arXiv:2003.03414 · Physical Review Letters

Efficient Simulation of Loop Quantum Gravity: A Scalable Linear-Optical Approach

Lior Cohen, Anthony J. Brady, Zichang Huang, Hongguang Liu, Dongxue Qu, Jonathan P. Dowling, Muxin Han

Published Jan 11, 2021• 18 citations

Abstract

The problem of simulating complex quantum processes on classical computers gave rise to the field of quantum simulations. Quantum simulators solve problems, such as boson sampling, where classical counterparts fail. In another field of physics, the unification of general relativity and quantum theory is one of the greatest challenges of our time. One leading approach is loop quantum gravity (LQG). Here, we connect these two fields and design a linear-optical simulator such that the evolution of the optical quantum gates simulates the spin-foam amplitudes of LQG. It has been shown that computing transition amplitudes in simple quantum field theories falls into the bounded-error quantum polynomial time class, which strongly suggests that computing transition amplitudes of LQG are classically intractable. Therefore, these amplitudes are efficiently computable with universal quantum computers, which are, alas, possibly decades away. We propose here an alternative special-purpose linear-optical quantum computer that can be implemented using current technologies. This machine is capable of efficiently computing these quantities. This work opens a new way to relate quantum gravity to quantum information and will expand our understanding of the theory.

DOI: 10.1103/physrevlett.126.020501

Related papers

Simulation of Loop Quantum Gravity -- A Scalable Linear-Optical Approach

Lior Cohen, Anthony J. Brady, Zichang Huang +4 more

The problem of simulating complex quantum processes on classical computers gave rise to the field of quantum simulations. Quantum simulators solve problems, such as Boson sampling, where classical counterparts fail. In another field of physics, the unification of general relativity and quantum theory is one of the greatest challenges of our time. One leading approach is Loop Quantum Gravity (LQG). Here, we connect these two fields and design a linear-optical simulator such that the evolution of the optical quantum gates simulates the spinfoam amplitudes of LQG. It has been shown that computing transition amplitudes in simple quantum field theories falls into the class BQP -- which strongly suggests that computing transition amplitudes of LQG are classically intractable. Therefore, these amplitudes are efficiently computable with universal quantum computers which are, alas, possibly decades away. We propose here an alternative special-purpose linear-optical quantum computer, which can be implemented using current technologies. This machine is capable of efficiently computing these quantities. This work opens a new way to relate quantum gravity to quantum information and will expand our understanding of the theory.

Mar 6, 20201 citation

Experimental simulation of loop quantum gravity on a photonic chip

Reinier van der Meer, Zichang Huang, Malaquias Correa Anguita +6 more

Abstract The unification of general relativity and quantum theory is one of the fascinating problems of modern physics. One leading solution is Loop Quantum Gravity (LQG). Simulating LQG may be important for providing predictions which can then be tested experimentally. However, such complex quantum simulations cannot run efficiently on classical computers, and quantum computers or simulators are needed. Here, we experimentally demonstrate quantum simulations of spinfoam amplitudes of LQG on an integrated photonics quantum processor. We simulate a basic transition of LQG and show that the derived spinfoam vertex amplitude falls within 4% error with respect to the theoretical prediction, despite experimental imperfections. We also discuss how to generalize the simulation for more complex transitions, in realistic experimental conditions, which will eventually lead to a quantum advantage demonstration as well as expand the toolbox to investigate LQG.

arXiv:2207.00557npj Quantum InformationApr 4, 202312 citations

Efficient Simulation of Loop Quantum Gravity — A Scalable Linear-Optical Approach

Lior Cohen, Anthony J. Brady, Zichang Huang +4 more

We unite loop quantum gravity (LQG) with linear-optical quantum simulation, by designing linear-optical quantum circuits which mimic scattering amplitudes of LQG. Our design efficiently computes LQG amplitudes, which are classically intractable.

Frontiers in OpticsJan 1, 20201 citation

Finite-Dimensional ZX-Calculus for Loop Quantum Gravity

Ben Priestley

Loop quantum gravity (LQG) attempts to unify general relativity with quantum physics to offer a complete description of the universe by quantising spacetime geometry, but the numerical calculations we encounter are extraordinarily difficult. Progress has been made in the covariant formulation of LQG, but the tools do not carry over to the canonical formulation. These tools are graphical by nature, describing space with spin networks to make calculations in LQG more intuitive to the human hand. Recently, a new notation for working with spin networks has been used by arXiv:2412.20272 to offer the first accurate numerical results in canonical LQG by allowing the underlying graphs to change throughout the calculation, though they are forced to concede visual intuitiveness. In this thesis, we offer a more radical rephrasing of spin network calculations by translating them into the finite-dimensional ZX-calculus, extending previous attempts to translate into the standard (qubit) ZX-calculus (arXiv:2111.03114). Specifically, we derive the mixed-dimensional ZX-diagrams representing the generating objects of spin networks and the rules for the Penrose Spin Calculus (arXiv:2511.06012), and use these to present the ZX-form and correctness of "loop removal". We also derive the forms for several fundamental LQG objects in the finite-dimensional ZX-calculus for the first time. This gives us a high-level, intuitive graphical language that retains a flexibility to handle changing graph structures, and thus we argue positions the PSC as the new definitive language for canonical LQG. Furthermore, we investigate the possibility for a matrix-like normal form for spin networks deriving from a novel perspective of the PSC in terms of W-nodes.

gr-qcCross-listedarXiv:2511.15966Nov 21, 20250 citations

Quantum Simulations of Loop Quantum Gravity

Swapnil Nitin Shah

Loop Quantum Gravity (LQG) is one of the leading approaches to unify quantum physics and General Relativity (GR). The Hilbert space of LQG is spanned by spin-networks which describe the local geometry of quantum space-time. Simulation of LQG spin-network states and their dynamics is classically intractable and is widely believed to fall in the Bounded Quantum Polynomial (BQP) time complexity class. There have been many recent attempts to simulate these states using novel and off the shelf quantum computing technologies. In this article, we review three such efforts which utilize superconducting qubits, linear optical qubits and Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) qubits respectively. The articles chosen for this review represent state of the art in quantum simulations of LQG.

arXiv:2112.02426Dec 4, 20210 citations

Single photons in linear optics: quantum computing and quantum simulations

Malaquias Correa Anguita

This dissertation explores the use of single photons in integrated photonic circuits as a platform for quantum computation and quantum simulation. In the noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) era, photonic implementations of boson sampling provide one of the most promising routes to demonstrating quantum advantage, while also enabling insight-driven experiments that probe many-body interference and computational complexity. The first part of the thesis is devoted to the hardware development and characterization of programmable silicon nitride photonic processors. We demonstrate large-scale multi-photon interference in a 20-mode universal processor, establishing the potential of integrated photonics for scaling up boson sampling experiments. In parallel, we introduce a validation protocol based on detector binning, implemented on a 12-mode predecessor of the device. Together, these studies advance the photonic platform itself, focusing on scalability, versatility, and benchmarking, rather than direct applications. The second part turns to quantum simulation. We first present a photonic simulation of a spin-foam amplitude from loop quantum gravity, illustrating how multi-photon interference can provide a testbed for problems in fundamental physics. We then implement a particle-number-difference Maxwell demon using conditional operations on photon subsets in a multi-mode interferometer. This experiment probes the link between thermodynamics and information theory, showing how a photonic platform with single-photon resolution and quantum interference can be used to explore information-driven control of physical systems. The final part addresses quantum computation, where we demonstrate a boson-sampling-accelerated Monte Carlo integrator. This hybrid quantum–classical algorithm represents one of the few proposals to extend boson sampling toward practical applications while plausibly retaining its computational hardness. We validate the method in a proof-of-principle experiment reproducing perturbative corrections in a model inspired by Efimov physics. Altogether, the results presented in this thesis position integrated photonics as both a scalable hardware platform for multi-photon experiments and a versatile tool for advancing quantum simulation and computation.

Sep 23, 20250 citations