© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

arXiv:1912.07111 · Acta Physica Polonica B

The Klein Paradox in a Magnetic Field: Effects of Electron Spin

Wlodek Zawadzki, P. Pfeffer

Published Jan 1, 2020• 1 citation

Abstract

Reflection and transmission of electrons scattered by a rectangular potential step in the presence of an external magnetic field parallel to the electron beam is described with the use of the Dirac equation. It is shown that in addition to the known effects present in the so called Klein paradox, the presence of magnetic field gives rise to electron components with reversed spin in the reflected and transmitted beams. The spin-flip scattering processes are caused by the spin-orbit interaction activated by electric field of the potential step and transverse momentum components of electron motion induced by the magnetic field. The contemporary understanding of the Klein paradox, consisting in the finite transmission even when the potential height tends to infinity, is generalized to the presence of magnetic field and spin-reversed electron beams. The spin-reversed beams are shown to occur also for electrons moving above the step. It is proposed that, accounting for the anomalous value of the electron spin $g$-factor related to radiation corrections, the reflection and transmission scattering from the potential step can be used as an electron spin filter.

DOI: 10.5506/aphyspolb.51.995

Related papers

QFT Treatment of the Klein Paradox

Chuting Xu, Y. J. Li

It is well known that, Klein paradox is one of the most exotic and counterintuitive consequences of quantum theory. Nevertheless, many discussions about the Klein paradox are based upon single-particle Dirac equation in quantum mechanics rather than quantum field method. By using the path integral formalism, we evaluate the reflection and transmission coefficients up to the lowest order for the electron scattering by the finite square barrier potential. Within the context of assuming the step potential is the limiting case of the finite square barrier potential, we explain the Klein paradox that is caused by the ill-definition of the step potential.

arXiv:1504.00901•Mar 31, 2015•0 citations

New Resolution of Klein Paradox by Modified Dirac Equations

Grigori G. Karapetyan

We present a new resolution of the Klein paradox by considering the problem of electron incidence on a step potential barrier using modified Dirac equations (MDE). Contrary to the generally accepted interpretation, which is based on the Dirac equation (DE) and predicts electron tunneling through an infinitely high barrier, our calculations show that tunneling is impossible if the electron kinetic energy is less than the barrier height. We propose to investigate MDE as an alternative DE relativistic quantum mechanical equation for spin ½ particles․

Armenian Journal of Physics•Sep 11, 2024•0 citations

Electric-type Stern–Gerlach effect

Jun Zhou, Zitao Fu, C. H. Oh +1 more

Abstract The Stern–Gerlach (SG) experiment is a fundamental experiment for revealing the existence of “spin”. In this experiment, beams of silver atoms are sent through inhomogeneous magnetic fields to observe their deflection. Thus, the conventional SG experiment can be viewed as a magnetic-type spin effect. In this work, we successfully generalize the SG effect from magnetic-type to electric-type by solving Dirac’s equation with a potential barrier, revealing an extraordinary spin effect. Beams of Dirac particles can be regarded as matter waves. Based on Dirac’s equation, we obtain the explicit forms of the incident, reflected, and transmitted waves. The electric-type SG effect shows that the reflected and transmitted waves can exhibit notable spatial shifts, which depend on the spin direction and the incident angle of the wave. The electric-type SG effect has potential applications for separating Dirac particles with different spin directions and for estimating the spin direction of Dirac particles. Some discussions related to the interaction between spin and the electric field are also presented.

arXiv:2501.04380•Chinese Physics B•Oct 9, 2025•0 citations

Scattering of relativistic electrons and analogies with optical phenomena: A study of longitudinal and transverse shifts at step potentials

Yue Ban, Xi Chen

We investigate the behavior of relativistic electrons encountering a potential step through analogies with optical phenomena. By accounting for the conservation of the Dirac current, we elucidate that the Goos-H\"anchen shift can be understood as a combination of two components: one arising from the current entering the transmission region and the other originating from the interference between the incident and reflected beams. This result has been proven to be consistent with findings obtained utilizing the stationary phase method. Moreover, we explore the transverse Imbert-Fedorov shift by applying both current conservation and total angular momentum conservation, revealing intriguing parallel to the spin Hall effect. Beyond enriching our comprehension of fundamental quantum phenomena, our findings have potential applications for designing and characterizing devices using Dirac and topological materials.

arXiv:2308.05413•Physical Review A•Oct 27, 2023•4 citations

Virtual beams and the Klein paradox for the Klein-Gordon equation

Alberto Molgado, Ociel Morales, José A. Vallejo

Whenever we consider any relativistic quantum wave equation we are confronted with the Klein paradox, which asserts that incident particles will suffer a surplus of reflection when dispersed by a discontinuous potential. Following recent results on the Dirac equation, we propose a solution to this paradox for the Klein-Gordon case by introducing virtual beams in a natural well-posed generalization of the method of images in the theory of partial differential equations. Thus, our solution considers a global reflection coefficient obtained from the two contributions, the reflected particles plus the incident virtual particles. Despite its simplicity, this method allows a reasonable understanding of the paradox within the context of the quantum relativistic theory of particles (according to the original setup for the Klein paradox) and without resorting to any quantum field theoretic issues.

arXiv:1602.00190•Revista Mexicana de Física E•Apr 10, 2018•6 citations

The Klein paradox: a new treatment

Egon Truebenbacher

Abstract The Dirac equation requires a treatment of the step potential that differs fundamentally from the traditional treatment, because the Dirac plane waves, besides momentum and spin, are characterized by a quantum number with the physical meaning of sign of charge. Since the Hermitean operator corresponding to this quantum number does not commute with the step potential, the time displacement parameter used in the ansatz of the stationary state does not have the physical meaning of energy. Therefore there are no paradoxal values of the ‘energy’. The new solution of the Dirac equation with a step potential is obtained. This solution, again, allows for phenomena of the Klein paradox type, but in addition it contains a positron amplitude localized at the threshold point of the step potential.

arXiv:1704.04108•European Journal of Physics•Jul 15, 2015•1 citation

Reflection and transmission of electrons scattered by a rectangular potential step in the presence of an external magnetic field parallel to the electron beam is described with the use of the Dirac equation. It is shown that in addition to the known effects present in the so called Klein paradox, the presence of magnetic field gives rise to electron components with reversed spin in the reflected and transmitted beams. The spin-flip scattering processes are caused by the spin-orbit interaction activated by electric field of the potential step and transverse momentum components of electron motion induced by the magnetic field. The contemporary understanding of the Klein paradox, consisting in the finite transmission even when the potential height tends to infinity, is generalized to the presence of magnetic field and spin-reversed electron beams. The spin-reversed beams are shown to occur also for electrons moving above the step. It is proposed that, accounting for the anomalous value of the electron spin

g

-factor related to radiation corrections, the reflection and transmission scattering from the potential step can be used as an electron spin filter.

It is well known that, Klein paradox is one of the most exotic and counterintuitive consequences of quantum theory. Nevertheless, many discussions about the Klein paradox are based upon single-particle Dirac equation in quantum mechanics rather than quantum field method. By using the path integral formalism, we evaluate the reflection and transmission coefficients up to the lowest order for the electron scattering by the finite square barrier potential. Within the context of assuming the step potential is the limiting case of the finite square barrier potential, we explain the Klein paradox that is caused by the ill-definition of the step potential.

We present a new resolution of the Klein paradox by considering the problem of electron incidence on a step potential barrier using modified Dirac equations (MDE). Contrary to the generally accepted interpretation, which is based on the Dirac equation (DE) and predicts electron tunneling through an infinitely high barrier, our calculations show that tunneling is impossible if the electron kinetic energy is less than the barrier height. We propose to investigate MDE as an alternative DE relativistic quantum mechanical equation for spin ½ particles․

Abstract The Stern–Gerlach (SG) experiment is a fundamental experiment for revealing the existence of “spin”. In this experiment, beams of silver atoms are sent through inhomogeneous magnetic fields to observe their deflection. Thus, the conventional SG experiment can be viewed as a magnetic-type spin effect. In this work, we successfully generalize the SG effect from magnetic-type to electric-type by solving Dirac’s equation with a potential barrier, revealing an extraordinary spin effect. Beams of Dirac particles can be regarded as matter waves. Based on Dirac’s equation, we obtain the explicit forms of the incident, reflected, and transmitted waves. The electric-type SG effect shows that the reflected and transmitted waves can exhibit notable spatial shifts, which depend on the spin direction and the incident angle of the wave. The electric-type SG effect has potential applications for separating Dirac particles with different spin directions and for estimating the spin direction of Dirac particles. Some discussions related to the interaction between spin and the electric field are also presented.

We investigate the behavior of relativistic electrons encountering a potential step through analogies with optical phenomena. By accounting for the conservation of the Dirac current, we elucidate that the Goos-H\"anchen shift can be understood as a combination of two components: one arising from the current entering the transmission region and the other originating from the interference between the incident and reflected beams. This result has been proven to be consistent with findings obtained utilizing the stationary phase method. Moreover, we explore the transverse Imbert-Fedorov shift by applying both current conservation and total angular momentum conservation, revealing intriguing parallel to the spin Hall effect. Beyond enriching our comprehension of fundamental quantum phenomena, our findings have potential applications for designing and characterizing devices using Dirac and topological materials.

Whenever we consider any relativistic quantum wave equation we are confronted with the Klein paradox, which asserts that incident particles will suffer a surplus of reflection when dispersed by a discontinuous potential. Following recent results on the Dirac equation, we propose a solution to this paradox for the Klein-Gordon case by introducing virtual beams in a natural well-posed generalization of the method of images in the theory of partial differential equations. Thus, our solution considers a global reflection coefficient obtained from the two contributions, the reflected particles plus the incident virtual particles. Despite its simplicity, this method allows a reasonable understanding of the paradox within the context of the quantum relativistic theory of particles (according to the original setup for the Klein paradox) and without resorting to any quantum field theoretic issues.

Abstract The Dirac equation requires a treatment of the step potential that differs fundamentally from the traditional treatment, because the Dirac plane waves, besides momentum and spin, are characterized by a quantum number with the physical meaning of sign of charge. Since the Hermitean operator corresponding to this quantum number does not commute with the step potential, the time displacement parameter used in the ansatz of the stationary state does not have the physical meaning of energy. Therefore there are no paradoxal values of the ‘energy’. The new solution of the Dirac equation with a step potential is obtained. This solution, again, allows for phenomena of the Klein paradox type, but in addition it contains a positron amplitude localized at the threshold point of the step potential.