symmetric dimer that arises in two distinct physical realizations, we demonstrate our procedure for static Hamiltonians and generalize it to time-periodic (Floquet) cases where intertwining operators are stroboscopically conserved. Inspired by the Lindblad density matrix equation, our approach provides a useful additionto the well-established methods for characterizing time-invariants in non-Hermitian systems.

arXiv:2201.05019•Acta Polytechnica•Feb 28, 2022•3 citations

Transition probabilities in the two-level quantum system with PT-symmetric non-Hermitian Hamiltonians

Tommy Ohlsson B, Shun Zhou C

We investigate how to define in a consistent way the probabilities of the transitions between the “flavor” states of the two-level quantum system, which is described by a non-Hermitian but parity and time-reversal (PT) symmetric Hamiltonian. Explicit calculations are carried out to demonstrate the conservation of probability if a proper definition of the final state is adopted. Finally, this formalism is applied to two-flavor neutrino oscillations νμ → νμ and νμ → ντ in vacuum, where the exact PT symmetry requires the vacuum mixing angle to be maximal, which is compatible with current neutrino oscillation experiments. A possible generalization to the three-flavor case is briefly discussed.

arXiv:1906.01567•Journal of Mathematical Physics•May 1, 2020•22 citations

A Possible Method for Non-Hermitian and Non-PT-Symmetric Hamiltonian Systems

Junqing Li, Yan-Gang Miao, Xue Zhu Zhao

A possible method to investigate non-Hermitian Hamiltonians is suggested through finding a Hermitian operator η+ and defining the annihilation and creation operators to be η+ -pseudo-Hermitian adjoint to each other. The operator η+ represents the η+ -pseudo-Hermiticity of Hamiltonians. As an example, a non-Hermitian and non-PT-symmetric Hamiltonian with imaginary linear coordinate and linear momentum terms is constructed and analyzed in detail. The operator η+ is found, based on which, a real spectrum and a positive-definite inner product, together with the probability explanation of wave functions, the orthogonality of eigenstates, and the unitarity of time evolution, are obtained for the non-Hermitian and non-PT-symmetric Hamiltonian. Moreover, this Hamiltonian turns out to be coupled when it is extended to the canonical noncommutative space with noncommutative spatial coordinate operators and noncommutative momentum operators as well. Our method is applicable to the coupled Hamiltonian. Then the first and second order noncommutative corrections of energy levels are calculated, and in particular the reality of energy spectra, the positive-definiteness of inner products, and the related properties (the probability explanation of wave functions, the orthogonality of eigenstates, and the unitarity of time evolution) are found not to be altered by the noncommutativity.

arXiv:1107.4972•PLoS ONE•Jun 4, 2014•10 citations

Quantum and semiclassical aspects of Lindblad dynamics

Bradley Longstaff

The Lindblad equation is commonly used to model dissipation and decoherence in open quantum systems. Yet many of the properties of Lindblad dynamics are still little understood. This thesis explores various aspects of the Lindblad equation and its connections with non-Hermitian quantum theories. The evolution speed of Lindblad dynamics is investigated and an explicit expression for the speed is derived. The radial component, connected to the rate at which the purity of the state changes, is shown to be determined by the modified skew information of the Lindblad operators. The semiclassical time evolution of Gaussian states under Lindblad dynamics is then considered and a new type of phase-space dynamics is derived for the centre of a Gaussian Wigner function. By viewing the phase-space Lindblad equation as a Schroedinger equation with a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian, a further set of semiclassical equations are derived. These can describe the interference terms in Wigner functions. Further, a PT-symmetric two-level system driven through two consecutive exceptional points at finite speed is considered and an analytical expression for the probability of a non-adiabatic transition is derived. It is shown that the transition through the exceptional points can be experimentally addressed in a PT-symmetric lattice using Bloch oscillations. Finally, a quantum implementation of this PT-symmetric system using ultracold atoms in an optical lattice with single-particle losses is investigated.

•Sep 1, 2019•0 citations

P T -symmetric, non-Hermitian quantum many-body physics—a methodological perspective

V. Meden, Lukas Grunwald, Dante Marvin Kennes

We review the methodology to theoretically treat parity-time- (PT-) symmetric, non-Hermitian quantum many-body systems. They are realized as open quantum systems withPTsymmetry and couplings to the environment which are compatible.PT-symmetric non-Hermitian quantum systems show a variety of fascinating properties which single them out among generic open systems. The study of the latter has a long history in quantum theory. These studies are based on the Hermiticity of the combined system-reservoir setup and were developed by the atomic, molecular, and optical physics as well as the condensed matter physics communities. The interest of the mathematical physics community inPT-symmetric, non-Hermitian systems led to a new perspective and the development of the elegant mathematical formalisms ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics, which do not make any reference to the environment. In the mathematical physics research, the focus is mainly on the remarkable spectral properties of the Hamiltonians and the characteristics of the corresponding single-particle eigenstates. Despite being non-Hermitian, the Hamiltonians can show parameter regimes, in which all eigenvalues are real. To investigate emergent quantum many-body phenomena in condensed matter physics and to make contact to experiments one, however, needs to study expectation values of observables and correlation functions. One furthermore, has to investigate statistical ensembles and not only eigenstates. The adoption of the concepts ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics by parts of the condensed matter community led to a controversial status of the methodology. There is no consensus on fundamental issues, such as, what a proper observable is, how expectation values are supposed to be computed, and what adequate equilibrium statistical ensembles and their corresponding density matrices are. With the technological progress in engineering and controlling open quantum many-body systems it is high time to reconcile the Hermitian with thePT-symmetric and biorthogonal perspectives. We comprehensively review the different approaches, including the overreaching idea of pseudo-Hermiticity. To motivate the Hermitian perspective, which we propagate here, we mainly focus on the ancilla approach. It allows to embed a non-Hermitian system into a larger, Hermitian one. In contrast to other techniques, e.g. master equations, it does not rely on any approximations. We discuss the peculiarities ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics. In these, what is considered to be an observable depends on the Hamiltonian or the selected (biorthonormal) basis. Crucially in addition, what is denoted as an 'expectation value' lacks a direct probabilistic interpretation, and what is viewed as the canonical density matrix is non-stationary and non-Hermitian. Furthermore, the non-unitarity of the time evolution is hidden within the formalism. We pick up several model Hamiltonians, which so far were either investigated from the Hermitian perspective or from thePT-symmetric and biorthogonal one, and study them within the respective alternative framework. This includes a simple two-level, single-particle problem but also a many-body lattice model showing quantum critical behavior. Comparing the outcome of the two types of computations shows that the Hermitian approach, which, admittedly, is in parts clumsy, always leads to results which are physically sensible. In the rare cases, in which a comparison to experimental data is possible, they furthermore agree to these. In contrast, the mathematically elegantPT-symmetric and biorthogonal approaches lead to results which, are partly difficult to interpret physically. We thus conclude that the Hermitian methodology should be employed. However, to fully appreciate the physics ofPT-symmetric, non-Hermitian quantum many-body systems, it is also important to be aware of the main concepts ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics. Our conclusion has far reaching consequences for the application of Green function methods, functional integrals, and generating functionals, which are at the heart of a large number of many-body methods. They cannot be transferred in their established forms to treatPT-symmetric, non-Hermitian quantum systems. It can be considered as an irony of fate that these methods are available only within the mathematical formalisms ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics.

Reports on Progress in Physics•Oct 23, 2023•37 citations

Quantum simulation of PT-arbitrary-phase–symmetric systems

Chao Zheng

Abstract Parity-time-reversal (PT) symmetric quantum mechanics promotes the increasing research interest of non-Hermitian (NH) systems for the theoretical value, novel properties, and links to open and dissipative systems in various areas. Recently, anti-PT–symmetric systems and their featured properties have started to be investigated. In this work, we develop the PT and anti-PT symmetry to PT-arbitrary-phase symmetry (or PT- φ symmetry) for the first time, being analogous to bosons, fermions and anyons. It can also be seen as a complex extension of the PT symmetry, unifying the PT and anti-PT symmetries and having intermediate properties between them. Many of the established concepts and mathematics in the PT-symmetric system are still compatible. We mainly investigate quantum simulation of this novel NH system in two dimensions in detail and discuss for higher-dimensional cases in general using the linear combinations of unitaries in the scheme of duality quantum computing, enabling implementations and experimental investigations of novel properties on both small quantum devices and near-term quantum computers.

Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Nov 1, 2021•17 citations
In the presence of Lindblad decoherence, i.e., dissipative effects in an open quantum system due to interaction with an environment, we examine the transition probabilities between the eigenstates in the two-level quantum system described by non-Hermitian Hamiltonians with the Lindblad equation, for which the parity-time-reversal (PT) symmetry is conserved. First, the density matrix formalism for PT\mathcal{PT}PT-symmetric non-Hermitian Hamiltonian systems is developed. It is shown that the Lindblad operators Lj{L}_{j}^{}Lj​ are pseudo-Hermitian, namely, \ensuremathηLj\ensuremathη\ensuremath−1=Lj\ifmmode†\else\textdagger\fi\ensuremath{\eta}{L}_{j}^{}{\ensuremath{\eta}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}={L}_{j}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}\ensuremathηLj​\ensuremathη\ensuremath−1=Lj\ifmmode†\else\textdagger\fi​ with \ensuremathη\ensuremath{\eta}\ensuremathη being a linear and positive-definite metric, and respect the PT\mathcal{PT}PT symmetry as well. We demonstrate that the generalized density matrix \ensuremathρG(t)\ensuremath≡\ensuremathρ(t)\ensuremathη{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{\mathrm{G}}^{}(t)\ensuremath{\equiv}\ensuremath{\rho}(t)\ensuremath{\eta}\ensuremathρG​(t)\ensuremath≡\ensuremathρ(t)\ensuremathη, instead of the normalized density matrix \ensuremathρN(t)\ensuremath≡\ensuremathρ(t)/tr[\ensuremathρ(t)]{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{\mathrm{N}}^{}(t)\ensuremath{\equiv}\ensuremath{\rho}(t)/\mathrm{tr}\left[\ensuremath{\rho}(t)\right]\ensuremathρN​(t)\ensuremath≡\ensuremathρ(t)/tr[\ensuremathρ(t)], should be implemented for the calculation of the transition probabilities in accordance with the linearity requirement. Second, the density matrix formalism is used to derive the transition probabilities in general cases of PT\mathcal{PT}PT-symmetric non-Hermitian Hamiltonians. In some concrete examples, we calculate compact analytical formulas for the transition probabilities and explore their main features with numerical illustrations. We also make a comparison between our present results and our previous ones using state vectors in the absence of Lindblad decoherence.
Open classical and quantum systems have attracted great interest in the past two decades. These include systems described by non-Hermitian Hamiltonians with parity-time (PT) symmetry that are best understood as systems with balanced, separated gain and loss. Here, we present an alternative way to characterize and derive conserved quantities, or intertwining operators, in such open systems. As a consequence, we also obtain non-Hermitian or Hermitian operators whose expectations values show single exponential time dependence. By using a simple example of a PT-symmetric dimer that arises in two distinct physical realizations, we demonstrate our procedure for static Hamiltonians and generalize it to time-periodic (Floquet) cases where intertwining operators are stroboscopically conserved. Inspired by the Lindblad density matrix equation, our approach provides a useful additionto the well-established methods for characterizing time-invariants in non-Hermitian systems.
We investigate how to define in a consistent way the probabilities of the transitions between the “flavor” states of the two-level quantum system, which is described by a non-Hermitian but parity and time-reversal (PT) symmetric Hamiltonian. Explicit calculations are carried out to demonstrate the conservation of probability if a proper definition of the final state is adopted. Finally, this formalism is applied to two-flavor neutrino oscillations νμ → νμ and νμ → ντ in vacuum, where the exact PT symmetry requires the vacuum mixing angle to be maximal, which is compatible with current neutrino oscillation experiments. A possible generalization to the three-flavor case is briefly discussed.
A possible method to investigate non-Hermitian Hamiltonians is suggested through finding a Hermitian operator η+ and defining the annihilation and creation operators to be η+ -pseudo-Hermitian adjoint to each other. The operator η+ represents the η+ -pseudo-Hermiticity of Hamiltonians. As an example, a non-Hermitian and non-PT-symmetric Hamiltonian with imaginary linear coordinate and linear momentum terms is constructed and analyzed in detail. The operator η+ is found, based on which, a real spectrum and a positive-definite inner product, together with the probability explanation of wave functions, the orthogonality of eigenstates, and the unitarity of time evolution, are obtained for the non-Hermitian and non-PT-symmetric Hamiltonian. Moreover, this Hamiltonian turns out to be coupled when it is extended to the canonical noncommutative space with noncommutative spatial coordinate operators and noncommutative momentum operators as well. Our method is applicable to the coupled Hamiltonian. Then the first and second order noncommutative corrections of energy levels are calculated, and in particular the reality of energy spectra, the positive-definiteness of inner products, and the related properties (the probability explanation of wave functions, the orthogonality of eigenstates, and the unitarity of time evolution) are found not to be altered by the noncommutativity.
The Lindblad equation is commonly used to model dissipation and decoherence in open quantum systems. Yet many of the properties of Lindblad dynamics are still little understood. This thesis explores various aspects of the Lindblad equation and its connections with non-Hermitian quantum theories. The evolution speed of Lindblad dynamics is investigated and an explicit expression for the speed is derived. The radial component, connected to the rate at which the purity of the state changes, is shown to be determined by the modified skew information of the Lindblad operators. The semiclassical time evolution of Gaussian states under Lindblad dynamics is then considered and a new type of phase-space dynamics is derived for the centre of a Gaussian Wigner function. By viewing the phase-space Lindblad equation as a Schroedinger equation with a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian, a further set of semiclassical equations are derived. These can describe the interference terms in Wigner functions. Further, a PT-symmetric two-level system driven through two consecutive exceptional points at finite speed is considered and an analytical expression for the probability of a non-adiabatic transition is derived. It is shown that the transition through the exceptional points can be experimentally addressed in a PT-symmetric lattice using Bloch oscillations. Finally, a quantum implementation of this PT-symmetric system using ultracold atoms in an optical lattice with single-particle losses is investigated.
We review the methodology to theoretically treat parity-time- (PT-) symmetric, non-Hermitian quantum many-body systems. They are realized as open quantum systems withPTsymmetry and couplings to the environment which are compatible.PT-symmetric non-Hermitian quantum systems show a variety of fascinating properties which single them out among generic open systems. The study of the latter has a long history in quantum theory. These studies are based on the Hermiticity of the combined system-reservoir setup and were developed by the atomic, molecular, and optical physics as well as the condensed matter physics communities. The interest of the mathematical physics community inPT-symmetric, non-Hermitian systems led to a new perspective and the development of the elegant mathematical formalisms ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics, which do not make any reference to the environment. In the mathematical physics research, the focus is mainly on the remarkable spectral properties of the Hamiltonians and the characteristics of the corresponding single-particle eigenstates. Despite being non-Hermitian, the Hamiltonians can show parameter regimes, in which all eigenvalues are real. To investigate emergent quantum many-body phenomena in condensed matter physics and to make contact to experiments one, however, needs to study expectation values of observables and correlation functions. One furthermore, has to investigate statistical ensembles and not only eigenstates. The adoption of the concepts ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics by parts of the condensed matter community led to a controversial status of the methodology. There is no consensus on fundamental issues, such as, what a proper observable is, how expectation values are supposed to be computed, and what adequate equilibrium statistical ensembles and their corresponding density matrices are. With the technological progress in engineering and controlling open quantum many-body systems it is high time to reconcile the Hermitian with thePT-symmetric and biorthogonal perspectives. We comprehensively review the different approaches, including the overreaching idea of pseudo-Hermiticity. To motivate the Hermitian perspective, which we propagate here, we mainly focus on the ancilla approach. It allows to embed a non-Hermitian system into a larger, Hermitian one. In contrast to other techniques, e.g. master equations, it does not rely on any approximations. We discuss the peculiarities ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics. In these, what is considered to be an observable depends on the Hamiltonian or the selected (biorthonormal) basis. Crucially in addition, what is denoted as an 'expectation value' lacks a direct probabilistic interpretation, and what is viewed as the canonical density matrix is non-stationary and non-Hermitian. Furthermore, the non-unitarity of the time evolution is hidden within the formalism. We pick up several model Hamiltonians, which so far were either investigated from the Hermitian perspective or from thePT-symmetric and biorthogonal one, and study them within the respective alternative framework. This includes a simple two-level, single-particle problem but also a many-body lattice model showing quantum critical behavior. Comparing the outcome of the two types of computations shows that the Hermitian approach, which, admittedly, is in parts clumsy, always leads to results which are physically sensible. In the rare cases, in which a comparison to experimental data is possible, they furthermore agree to these. In contrast, the mathematically elegantPT-symmetric and biorthogonal approaches lead to results which, are partly difficult to interpret physically. We thus conclude that the Hermitian methodology should be employed. However, to fully appreciate the physics ofPT-symmetric, non-Hermitian quantum many-body systems, it is also important to be aware of the main concepts ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics. Our conclusion has far reaching consequences for the application of Green function methods, functional integrals, and generating functionals, which are at the heart of a large number of many-body methods. They cannot be transferred in their established forms to treatPT-symmetric, non-Hermitian quantum systems. It can be considered as an irony of fate that these methods are available only within the mathematical formalisms ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics.
Abstract Parity-time-reversal (PT) symmetric quantum mechanics promotes the increasing research interest of non-Hermitian (NH) systems for the theoretical value, novel properties, and links to open and dissipative systems in various areas. Recently, anti-PT–symmetric systems and their featured properties have started to be investigated. In this work, we develop the PT and anti-PT symmetry to PT-arbitrary-phase symmetry (or PT- φ symmetry) for the first time, being analogous to bosons, fermions and anyons. It can also be seen as a complex extension of the PT symmetry, unifying the PT and anti-PT symmetries and having intermediate properties between them. Many of the established concepts and mathematics in the PT-symmetric system are still compatible. We mainly investigate quantum simulation of this novel NH system in two dimensions in detail and discuss for higher-dimensional cases in general using the linear combinations of unitaries in the scheme of duality quantum computing, enabling implementations and experimental investigations of novel properties on both small quantum devices and near-term quantum computers.