Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2002.09944

Equivalent critical behavior of a helical point contact and a two-channel Luttinger liquid - topological superconductor junction

C. L. Kane, Domenico Giuliano, Ian K. Affleck

Published Feb 23, 2020• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We demonstrate the equivalence between two distinct Luttinger liquid impurity problems. The first concerns a one-dimensional topological superconductor coupled at one end to the ends of two single channel Luttinger liquids. The second concerns a point contact in the quantum spin Hall effect, where four helical Luttinger liquids meet at a point. Both problems have been studied previously and exhibit several stable phases depending on the Luttinger parameter K, that can be characterized in terms of simple conformally invariant boundary conditions describing perfect normal (or Andreev) transmission or reflection. In addition, both problems exhibit critical points that are described by "intermediate" fixed points similar to those found in earlier studies of an impurity in a Luttinger liquid with spin. Though these two models have different symmetries and numbers of modes, we show they are equivalent and are related by a duality transformation, and we show that the non-trivial intermediate critical points are the same. In the non-interacting limit, K=1, the duality involves two distinct free fermion representations that are related by a non-local transformation that derives from the triality of SO(8). Using the explicit translation between the two theories, we translate results from one problem to the other and vice versa. This allows us to make new predictions about the topological superconductor-Luttinger liquid junction, including predictions about the global behavior of the critical conductance G*(K), as well predictions for the critical exponents and universal crossover scaling functions. In this paper we introduce both models from scratch, using a common notation that facilitates their comparison, and we discuss in detail the dualities that relate them, along with their free fermion limits. We close with a discussion of open problems and future directions.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2002.09944

Related papers

Critical behavior of a point contact in a quantum spin Hall insulator

Jeffrey C. Y. Teo, C. L. Kane

We study a quantum point contact in a quantum spin Hall insulator. It has recently been shown that the Luttinger liquid theory of such a structure maps to the theory of a weak link in a Luttinger liquid with spin with Luttinger liquid parameters ${g}_{\ensuremath{\rho}}=1/{g}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}}=g<1$. We show that for weak interactions, $1/2<g<1$, the pinch-off of the point contact as a function of gate voltage is controlled by a novel quantum critical point, which is a realization of a nontrivial intermediate fixed point found previously in the Luttinger liquid model with spin. We predict that the dependence of the conductance on gate voltage near the pinch-off transition for different temperatures collapses onto a universal curve described by a crossover scaling function associated with that fixed point. We compute the conductance and critical exponents of the critical point as well as the universal scaling function in solvable limits, which include $g=1\ensuremath{-}ϵ$, $g=1/2+ϵ$, and $g=1/\sqrt{3}$. These results, along with a general scaling analysis, provide an overall picture of the critical behavior as a function of $g$. In addition, we analyze the structure of the four-terminal conductance of the point contact in the weak tunneling and weak backscattering limits. We find that different components of the conductance can have different temperature dependences. In particular, we identify a skew conductance ${G}_{XY}$, which we predict vanishes as ${T}^{\ensuremath{\gamma}}$ with $\ensuremath{\gamma}\ensuremath{\ge}2$. This behavior is a direct consequence of the unique edge state structure of the quantum spin Hall insulator. Finally, we show that for strong interactions, $g<1/2$, the presence of spin nonconserving spin-orbit interactions leads to a novel time-reversal-symmetry breaking insulating phase. In this phase, the transport is carried by spinless chargons and chargeless spinons. These lead to nontrivial correlations in the low frequency shot noise. Implications for experiments on HgCdTe quantum well structures will be discussed.

arXiv:0904.3109•Physical Review B•Jun 18, 2009•137 citations

Duality between normal and superconducting junctions of multiple quantum wires

Sourin Das, Sumathi Rao

We study junctions of single-channel spinless Luttinger liquids using bosonization. We generalize earlier studies by allowing the junction to be superconducting and find new charge nonconserving low-energy fixed points. We establish the existence of $g\ensuremath{\leftrightarrow}1/g$ duality (where $g$ is the Luttinger liquid parameter) between the charge-conserving (normal) junction and the charge nonconserving (superconducting) junction by evaluating and comparing the scaling dimensions of various operators around the fixed points in both the normal and superconducting sectors of the theory. For the most general two-wire junction, we show that there are two conformally invariant one-parameter families of fixed points which are also connected by a duality transformation. We also show that the stable fixed point for the two-wire superconducting junction corresponds to the situation where the crossed Andreev reflection (an incoming electron is transmitted as an outgoing hole) is perfect between the wires. For the three-wire junction, we study, in particular, the superconducting analogs of the chiral ${\mathbsf{D}}_{\mathbsf{P}}$ and the disconnected fixed points obtained earlier in the literature in the context of charge-conserving three-wire junctions. We show that these fixed points can be stabilized for $g<1$ (repulsive electrons) within the superconducting sector of the theory which makes them experimentally relevant.

arXiv:0807.0804•Physical Review B•Nov 14, 2008•29 citations

Josephson current and proximity effect in Luttinger liquids

Dmitrii L. Maslov, Michael Stone, Paul M. Goldbart +1 more

A theory describing a one-dimensional Luttinger liquid in contact with a superconductor is developed. Boundary conditions for the fermion fields describing Andreev reflection at the contacts are derived and used to construct a bosonic representation of the fermions. The Josephson current through a superconductor/Luttinger liquid/superconductor junction is considered for both perfectly and poorly transmitting interfaces. In the former case, the Josephson current at low temperatures is found to be essentially unaffected by electron-electron interactions. In the latter case, significant renormalization of the Josephson current occurs. The profile of the (induced) condensate wave function in a semi-infinite Luttinger liquid in contact with a superconductor is shown to decay as a power law, the exponent depending on the sign and strength of the interactions. In the case of repulsive (attractive) interactions the decay is faster (slower) than in their absence. An equivalent method of calculating the Josephson current through a Luttinger liquid, which employs the bosonization of the system as a whole (i.e., superconductor, as well as Luttinger liquid) is developed and shown to give the results equivalent to those obtained via boundary conditions describing Andreev reflection. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

arXiv:cond-mat/9508020•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jan 15, 1996•98 citations

Universal Symmetry-Protected Resonances in a Spinful Luttinger Liquid

Yichen Hu, C. L. Kane

We study the problem of resonant tunneling through a quantum dot in a spinful Luttinger liquid. For a range of repulsive interactions, we find that for symmetric barriers there exist resonances with a universal peak conductance $2g^* e^2/h$ that are controlled by a non-trivial intermediate fixed point. This fixed point is also a quantum critical point separating symmetry-protected topological phases. By tuning the system through resonance, all SPT phases can be accessed. For a particular interaction strength with Luttinger parameters $g_ρ=1/3$ and $g_σ=1$, we show that the problem is equivalent to a two channel $SU(3)$ Kondo problem($SU(3)_2$ CFT). At the Toulouse limit, both problems can be mapped to a quantum Brownian motion model on a Kagome lattice, which in turn is related to the quantum Brownian motion on a honeycomb lattice and the three-channel $SU(2)$ Kondo problem($SU(2)_3$ CFT). "Level-rank duality" in the quantum Brownian motion model relating $SU(2)_k$ CFT to $SU(k)_2$ CFT is also explored. Utilizing the boundary conformal field theory, the on-resonance conductance of our resonant tunneling problem is calculated as well as the scaling dimension of the leading relevant operator. This allows us to compute the scaling behavior of the resonance line-shape as a function of temperature.

arXiv:1604.08280•Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Apr 28, 2016•3 citations

Magnetic impurity in a Luttinger liquid: A conformal field theory approach

Per Fröjdh, Henrik Johannesson

We study the low-temperature properties of a spin-1/2 magnetic impurity coupled to a one-dimensional interacting electron system. Using a formalism by Affleck and Ludwig, with a scale invariant boundary condition replacing the impurity, we exploit boundary conformal field theory to deduce the impurity thermal and magnetic response. In the case of only forward electron scattering off the impurity, we predict the same critical scaling as for the two-channel Kondo effect for noninteracting electrons, but with a different Wilson ratio. Backward electron scattering off the impurity destabilizes this behavior and drives the system to a new fixed point. In the case of equal amplitudes for forward and backward scattering (Kondo interaction), we show that there are only two types of scaling behaviors consistent with the symmetries of the problem: either a local Fermi liquid or a critical theory with an anomalous specific heat. The latter case agrees with a recent poor-man's scaling result proposed by Furusaki and Nagaosa. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

arXiv:cond-mat/9506099•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Feb 1, 1996•53 citations

Bounded Luttinger liquids as a universality class of quantum critical behavior

Johannes Voit, Yupeng Wang, M. Grioni

We show that one-dimensional quantum systems with gapless degrees of freedom and open boundary conditions form a universality class of quantum critical behavior, which we propose to call ``bounded Luttinger liquids.'' They share the following properties with ordinary (periodic) Luttinger liquids: the absence of fermionic quasiparticle excitations, charge-spin separation, and anomalous power-law correlations with exponents whose scaling relations are parametrized by a single coupling constant per degree of freedom, ${K}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}.$ The values of ${K}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}$ are independent of boundary conditions, but the representation of the critical exponents in terms of these ${K}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}'\mathrm{s}$ depends on boundary conditions. We illustrate these scaling relations by exploring general rules for boundary critical exponents derived earlier using the Bethe ansatz solution of the one-dimensional Hubbard model together with boundary conformal field theory, and the theory of Luttinger liquids in finite-size systems. We apply this theory to the photoemission properties of the organic conductors $(\mathrm{TMTSF}{)}_{2}X,$ where TMTSF is tetramethyltetraselenafulvalene, and $X={\mathrm{ClO}}_{9},$ ${\mathrm{PF}}_{6},$ $\mathrm{Re}{\mathrm{O}}_{4},$ and discuss to what extent the assumption of finite strands with open boundaries at the sample surface can reconcile the experimental results with independent information on the Luttinger-liquid state in these materials.

arXiv:cond-mat/9912392•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Mar 15, 2000•34 citations
We demonstrate the equivalence between two distinct Luttinger liquid impurity problems. The first concerns a one-dimensional topological superconductor coupled at one end to the ends of two single channel Luttinger liquids. The second concerns a point contact in the quantum spin Hall effect, where four helical Luttinger liquids meet at a point. Both problems have been studied previously and exhibit several stable phases depending on the Luttinger parameter K, that can be characterized in terms of simple conformally invariant boundary conditions describing perfect normal (or Andreev) transmission or reflection. In addition, both problems exhibit critical points that are described by "intermediate" fixed points similar to those found in earlier studies of an impurity in a Luttinger liquid with spin. Though these two models have different symmetries and numbers of modes, we show they are equivalent and are related by a duality transformation, and we show that the non-trivial intermediate critical points are the same. In the non-interacting limit, K=1, the duality involves two distinct free fermion representations that are related by a non-local transformation that derives from the triality of SO(8). Using the explicit translation between the two theories, we translate results from one problem to the other and vice versa. This allows us to make new predictions about the topological superconductor-Luttinger liquid junction, including predictions about the global behavior of the critical conductance G*(K), as well predictions for the critical exponents and universal crossover scaling functions. In this paper we introduce both models from scratch, using a common notation that facilitates their comparison, and we discuss in detail the dualities that relate them, along with their free fermion limits. We close with a discussion of open problems and future directions.
We study a quantum point contact in a quantum spin Hall insulator. It has recently been shown that the Luttinger liquid theory of such a structure maps to the theory of a weak link in a Luttinger liquid with spin with Luttinger liquid parameters ${g}_{\ensuremath{\rho}}=1/{g}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}}=g<1$. We show that for weak interactions, 1/2<g<11/2<g<11/2<g<1, the pinch-off of the point contact as a function of gate voltage is controlled by a novel quantum critical point, which is a realization of a nontrivial intermediate fixed point found previously in the Luttinger liquid model with spin. We predict that the dependence of the conductance on gate voltage near the pinch-off transition for different temperatures collapses onto a universal curve described by a crossover scaling function associated with that fixed point. We compute the conductance and critical exponents of the critical point as well as the universal scaling function in solvable limits, which include $g=1\ensuremath{-}ϵ$, g=1/2+ϵg=1/2+ϵg=1/2+ϵ, and g=1/3g=1/\sqrt{3}g=1/3​. These results, along with a general scaling analysis, provide an overall picture of the critical behavior as a function of ggg. In addition, we analyze the structure of the four-terminal conductance of the point contact in the weak tunneling and weak backscattering limits. We find that different components of the conductance can have different temperature dependences. In particular, we identify a skew conductance GXY{G}_{XY}GXY​, which we predict vanishes as ${T}^{\ensuremath{\gamma}}$ with $\ensuremath{\gamma}\ensuremath{\ge}2$. This behavior is a direct consequence of the unique edge state structure of the quantum spin Hall insulator. Finally, we show that for strong interactions, g<1/2g<1/2g<1/2, the presence of spin nonconserving spin-orbit interactions leads to a novel time-reversal-symmetry breaking insulating phase. In this phase, the transport is carried by spinless chargons and chargeless spinons. These lead to nontrivial correlations in the low frequency shot noise. Implications for experiments on HgCdTe quantum well structures will be discussed.
We study junctions of single-channel spinless Luttinger liquids using bosonization. We generalize earlier studies by allowing the junction to be superconducting and find new charge nonconserving low-energy fixed points. We establish the existence of $g\ensuremath{\leftrightarrow}1/g$ duality (where ggg is the Luttinger liquid parameter) between the charge-conserving (normal) junction and the charge nonconserving (superconducting) junction by evaluating and comparing the scaling dimensions of various operators around the fixed points in both the normal and superconducting sectors of the theory. For the most general two-wire junction, we show that there are two conformally invariant one-parameter families of fixed points which are also connected by a duality transformation. We also show that the stable fixed point for the two-wire superconducting junction corresponds to the situation where the crossed Andreev reflection (an incoming electron is transmitted as an outgoing hole) is perfect between the wires. For the three-wire junction, we study, in particular, the superconducting analogs of the chiral ${\mathbsf{D}}_{\mathbsf{P}}$ and the disconnected fixed points obtained earlier in the literature in the context of charge-conserving three-wire junctions. We show that these fixed points can be stabilized for g<1g<1g<1 (repulsive electrons) within the superconducting sector of the theory which makes them experimentally relevant.
A theory describing a one-dimensional Luttinger liquid in contact with a superconductor is developed. Boundary conditions for the fermion fields describing Andreev reflection at the contacts are derived and used to construct a bosonic representation of the fermions. The Josephson current through a superconductor/Luttinger liquid/superconductor junction is considered for both perfectly and poorly transmitting interfaces. In the former case, the Josephson current at low temperatures is found to be essentially unaffected by electron-electron interactions. In the latter case, significant renormalization of the Josephson current occurs. The profile of the (induced) condensate wave function in a semi-infinite Luttinger liquid in contact with a superconductor is shown to decay as a power law, the exponent depending on the sign and strength of the interactions. In the case of repulsive (attractive) interactions the decay is faster (slower) than in their absence. An equivalent method of calculating the Josephson current through a Luttinger liquid, which employs the bosonization of the system as a whole (i.e., superconductor, as well as Luttinger liquid) is developed and shown to give the results equivalent to those obtained via boundary conditions describing Andreev reflection. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
We study the problem of resonant tunneling through a quantum dot in a spinful Luttinger liquid. For a range of repulsive interactions, we find that for symmetric barriers there exist resonances with a universal peak conductance 2g∗e2/h2g^* e^2/h2g∗e2/h that are controlled by a non-trivial intermediate fixed point. This fixed point is also a quantum critical point separating symmetry-protected topological phases. By tuning the system through resonance, all SPT phases can be accessed. For a particular interaction strength with Luttinger parameters gρ=1/3g_ρ=1/3gρ​=1/3 and gσ=1g_σ=1gσ​=1, we show that the problem is equivalent to a two channel SU(3)SU(3)SU(3) Kondo problem(SU(3)2SU(3)_2SU(3)2​ CFT). At the Toulouse limit, both problems can be mapped to a quantum Brownian motion model on a Kagome lattice, which in turn is related to the quantum Brownian motion on a honeycomb lattice and the three-channel SU(2)SU(2)SU(2) Kondo problem(SU(2)3SU(2)_3SU(2)3​ CFT). "Level-rank duality" in the quantum Brownian motion model relating SU(2)kSU(2)_kSU(2)k​ CFT to SU(k)2SU(k)_2SU(k)2​ CFT is also explored. Utilizing the boundary conformal field theory, the on-resonance conductance of our resonant tunneling problem is calculated as well as the scaling dimension of the leading relevant operator. This allows us to compute the scaling behavior of the resonance line-shape as a function of temperature.
We study the low-temperature properties of a spin-1/2 magnetic impurity coupled to a one-dimensional interacting electron system. Using a formalism by Affleck and Ludwig, with a scale invariant boundary condition replacing the impurity, we exploit boundary conformal field theory to deduce the impurity thermal and magnetic response. In the case of only forward electron scattering off the impurity, we predict the same critical scaling as for the two-channel Kondo effect for noninteracting electrons, but with a different Wilson ratio. Backward electron scattering off the impurity destabilizes this behavior and drives the system to a new fixed point. In the case of equal amplitudes for forward and backward scattering (Kondo interaction), we show that there are only two types of scaling behaviors consistent with the symmetries of the problem: either a local Fermi liquid or a critical theory with an anomalous specific heat. The latter case agrees with a recent poor-man's scaling result proposed by Furusaki and Nagaosa. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
We show that one-dimensional quantum systems with gapless degrees of freedom and open boundary conditions form a universality class of quantum critical behavior, which we propose to call ``bounded Luttinger liquids.'' They share the following properties with ordinary (periodic) Luttinger liquids: the absence of fermionic quasiparticle excitations, charge-spin separation, and anomalous power-law correlations with exponents whose scaling relations are parametrized by a single coupling constant per degree of freedom, ${K}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}.$ The values of ${K}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}$ are independent of boundary conditions, but the representation of the critical exponents in terms of these ${K}_{\ensuremath{\nu}}'\mathrm{s}$ depends on boundary conditions. We illustrate these scaling relations by exploring general rules for boundary critical exponents derived earlier using the Bethe ansatz solution of the one-dimensional Hubbard model together with boundary conformal field theory, and the theory of Luttinger liquids in finite-size systems. We apply this theory to the photoemission properties of the organic conductors (TMTSF)2X,(\mathrm{TMTSF}{)}_{2}X,(TMTSF)2​X, where TMTSF is tetramethyltetraselenafulvalene, and X=ClO9,X={\mathrm{ClO}}_{9},X=ClO9​, PF6,{\mathrm{PF}}_{6},PF6​, ReO4,\mathrm{Re}{\mathrm{O}}_{4},ReO4​, and discuss to what extent the assumption of finite strands with open boundaries at the sample surface can reconcile the experimental results with independent information on the Luttinger-liquid state in these materials.