We find that the effects of a localized perturbation in a chaotic classical many-body system-the classical Heisenberg chain at infinite temperature-spread ballistically with a finite speed even when the local spin dynamics is diffusive. We study two complementary aspects of this butterfly effect: the rapid growth of the perturbation, and its simultaneous ballistic (light-cone) spread, as characterized by the Lyapunov exponents and the butterfly speed, respectively. We connect this to recent studies of the out-of-time-ordered commutators (OTOC), which have been proposed as an indicator of chaos in a quantum system. We provide a straightforward identification of the OTOC with a natural correlator in our system and demonstrate that many of its interesting qualitative features are present in the classical system. Finally, by analyzing the scaling forms, we relate the growth, spread, and propagation of the perturbation with the growth of one-dimensional interfaces described by the Kardar-Parisi-Zhang equation.
We study correlations, transport, and chaos in a Heisenberg magnet as a classical model many-body system. By varying temperature and dimensionality, we can tune between settings with and without symmetry breaking and accompanying collective modes or quasiparticles (spin waves) which in the limit of low temperatures become increasingly long-lived. Changing the sign of the exchange interaction from a ferro- to an antiferromagnetic one varies the spin-wave spectrum, and hence the low-energy spectral density. We analyze both conventional and out-of-time-ordered spin correlators (decorrelators) to track the spreading of a spatiotemporally localized perturbation---the wing beat of the butterfly---as well as transport coefficients and Lyapunov exponents. We identify a number of qualitatively different regimes. Trivially, at
T=0, there is no dynamics at all. In the limit of low temperature,
T=0+, integrability emerges, with infinitely long-lived magnons; here the wave packet created by the perturbation propagates ballistically, yielding a light cone at the spin-wave velocity which thus subsumes the butterfly velocity; inside the light cone, a pattern characteristic of the free spin-wave spectrum is visible at short times. On top of this, residual interactions (nonlinearities in the equations of motion) lead to spin-wave lifetimes which, while divergent in this limit, remain finite at any nonzero
T. At the longest times, this leads to a standard chaotic regime; for this regime, we show that the Lyapunov exponent is simply proportional to the (inverse) spin-wave lifetime. Visibly strikingly, between this and the short-time integrable regimes, a scarred regime emerges: Here, the decorrelator is spatiotemporally highly nonuniform, being dominated by rare and random scattering events seeding secondary light cones. As the spin correlation length decreases with increasing
T, the distinction between these regimes disappears and at high temperature the previously studied chaotic paramagnetic regime emerges. For this, we elucidate how, somewhat counterintuitively, the ballistic butterfly velocity arises from a diffusive spin dynamics.
It has been a long-standing challenge to expand the notion of exponential sensitivity to small perturbations in the initial conditions from the realm of classical chaos to that of many-body quantum systems. Recently, exponential growth in a measure known as the out-of-time-order commutator (OTOC) has been proposed as a diagnostic of chaos in the setting of many-body quantum systems. The authors examine the behavior of the OTOC along rays of different velocities for a variety of spatially local extended many-body quantum systems, both integrable and nonintegrable. They find that the velocity-dependent Lyapunov exponents are negative for velocities greater than a characteristic ``butterfly speed'', which defines the light cone for the spreading of operators. It is demonstrated that a regime with well-defined positive Lyapunov exponents inside the light-cone may only exist for classical, semiclassical, weakly interacting, or large-
N systems, but not for fully quantum systems with strong short-range interactions and local Hilbert space dimensions of order one.
Abstract A simple probe of chaos and operator growth in many-body quantum systems is the out of time ordered four point function. In a large class of local systems, the effects of chaos in this correlator build up exponentially fast inside the so called butterfly cone. It has been previously observed that the growth of these effects is organized along rays and can be characterized by a velocity dependent Lyapunov exponent, λ(v). We show that this exponent is bounded inside the butterfly cone as λ(v) ≤ 2πT (1 − | v |/v B ), where T is the temperature and v B is the butterfly speed. This result generalizes the chaos bound of Maldacena, Shenker and Stanford. We study λ(v) in some examples such as two dimensional SYK models and holographic gauge theories, and observe that in these systems the bound gets saturated at some critical velocity v * < v B . In this sense, boosting a system enhances chaos. We discuss the connection to conformal Regge theory, where λ(v) is related to the spin of the leading large N Regge trajectory, and controls the four point function in an interpolating regime between the Regge and the light cone limit. Finally, we comment on the generalization of the chaos bound to boosted and rotating ensembles and clarify some recent results on this in the literature.
We study the chaotic dynamics in a classical many-body system of interacting spins on the kagome lattice. We characterize many-body chaos via the butterfly effect as captured by an appropriate out-of-time-ordered commutator. Due to the emergence of a spin-liquid phase, the chaotic dynamics extends all the way to zero temperature. We thus determine the full temperature dependence of two complementary aspects of the butterfly effect: the Lyapunov exponent, $\ensuremath{\mu}$, and the butterfly speed,
vb, and study their interrelations with usual measures of spin dynamics such as the spin-diffusion constant,
D, and spin-autocorrelation time, $\ensuremath{\tau}$. We find that they all exhibit power-law behavior at low temperature, consistent with scaling of the form $D\ensuremath{\sim}{v}_{b}^{2}/\ensuremath{\mu}$ and ${\ensuremath{\tau}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}\ensuremath{\sim}T$. The vanishing of $\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\sim}{T}^{0.48}$ is parametrically slower than that of the corresponding quantum bound, $\ensuremath{\mu}\ensuremath{\sim}T$, raising interesting questions regarding the semiclassical limit of such spin systems.
A closed quantum system never forgets its initial state, but the encoded information can get scrambled and become inaccessible without measuring a large fraction of all the system degrees of freedom. This scrambling can be diagnosed by studying the spatial spreading of initially local operators under the Heisenberg time evolution, and the decay of the out-of-time-ordered correlators (OTOC). What insights can OTOCs provide to understand the dynamics of quantum many-body systems? What are the characteristic behaviors of OTOCs during the time evolution? How is information scrambling affected by the dissipation in open quantum many-body systems? We first study slow scrambling in many-body localized systems via calculating various correlators, two-point retarded correlators and OTOCs. Comparing with retarded correlators, OTOCs provide more information about the dynamics. We find that disorder slows and partially halts the onset of information scrambling. Instead of ballistic spreading, propagation of information forms a logarithmic light cone. Next, we study the finite-size scaling of OTOCs at late times in generic thermalizing quantum many-body systems. When energy is conserved, the late-time saturation value of the OTOC of generic traceless local operators scales as an inverse polynomial in the system size. This is in contrast to the inverse exponential scaling expected for chaotic dynamics without energy conservation. We also study information scrambling in open quantum many-body systems. We define a dissipative version of OTOC and study its behaviors in a prototypical chaotic quantum chain with dissipation. We find that dissipation leads to not only the overall decay of the scrambled information due to leaking, but also structural changes so that the information light cone can only reach a finite distance even when the effect of overall decay is removed. Finally, we construct a family of local Hamiltonians for understanding the asymmetric information scrambling. Our models live on a one-dimensional lattice and exhibit asymmetric butterfly light cone between the left and right spatial directions.
Out-of-Time-Ordered Commutators (OTOCs), representing a key diagnostic for scrambling as a facet of short-time quantum chaos, have attracted wide-ranging interest, from many-body physics to quantum gravity. By means of a suitable form of the Wigner-Moyal expansion, and invoking ensemble equivalence in statistical physics, we provide a consistent approach to the growth rate of the OTOC for many-body systems with chaotic classical limit where both the classical Lyapunov exponent and the quantum nature of the density of states enter. Applying this construction to quantized high-dimensional hyperbolic motion, i.e., a quantum chaotic system that exhibits gravity-like correlation functions in the late-time regime, we compute the OTOC growth rate Λ as a function of the number of degrees of freedom, f, and inverse temperature, β. We show that the scaled growth rate, Λ/f, can be described by a universal function of fβ and displays a cross-over from classical to quantum behavior as we increase f and/or lower the temperature. In the deep quantum regime of infinite f, we find maximally fast scrambling in the sense of the Maldacena-Shenker-Stanford bound on chaos. This elucidates the non-perturbative mechanism underlying the saturation of the bound via quantum contributions to the mean density of states, and it provides further support for this dynamical system as a dual to two-dimensional quantum gravity. In this way, we present first evidence of maximally fast scrambling in a quantum chaotic system with a well-defined classical Hamiltonian limit, without invoking any external mechanism such as (disorder) averaging.