Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1909.05219 · Physical Review A

Benchmarking noise extrapolation with the OpenPulse control framework

John W. O. Garmon, Raphael C. Pooser, Eugene Dumitrescu

Published Apr 6, 2020• 18 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Distilling precise estimates from noisy intermediate scale quantum (NISQ) data has recently attracted considerable attention Kandala et al., Nature (London) 567, 491 (2019). In order to augment digital qubit metrics, such as gate fidelity, we discuss analog error mitigability, i.e., the ability to accurately distill precise observable estimates, as a hybrid quantum classical computing benchmarking task. Specifically, using Rabi oscillations as a test program, we characterize single qubit error rates on IBM's Poughkeepsie superconducting quantum hardware, incorporate control-mediated noise dependence into a generalized rescaling protocol, and analyze how noise characteristics influence Richardson extrapolation-based error mitigation. Our results identify regions in the space of Hamiltonian control fields and circuit depth which are most amenable to reliable noise extrapolation, as well as shed light on how low-level hardware characterization can be used as a predictive tool for uncertainty quantification in error-mitigated NISQ computations.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.101.042308

Related papers

Mitigating Realistic Noise in Practical Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum Devices

Jinzhao Sun, Xiao Yuan, Takahiro Tsunoda +3 more

Quantum error mitigation (QEM) is vital for noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. While most conventional QEM schemes assume discrete gate-based circuits with noise appearing either before or after each gate, the assumptions are inappropriate for describing realistic noise that may have strong gate dependence and complicated nonlocal effects, and general computing models such as analog quantum simulators. To address these challenges, we first extend the scenario, where each computation process, being either digital or analog, is described by a continuous time evolution. For noise from imperfections of the engineered Hamiltonian or additional noise operators, we show it can be effectively suppressed by a stochastic QEM method. Since our method assumes only accurate single qubit controls, it is applicable to all digital quantum computers and various analog simulators. Meanwhile, errors in the mitigation procedure can be suppressed by leveraging the Richardson extrapolation method. As we numerically test our method with various Hamiltonians under energy relaxation and dephasing noise and digital quantum circuits with additional two-qubit crosstalk, we show an improvement of simulation accuracy by 2 orders. We assess the resource cost of our scheme and conclude the feasibility of accurate quantum computing with NISQ devices.

arXiv:2001.04891•Physical Review Applied•Mar 9, 2021•104 citations

Practical quantum error mitigation for analog quantum simulation

Jinzhao Sun, Xiao Yuan, Takahiro Tsunoda +3 more

Analog quantum simulation has been proposed as an efficient approach for probing classically intractable many-body physics. In contrast to digital, gate-based quantum simulation, the analog approach involves configuring the quantum hardware to directly mimic the physics of the target system. This reduces the level of control required and can offer a degree of inherent robustness, but it comes at the cost that known error-handling techniques may be inapplicable. Accumulation of error is thus a major challenge facing medium-scale and large-scale analog quantum simulation with current and near-term noisy quantum (NISQ) devices. Here we propose a hybrid error mitigation scheme that can suppress general local Markovian noise in analog quantum simulators. We employ stochastic error mitigation for physical noise and use Richardson extrapolation to compensate for model estimation error. We numerically test the error mitigation scheme for an Ising-type Hamiltonian with energy relaxation and dephasing noise, and show an improvement of simulation accuracy by two orders. We assess the resource cost of our error mitigation scheme and conclude that analog quantum simulation at scale is feasible with NISQ hardware.

•Jan 14, 2020•1 citation

Pulse-level characterization of qubits on quantum devices

David Andrés Quiroga Salamanca

ABSTRACT: Recent research has tackled the problem of mitigating noise present in quantum computers in the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era to enable precise computations and to benefit from the intrinsic properties of quantum mechanics. For this matter, an important task is the characterization of qubits available in quantum devices so as to provide insights on how to reduce noise on the final output of a quantum circuit. Characterization comprises analysis of noise sources and this information can be used to reduce noise with methods such as Cycle Benchmarking, Quantum Error Mitigation, Quantum Error Correction and others. Here, we study optimization of pulses through Quantum Optimal Control (QOC) to obtain higher gate fidelity. We will explore an algorithm that performs calibration on specific quantum gates by implementing optimized pulse schedules to subsequently use the algorithm for analysis of noise sources. Using calibrated gates as input, several benchmarking protocols, including pulse noise extrapolation, leakage analysis from quantum optimal control, and machine learning based classification of qubit readout, will be tested to extract precise information on how noise influences the analyzed qubits. We will explain and discuss different techniques for obtaining properties of qubits and quantum computers. We will implement state discrimination with a Machine Learning (ML) focus to analyze readout errors caused by factors such as cross-talk and leakage into higher quantum states. We will perform noise fitting of optimized pulses and evaluate the effectiveness of important quantum algorithms at the pulse level.

•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

Mitigating noise in digital and digital–analog quantum computation

Paula García-Molina, Ana Martin, Mikel Garcia de Andoin +1 more

Abstract Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices lack error correction, limiting scalability for quantum algorithms. In this context, digital-analog quantum computing (DAQC) offers a more resilient alternative quantum computing paradigm that outperforms digital quantum computation by combining the flexibility of single-qubit gates with the robustness of analog simulations. This work explores the impact of noise on both digital and DAQC paradigms and demonstrates DAQC’s effectiveness in error mitigation. We compare the quantum Fourier transform and quantum phase estimation algorithms under a wide range of single and two-qubit noise sources in superconducting processors. DAQC consistently surpasses digital approaches in fidelity, particularly as processor size increases. Moreover, zero-noise extrapolation further enhances DAQC by mitigating decoherence and intrinsic errors, achieving fidelities above 0.95 for 8 qubits, and reducing computation errors to the order of 10 −3 . These results establish DAQC as a viable alternative for quantum computing in the NISQ era.

arXiv:2107.12969•Communications Physics•Oct 6, 2024•19 citations

A useful metric for the NISQ era: Qubit error probability and its role in zero noise extrapolation

Nahual Sobrino, Unai Aseginolaza, Joaquim Jornet-Somoza +1 more

Accurate assessment and management of errors is indispensable for extracting useful results from noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices. In this work, we propose the qubit error probability (QEP), a device specific metric that combines relaxation, dephasing, gate, and measurement contributions into a single per qubit figure of merit computable before execution. Leveraging QEP as the control variable, we revisit zero noise extrapolation (ZNE) by adding pairs of controlled native two-qubit gates on all connected qubit pairs to generate circuits with successively larger mean QEP; the zero error limit is then approximated by a linear regression of the measured observable against those values. Benchmarking on IBM Quantum Heron processors, we apply QEP guided ZNE to first order Trotterized simulations of the two dimensional transverse field Ising model, chosen as a representative interacting many body system, involving up to 68 qubits and 15 Trotter steps. In regimes where the raw circuits exhibit a finite mean QEP, the method suppresses observable errors beyond those attainable with circuit depth scaled ZNE, while requiring only three noise scaled evaluations and no additional classical post processing. These results demonstrate that QEP serves as a transparent and efficient error metric and that its integration into ZNE provides a practical route to reliability gains on current superconducting hardware, without the resource costs associated with full quantum error correction.

arXiv:2503.10204•AVS Quantum Science•Feb 13, 2026•0 citations

Hybrid Gaussian-exponential zero-noise extrapolation for periodic circuits

Tao Wang, Yun Shang

Zero-noise extrapolation provides a practical means of suppressing gate errors in current noisy intermediate-scale quantum hardware. The accuracy of the zero-noise estimate depends sensitively on the fidelity of the assumed noise model to the actual error scaling. This work introduces a hybrid Gaussian-exponential extrapolation scheme tailored for quantum circuits with periodic structure, which are ubiquitous in quantum algorithms. Under Pauli diagonal errors, by constructing and analyzing an approximate Markov process for the transfer of Pauli operators, we prove a central limit theorem: the noise amplification factor weakly approaches a log-normal distribution, which motivates augmenting the standard exponential model with Gaussian variance corrections. The resulting model requires no prior noise characterization and applies directly to arbitrary periodic circuits. Performance is assessed on Trotterized Ising dynamics, random circuits, and Grover search algorithm using Qiskit noise simulators. For moderate to large circuit depths, the hybrid model yields measurable reductions in bias relative to previous extrapolation variants, indicating its utility for error mitigation on near-term quantum hardware.

quant-pharXiv:2605.29242•May 29, 2026•0 citations
Distilling precise estimates from noisy intermediate scale quantum (NISQ) data has recently attracted considerable attention Kandala et al., Nature (London) 567, 491 (2019). In order to augment digital qubit metrics, such as gate fidelity, we discuss analog error mitigability, i.e., the ability to accurately distill precise observable estimates, as a hybrid quantum classical computing benchmarking task. Specifically, using Rabi oscillations as a test program, we characterize single qubit error rates on IBM's Poughkeepsie superconducting quantum hardware, incorporate control-mediated noise dependence into a generalized rescaling protocol, and analyze how noise characteristics influence Richardson extrapolation-based error mitigation. Our results identify regions in the space of Hamiltonian control fields and circuit depth which are most amenable to reliable noise extrapolation, as well as shed light on how low-level hardware characterization can be used as a predictive tool for uncertainty quantification in error-mitigated NISQ computations.
Quantum error mitigation (QEM) is vital for noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. While most conventional QEM schemes assume discrete gate-based circuits with noise appearing either before or after each gate, the assumptions are inappropriate for describing realistic noise that may have strong gate dependence and complicated nonlocal effects, and general computing models such as analog quantum simulators. To address these challenges, we first extend the scenario, where each computation process, being either digital or analog, is described by a continuous time evolution. For noise from imperfections of the engineered Hamiltonian or additional noise operators, we show it can be effectively suppressed by a stochastic QEM method. Since our method assumes only accurate single qubit controls, it is applicable to all digital quantum computers and various analog simulators. Meanwhile, errors in the mitigation procedure can be suppressed by leveraging the Richardson extrapolation method. As we numerically test our method with various Hamiltonians under energy relaxation and dephasing noise and digital quantum circuits with additional two-qubit crosstalk, we show an improvement of simulation accuracy by 2 orders. We assess the resource cost of our scheme and conclude the feasibility of accurate quantum computing with NISQ devices.
Analog quantum simulation has been proposed as an efficient approach for probing classically intractable many-body physics. In contrast to digital, gate-based quantum simulation, the analog approach involves configuring the quantum hardware to directly mimic the physics of the target system. This reduces the level of control required and can offer a degree of inherent robustness, but it comes at the cost that known error-handling techniques may be inapplicable. Accumulation of error is thus a major challenge facing medium-scale and large-scale analog quantum simulation with current and near-term noisy quantum (NISQ) devices. Here we propose a hybrid error mitigation scheme that can suppress general local Markovian noise in analog quantum simulators. We employ stochastic error mitigation for physical noise and use Richardson extrapolation to compensate for model estimation error. We numerically test the error mitigation scheme for an Ising-type Hamiltonian with energy relaxation and dephasing noise, and show an improvement of simulation accuracy by two orders. We assess the resource cost of our error mitigation scheme and conclude that analog quantum simulation at scale is feasible with NISQ hardware.
ABSTRACT: Recent research has tackled the problem of mitigating noise present in quantum computers in the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era to enable precise computations and to benefit from the intrinsic properties of quantum mechanics. For this matter, an important task is the characterization of qubits available in quantum devices so as to provide insights on how to reduce noise on the final output of a quantum circuit. Characterization comprises analysis of noise sources and this information can be used to reduce noise with methods such as Cycle Benchmarking, Quantum Error Mitigation, Quantum Error Correction and others. Here, we study optimization of pulses through Quantum Optimal Control (QOC) to obtain higher gate fidelity. We will explore an algorithm that performs calibration on specific quantum gates by implementing optimized pulse schedules to subsequently use the algorithm for analysis of noise sources. Using calibrated gates as input, several benchmarking protocols, including pulse noise extrapolation, leakage analysis from quantum optimal control, and machine learning based classification of qubit readout, will be tested to extract precise information on how noise influences the analyzed qubits. We will explain and discuss different techniques for obtaining properties of qubits and quantum computers. We will implement state discrimination with a Machine Learning (ML) focus to analyze readout errors caused by factors such as cross-talk and leakage into higher quantum states. We will perform noise fitting of optimized pulses and evaluate the effectiveness of important quantum algorithms at the pulse level.
Abstract Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices lack error correction, limiting scalability for quantum algorithms. In this context, digital-analog quantum computing (DAQC) offers a more resilient alternative quantum computing paradigm that outperforms digital quantum computation by combining the flexibility of single-qubit gates with the robustness of analog simulations. This work explores the impact of noise on both digital and DAQC paradigms and demonstrates DAQC’s effectiveness in error mitigation. We compare the quantum Fourier transform and quantum phase estimation algorithms under a wide range of single and two-qubit noise sources in superconducting processors. DAQC consistently surpasses digital approaches in fidelity, particularly as processor size increases. Moreover, zero-noise extrapolation further enhances DAQC by mitigating decoherence and intrinsic errors, achieving fidelities above 0.95 for 8 qubits, and reducing computation errors to the order of 10 −3 . These results establish DAQC as a viable alternative for quantum computing in the NISQ era.
Accurate assessment and management of errors is indispensable for extracting useful results from noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices. In this work, we propose the qubit error probability (QEP), a device specific metric that combines relaxation, dephasing, gate, and measurement contributions into a single per qubit figure of merit computable before execution. Leveraging QEP as the control variable, we revisit zero noise extrapolation (ZNE) by adding pairs of controlled native two-qubit gates on all connected qubit pairs to generate circuits with successively larger mean QEP; the zero error limit is then approximated by a linear regression of the measured observable against those values. Benchmarking on IBM Quantum Heron processors, we apply QEP guided ZNE to first order Trotterized simulations of the two dimensional transverse field Ising model, chosen as a representative interacting many body system, involving up to 68 qubits and 15 Trotter steps. In regimes where the raw circuits exhibit a finite mean QEP, the method suppresses observable errors beyond those attainable with circuit depth scaled ZNE, while requiring only three noise scaled evaluations and no additional classical post processing. These results demonstrate that QEP serves as a transparent and efficient error metric and that its integration into ZNE provides a practical route to reliability gains on current superconducting hardware, without the resource costs associated with full quantum error correction.
Zero-noise extrapolation provides a practical means of suppressing gate errors in current noisy intermediate-scale quantum hardware. The accuracy of the zero-noise estimate depends sensitively on the fidelity of the assumed noise model to the actual error scaling. This work introduces a hybrid Gaussian-exponential extrapolation scheme tailored for quantum circuits with periodic structure, which are ubiquitous in quantum algorithms. Under Pauli diagonal errors, by constructing and analyzing an approximate Markov process for the transfer of Pauli operators, we prove a central limit theorem: the noise amplification factor weakly approaches a log-normal distribution, which motivates augmenting the standard exponential model with Gaussian variance corrections. The resulting model requires no prior noise characterization and applies directly to arbitrary periodic circuits. Performance is assessed on Trotterized Ising dynamics, random circuits, and Grover search algorithm using Qiskit noise simulators. For moderate to large circuit depths, the hybrid model yields measurable reductions in bias relative to previous extrapolation variants, indicating its utility for error mitigation on near-term quantum hardware.