Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1908.03574 · Journal of High Energy Physics

Chaos in the butterfly cone

Márk Mezei, Gábor Sárosi

Published Jan 29, 2020• 62 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract A simple probe of chaos and operator growth in many-body quantum systems is the out of time ordered four point function. In a large class of local systems, the effects of chaos in this correlator build up exponentially fast inside the so called butterfly cone. It has been previously observed that the growth of these effects is organized along rays and can be characterized by a velocity dependent Lyapunov exponent, λ(v). We show that this exponent is bounded inside the butterfly cone as λ(v) ≤ 2πT (1 − | v |/v B ), where T is the temperature and v B is the butterfly speed. This result generalizes the chaos bound of Maldacena, Shenker and Stanford. We study λ(v) in some examples such as two dimensional SYK models and holographic gauge theories, and observe that in these systems the bound gets saturated at some critical velocity v * < v B . In this sense, boosting a system enhances chaos. We discuss the connection to conformal Regge theory, where λ(v) is related to the spin of the leading large N Regge trajectory, and controls the four point function in an interpolating regime between the Regge and the light cone limit. Finally, we comment on the generalization of the chaos bound to boosted and rotating ensembles and clarify some recent results on this in the literature.

DOI
10.1007/jhep01(2020)186

Related papers

Velocity-dependent Lyapunov exponents in many-body quantum, semiclassical, and classical chaos

Vedika Khemani, David A. Huse, Adam Nahum

It has been a long-standing challenge to expand the notion of exponential sensitivity to small perturbations in the initial conditions from the realm of classical chaos to that of many-body quantum systems. Recently, exponential growth in a measure known as the out-of-time-order commutator (OTOC) has been proposed as a diagnostic of chaos in the setting of many-body quantum systems. The authors examine the behavior of the OTOC along rays of different velocities for a variety of spatially local extended many-body quantum systems, both integrable and nonintegrable. They find that the velocity-dependent Lyapunov exponents are negative for velocities greater than a characteristic ``butterfly speed'', which defines the light cone for the spreading of operators. It is demonstrated that a regime with well-defined positive Lyapunov exponents inside the light-cone may only exist for classical, semiclassical, weakly interacting, or large-$N$ systems, but not for fully quantum systems with strong short-range interactions and local Hilbert space dimensions of order one.

arXiv:1803.05902•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 16, 2018•168 citations

Light-Cone Spreading of Perturbations and the Butterfly Effect in a Classical Spin Chain

Avijit Das, Saurish Chakrabarty, Abhishek Dhar +5 more

We find that the effects of a localized perturbation in a chaotic classical many-body system-the classical Heisenberg chain at infinite temperature-spread ballistically with a finite speed even when the local spin dynamics is diffusive. We study two complementary aspects of this butterfly effect: the rapid growth of the perturbation, and its simultaneous ballistic (light-cone) spread, as characterized by the Lyapunov exponents and the butterfly speed, respectively. We connect this to recent studies of the out-of-time-ordered commutators (OTOC), which have been proposed as an indicator of chaos in a quantum system. We provide a straightforward identification of the OTOC with a natural correlator in our system and demonstrate that many of its interesting qualitative features are present in the classical system. Finally, by analyzing the scaling forms, we relate the growth, spread, and propagation of the perturbation with the growth of one-dimensional interfaces described by the Kardar-Parisi-Zhang equation.

arXiv:1711.07505•Physical Review Letters•Jul 10, 2018•75 citations

Holographic butterfly effect at quantum critical points

Yi Ling, Peng Liu, Jian-Pin Wu

When the Lyapunov exponent λL in a quantum chaotic system saturates the bound λL ≤ 2πk B T , it is proposed that this system has a holographic dual described by a gravity theory. In particular, the butterfly effect as a prominent phenomenon of chaos can ubiquitously exist in a black hole system characterized by a shockwave solution near the horizon. In this paper we propose that the butterfly velocity can be used to diagnose quantum phase transition (QPT) in holographic theories. We provide evidences for this proposal with an anisotropic holographic model exhibiting metal-insulator transitions (MIT), in which the derivatives of the butterfly velocity with respect to system parameters characterizes quantum critical points (QCP) with local extremes in zero temperature limit. We also point out that this proposal can be tested by experiments in the light of recent progress on the measurement of out-of-time-order correlation function (OTOC).

arXiv:1610.02669•Journal of High Energy Physics•Oct 1, 2017•51 citations

Onset of many-body chaos in the O(N) model

Brian G. Swingle, Debanjan Chowdhury

The growth of commutators of initially commuting local operators diagnoses the onset of chaos in quantum many-body systems. We compute such commutators of local field operators with N components in the (2+1)-dimensional O(N) nonlinear sigma model to leading order in 1/N. The system is taken to be in thermal equilibrium at a temperature T above the zero temperature quantum critical point separating the symmetry broken and unbroken phases. The commutator grows exponentially in time with a rate denoted λ[subscript L]. At large N the growth of chaos as measured by λ[subscript L] is slow because the model is weakly interacting, and we find λ[subscript L]≈3.2T/N. The scaling with temperature is dictated by conformal invariance of the underlying quantum critical point. We also show that operators grow ballistically in space with a “butterfly velocity” given by v[subscript B]/c≈1 where c is the Lorentz-invariant speed of particle excitations in the system. We briefly comment on the behavior of λ[subscript L] and v_{B} in the neighboring symmetry broken and unbroken phases.

Physical Review Letters•Sep 1, 2017•14 citations

Scrambling and Lyapunov exponent in spatially extended systems

Anna Keselman, Laimei Nie, Erez Berg

Scrambling of information in a quantum many-body system, quantified by the out-of-time-ordered correlator (OTOC), is a key manifestation of quantum chaos. A regime of exponential growth in the OTOC, characterized by a Lyapunov exponent, has so far mostly been observed in systems with a high-dimensional local Hilbert space and in weakly-coupled systems. Here, we propose a general criterion for the existence of a well-defined regime of exponential growth of the OTOC in spatially extended systems with local interactions. In such systems, we show that a parametrically long period of exponential growth requires the butterfly velocity to be much larger than the Lyapunov exponent times a microscopic length scale, such as the lattice spacing. As an explicit example, we study a random unitary circuit with tunable interactions. In this model, we show that in the weakly interacting limit, the above criterion is satisfied, and there is a prolonged window of exponential growth. Our results are based on numerical simulations of both Clifford and universal random circuits supported by an analytical treatment.

arXiv:2009.10104•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 16, 2021•26 citations

A bound on chaos

JUAN M. MALDACENA, Stephen H. Shenker, Douglas Stanford

We conjecture a sharp bound on the rate of growth of chaos in thermal quantum systems with a large number of degrees of freedom. Chaos can be diagnosed using an out-of-time-order correlation function closely related to the commutator of operators separated in time. We conjecture that the influence of chaos on this correlator can develop no faster than exponentially, with Lyapunov exponent λ L ≤ 2πk B T/ℏ. We give a precise mathematical argument, based on plausible physical assumptions, establishing this conjecture.

arXiv:1503.01409•Journal of High Energy Physics•Aug 1, 2016•2,313 citations
Abstract A simple probe of chaos and operator growth in many-body quantum systems is the out of time ordered four point function. In a large class of local systems, the effects of chaos in this correlator build up exponentially fast inside the so called butterfly cone. It has been previously observed that the growth of these effects is organized along rays and can be characterized by a velocity dependent Lyapunov exponent, λ(v). We show that this exponent is bounded inside the butterfly cone as λ(v) ≤ 2πT (1 − | v |/v B ), where T is the temperature and v B is the butterfly speed. This result generalizes the chaos bound of Maldacena, Shenker and Stanford. We study λ(v) in some examples such as two dimensional SYK models and holographic gauge theories, and observe that in these systems the bound gets saturated at some critical velocity v * < v B . In this sense, boosting a system enhances chaos. We discuss the connection to conformal Regge theory, where λ(v) is related to the spin of the leading large N Regge trajectory, and controls the four point function in an interpolating regime between the Regge and the light cone limit. Finally, we comment on the generalization of the chaos bound to boosted and rotating ensembles and clarify some recent results on this in the literature.
It has been a long-standing challenge to expand the notion of exponential sensitivity to small perturbations in the initial conditions from the realm of classical chaos to that of many-body quantum systems. Recently, exponential growth in a measure known as the out-of-time-order commutator (OTOC) has been proposed as a diagnostic of chaos in the setting of many-body quantum systems. The authors examine the behavior of the OTOC along rays of different velocities for a variety of spatially local extended many-body quantum systems, both integrable and nonintegrable. They find that the velocity-dependent Lyapunov exponents are negative for velocities greater than a characteristic ``butterfly speed'', which defines the light cone for the spreading of operators. It is demonstrated that a regime with well-defined positive Lyapunov exponents inside the light-cone may only exist for classical, semiclassical, weakly interacting, or large-NNN systems, but not for fully quantum systems with strong short-range interactions and local Hilbert space dimensions of order one.
We find that the effects of a localized perturbation in a chaotic classical many-body system-the classical Heisenberg chain at infinite temperature-spread ballistically with a finite speed even when the local spin dynamics is diffusive. We study two complementary aspects of this butterfly effect: the rapid growth of the perturbation, and its simultaneous ballistic (light-cone) spread, as characterized by the Lyapunov exponents and the butterfly speed, respectively. We connect this to recent studies of the out-of-time-ordered commutators (OTOC), which have been proposed as an indicator of chaos in a quantum system. We provide a straightforward identification of the OTOC with a natural correlator in our system and demonstrate that many of its interesting qualitative features are present in the classical system. Finally, by analyzing the scaling forms, we relate the growth, spread, and propagation of the perturbation with the growth of one-dimensional interfaces described by the Kardar-Parisi-Zhang equation.
When the Lyapunov exponent λL in a quantum chaotic system saturates the bound λL ≤ 2πk B T , it is proposed that this system has a holographic dual described by a gravity theory. In particular, the butterfly effect as a prominent phenomenon of chaos can ubiquitously exist in a black hole system characterized by a shockwave solution near the horizon. In this paper we propose that the butterfly velocity can be used to diagnose quantum phase transition (QPT) in holographic theories. We provide evidences for this proposal with an anisotropic holographic model exhibiting metal-insulator transitions (MIT), in which the derivatives of the butterfly velocity with respect to system parameters characterizes quantum critical points (QCP) with local extremes in zero temperature limit. We also point out that this proposal can be tested by experiments in the light of recent progress on the measurement of out-of-time-order correlation function (OTOC).
The growth of commutators of initially commuting local operators diagnoses the onset of chaos in quantum many-body systems. We compute such commutators of local field operators with N components in the (2+1)-dimensional O(N) nonlinear sigma model to leading order in 1/N. The system is taken to be in thermal equilibrium at a temperature T above the zero temperature quantum critical point separating the symmetry broken and unbroken phases. The commutator grows exponentially in time with a rate denoted λ[subscript L]. At large N the growth of chaos as measured by λ[subscript L] is slow because the model is weakly interacting, and we find λ[subscript L]≈3.2T/N. The scaling with temperature is dictated by conformal invariance of the underlying quantum critical point. We also show that operators grow ballistically in space with a “butterfly velocity” given by v[subscript B]/c≈1 where c is the Lorentz-invariant speed of particle excitations in the system. We briefly comment on the behavior of λ[subscript L] and v_{B} in the neighboring symmetry broken and unbroken phases.
Scrambling of information in a quantum many-body system, quantified by the out-of-time-ordered correlator (OTOC), is a key manifestation of quantum chaos. A regime of exponential growth in the OTOC, characterized by a Lyapunov exponent, has so far mostly been observed in systems with a high-dimensional local Hilbert space and in weakly-coupled systems. Here, we propose a general criterion for the existence of a well-defined regime of exponential growth of the OTOC in spatially extended systems with local interactions. In such systems, we show that a parametrically long period of exponential growth requires the butterfly velocity to be much larger than the Lyapunov exponent times a microscopic length scale, such as the lattice spacing. As an explicit example, we study a random unitary circuit with tunable interactions. In this model, we show that in the weakly interacting limit, the above criterion is satisfied, and there is a prolonged window of exponential growth. Our results are based on numerical simulations of both Clifford and universal random circuits supported by an analytical treatment.
We conjecture a sharp bound on the rate of growth of chaos in thermal quantum systems with a large number of degrees of freedom. Chaos can be diagnosed using an out-of-time-order correlation function closely related to the commutator of operators separated in time. We conjecture that the influence of chaos on this correlator can develop no faster than exponentially, with Lyapunov exponent λ L ≤ 2πk B T/ℏ. We give a precise mathematical argument, based on plausible physical assumptions, establishing this conjecture.