Abstract Recent proposals in quantum gravity have suggested that unknown systems can mediate entanglement between two known quantum systems, if the mediator itself is non-classical. This approach may be applicable to the brain, where speculations about quantum operations in consciousness and cognition have a long history. Proton spins of bulk water, which most likely interfere with any brain function, can act as the known quantum systems. If an unknown mediator exists, then NMR methods based on multiple quantum coherence (MQC) can act as an entanglement witness. However, there are doubts that today’s NMR signals can contain quantum correlations in general, and specifically in the brain environment. Here, we used a witness protocol based on zero quantum coherence (ZQC) where we minimized the classical signals to circumvent the NMR detection limits for quantum correlation. For short repetitive periods, we found evoked signals in most parts of the brain, whereby the temporal appearance resembled heartbeat-evoked potentials (HEPs). We found that those signals had no correlates with any classical NMR contrast. Similar to HEPs, the evoked signal depended on conscious awareness. Consciousness-related or electrophysiological signals are unknown in NMR. Remarkably, these signals only appeared if the local properties of the magnetization were reduced. Our findings suggest that we may have witnessed entanglement mediated by consciousness-related brain functions. Those brain functions must then operate non-classically, which would mean that consciousness is non-classical.
Abstract Recent proposals in quantum gravity have suggested that unknown systems can mediate entanglement between two known quantum systems, if the mediator itself is non-classical. This approach may be applicable to the brain, where speculations about quantum operations in consciousness and cognition have a long history. Proton spins of bulk water, which most likely interfere with any brain function, can act as the known quantum systems. If an unknown mediator exists, then NMR methods based on multiple quantum coherence (MQC) can act as an entanglement witness. However, there are doubts that today’s NMR signals can contain quantum correlations in general, and specifically in the brain environment. Here, we used a witness protocol based on zero quantum coherence (ZQC) where we minimized the classical signals to circumvent the NMR detection limits for quantum correlation. For short repetitive periods, we found evoked signals in most parts of the brain, whereby the temporal appearance resembled heartbeat-evoked potentials (HEPs). We found that those signals had no correlates with any classical NMR contrast. Similar to HEPs, the evoked signal depended on conscious awareness. Consciousness-related or electrophysiological signals are unknown in NMR. Remarkably, these signals only appeared if the local properties of the magnetization were reduced. Our findings suggest that we may have witnessed entanglement mediated by consciousness-related brain functions. Those brain functions must then operate non-classically, which would mean that consciousness is non-classical.
Abstract Recent proposals in quantum gravity have suggested that unknown systems can mediate entanglement between two known quantum systems, if and only if the mediator itself is non-classical. This approach may be applicable to the brain, where speculations about quantum operations in consciousness and cognition have a long history. Proton spins of bulk water, which most likely interfere with any brain function, can act as the known quantum systems. If an unknown mediator exists, then NMR methods based on multiple quantum coherence (MQC) can act as entanglement witness. However, there are doubts that today’s NMR signals can contain quantum correlations in general, and specifically in the brain environment. Here, we used a witness protocol based on zero quantum coherence (ZQC) whereby we minimised the classical signals to circumvent the NMR detection limits for quantum correlation. For short repetitive periods, we found evoked signals in most parts of the brain, whereby the temporal appearance resembled heartbeatevoked potentials (HEPs). We found that those signals had no correlates with any classical NMR contrast. Similar to HEPs, the evoked signal depended on conscious awareness. Consciousness-related or electrophysiological signals are unknown in NMR. Remarkably, these signals only appeared if the local properties of the magnetisation were reduced. Our findings suggest that we may have witnessed entanglement mediated by consciousness-related brain functions. Those brain functions must then operate non-classically, which would mean that consciousness is non-classical.
Recent proposals in quantum gravity have suggested that unknown systems can mediate entanglement between two known quantum systems, if and only if the mediator itself is non-classical. This approach may be applicable to the brain, where speculations about quantum operations in consciousness and cognition have a long history. Proton spins of bulk water, which most likely interfere with any brain function, can act as the known quantum systems. If an unknown mediator exists, then NMR methods based on multiple quantum coherence (MQC) can act as entanglement witness. However, there are doubts that today’s NMR signals can contain quantum correlations in general, and specifically in the brain environment. Here, we used a witness protocol based on zero quantum coherence (ZQC) whereby we minimised the classical signals to circumvent the NMR detection limits for quantum correlation. For short repetitive periods, we found evoked signals in most parts of the brain, whereby the temporal appearance resembled heartbeat-evoked potentials (HEPs). We found that those signals had no correlates with any classical NMR contrast. Similar to HEPs, the evoked signal depended on conscious awareness. Consciousness-related or electrophysiological signals are unknown in NMR. Remarkably, these signals only appeared if the local properties of the magnetisation were reduced. Our findings suggest that we may have witnessed entanglement mediated by consciousness-related brain functions. Those brain functions must then operate non-classically, which would mean that consciousness is non-classical.
Abstract Exploring unknown quantum systems is an experimental challenge. Recent proposals exploring quantum gravity have suggested circumventing this problem by considering the unknown system as a mediator between two known systems. If such a mediation can locally generate entanglement in the known systems, then the mediator must be non-classical. The same approach may be applicable to other systems, in particular the brain, where speculations about quantum operations in consciousness and cognition have a long history. Translated to the brain, the mediator is then an unknown brain function. For the quantum systems, we could use proton spins of bulk water, which most likely interfere with the any brain function. Entanglement in these spins can be witnessed with multiple quantum coherence (MQC). We based our witness protocol on zero quantum coherence (ZQC) whereby potential signals from local properties were minimised. For short repetitive periods, we found ZQC signals in large parts of the brain, whereby the temporal appearance resembled heartbeat-evoked potentials (HEPs). Similar to HEPs, we also found that the ZQC signal depended on conscious awareness. Consciousness-related signals have, to our knowledge, not yet been reported in NMR. Remarkably, we could exclude local properties as contrast mechanism because (a) the ZQC signals had no correlates known in conventional MRI, and (b) the ZQC signals only appeared if the local properties of the magnetisation, which are complementary to non-local properties, were reduced. Our findings suggest that we may have witnessed entanglement mediated by consciousness-related brain functions. Those brain functions must then operate non-classically, which would mean that consciousness is non-classical.
• Using clinical MRI, researchers observed the first indications of a macroscopic quantum entangled state formed by proton spins of water molecules in the living human brain. • By introducing an entanglement witness technique—originally proposed for quantum gravity research—into neuroscience, the team discovered that entanglement signals of proton spins are surprisingly synchronized with Heartbeat-Evoked Potentials (HEPs). • The study provides strong experimental indications that human consciousness, cognition, and brain computational processes are based on non-classical quantum mechanics, confirming that the entanglement-based signals fade away when the subject falls asleep. [Quantum Biology Society] Whether human brain functions, especially consciousness and cognition, are merely the result of classical electrical and chemical signal exchanges between brain cells, or the result of computations akin to a quantum computer based on quantum mechanical principles, has been one of the hottest debates in modern science. While the dominant argument has been that quantum effects would instantly break down in a macroscopic, hot, and wet environment like the brain, a recent study directly capturing strong indications of macroscopic quantum entanglement in the living human brain is exciting the global scientific community. The paper "Experimental indications of non-classical brain functions," published entirely free of charge in the Journal of Physics Communications, contains these remarkable achievements. A research team led by Christian Matthias Kerskens and David López Pérez from the Trinity College Institute of Neuroscience (TCIN) in Dublin, Ireland, successfully conducted this groundbreaking experiment. ■ Quantum Gravity Research Techniques Open the Door to Neuroscience To detect quantum effects in the macroscopic environment of the brain responsible for cognitive functions, the researchers made an unconventional attempt by applying an entanglement witness protocol—originally proposed for quantum gravity research—to clinical magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of a living human body. MRI measures the proton spins of bulk water in the brain; the researchers highly saturated the magnetization to minimize classical single quantum coherence (SQC) signals, selectively capturing only the target zero quantum coherence (ZQC) signals. ■ Quantum Entanglement in the Brain Synchronized with the Heartbeat The observation results were astonishing. The network of fluid spins (proton spins of bulk water) inside the brain interacted with each other, showing indications of a specific entangled state, and these entanglement-based signal bursts were surprisingly synchronized with the heartbeat-evoked potentials (HEPs) induced by the subject's heartbeat. These pulsating signals could not be explained by any existing classical MRI contrast techniques. ■ Entanglement Signals Disappear as Consciousness Fades Even more interestingly, these quantum entanglement-related signals appeared strongly only when the subjects were in a state of conscious awareness. When the subjects' consciousness faded, such as when falling asleep, the signals invariably and gradually disappeared. This is a strong experimental indication that macroscopic water proton spins related to brain physiology are mediating entanglement through unknown brain functions, further suggesting that the foundation of human brain computational processes and consciousness could be strictly non-classical. This research leaves open the possibility that the human brain operates effectively like a highly complex quantum computer, and it is expected to bring a groundbreaking paradigm shift in neuroscience, psychology, medicine, and the development of next-generation artificial intelligence in the future.
For many years, it has been speculated that consciousness and cognition could be the based on quantum information \cite{sep-qt-consciousness} which opposes the view that quantum coherence, the primary basis of quantum computing \cite{nielsen_chuang_2010} , cannot survive in complex biological systems \cite{Koch_2006,Tegmark_2000} . However, recent findings in photosynthesis \cite{Engel_2007,Collini_2010} have challenged this view suggesting that only long-range quantum coherence between molecules can account for its efficiency in light-harvesting. Here, we investigated if long-range quantum coherence may also play a decisive role in brain function. We found surprisingly that the cardiac pressure pulse evoked zero-quantum coherence (iZQC) \cite{Warren_1998} which were by a magnitude higher than theoretically expected. From this finding, we concluded that underlying physiological process is - cautiously speaking - of an unknown macroscopic non-classical kind. The process reveals it importance by it temporal appearance; during consciousness it is highly synchronized with the cardiac pulse, while during sleep, no or only sporadic iZQC could be detected. This findings suggest that this non-classical phenomenon is most likely a necessity for consciousness.
Abstract We have recently suggested a proposal to explore non-classicality in the brain, for which we developed an entanglement witness protocol using MRI. The witness protocol intended to find spin interactions which could not be explained by classical interactions, based on intermolecular multiple quantum coherence (iMQC). As for Warren’s comments, we show in more detail that this was indeed the case; our observations were certainly not generated by interactions based on the iMQC model. Further, we discuss some additional details not present in the original paper.