Quantum annealing is a promising heuristic method to solve combinatorial optimization problems, and efforts to quantify performance on real-world problems provide insights into how this approach may be best used in practice. We investigate the empirical performance of quantum annealing to solve the Nurse Scheduling Problem (NSP) with hard constraints using the D-Wave 2000Q quantum annealing device. NSP seeks the optimal assignment for a set of nurses to shifts under an accompanying set of constraints on schedule and personnel. After reducing NSP to a novel Ising-type Hamiltonian, we evaluate the solution quality obtained from the D-Wave 2000Q against the constraint requirements as well as the diversity of solutions. For the test problems explored here, our results indicate that quantum annealing recovers satisfying solutions for NSP and suggests the heuristic method is potentially achievable for practical use. Moreover, we observe that solution quality can be greatly improved through the use of reverse annealing, in which it is possible to refine returned results by using the annealing process a second time. We compare the performance of NSP using both forward and reverse annealing methods and describe how this approach might be used in practice.
Quantum annealing is a promising heuristic method to solve combinatorial optimization problems, and efforts to quantify performance on real-world problems provide insights into how this approach may be best used in practice. We investigate the empirical performance of quantum annealing to solve the Nurse Scheduling Problem (NSP) with hard constraints using the D-Wave 2000Q quantum annealing device. NSP seeks the optimal assignment for a set of nurses to shifts under an accompanying set of constraints on schedule and personnel. After reducing NSP to a novel Ising-type Hamiltonian, we evaluate the solution quality obtained from the D-Wave 2000Q against the constraint requirements as well as the diversity of solutions. For the test problems explored here, our results indicate that quantum annealing recovers satisfying solutions for NSP and suggests the heuristic method is potentially achievable for practical use. Moreover, we observe that solution quality can be greatly improved through the use of reverse annealing, in which it is possible to refine returned results by using the annealing process a second time. We compare the performance of NSP using both forward and reverse annealing methods and describe how this approach might be used in practice.
Quantum annealing (QA) is a metaheuristic methodologythat has recently been used to analyze the performance of first generation adiabatic quantum processors, like the oneavailable from D-wave Systems, in solving combinatorial optimization problems. In this paper, we formulate QA representation of problems essential to mitigating the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic, namely, the Nurse Scheduling Problem (NSP), the Physician Scheduling Problem (PSP), and the Nurse-Physician Scheduling Problem (NPSP). The proposed objective functions for each problem are scripted to the Ising model and then transformed into thequadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO)format. An optimal solutionis soughtfor a set of constraints, including thenumber ofnurses or physicians per shift andthe maximum number of shifts for each nurse or physician.After reducingtheproposed NSP, PSP, and NPSP QUBOs to a novel Ising type Hamiltonian, we obtain solutions from a classical (simulated) annealer,and then from the D-wave 2000Q forward and reverse annealer. Results from the reverse quantum annealer show a dramatic improvement in solution quality as compared to those from the classical annealer. We observe that the reverse annealing method gives us the most satisfactory output from among three heuristic processes used, for each scheduling problem.
Quantum annealing (QA) has shown good solutions quickly in benchmarks of combinatorial optimization problems. There are not many real-world problems that illustrate the effectiveness of QA compared to the typical optimization methods. We applied QA to a shift scheduling problem for call centers with four conditions. The shift scheduling problem for call centers optimizes shifts for a specific period of time while satisfying various constraints, such as satisfying the desired worker's shifts. In this paper, we formulated the shift scheduling problem for call centers in QUBO to apply QA. We tuned various parameters required to execute the QA. Then, we compared QA with six typical optimization methods using a classical computer to investigate QA's effectiveness for the shift scheduling problem for call centers. The results show that for three instances with up to 126 variables, QA is about 3-14 times faster than other methods and obtains enough quality of solutions. This shows that QA can be one of the effective methods to solve practical applications in the real-world.
Quantum annealing is a promising heuristic for combinatorial optimization, but on current hardware its performance degrades for larger and more complex problems due to noise and small energy gaps. Reverse annealing has been proposed as a refinement strategy, yet it remains unclear when it provides systematic advantages over standard forward annealing or simply increasing annealing time. We find that combining forward and reverse annealing consistently improves solution quality and efficiency across multiple problem classes. The benefits of reverse annealing increase with problem complexity and are strongest in regimes where forward annealing is increasingly limited. Moreover, reverse annealing yields larger efficiency gains than simply extending forward annealing times. We establish these results through a systematic experimental study on a D-Wave Advantage system, benchmarking reverse annealing across Max-Cut, Number Partitioning, and sparse clustering problems while varying reverse distance, pause duration, and annealing time. We identify a narrow optimal regime for reverse annealing parameters linked to the location of freeze-out points and energy-level crossings in the annealing schedule. These findings demonstrate that reverse annealing is most valuable for large, high-complexity optimization problems and is likely to gain importance as quantum annealing hardware scales toward more realistic applications.
Job Shop Scheduling is a combinatorial optimization problem of particular importance for production environments where the goal is to complete a production task in the shortest possible time given limitations in the resources available. Due to its computational complexity it quickly becomes intractable for problems of interesting size. The emerging technology of Quantum Annealing provides an alternative computational architecture that promises improved scalability and solution quality. However, several limitations as well as open research questions exist in this relatively new and rapidly developing technology. This paper studies the application of quantum annealing to solve the job shop scheduling problem, describing each step required from the problem formulation to the fine-tuning of the quantum annealer and compares the solution quality with various classical solvers. Particular attention is devoted to aspects that are often overlooked, such as the computational cost of representing the problem in the formulation required by the quantum annealer, the relative qubits requirements and how to mitigate chain breaks. Furthermore, the impact of advanced tools such as reverse annealing is presented and its effectiveness discussed. The results indicate several challenges emerging at various stages of the experimental pipeline which bring forward important research questions and directions of improvement.
A promising use of quantum computers lies in the logistics and scheduling of industrial problems, such as space mission planning, maritime management, and many others. This field is expected to provide useful applications for quantum computing at the current stage of hardware development. Quantum annealing techniques have been proposed to solve scheduling problems, along with many other optimization problems. In this work, we test quantum annealing and hybrid techniques based on the D-Wave hardware to solve scheduling problems in the framework of job shop scheduling (JSP), which consists of optimally assigning operations to certain resources, while satisfying specific constraints and minimizing the total scheduling time, known as timespan. We devised an iterative algorithm that produces valid schedules for decreasing timespan values. We implemented a refined iterative variable pruning technique, which significantly reduces the number of spin variables in the corresponding Ising model, whose low-energy configurations are sampled by using the D-Wave Hybrid Solver Service. Our novel iterative algorithm leverages a directed acyclic graph (DAG) representation of partial or complete solutions of the JSP instance, which enables an efficient update of the feasible processing time windows for each operation. This approach leads to significantly improved results compared to the standard state-of-the-art applications of quantum annealing for the JSP. Remarkably, we can often prove the absolute optimality of the obtained solution, namely that a more efficient schedule within a shorter timespan can not exist.
Quantum annealing (QA) has the potential to significantly improve solution quality and reduce time complexity in solving combinatorial optimization problems compared to classical optimization methods. However, due to the limited number of qubits and their connectivity, the QA hardware did not show such an advantage over classical methods in past benchmarking studies. Recent advancements in QA with more than 5000 qubits, enhanced qubit connectivity, and the hybrid architecture promise to realize the quantum advantage. Here, we use a quantum annealer with state-of-the-art techniques and benchmark its performance against classical solvers. To compare their performance, we solve over 50 optimization problem instances represented by large and dense Hamiltonian matrices using quantum and classical solvers. The results demonstrate that a state-of-the-art quantum solver has higher accuracy (~0.013%) and a significantly faster problem-solving time (~6561×) than the best classical solver. Our results highlight the advantages of leveraging QA over classical counterparts, particularly in hybrid configurations, for achieving high accuracy and substantially reduced problem solving time in large-scale real-world optimization problems.