We present error mitigation (EM) techniques for noisy intermediate-scale quantum computers (QC) based on density matrix purification and perturbative corrections to the target energy. We incorporate this scheme into the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) and demonstrate chemically-accurate ground state energy calculations of various alkali metal hydrides using IBM quantum computers. Both the density matrix purification improvements and the perturbative corrections require only meager classical computational resources, and are conducted exclusively as post-processing of the measured density matrix. The improved density matrix leads to better simulation accuracy at each step of the variational optimization, resulting in a better input into the next optimization step without additional measurements. Adding perturbative corrections to the resulting energies further increases the accuracy, and decreases variation between consecutive measurements. These EM schemes allow for previously unavailable levels of accuracy over remote QC resources.
We present error mitigation (EM) techniques for noisy intermediate-scale quantum computers (QC) based on density matrix purification and perturbative corrections to the target energy. We incorporate this scheme into the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) and demonstrate chemically-accurate ground state energy calculations of various alkali metal hydrides using IBM quantum computers. Both the density matrix purification improvements and the perturbative corrections require only meager classical computational resources, and are conducted exclusively as post-processing of the measured density matrix. The improved density matrix leads to better simulation accuracy at each step of the variational optimization, resulting in a better input into the next optimization step without additional measurements. Adding perturbative corrections to the resulting energies further increases the accuracy, and decreases variation between consecutive measurements. These EM schemes allow for previously unavailable levels of accuracy over remote QC resources.
Abstract We present a quantum chemistry benchmark for noisy intermediate-scale quantum computers that leverages the variational quantum eigensolver, active-space reduction, a reduced unitary coupled cluster ansatz, and reduced density purification as error mitigation. We demonstrate this benchmark using 4 of the available qubits on the 20-qubit IBM Tokyo and 16-qubit Rigetti Aspen processors via the simulation of alkali metal hydrides (NaH, KH, RbH), with accuracy of the computed ground state energy serving as the primary benchmark metric. We further parameterize this benchmark suite on the trial circuit type, the level of symmetry reduction, and error mitigation strategies. Our results demonstrate the characteristically high noise level present in near-term superconducting hardware, but provide a relevant baseline for future improvement of the underlying hardware, and a means for comparison across near-term hardware types. We also demonstrate how to reduce the noise in post processing with specific error mitigation techniques. Particularly, the adaptation of McWeeny purification of noisy density matrices dramatically improves accuracy of quantum computations, which, along with adjustable active space, significantly extends the range of accessible molecular systems. We demonstrate that for specific benchmark settings and a selected range of problems, the accuracy metric can reach chemical accuracy when computing over the cloud on certain quantum computers.
Variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) is a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm designed for noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computers. It is promising for quantum chemical calculations (QCC) because it can calculate the ground-state energy of a target molecule. Although VQE has a potential to achieve a higher accuracy than classical approximation methods in QCC, it is challenging to achieve it on current NISQ computers due to the significant impact of noises. Density matrix embedding theory (DMET) is a well-known technique to divide a molecule into multiple fragments, which is available to mitigate the noise impact on VQE. However, our preliminary evaluation shows that the naive combination of DMET and VQE does not outperform a gold standard classical method. In this work, we present three approaches to mitigate the noise impact for the DMET+VQE combination. (1) The size of quantum circuits used by VQE is decreased by reducing the number of bath orbitals which represent interactions between multiple fragments in DMET. (2) Reduced density matrices (RDMs), which are used to calculate a molecular energy in DMET, are calculated accurately based on expectation values obtained by executing quantum circuits using a noise-less quantum computer simulator. (3) The parameters of a quantum circuit optimized by VQE are refined with mathematical post-processing. The evaluation using a noisy quantum computer simulator shows that our approaches significantly improve the accuracy of the DMET+VQE combination. Moreover, we demonstrate that on a real NISQ device, the DMET+VQE combination applying our three approaches achieves a higher accuracy than the gold standard classical method.
Variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) is a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm designed for noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computers. It is promising for quantum chemical calculations (QCC) because it can calculate the ground-state energy of molecules. Although VQE has a theoretical potential to achieve a higher accuracy than classical approximation methods, it is challenging to achieve it on current NISQ computers due to the significant impact of noise. Density matrix embedding theory (DMET) is a well-known technique that can be used to decompose a molecule into multiple fragments, which is available to mitigate the noise impact on VQE. However, our preliminary evaluation shows that the naive combination of DMET and VQE hardly mitigates it. In this work, we present two proposals to mitigate the noise impact on the DMET+VQE combination. (1) The size of quantum circuits used by VQE is decreased by reducing the number of bath orbitals which represent interactions between multiple fragments in DMET. (2) While VQE is executed on a NISQ computer, reduced density matrices (RDMs), which are used to calculate the energy of fragments in DMET, are calculated accurately by executing quantum circuits using a noise-less quantum computer simulator. The evaluation using a noisy quantum computer simulator shows that our proposals improve the accuracy of the DMET+VQE combination by an order of magnitude.
Quantum computing offers a potential for algorithmic speedups for applications, such as large-scale simulations in chemistry and physics. However, these speedups must yield results that are sufficiently accurate to predict realistic outcomes of experiments precisely. Delivering on the promise of high accuracy and precision requires methods to evaluate the computational accuracy of the quantum computing devices. We develop a framework to estimate the computational accuracy of near-term noisy, intermediate scale quantum (NISQ) computing devices using a quantum chemistry application. Application benchmarks that run on NISQ devices require techniques for mitigating errors to improve accuracy and precision. We use device agnostic error-mitigation schemes, quantum error detection and readout error detection, with post-selection to mitigate the dominant sources of noise. We evaluate the framework by simulating the ground state of molecular hydrogen with the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) algorithm, estimating the energy and calculating the precision of the estimate using numerical simulations with realistic noise models. We first quantify the improvement in the logical error rate and state fidelity of the VQE application when encoded with the [[4,2,2]] quantum error detection code. When additionally encoded with readout error detection, we show that compared to the unencoded simulation, the encoded simulation yields a more accurate estimate by more than 1 mHa (0.027 eV) with comparable precision and higher state fidelity. Additionally, unlike the best estimate from the unencoded simulations, the results from the encoded simulation fall within the chemical accuracy threshold of 1.6 mHa of the exact energy. The estimated accuracy and precision indicate that current quantum computers can achieve error rates that yield useful outcomes for chemical applications.
Abstract The inherent noise in current Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices presents a major obstacle to the accurate implementation of quantum algorithms such as the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) for quantum chemistry applications. This study examines the impact of error mitigation strategies on VQE performance. We show that, for small molecular systems, an older-generation 5-qubit quantum processing unit (IBMQ Belem), when combined with optimized Twirled Readout Error Extinction (T-REx), achieves ground-state energy estimations an order of magnitude more accurate than those obtained from a more advanced 156-qubit device (IBM Fez) without error mitigation. Our findings demonstrate that T-REx, a computationally inexpensive error mitigation technique, substantially improves VQE accuracy not only in energy estimation, but more importantly in optimizing the variational parameters that characterize the molecular ground state. Consequently, state-vector simulated energies suggest that the accuracy of the optimized variational parameters provides a more reliable benchmark of VQE performance than quantum hardware energy estimates alone. Our results point to the critical role of error mitigation in extending the utility of noisy quantum hardware for molecular simulations.
Quantum hardware noise remains a major obstacle to accurate molecular simulations using the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE). We introduce a novel error-mitigation strategy based on the extended random phase approximation (ERPA), which reconstructs the two-particle reduced density matrix (2-RDM) from approximate transition density matrices, effectively filtering errors in quantum measurements. Unlike quantum subspace expansion, the approach requires only the one- and two-particle RDMs. Since ERPA preserves the input 1-RDM, we further propose a hybrid quantum-classical scheme employing an inexpensive density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) calculation to provide a noise-free approximation to this quantity. Benchmarks on water double-bond stretching and cyclobutadiene automerization, performed on IBM quantum hardware, demonstrate reductions in energy errors by orders of magnitude. Combined with multireference adiabatic connection (AC0) corrections, the approach additionally recovers dynamical correlation beyond the active space, yielding accurate molecular potential energy curves and reaction barriers. Our results establish ERPA as a promising, measurement-efficient route toward reliable quantum-classical electronic structure calculations.