We show that the nature of quantum phases around the superconductor-insulator transition (SIT) is controlled by charge-vortex topological interactions and does not depend on the details of material parameters and disorder. We find three distinct phases, superconductor, superinsulator and bosonic topological insulator. The superinsulator is a state of matter with infinite resistance in a finite temperature range, which is the S-dual of the superconductor and in which charge transport is prevented by electric strings binding charges of opposite sign. The electric strings ensuring linear confinement of charges are generated by instantons and are dual to superconducting Abrikosov vortices. Material parameters and disorder enter the London penetration depth of the superconductor, the string tension of the superinsulator and the quantum fluctuation parameter driving the transition between them. They are entirely encoded in four phenomenological parameters of a topological gauge theory of the SIT. Finally, we point out that, in the context of strong coupling gauge theories, the many-body localization phenomenon that is often referred to as an underlying mechanism for superinsulation is a mere transcription of the well-known phenomenon of confinement into solid state physics language and is entirely driven by endogenous disorder embodied by instantons with no need of exogenous disorder.
In the previous chapter, we discussed both the insulator–superconductor and the insulator–metal transitions. As such transitions are disorder or magnetic-field tuned, thermal fluctuations play no role. Phase transitions of the insulator–superconductor or insulator–metal type are called quantum phase transitions. Such phase transitions are not controlled by changing the temperature, as in the melting of ice or the λ-point of liquid helium, but rather by changing some system parameter, such as the number of defects or the concentration of charge carriers. In all such instances, the tuning parameter transforms the system between quantum mechanical states that either look different topologically (as in the transition between localized and extended electronic states) or have distinctly different magnetic properties. As quantum mechanics underlies such phase transitions, all quantum phase transitions obtain at the absolute zero of temperature and thus are governed by a T = 0 quantum critical point. While initially surprising, this state of affairs is expected, because quantum mechanics is explicitly a zero-temperature theory of matter. Of course, this is of no surprise to chemists who have known for quite some time that numerous materials can exhibit vastly distinct properties simply by changing the chemical composition and, most importantly, that such transformations persist down to zero temperature. Common examples include turning insulators such as the layered cuprates into superconductors simply by chemical doping or semiconductors into metals once again by doping, or ferromagnets such as Li(Ho, Tb) x Y 1- x F 4 into a spin glass (AR1998) by altering x .
The three-dimensional integer-valued lattice gauge theory, which is also known as a ``frozen superconductor,'' can be obtained as a certain limit of the Ginzburg-Landau theory of superconductivity, and is believed to be in the same universality class. It is also exactly dual to the three-dimensional XY model. We use this duality to demonstrate the practicality of recently developed methods for studying topological defects, and investigate the critical behavior of the phase transition using numerical Monte Carlo simulations of both theories. On the gauge theory side, we concentrate on the vortex tension and the penetration depth, which map onto the correlation lengths of the order parameter and the Noether current in the XY model, respectively. We show how these quantities behave near the critical point, and that the penetration depth exhibits critical scaling only very close to the transition point. This may explain the failure of superconductor experiments to see the inverted XY model scaling.
We develop an analytical theory for generic disorder-driven quantum phase transitions. We apply this formalism to the superconductor-insulator transition and we briefly discuss the applications to the order-disorder transition in quantum magnets. The effective spin-
21 models for these transitions are solved in the cavity approximation which becomes exact on a Bethe lattice with large branching number
K⪢1 and weak dimensionless coupling
g⪡1. The characteristic feature of the low-temperature phase is a large self-formed inhomogeneity of the order-parameter distribution near the critical point $K\ensuremath{\ge}{K}_{c}(g)$, where the critical temperature
Tc of the ordering transition vanishes. We find that the local probability distribution
P(B) of the order parameter
B has a long power-law tail in the region where
B is much larger than its typical value
B0. Near the quantum-critical point, at $K\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{K}_{c}(g)$, the typical value of the order parameter vanishes exponentially, ${B}_{0}\ensuremath{\propto}{e}^{\ensuremath{-}C/[K\ensuremath{-}{K}_{c}(g)]}$ while the spatial scale
Ninh of the order parameter inhomogeneities diverges as ${[K\ensuremath{-}{K}_{c}(g)]}^{\ensuremath{-}2}$. In the disordered regime, realized at
K<Kc(g) we find actually two distinct phases characterized by different behavior of relaxation rates. The first phase exists in an intermediate range of ${K}^{\ensuremath{\ast}}(g)<K<{K}_{c}(g)$. It has two regimes of energies: at low excitation energies, $\ensuremath{\omega}<{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{d}(K,g)$, the many-body spectrum of the model is discrete, with zero-level widths, while at $\ensuremath{\omega}>{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{d}$ the level acquire a nonzero width which is self-generated by the many-body interactions. In this phase the spin model provides by itself an intrinsic thermal bath. Another phase is obtained at smaller $K<{K}^{\ensuremath{\ast}}(g)$, where all the eigenstates are discrete, corresponding to full many-body localization. These results provide an explanation for the activated behavior of the resistivity in amorphous materials on the insulating side near the superconductor-insulator transition and a semiquantitative description of the scanning tunneling data on its superconductive side.
We study the nature of the zero-temperature phase transition between a d-wave superconductor and a Mott insulator in two dimensions. In this ``quantum confinement transition,'' spin and charge are confined to form the electron in the Mott insulator. Within a dual formulation, direct transitions from d-wave superconductors at half-filling to insulators with spin-Peierls (as well as other) order emerge naturally. The possibility of striped superconductors is also discussed within the dual formulation. The transition is described by nodal fermions and bosonic vortices, interacting via a long-ranged statistical interaction modeled by two coupled Chern-Simons gauge fields, and the critical properties of this model are discussed.
The interplay of interactions and disorder in low-dimensional superconductors supports the formation of multiple quantum phases as possible instabilities of the superconductor-insulator transition (SIT) at a singular quantum critical point. We explore a one-dimensional model which exhibits such a variety of phases in the strongly quantum fluctuations regime. Specifically, we study the effect of weak disorder on a two-leg Josephson ladder with comparable Josephson and charging energies $({E}_{J}\ensuremath{\sim}{E}_{C})$. An additional key feature of our model is the requirement of perfect
Z2 symmetry, respected by all parameters including the disorder. Using a perturbative renormalization-group (RG) analysis, we derive the phase diagram and identify at least one intermediate phase between a full-fledged superconductor and a disorder-dominated insulator. Most prominently, for repulsive interactions on the rungs we identify two distinct mixed phases: In both of them the longitudinal charge mode is a gapless superconductor, however one phase exhibits a dipolar charge density order on the rungs, while the other is disordered. This latter phase is characterized by coexisting superconducting (phase-locked) and charge-ordered rungs, and encompasses the potential of evolving into a Griffith's phase characteristic of the random-field Ising model in the strong disorder limit.