Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2002.04241 · Physical Review A

Gauge invariance of the Dicke and Hopfield models

Luigi Garziano, Alessio Settineri, Omar Di Stefano, Salvatore Savasta, Franco Nori

Published Aug 26, 2020• 58 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The Dicke model, which describes the dipolar coupling between $N$ two-level atoms and a quantized electromagnetic field, seemingly violates gauge invariance in the presence of ultrastrong light-matter coupling, a regime that is now experimentally accessible in many physical systems. Specifically, it has been shown that, while the two-level approximation can work well in the dipole gauge, the Coulomb gauge fails to provide the correct spectra in the ultrastrong coupling regime. Here we show that, taking into account the nonlocality of the atomic potential induced by the two-level approximation, gauge invariance is fully restored for arbitrary interaction strengths, even in the $N\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$ limit. Finally, we express the Hopfield model, a general description based on the quantization of a linear dielectric medium, in a manifestly gauge-invariant form, and show that the Dicke model in the dilute regime can be regarded as a particular case of the more general Hopfield model.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.102.023718

Related papers

Breakdown of gauge invariance in ultrastrong-coupling cavity QED

Daniele De Bernardis, Philipp Pilar, Tuomas Jaako +2 more

We revisit the derivation of Rabi- and Dicke-type models, which are commonly used for the study of quantum light-matter interactions in cavity and circuit QED. We demonstrate that the validity of the two-level approximation, which is an essential step in this derivation, depends explicitly on the choice of gauge once the system enters the ultrastrong-coupling regime. In particular, while in the electric dipole gauge the two-level approximation can be performed as long as the Rabi frequency remains much smaller than the energies of all higher-lying levels, it can dramatically fail in the Coulomb gauge, even for systems with an extremely anharmonic spectrum. We extensively investigate this phenomenon both in the single-dipole (Rabi) and multidipole (Dicke) case, and consider the specific examples of dipoles confined by double-well and square-well potentials, and of circuit QED systems with flux qubits coupled to an LC resonator.

arXiv:1805.05339•Physical Review A•Nov 13, 2018•182 citations

Gauge principle and gauge invariance in two-level systems

Salvatore Savasta, Omar Di Stefano, Alessio Settineri +3 more

The quantum Rabi model is a widespread description of the coupling between a two-level system and a quantized single mode of an electromagnetic resonator. Issues about this model's gauge invariance have been raised. These issues become evident when the light-matter interaction reaches the so-called ultrastrong coupling regime. Recently, a modified quantum Rabi model able to provide gauge-invariant physical results (e.g., energy levels, expectation values of observables, quantum probabilities) in any interaction regime was introduced [O. Di Stefano, A. Settineri, V. Macr\`{\i}, L. Garziano, R. Stassi, S. Savasta, and F. Nori, Nat. Phys. 15, 803 (2019)]. Here we provide an alternative derivation of this result, based on the implementation in two-state systems of the gauge principle, which is the principle from which all the fundamental interactions in quantum field theory are derived. The adopted procedure can be regarded as the two-site version of the general method used to implement the gauge principle in lattice gauge theories. Applying this method, we also obtain the gauge-invariant quantum Rabi model for asymmetric two-state systems, and the multimode gauge-invariant quantum Rabi model beyond the dipole approximation.

arXiv:2006.06583•Physical Review A•May 7, 2021•38 citations

Gauge-invariant theory of truncated quantum light-matter interactions in arbitrary media

Chris Gustin, Sebastian Franke, Stephen Hughes

The loss of gauge invariance in models of light-matter interaction which arises from material and photonic space truncation can pose significant challenges to conventional quantum optical models when matter and light strongly hybridize. In structured photonic environments, necessary in practice to achieve strong light-matter coupling, a rigorous model of field quantization within the medium is also needed. Here we use the framework of macroscopic QED by quantizing the fields in an arbitrary material system, with a spatially dependent dispersive and absorptive dielectric, starting from a fundamental light-matter action. We truncate the material and mode degrees of freedom while respecting the gauge principle by imposing a partial gauge-fixing constraint during canonical quantization, which admits a large number of gauges including the Coulomb and multipolar gauges commonly used in quantum optics. We also consider gauge conditions with explicit time dependence, enabling us to unambiguously introduce additional phenomenologically time-dependent light-matter interactions in any gauge. Our results allow one to derive rigorous nonrelativistic models of ultrastrong light-matter interactions in structured photonic environments with no gauge ambiguity. Results for two-level systems and the dipole approximation are discussed, as well as how to go beyond the dipole approximation for effective single-particle models. By comparing with the limiting case of an inhomogeneous dielectric, where dispersion and absorption can be neglected and the fields can be expanded in terms of the generalized transverse eigenfunctions of the dielectric, we show how lossy systems can introduce an additional gauge ambiguity, which we resolve and predict to have fundamental implications for open quantum system models. Finally, we show how observables in mode-truncated systems can be calculated without ambiguity by using a simple gauge-invariant model of photodetection.

arXiv:2208.11796•Physical Review A•Jan 27, 2023•20 citations

Regimes of cavity QED under incoherent excitation: From weak to deep strong coupling

Alberto Mercurio, Vincenzo Macrí, Chris Gustin +3 more

The prototypical system constituted by a two-level atom interacting with a quantized single-mode electromagnetic field is described by the quantum Rabi model (QRM). The QRM is potentially valid at any light-matter interaction regime, ranging from the weak (where the decay rates exceeds the coupling rate) to the deep strong coupling (where the interaction rate exceeds the bare transition frequencies of the subsystems). However, when reaching the ultrastrong coupling regime, several theoretical issues may prevent the correct description of the observable dynamics of such a system: (i) the standard quantum optics master equation fails to correctly describe the interaction of this system with the reservoirs; (ii) the correct output photon rate is no longer proportional to the intracavity photon number; and (iii) they appear to violate gauge invariance. Here, we study the photon flux emission rate of this system under the incoherent excitation of the two-level atom for any light-matter interaction strength and consider different effective temperatures. The dependence of the emission spectra on the coupling strength is the result of the interplay between energy levels, matrix elements of the observables, and the density of states of the reservoirs. Within this approach, we also study the occurrence of light-matter decoupling in the deep strong-coupling regime and show how all of the obtained results are gauge invariant.

arXiv:2112.08917•Physical Review Research•Apr 20, 2022•25 citations

Gauge-Independent Emission Spectra and Quantum Correlations in the Ultrastrong Coupling Regime of Cavity-QED

Will Salmon, Chris Gustin, Alessio Settineri +5 more

A quantum dipole interacting with an optical cavity is one of the key models in cavity quantum electrodynamics (cavity-QED). To treat this system theoretically, the typical approach is to truncate the dipole to two levels. However, it has been shown that in the ultrastrong-coupling regime, this truncation naively destroys gauge invariance. By truncating in a manner consistent with the gauge principle, we introduce master equations to compute gauge-invariant emission spectra and quantum correlation functions which show significant disagreement with previous results obtained using the standard quantum Rabi model, with quantitative differences already present in the strong coupling regime. Explicit examples are shown using both the dipole gauge and the Coulomb gauge.

•Feb 24, 2021•1 citation

Generalized Dicke model and gauge-invariant master equations for two atoms in ultrastrongly-coupled cavity quantum electrodynamics

Kamran Akbari, Will Salmon, Franco Nori +1 more

We study a generalization of the well-known Dicke model, using two dissimilar atoms in the regime of ultrastrongly-coupled cavity quantum electrodynamics. Our theory uses gauge-invariant master equations, which yields consistent results in either of the standard multipolar and Coulomb gauges, including system-bath interactions for open cavity systems. We first show how a second atom can be treated as a sensor atom to measure the output spectrum from a single atom in the ultrastrong-coupling regime, and compare results with the quantum regression theorem, explaining when they can be different. We then focus on the case where the second atom is also ultrastrongly coupled to the cavity, but with different parameters from those of the first atom, which introduces complex coupling effects and additional resonances and spectral features. In particular, we show multiple resonances in the cavity spectra that are visible off-resonance. We also observe clear anticrossing features, which are particularly pronounced when the second atom is tuned through its resonance.

arXiv:2301.02127•Physical Review Research•Jul 5, 2023•15 citations
The Dicke model, which describes the dipolar coupling between NNN two-level atoms and a quantized electromagnetic field, seemingly violates gauge invariance in the presence of ultrastrong light-matter coupling, a regime that is now experimentally accessible in many physical systems. Specifically, it has been shown that, while the two-level approximation can work well in the dipole gauge, the Coulomb gauge fails to provide the correct spectra in the ultrastrong coupling regime. Here we show that, taking into account the nonlocality of the atomic potential induced by the two-level approximation, gauge invariance is fully restored for arbitrary interaction strengths, even in the N\ensuremath→\ensuremath∞N\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}N\ensuremath→\ensuremath∞ limit. Finally, we express the Hopfield model, a general description based on the quantization of a linear dielectric medium, in a manifestly gauge-invariant form, and show that the Dicke model in the dilute regime can be regarded as a particular case of the more general Hopfield model.
We revisit the derivation of Rabi- and Dicke-type models, which are commonly used for the study of quantum light-matter interactions in cavity and circuit QED. We demonstrate that the validity of the two-level approximation, which is an essential step in this derivation, depends explicitly on the choice of gauge once the system enters the ultrastrong-coupling regime. In particular, while in the electric dipole gauge the two-level approximation can be performed as long as the Rabi frequency remains much smaller than the energies of all higher-lying levels, it can dramatically fail in the Coulomb gauge, even for systems with an extremely anharmonic spectrum. We extensively investigate this phenomenon both in the single-dipole (Rabi) and multidipole (Dicke) case, and consider the specific examples of dipoles confined by double-well and square-well potentials, and of circuit QED systems with flux qubits coupled to an LC resonator.
The quantum Rabi model is a widespread description of the coupling between a two-level system and a quantized single mode of an electromagnetic resonator. Issues about this model's gauge invariance have been raised. These issues become evident when the light-matter interaction reaches the so-called ultrastrong coupling regime. Recently, a modified quantum Rabi model able to provide gauge-invariant physical results (e.g., energy levels, expectation values of observables, quantum probabilities) in any interaction regime was introduced [O. Di Stefano, A. Settineri, V. Macr\`{\i}, L. Garziano, R. Stassi, S. Savasta, and F. Nori, Nat. Phys. 15, 803 (2019)]. Here we provide an alternative derivation of this result, based on the implementation in two-state systems of the gauge principle, which is the principle from which all the fundamental interactions in quantum field theory are derived. The adopted procedure can be regarded as the two-site version of the general method used to implement the gauge principle in lattice gauge theories. Applying this method, we also obtain the gauge-invariant quantum Rabi model for asymmetric two-state systems, and the multimode gauge-invariant quantum Rabi model beyond the dipole approximation.
The loss of gauge invariance in models of light-matter interaction which arises from material and photonic space truncation can pose significant challenges to conventional quantum optical models when matter and light strongly hybridize. In structured photonic environments, necessary in practice to achieve strong light-matter coupling, a rigorous model of field quantization within the medium is also needed. Here we use the framework of macroscopic QED by quantizing the fields in an arbitrary material system, with a spatially dependent dispersive and absorptive dielectric, starting from a fundamental light-matter action. We truncate the material and mode degrees of freedom while respecting the gauge principle by imposing a partial gauge-fixing constraint during canonical quantization, which admits a large number of gauges including the Coulomb and multipolar gauges commonly used in quantum optics. We also consider gauge conditions with explicit time dependence, enabling us to unambiguously introduce additional phenomenologically time-dependent light-matter interactions in any gauge. Our results allow one to derive rigorous nonrelativistic models of ultrastrong light-matter interactions in structured photonic environments with no gauge ambiguity. Results for two-level systems and the dipole approximation are discussed, as well as how to go beyond the dipole approximation for effective single-particle models. By comparing with the limiting case of an inhomogeneous dielectric, where dispersion and absorption can be neglected and the fields can be expanded in terms of the generalized transverse eigenfunctions of the dielectric, we show how lossy systems can introduce an additional gauge ambiguity, which we resolve and predict to have fundamental implications for open quantum system models. Finally, we show how observables in mode-truncated systems can be calculated without ambiguity by using a simple gauge-invariant model of photodetection.
The prototypical system constituted by a two-level atom interacting with a quantized single-mode electromagnetic field is described by the quantum Rabi model (QRM). The QRM is potentially valid at any light-matter interaction regime, ranging from the weak (where the decay rates exceeds the coupling rate) to the deep strong coupling (where the interaction rate exceeds the bare transition frequencies of the subsystems). However, when reaching the ultrastrong coupling regime, several theoretical issues may prevent the correct description of the observable dynamics of such a system: (i) the standard quantum optics master equation fails to correctly describe the interaction of this system with the reservoirs; (ii) the correct output photon rate is no longer proportional to the intracavity photon number; and (iii) they appear to violate gauge invariance. Here, we study the photon flux emission rate of this system under the incoherent excitation of the two-level atom for any light-matter interaction strength and consider different effective temperatures. The dependence of the emission spectra on the coupling strength is the result of the interplay between energy levels, matrix elements of the observables, and the density of states of the reservoirs. Within this approach, we also study the occurrence of light-matter decoupling in the deep strong-coupling regime and show how all of the obtained results are gauge invariant.
A quantum dipole interacting with an optical cavity is one of the key models in cavity quantum electrodynamics (cavity-QED). To treat this system theoretically, the typical approach is to truncate the dipole to two levels. However, it has been shown that in the ultrastrong-coupling regime, this truncation naively destroys gauge invariance. By truncating in a manner consistent with the gauge principle, we introduce master equations to compute gauge-invariant emission spectra and quantum correlation functions which show significant disagreement with previous results obtained using the standard quantum Rabi model, with quantitative differences already present in the strong coupling regime. Explicit examples are shown using both the dipole gauge and the Coulomb gauge.
We study a generalization of the well-known Dicke model, using two dissimilar atoms in the regime of ultrastrongly-coupled cavity quantum electrodynamics. Our theory uses gauge-invariant master equations, which yields consistent results in either of the standard multipolar and Coulomb gauges, including system-bath interactions for open cavity systems. We first show how a second atom can be treated as a sensor atom to measure the output spectrum from a single atom in the ultrastrong-coupling regime, and compare results with the quantum regression theorem, explaining when they can be different. We then focus on the case where the second atom is also ultrastrongly coupled to the cavity, but with different parameters from those of the first atom, which introduces complex coupling effects and additional resonances and spectral features. In particular, we show multiple resonances in the cavity spectra that are visible off-resonance. We also observe clear anticrossing features, which are particularly pronounced when the second atom is tuned through its resonance.