Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1809.07771 · Physical Review Letters

Continuous Topological Phase Transition between Two 1D Antiferromagnetic Spin-1 Boson Superfluids with the Same Symmetry

Wenjie Ji, Xiao-Gang Wen

Published Jul 19, 2019• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Spin-1 bosons on a one-dimensional chain, at incommensurate filling with an antiferromagnetic spin interaction between neighboring bosons, may form a spin-1 boson condensed state that contains both a gapless charge and spin excitations. We argue that the spin-1 boson condensed state is unstable, and will become one of two superfluids by opening a spin gap. One superfluid must have a spin-1 ground state on a ring if it contains an odd number of bosons and has no degenerate states at the chain end. The other superfluid has a spin-0 ground state on a ring for any number of bosons and has a spin-1/2 degeneracy at the chain end. The two superfluids have the same symmetry and only differ by a spin-SO(3) symmetry protected topological order. Although Landau theory forbids a continuous phase transition between two phases with the same symmetry, the phase transition between the two superfluids can be generically continuous, which is described by conformal field theory (CFT) su(2)_{2}⊕u(1)_{4}⊕su(2)[over ¯]_{2}⊕u(1)[over ¯]_{4}. Such a CFT has a spin fractionalization: spin-1 excitation can decay into a spin-1/2 right mover and a spin-1/2 left mover. We determine the critical theory by solving the partition function based on emergent symmetries and modular invariance condition of CFTs.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.123.035301

Related papers

Aspects of critical spin 1 chains and 2 dimensional symmetry protected topological phases of matter

Olabode Mayodele Sule

Effective field theory is a very useful technique for understanding quantum many body systems. We use this approach to study a certain class of critical quantum spin-1 chains and symmetry protected topological phases of matter in two spatial dimensions. In the first context we consider the SU(3) symmetric spin-1 chain with additional interactions. We use bosonization to demonstrate that the effective field theories describing the critical behaviour of these spin chains can be mapped to free compact boson conformal field theories (CFTs) with central charge c=2. We also describe how some predictions from field theory can be verified in numerical calculations using exact diagonalization (ED) and the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) algorithm. In particular, the bosonization method gives a formula for the evolution of four Tomonaga-Luttinger liquid (TLL) parameters as a function of the lattice parameters. Using the analytic formulae for the scaling dimensions in terms of the TLL parameters and matching of lowest scaling dimensions, we numerically calculate these field-theoretic parameters and confirm that their evolution agrees with the prediction using bosonization. We also tackle aspects of the challenging problem of understanding interacting topological phases. In this context, we aim to understand the effects if interactions in certain classes of symmetry protected topological (SPT) phases of matter. We consider non-chiral SPT phases in two spatial dimensions protected by a discrete symmetry such as Z_K or Z_K x Z_K symmetry. We argue that modular invariance/noninvariance of the partition function of the one-dimensional edge theory can be used to diagnose whether, by adding a suitable potential, the edge theory can be gapped or not without breaking the symmetry. By taking bosonic phases described by Chern-Simons K-matrix theories and fermionic phases relevant to topological superconductors as examples, we demonstrate explicitly that when modular invariance is achieved, we can construct an interaction potential that is consistent with the symmetry and can completely gap out the edge. We also briefly discuss preliminary results of a numerical approach for simulating the 3 dimensional Landau Level problem. This includes a brief description of a potential application of variational Monte Carlo to spin-orbit coupled ab initio systems.

•Feb 3, 2016•0 citations

Topological Phase Transitions

Tsui, Lokman

The study of continuous phase transitions triggered by spontaneous symmetry breaking has brought revolutionary ideas to physics. Recently, through the discovery of symmetry protected topological phases, it is realized that continuous quantum phase transition can also occur between states with the same symmetry but different topology. The subject of this dissertation is the phase transition between these symmetry protected topological states (SPTs). There are two main parts in this dissertation.In the first part we consider spatial dimension $d$ and symmetry group $G$ so that the cohomology group, $H^{d+1}(G,U(1))$, contains at least one $Z_{2n}$ or $Z$ factor. We show that the phase transition between the trivial SPT and the root states that generate the $ Z_{2n} $ or $Z$ groups can be induced on the boundary of a d+1 dimensional $G\\times Z_2^T$-symmetric SPT by a $Z_2^T$ symmetry breaking field. Moreover we show these boundary phase transitions can be ``transplanted'' to d dimensions and realized in lattice models as a function of a tuning parameter. The price one pays is for the critical value of the tuning parameter there is an extra non-local (duality-like) symmetry. In the case where the phase transition is continuous, our theory predicts the presence of unusual (sometimes fractionalized) excitations corresponding to delocalized boundary excitations of the non-trivial SPT on one side of the transition. This theory also predicts other phase transition scenarios including first order transition and transition via an intermediate symmetry breaking phase. In the second part, we study the phase transition between bosonic topological phases protected by $Z_n\\times Z_n$ in 1+1 dimensions. We find a direct transition occurs when $ n=2,3,4 $ and in all cases the critical point possesses two gap opening relevant operators: one leads to a Landau-forbidden symmetry breaking phase transition and the other to the topological phase transition. We also obtained a constraint($ c\\geq1 $) on the central charge for general phase transitions between symmetry protected bosonic topological phases in 1+1D.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Mar 1, 1998•1 citation

Symmetry protected bosonic topological phase transitions: Quantum Anomalous Hall system of weakly interacting spinor bosons in a square lattice

Fadi Sun, Wang, Junsen, Jinwu Ye +2 more

We study possible many body phenomena in the Quantum Anomalous Hall system of weakly interacting spinor bosons in a square lattice. There are various novel spin-bond correlated superfluids (SF) and quantum or topological phase transitions among these SF phases. One transition is a first order one driven by roton droppings ( but with non-zero gaps $ Δ_R $ ) tuned by the Zeeman field $ h $. Another is a second order bosonic Lifshitz transition with the dynamic exponents $ z_x=z_y=2 $ and an accompanying $ [C_4 \times C_4]_D $ symmetry breaking. It is driven by the softening of the superfluid Goldstone mode tuned by the ratio of spin-orbit coupled (SOC) strength over the hopping strength. The two phase boundaries meet at a topological tri-critical (TT) point which separates the $ h=0 $ line into two SF phases with $ N=2 $ and $ N=4 $ condensation momenta respectively. At the $ h=0 $ line where the system has an anti-unitary $ Z_2 $ Reflection symmetry, there are infinite number of classically degenerate family of states on both sides. We perform a systematic order from quantum disorder analysis to find the quantum ground states, also calculate the roton gaps $ Δ_R $ generated by the order from disorder mechanism on both sides of the TT point. The $ N=2 $ and $ N=4 $ SF phases have the same spin-orbital XY-AFM spin structure, respect the anti-unitary symmetry and break the $ [C_4 \times C_4]_D $ symmetry, so they be distinguished only by the different topology of the BEC condensation momenta instead of by any differences in the symmetry breaking patterns. All these novel quantum or topological phenomena can be probed in the recent experimentally realized weakly interacting Quantum Anomalous Hall (QAH) model of $ ^87 Rb $ by Wu, {\sl et.al}, Science 354, 83-88 (2016).

arXiv:1711.11580•Nov 30, 2017•0 citations

The phase transitions between Zn×Zn bosonic topological phases in 1+1D, and a constraint on the central charge for the critical points between bosonic symmetry protected topological phases

Lokman Tsui, Yen-Ta Huang, Hong‐Chen Jiang +1 more

The study of continuous phase transitions triggered by spontaneous symmetry breaking has brought revolutionary ideas to physics. Recently, through the discovery of symmetry protected topological phases, it is realized that continuous quantum phase transition can also occur between states with the same symmetry but different topology. Here we study a specific class of such phase transitions in 1 + 1 dimensions – the phase transition between bosonic topological phases protected by Z n × Z n . We find in all cases the critical point possesses two gap opening relevant operators: one leads to a Landau-forbidden symmetry breaking phase transition and the other to the topological phase transition. We also obtained a constraint on the central charge for general phase transitions between symmetry protected bosonic topological phases in 1 + 1 D .

arXiv:1701.00834•Nuclear Physics B•Mar 27, 2017•48 citations

Topological transition on the conformal manifold

Wenjie Ji, Shu-Heng Shao, Xiao-Gang Wen

Despite great successes in the study of gapped phases, a comprehensive understanding of the gapless phases and their transitions is still under development.In this paper, we study a general phenomenon in the space of (1 + 1)-dimensional critical phases with fermionic degrees of freedom described by a continuous family of conformal field theories (CFTs), also known as the conformal manifold.Along a one-dimensional locus on the conformal manifold, there can be a transition point, across which the fermionic CFTs on the two sides differ by stacking an invertible fermionic topological order (IFTO), point by point along the locus.At every point on the conformal manifold, the order and disorder operators have power-law two-point functions, but their critical exponents cross over with each other at the transition point, where stacking the IFTO leaves the fermionic CFT unchanged.We call this continuous transition on the fermionic conformal manifold a topological transition.By gauging the fermion parity, the IFTO stacking becomes a Kramers-Wannier duality between the corresponding bosonic CFTs.Both the IFTO stacking and the Kramers-Wannier duality are induced by the electromagnetic duality of the (2 + 1)-dimensional Z 2 topological order.We provide several examples of topological transitions, including the familiar Luttinger model of spinless fermions (i.e., the c = 1 massless Dirac fermion with the Thirring interaction) and a class of c = 2 examples describing U(1) × SU(2)-protected gapless phases.

arXiv:1909.01425•Physical Review Research•Aug 26, 2020•120 citations

Spin-disordered superfluid state for spin-1 bosons with fractional spin and statistics

W. Vincent Liu, Xiao-Gang Wen

We study a strongly correlated spin-1 Bose gas in 2D space by using the projective construction. A spin-disordered superfluid state is constructed and proposed as a candidate competing with the conventional polar condensate when interaction is antiferromagnetic. This novel state has a non-trivial topological order whose low energy excitations carry fractional spin, charge, and statistics. The spin excitations become gapless only at the edge and are described by level-1 SU(2) Kac-Moody algebra. The edge state is identical to the edge state of the chiral spin liquid or the right moving sector of spin-1/2 chain.

arXiv:cond-mat/0201187•Jan 11, 2002•1 citation
Spin-1 bosons on a one-dimensional chain, at incommensurate filling with an antiferromagnetic spin interaction between neighboring bosons, may form a spin-1 boson condensed state that contains both a gapless charge and spin excitations. We argue that the spin-1 boson condensed state is unstable, and will become one of two superfluids by opening a spin gap. One superfluid must have a spin-1 ground state on a ring if it contains an odd number of bosons and has no degenerate states at the chain end. The other superfluid has a spin-0 ground state on a ring for any number of bosons and has a spin-1/2 degeneracy at the chain end. The two superfluids have the same symmetry and only differ by a spin-SO(3) symmetry protected topological order. Although Landau theory forbids a continuous phase transition between two phases with the same symmetry, the phase transition between the two superfluids can be generically continuous, which is described by conformal field theory (CFT) su(2){2}⊕u(1){4}⊕su(2)[over ¯]{2}⊕u(1)[over ¯]{4}. Such a CFT has a spin fractionalization: spin-1 excitation can decay into a spin-1/2 right mover and a spin-1/2 left mover. We determine the critical theory by solving the partition function based on emergent symmetries and modular invariance condition of CFTs.
Effective field theory is a very useful technique for understanding quantum many body systems. We use this approach to study a certain class of critical quantum spin-1 chains and symmetry protected topological phases of matter in two spatial dimensions. In the first context we consider the SU(3) symmetric spin-1 chain with additional interactions. We use bosonization to demonstrate that the effective field theories describing the critical behaviour of these spin chains can be mapped to free compact boson conformal field theories (CFTs) with central charge c=2. We also describe how some predictions from field theory can be verified in numerical calculations using exact diagonalization (ED) and the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) algorithm. In particular, the bosonization method gives a formula for the evolution of four Tomonaga-Luttinger liquid (TLL) parameters as a function of the lattice parameters. Using the analytic formulae for the scaling dimensions in terms of the TLL parameters and matching of lowest scaling dimensions, we numerically calculate these field-theoretic parameters and confirm that their evolution agrees with the prediction using bosonization. We also tackle aspects of the challenging problem of understanding interacting topological phases. In this context, we aim to understand the effects if interactions in certain classes of symmetry protected topological (SPT) phases of matter. We consider non-chiral SPT phases in two spatial dimensions protected by a discrete symmetry such as Z_K or Z_K x Z_K symmetry. We argue that modular invariance/noninvariance of the partition function of the one-dimensional edge theory can be used to diagnose whether, by adding a suitable potential, the edge theory can be gapped or not without breaking the symmetry. By taking bosonic phases described by Chern-Simons K-matrix theories and fermionic phases relevant to topological superconductors as examples, we demonstrate explicitly that when modular invariance is achieved, we can construct an interaction potential that is consistent with the symmetry and can completely gap out the edge. We also briefly discuss preliminary results of a numerical approach for simulating the 3 dimensional Landau Level problem. This includes a brief description of a potential application of variational Monte Carlo to spin-orbit coupled ab initio systems.
The study of continuous phase transitions triggered by spontaneous symmetry breaking has brought revolutionary ideas to physics. Recently, through the discovery of symmetry protected topological phases, it is realized that continuous quantum phase transition can also occur between states with the same symmetry but different topology. The subject of this dissertation is the phase transition between these symmetry protected topological states (SPTs). There are two main parts in this dissertation.In the first part we consider spatial dimension ddd and symmetry group GGG so that the cohomology group, Hd+1(G,U(1))H^{d+1}(G,U(1))Hd+1(G,U(1)), contains at least one Z2nZ_{2n}Z2n​ or ZZZ factor. We show that the phase transition between the trivial SPT and the root states that generate the $ Z_{2n} $ or ZZZ groups can be induced on the boundary of a d+1 dimensional GtimesZ2TG\\times Z_2^TGtimesZ2T​-symmetric SPT by a Z2TZ_2^TZ2T​ symmetry breaking field. Moreover we show these boundary phase transitions can be ``transplanted'' to d dimensions and realized in lattice models as a function of a tuning parameter. The price one pays is for the critical value of the tuning parameter there is an extra non-local (duality-like) symmetry. In the case where the phase transition is continuous, our theory predicts the presence of unusual (sometimes fractionalized) excitations corresponding to delocalized boundary excitations of the non-trivial SPT on one side of the transition. This theory also predicts other phase transition scenarios including first order transition and transition via an intermediate symmetry breaking phase. In the second part, we study the phase transition between bosonic topological phases protected by ZntimesZnZ_n\\times Z_nZn​timesZn​ in 1+1 dimensions. We find a direct transition occurs when $ n=2,3,4 $ and in all cases the critical point possesses two gap opening relevant operators: one leads to a Landau-forbidden symmetry breaking phase transition and the other to the topological phase transition. We also obtained a constraint($ c\\geq1 $) on the central charge for general phase transitions between symmetry protected bosonic topological phases in 1+1D.
We study possible many body phenomena in the Quantum Anomalous Hall system of weakly interacting spinor bosons in a square lattice. There are various novel spin-bond correlated superfluids (SF) and quantum or topological phase transitions among these SF phases. One transition is a first order one driven by roton droppings ( but with non-zero gaps $ Δ_R $ ) tuned by the Zeeman field $ h $. Another is a second order bosonic Lifshitz transition with the dynamic exponents $ z_x=z_y=2 $ and an accompanying $ [C_4 \times C_4]_D $ symmetry breaking. It is driven by the softening of the superfluid Goldstone mode tuned by the ratio of spin-orbit coupled (SOC) strength over the hopping strength. The two phase boundaries meet at a topological tri-critical (TT) point which separates the $ h=0 $ line into two SF phases with $ N=2 $ and $ N=4 $ condensation momenta respectively. At the $ h=0 $ line where the system has an anti-unitary $ Z_2 $ Reflection symmetry, there are infinite number of classically degenerate family of states on both sides. We perform a systematic order from quantum disorder analysis to find the quantum ground states, also calculate the roton gaps $ Δ_R $ generated by the order from disorder mechanism on both sides of the TT point. The $ N=2 $ and $ N=4 $ SF phases have the same spin-orbital XY-AFM spin structure, respect the anti-unitary symmetry and break the $ [C_4 \times C_4]_D $ symmetry, so they be distinguished only by the different topology of the BEC condensation momenta instead of by any differences in the symmetry breaking patterns. All these novel quantum or topological phenomena can be probed in the recent experimentally realized weakly interacting Quantum Anomalous Hall (QAH) model of $ ^87 Rb $ by Wu, {\sl et.al}, Science 354, 83-88 (2016).
The study of continuous phase transitions triggered by spontaneous symmetry breaking has brought revolutionary ideas to physics. Recently, through the discovery of symmetry protected topological phases, it is realized that continuous quantum phase transition can also occur between states with the same symmetry but different topology. Here we study a specific class of such phase transitions in 1 + 1 dimensions – the phase transition between bosonic topological phases protected by Z n × Z n . We find in all cases the critical point possesses two gap opening relevant operators: one leads to a Landau-forbidden symmetry breaking phase transition and the other to the topological phase transition. We also obtained a constraint on the central charge for general phase transitions between symmetry protected bosonic topological phases in 1 + 1 D .
Despite great successes in the study of gapped phases, a comprehensive understanding of the gapless phases and their transitions is still under development.In this paper, we study a general phenomenon in the space of (1 + 1)-dimensional critical phases with fermionic degrees of freedom described by a continuous family of conformal field theories (CFTs), also known as the conformal manifold.Along a one-dimensional locus on the conformal manifold, there can be a transition point, across which the fermionic CFTs on the two sides differ by stacking an invertible fermionic topological order (IFTO), point by point along the locus.At every point on the conformal manifold, the order and disorder operators have power-law two-point functions, but their critical exponents cross over with each other at the transition point, where stacking the IFTO leaves the fermionic CFT unchanged.We call this continuous transition on the fermionic conformal manifold a topological transition.By gauging the fermion parity, the IFTO stacking becomes a Kramers-Wannier duality between the corresponding bosonic CFTs.Both the IFTO stacking and the Kramers-Wannier duality are induced by the electromagnetic duality of the (2 + 1)-dimensional Z 2 topological order.We provide several examples of topological transitions, including the familiar Luttinger model of spinless fermions (i.e., the c = 1 massless Dirac fermion with the Thirring interaction) and a class of c = 2 examples describing U(1) × SU(2)-protected gapless phases.
We study a strongly correlated spin-1 Bose gas in 2D space by using the projective construction. A spin-disordered superfluid state is constructed and proposed as a candidate competing with the conventional polar condensate when interaction is antiferromagnetic. This novel state has a non-trivial topological order whose low energy excitations carry fractional spin, charge, and statistics. The spin excitations become gapless only at the edge and are described by level-1 SU(2) Kac-Moody algebra. The edge state is identical to the edge state of the chiral spin liquid or the right moving sector of spin-1/2 chain.