Cryogenic microwave-to-optical conversion using a triply resonant lithium-niobate-on-sapphire transducer
Timothy P. McKenna, Jeremy D. Witmer, Rishi N. Patel, Wentao Jiang, Raphaël Van Laer, Patricio Arrangoiz-Arriola, E. Alex Wollack, Jason F. Herrmann, Amir H. Safavi‐Naeini
Quantum networks are likely to have a profound impact on the way we compute and communicate in the future. In order to wire together superconducting quantum processors over kilometer-scale distances, we need transducers that can generate entanglement between the microwave and optical domains with high fidelity. We present an integrated electro-optic transducer that combines low-loss lithium niobate photonics with superconducting microwave resonators on a sapphire substrate. Our triply resonant device operates in a dilution refrigerator and converts microwave photons to optical photons with an on-chip efficiency of 6.6 × 10 − 6 and a conversion bandwidth of 20 MHz. We discuss design trade-offs in this device, including strategies to manage acoustic loss, and outline ways to increase the conversion efficiency in the future.
Quantum networks are likely to have a profound impact on the way we compute and communicate in the future. In order to wire together superconducting quantum processors over kilometer-scale distances, we need transducers that can generate entanglement between the microwave and optical domains with high fidelity. We present an integrated electro-optic transducer that combines low-loss lithium niobate photonics with superconducting microwave resonators on a sapphire substrate. Our triply resonant device operates in a dilution refrigerator and converts microwave photons to optical photons with an on-chip efficiency of 6.6 × 10 − 6 and a conversion bandwidth of 20 MHz. We discuss design trade-offs in this device, including strategies to manage acoustic loss, and outline ways to increase the conversion efficiency in the future.
Efficient, low-noise, and high-bandwidth transduction between optical and microwave photons is key to long-range quantum communication between distant superconducting quantum processors. Recent demonstrations of microwave-optical transduction using the broadband direct electro-optic (Pockels) effect in optical thin films made of AlN or LiNbO 3 have shown promise. To improve efficiency and added noise, materials with larger Pockels coefficients, such as the soft ferroelectrics BaTiO 3 or SrTiO 3 , are needed. However, these materials require adapted designs and fabrication approaches due to their nonlinear and, in some cases, hysteretic electro-optic response. Here, we engineer an on-chip, triply resonant transducer comprising low-loss BaTiO 3 -on- SiO 2 waveguides monolithically integrated with a superconducting microwave resonator made of Nb. We demonstrate bidirectional microwave-optical transduction and reach total off-chip efficiencies of 1 × 10 − 6 using pulsed pumping. The device design permits poling of the ferroelectric material without introducing excess microwave loss, exploiting superconducting air bridges fabricated using only subtractive patterning steps. In addition, we investigate optically induced heating, revealing fast thermalization and quasiparticle resilience of the microwave resonator. Our transducer concept and fabrication process are applicable to other materials with a large bias-induced Pockels effect like SrTiO 3 and pave the way for efficient, low-power quantum interconnects.
We present a resonant electro-optic transducer for efficient conversion between microwave and telecom wavelength photons. Our platform employs a bulk lithium niobate crystal whose large dielectric constant creates wavelength-scale confinement of microwave photons. By incorporating this crystal within a high-finesse Fabry - Perot optical cavity, microwave photons couple to optical photons through the electro-optic effect. We demonstrate the ability to tune our system into triply resonant operation, where microwave photons, optical pump photons, and upconverted optical photons are simultaneously resonant with high quality factor electromagnetic modes of the system. The device achieves photon number conversion efficiency at the percent level, comparable to state-of-the-art devices at room temperature -- sufficient to resolve the thermal occupation of the microwave mode -- while avoiding the noise and loss associated with metal electrodes. These results establish our all-dielectric devices as a promising platform for high-precision sensing of optically detected microwave fields and as a viable route toward single-photon-level microwave - optical quantum transduction.
Linking superconducting quantum devices to optical fibers via microwave-optical quantum transducers may enable large-scale quantum networks. For this application, transducers based on the Pockels electro-optic (EO) effect are promising for their direct conversion mechanism, high bandwidth, and potential for low-noise operation. However, previously demonstrated EO transducers require large optical pump power to overcome weak EO coupling and reach high efficiency. Here, we create an EO transducer in thin-film lithium niobate, a platform that provides low optical loss and strong EO coupling. We demonstrate on-chip transduction efficiencies of up to and of optical pump power. The transduction efficiency can be improved by further reducing the microwave resonator’s piezoelectric coupling to acoustic modes, increasing the optical resonator quality factor to previously demonstrated levels, and changing the electrode geometry for enhanced EO coupling. We expect that with further development, EO transducers in thin-film lithium niobate can achieve near-unity efficiency with low optical pump power.
Efficient and stable microwave-optical transduction is a key enabling technology for distributed superconducting quantum computing and heterogeneous quantum networks. Electro-optic transducers based on thin-film lithium niobate (TFLN) have shown strong promise, but demonstrations to date have been limited by various factors such as low frequency bias drift, low efficiency, fabrication complexity, and scalability. Here we demonstrate the first integrated electro-optic microwave-optical transducers realized in thin-film lithium tantalate (TFLT), a material platform offering Pockels nonlinearity comparable to TFLN together with improved bias stability and high-power handling. We fabricate superconducting microwave resonators coupled to tunable photonic-molecule optical resonators using wafer-scale deep ultraviolet lithography, offering high-throughput production of hundreds of devices per wafer. Across six devices we observe coherent bidirectional conversion between C-band optical photons and 4.9-5.5 GHz microwave photons, with measured on-chip efficiencies and inferred single-photon coupling rates g_0/2π ~ 1 kHz consistent with theory. Continuous operation over multiple days is achieved using a static bias field with minimal feedback, demonstrating a major operational advantage. We further characterize optical loss statistics, microwave resonator performance, and optically induced added noise under pulsed pumping, finding less than one added photon for 100 microsecond pulses at the highest measured efficiencies. These results establish TFLT as a scalable and robust electro-optic platform for future quantum interconnects and modular quantum processors.
Superconducting circuits are important technological tools that have found various applications, notably hypothetical future superconducting quantum computers. Scaling such systems further is, however, proving challenging because of thermal heat load and space constraints in cryostats. One way of improving the scalability of such systems would be to resort to optical fibers for controlling the circuits in cryostats, as well as mediating long-distance interaction between them while preserving quantum coherence. Such a strategy relies on building a coherent interface between GHz frequencies and optical frequencies. This interface, referred to as "microwave-optical transducer", would need to exhibit high photon conversion efficiencies and very low added noise, ideally less than a quantum, in a cryogenic environment. Since the prospects of weaving networks of optically connected superconducting quantum processors have now attracted the attention of the scientific community for more than a decade, very efficient transducers have already been proposed and realized. However, despite their impressive performances against selected metrics, often equivalent to optimizing the on-chip conversion efficiency alone, none of the approaches pursued so far really solved the qubit interconnection problems in ways that could be applied to large-scale systems in the near future. The aim of this thesis was to develop transduction approaches that would ultimately enable optical driving of superconducting circuits and quantum state transfer between microwave and optical frequencies, while at the same time ensuring good scalability, both in terms of wafer manufacturability and integration in cryogenic environments. Integrated photonic circuits based on silicon nitride appeared as a promising platform, as silicon nitride is a CMOS-certified material, has a transparency window compatible with optical fibers and lacks two photon absorption. Realizing the coupling between microwave and optical frequencies in a way similar to what is done in optomechanics is desirable, because the field of optomechanics has seen the establishement of techniques that enable control of the low frequency degree of freedom at the quantum mechanical level, including ground state cooling, control of the susceptibility by dynamical backaction, quantum state transfer and entanglement. The heterogeneous integration of nonlinear crystalline thin films, such as lithium niobate and lithium tantalate, onto silicon nitride photonic circuitry endows it with an electro-optic activity that emulates the optomechanical interaction, while offering an inherent access to the microwave degree of freedom. However, material nonlinearities, including photorefraction, charge screening, and hysteresis, introduce complications that motivate exploring alternative approaches. Here, alongside an electro-optic implementation, a transducer that leverages the interaction of bulk acoustic resonances excited by micro-electromechanical systems with whispering-gallery-like modes of microresonators is presented. Coherent transduction between microwave and optical fields is demonstrated, and optomechanical dynamical backaction is observed. The transducers fast bandwidth, compatibility with multiplexing and ability to down-convert microwaves suggest interesting prospects, particularly upon further improvements of the optomechanical coupling.
Abstract Emerging communications and computing technologies will rely ever-more on expanding the useful radio frequency spectrum into the millimeter-wave and terahertz frequency range. Both classical and quantum applications would benefit from advancing integration and incorporation of millimeter-wave and electro-optic technologies into common devices, such as modulators. Here we demonstrate an integrated triply-resonant, superconducting electro-optic transducer. Our design incorporates an on-chip 107 GHz niobium titanium nitride superconducting resonator, modulating a thin-film lithium niobate optical racetrack resonator operating at telecom wavelengths. We observe a maximum photon transduction efficiency of η OE ≈ 0.82 × 10 −6 and an average single-photon electro-optic interaction rate of g 0 /2 π ≈ 0.7 kHz. We also present a study and analysis of the challenges associated with the design of integrated millimeter-wave resonators and propose possible solutions to these challenges. Our work paves the way for further advancements in resonant electro-optic technologies operating at millimeter-wave frequencies.