Abstract Thermalization of isolated quantum systems has been studied intensively in recent years and significant progresses have been achieved. Here, we study thermalization of small quantum systems that interact with large chaotic environments under the consideration of Schrödinger evolution of composite systems, from the perspective of the zeroth law of thermodynamics. Namely, we consider a small quantum system that is brought into contact with a large environmental system; after they have relaxed, they are separated and their temperatures are studied. Our question is under what conditions the small system may have a detectable temperature that is identical with the environmental temperature. This should be a necessary condition for the small quantum system to be thermalized and to have a well-defined temperature. By using a two-level probe quantum system that plays the role of a thermometer, we find that the zeroth law is applicable to quantum chaotic systems, but not to integrable systems.
Abstract Thermalization of isolated quantum systems has been studied intensively in recent years and significant progresses have been achieved. Here, we study thermalization of small quantum systems that interact with large chaotic environments under the consideration of Schrödinger evolution of composite systems, from the perspective of the zeroth law of thermodynamics. Namely, we consider a small quantum system that is brought into contact with a large environmental system; after they have relaxed, they are separated and their temperatures are studied. Our question is under what conditions the small system may have a detectable temperature that is identical with the environmental temperature. This should be a necessary condition for the small quantum system to be thermalized and to have a well-defined temperature. By using a two-level probe quantum system that plays the role of a thermometer, we find that the zeroth law is applicable to quantum chaotic systems, but not to integrable systems.
We study two small quantum systems coupled to the same reservoir which is in thermal equilibrium. By studying the particle density and the energy density in the two systems before and after they contact each other, we find that the two systems are not in thermal equilibrium with each other. Our result shows that the zeroth law of thermodynamics is broken in small quantum systems at low temperatures. Therefore, the traditional way of defining temperature fails due to the breakdown of the transitive relation of thermal equilibrium. Then we show a different way of defining temperature by attaching an auxiliary site, which plays the role of a thermometer, to the small quantum system.
The rather new field of quantum thermodynamics intends to derive thermodynamics from quantum mechanics, as well as to study thermodynamical behavior of quantum systems. It turns out that, indeed, thermalization can be obtained even for very small quantum systems due to the interaction with an appropriate environment. The consideration of an ensemble, as in statistical mechanics, is not necessary. However, the total system - consisting of system and environment - in quantum thermodynamics is usually considered to be closed. In particular, there exists no interaction with an external observer. Since quantum measurements typically influence the measured system, one may wonder which influence such an observation will have in the quantum thermodynamical setting. In this thesis, we study this influence of measurements in quantum thermodynamical systems. It turns out that various concepts known from statistical mechanics arise from such a "quantum thermodynamics under observation", although they do not have any meaning in the isolated quantum thermodynamical setting. The model discussed in the first part consists of a two-level system coupled to a large spin environment, the magnetization of which is measured periodically. This leads to quasi-classical trajectories for the system and - as in statistical mechanics - thermalization and temperature only have a meaning in terms of an ensemble average or a long-time average. Calculating these averages, we prove the ergodicity of the system. Interestingly, the entropy of the obtained attractor state depends on the time between the measurements and can be shown to be connected with the subjective lack of knowledge of the observer. In case of optimal measurements, the ensemble averaged state of the system under periodic measurements equals the state of the system in the quantum thermodynamical model without measurements. Introducing a detuning between system and environment, we find that the system can be prepared in almost arbitrary thermal states due to the periodic measurements. Even the creation of inversion becomes possible. As shown in numerical simulations, our results, which were analytically obtained for large environments, are even applicable to describe the behavior of the system coupled to small environments consisting of only a few spins. Besides measurements of the environment, we also study direct projective measurements of the system, as well as measurements with finite duration, obtaining that the dynamics of the system is almost independent of the concrete realization of the measurements. In the second part of the thesis, we discuss the meaning of temperature fluctuations in quantum thermodynamical systems. In statistical mechanics, there exist different approaches to the problem of temperature fluctuations, which lead to the well-known temperature fluctuation formula. The nature and operational accessibility of these fluctuations, however, remains rather unclear. We argue that according to quantum thermodynamics a system relaxes into a quasi-stationary thermal state and therefore the temperature does not fluctuate. However, since temperature is not an observable, it can only be determined indirectly. For modular systems, we show that the fluctuations of the temperature estimate obtained from a single energy measurement, indeed, are given by the temperature fluctuation formula derived in statistical mechanics, but only within a certain temperature range. The validity range of this formula increases with increasing size of the system. Thus, one can conclude that these "temperature fluctuations" can be interpreted as representing a fundamental limit for the instantaneous determination of temperature.
The zeroth law of thermodynamics involves a transitivity relation (pairwise between three objects) expressed either in terms of ``equal temperature'' (ET), or ``in equilibrium'' (EQ) conditions. In conventional thermodynamics conditional on vanishingly weak system-bath coupling these two conditions are commonly regarded as equivalent. In this work we show that for thermodynamics at strong coupling they are inequivalent: namely, two systems can be in equilibrium and yet have different effective temperatures. A recent result [J.-T. Hsiang and B. L. Hu, Phys. Rev. D 103, 065001 (2021) for Gaussian quantum systems shows that an effective temperature T∗ can be defined at all times during a system's nonequilibrium evolution, but because of the inclusion of interaction energy, after equilibration the system's T∗ is slightly higher than the bath temperature TB, with the deviation depending on the coupling. A second object coupled with a different strength with an identical bath at temperature TB will not have the same equilibrated temperature as the first object. Thus $ET\ensuremath{\ne}EQ$ for strong coupling thermodynamics. We then investigate the conditions for dynamical equilibration for two objects 1 and 2 strongly coupled with a common bath B, each with a different equilibrated effective temperature. We show this is possible, and prove the existence of a generalized fluctuation-dissipation relation under this configuration. This affirms that in equilibrium is a valid and perhaps more fundamental notion which the zeroth law for quantum thermodynamics at strong coupling should be based on. Only when the system-bath coupling becomes vanishingly weak that ``temperature'' appearing in thermodynamic relations becomes universally defined and makes better physical sense.
A system put in contact with a large heat bath normally thermalizes. This means that the state of the system ρℐ(t) approaches an equilibrium state ρ eq ℐ , the latter depending only on macroscopic characteristics of the bath (e.g. temperature), but not on the initial state of the system. The above statement is the cornerstone of the equilibrium statistical mechanics; its validity and its domain of applicability are central questions in the studies of the foundations of statistical mechanics. In the present contribution we discuss the recently proven general theorems about thermalization and demonstrate how they work in exactly solvable models. In particular, we review a necessary condition for the system initial state independence (ISI) of ρ eq ℐ , which was proven in our previous work, and apply it for two exactly solvable models, the XX spin chain and a central spin model with a special interaction with the environment. In the latter case we are able to prove the absence of the system ISI. Also the Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis is discussed. It is pointed out that although it is supposed to be generically true in essentially not-integrable (chaotic) quantum systems, it is how-ever also valid in the integrable XX model.
Two identical finite quantum systems prepared initially at different temperatures, isolated from the environment, and subsequently brought into contact are demonstrated to relax towards Gibbs-like quasiequilibrium states with a common temperature and small fluctuations around the time-averaged expectation values of generic observables. The temporal thermalization process proceeds via a chain of intermediate Gibbs-like states. We specify the conditions under which this scenario occurs and corroborate the quantum equilibration with two different models.
Quantum thermalization describes how closed quantum systems can effectively reach thermal equilibrium, resolving the apparent incongruity between the reversibility of Schrödinger's equation and the second law of thermodynamics. Despite its ubiquity and conceptual significance, the precise conditions that give rise to quantum thermalization are still not well understood. After nearly a century of efforts, we have yet to find a complete mathematical proof that an effective statistical description naturally emerges the underlying quantum dynamics in generic settings. Here, we prove that quantum thermalization must occur in any qubit system with local interactions under three conditions: (i) high effective temperature, (ii) translation invariance, and (iii) no perfect resonances in the energy spectrum. Specifically, we show that a typical, low-complexity pure state drawn from any ensemble with large entropy and well-defined effective temperature becomes locally indistinguishable from a Gibbs state upon unitary evolution. In this setting, our rigorous results prove the widely anticipated notion that statistical physics should be understood as an emergent phenomenon, explicitly derived from the first principles of quantum mechanics.