© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

arXiv:1807.07414 · Optics Letters

Patterning-effect mitigating intensity modulator for secure decoy-state quantum key distribution

George L. Roberts, Mirko Pittaluga, Mariella Minder, Marco Lucamarini, J. F. Dynes, Zhiliang L. Yuan, A. J. Shields

Published Oct 11, 2018• 92 citations

Abstract

Quantum key distribution (QKD) is a technology that allows two users to exchange cryptographic keys securely. The decoy state technique enhances the technology, ensuring keys can be shared at high bit rates over long distances with information theoretic security. However, imperfections in the implementation, known as side-channels, threaten the perfect security of practical QKD protocols. Intensity modulators are required for high-rate decoy-state QKD systems, although these are unstable and can display a side channel where the intensity of a pulse is dependent on the previous pulse. Here we demonstrate the superior practicality of a tunable extinction ratio Sagnac-based intensity modulator (IM) for practical QKD systems. The ability to select low extinction ratios, alongside the immunity of Sagnac interferometers to DC drifts, ensures that random decoy state QKD patterns can be faithfully reproduced with the patterning effects mitigated. The inherent stability of Sagnac interferometers also ensures that the modulator output does not wander over time.

DOI: 10.1364/ol.43.005110

Related papers

Suppression of patterning effect using IQ modulator for high-speed quantum key distribution systems

Yuanfei Gao, Zhiliang L. Yuan

Quantum key distribution (QKD) is an attractive technology for distributing secret encryption keys between distant users. The decoy-state technique has drastically improved its practicality and performance, and has been widely adopted in commercial systems. However, conventional intensity modulators can introduce security side channels in high speed QKD systems because of their non-stationary working points for decoy-state generation. Here, we analyze the transfer function of an in-phase/quadrature (IQ) modulator and reveal its superiority for stable decoy-state generation, followed by an experimental demonstration. Thanks to their convenient two-level modulation and inherent high speed, IQ modulators are ideal for use in high-speed decoy-state QKD systems.

arXiv:2305.03909•Optics Letters•Jan 17, 2023•12 citations

Intensity modulator for secure, stable and high-performance decoy-state quantum key distribution

Feng-Yu Lu, Xing Lin, Shuang Wang +7 more

The decoy-state method substantially improves the performance of quantum key distribution (QKD) and perfectly solves crucial issues caused by multiphoton pulses. In recent years, the decoy-state method has occupied a key position in practicality, and almost all the QKD systems have employed the decoy-state method. However, the imperfections of traditional intensity modulators limit the performance of the decoy-state method and bring side-channels. In this work, a special intensity modulator and its accompanying modulation method are designed and experimentally verified for the secure, stable and high-performance decoy-state QKDs. The experimental result indicates that its stable and adjustable intensities, convenient two-level modulation, inherently high speed, and compact structure is extremely fit the future trends and will help the decoy-state method to be perfectly applied to QKD systems.

SPIE Conference on Quantum and Nonlinear Optics•Oct 8, 2021•1 citation

Patterning-Effect Calibration Algorithm for Secure Decoy-State Quantum Key Distribution

Xiang Kang, Feng-Yu Lu, Shuang Wang +8 more

The decoy-state method for the quantum key distribution (QKD) is a great countermeasure against the fatal photon number splitting attack. At present, the decoy-state method has been widely employed in practical QKD systems. However, the patterning effect, namely the correlated intensity fluctuations in practical QKD systems, violates the important assumption of the decoy-state method and seriously threatens the protocol security. The previous works investigated the patterning effect between the adjacent pulses and proposed the countermeasures from the degree of post selection and modulators. In this work, we investigate the patterning effect with larger correlation range and present an algorithm to calibrate the driving voltages to mitigate the patterning effect. According to our methods, we experimentally observe the higher-order patterning effect and successfully mitigate it by our calibration algorithm. The experiment results indicate that our methods efficiently improve the protocol security and are expected to be widely employed in practical decoy-state QKD systems.

Journal of Lightwave Technology•Oct 3, 2022•17 citations

Intensity modulator for secure, stable, and high-performance decoy-state quantum key distribution

Feng-Yu Lu, Xing Ping Lin, Shuang Wang +8 more

Abstract The decoy-state method substantially improves the performance of quantum key distribution (QKD) and perfectly solves crucial issues caused by multiphoton pulses. In recent years, the decoy-state method has occupied a key position in practicality, and almost all the QKD systems have employed the decoy-state method. However, the imperfections of traditional intensity modulators limit the performance of the decoy-state method and bring side channels. In this work, a special intensity modulator and its accompanying modulation method are designed and experimentally verified for the secure, stable, and high-performance decoy-state QKDs. The experimental result indicates that its stable and adjustable intensities, convenient two-level modulation, inherently high speed, and compact structure is extremely fit for future trends and will help the decoy-state method to be perfectly applied to QKD systems.

npj Quantum Information•May 20, 2021•38 citations

Deterministic QKD source robust against side-channel attacks

Kiyoshi Tamaki, Marcos Curty, Akihiro Mizutani +1 more

Quantum key distribution (QKD) is secure in principle, but practical security can be undermined by discrepancies between real devices and the idealized models assumed in security proofs. Source side channels, including those exploited by Trojan-horse attacks, are particularly detrimental: neglecting them compromises implementation security, whereas accounting for them reduces performance. Here we propose a QKD source that is intrinsically robust against side-channel attacks. Unlike existing passive and modulator-free schemes, it requires neither post-selection of the emitted pulses nor devices with a perfect extinction ratio to suppress side channels, and it does not introduce correlations between the intensity and the encoded bit or basis. Consequently, under idealized source assumptions commonly adopted in proposals for existing schemes, conventional decoy-state security analyses apply directly, yielding substantially higher key rates. Our proposal appears to be within reach of current technology and therefore provides a clear and practical path toward implementation-secure QKD.

quant-pharXiv:2607.28063•Jul 31, 2026•0 citations

High-speed Robust Intensity Modulator for Decoy-state Quantum Key Distribution

Zexu Wang, Huaxing Xu, Changlei Wang +3 more

We propose a novel high-speed robust intensity modulator based on the Sagnac interferometer to support practical decoy-state quantum key distribution systems. It achieves intensity modulation at 10 GHz with a pattern effect below 0.16%.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Quantum key distribution (QKD) is a technology that allows two users to exchange cryptographic keys securely. The decoy state technique enhances the technology, ensuring keys can be shared at high bit rates over long distances with information theoretic security. However, imperfections in the implementation, known as side-channels, threaten the perfect security of practical QKD protocols. Intensity modulators are required for high-rate decoy-state QKD systems, although these are unstable and can display a side channel where the intensity of a pulse is dependent on the previous pulse. Here we demonstrate the superior practicality of a tunable extinction ratio Sagnac-based intensity modulator (IM) for practical QKD systems. The ability to select low extinction ratios, alongside the immunity of Sagnac interferometers to DC drifts, ensures that random decoy state QKD patterns can be faithfully reproduced with the patterning effects mitigated. The inherent stability of Sagnac interferometers also ensures that the modulator output does not wander over time.

Quantum key distribution (QKD) is an attractive technology for distributing secret encryption keys between distant users. The decoy-state technique has drastically improved its practicality and performance, and has been widely adopted in commercial systems. However, conventional intensity modulators can introduce security side channels in high speed QKD systems because of their non-stationary working points for decoy-state generation. Here, we analyze the transfer function of an in-phase/quadrature (IQ) modulator and reveal its superiority for stable decoy-state generation, followed by an experimental demonstration. Thanks to their convenient two-level modulation and inherent high speed, IQ modulators are ideal for use in high-speed decoy-state QKD systems.

The decoy-state method substantially improves the performance of quantum key distribution (QKD) and perfectly solves crucial issues caused by multiphoton pulses. In recent years, the decoy-state method has occupied a key position in practicality, and almost all the QKD systems have employed the decoy-state method. However, the imperfections of traditional intensity modulators limit the performance of the decoy-state method and bring side-channels. In this work, a special intensity modulator and its accompanying modulation method are designed and experimentally verified for the secure, stable and high-performance decoy-state QKDs. The experimental result indicates that its stable and adjustable intensities, convenient two-level modulation, inherently high speed, and compact structure is extremely fit the future trends and will help the decoy-state method to be perfectly applied to QKD systems.

The decoy-state method for the quantum key distribution (QKD) is a great countermeasure against the fatal photon number splitting attack. At present, the decoy-state method has been widely employed in practical QKD systems. However, the patterning effect, namely the correlated intensity fluctuations in practical QKD systems, violates the important assumption of the decoy-state method and seriously threatens the protocol security. The previous works investigated the patterning effect between the adjacent pulses and proposed the countermeasures from the degree of post selection and modulators. In this work, we investigate the patterning effect with larger correlation range and present an algorithm to calibrate the driving voltages to mitigate the patterning effect. According to our methods, we experimentally observe the higher-order patterning effect and successfully mitigate it by our calibration algorithm. The experiment results indicate that our methods efficiently improve the protocol security and are expected to be widely employed in practical decoy-state QKD systems.

Abstract The decoy-state method substantially improves the performance of quantum key distribution (QKD) and perfectly solves crucial issues caused by multiphoton pulses. In recent years, the decoy-state method has occupied a key position in practicality, and almost all the QKD systems have employed the decoy-state method. However, the imperfections of traditional intensity modulators limit the performance of the decoy-state method and bring side channels. In this work, a special intensity modulator and its accompanying modulation method are designed and experimentally verified for the secure, stable, and high-performance decoy-state QKDs. The experimental result indicates that its stable and adjustable intensities, convenient two-level modulation, inherently high speed, and compact structure is extremely fit for future trends and will help the decoy-state method to be perfectly applied to QKD systems.

Quantum key distribution (QKD) is secure in principle, but practical security can be undermined by discrepancies between real devices and the idealized models assumed in security proofs. Source side channels, including those exploited by Trojan-horse attacks, are particularly detrimental: neglecting them compromises implementation security, whereas accounting for them reduces performance. Here we propose a QKD source that is intrinsically robust against side-channel attacks. Unlike existing passive and modulator-free schemes, it requires neither post-selection of the emitted pulses nor devices with a perfect extinction ratio to suppress side channels, and it does not introduce correlations between the intensity and the encoded bit or basis. Consequently, under idealized source assumptions commonly adopted in proposals for existing schemes, conventional decoy-state security analyses apply directly, yielding substantially higher key rates. Our proposal appears to be within reach of current technology and therefore provides a clear and practical path toward implementation-secure QKD.