Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1802.05719 · Physical Review Letters

Generic Emergence of Objectivity of Observables in Infinite Dimensions

Paul A. Knott, Tommaso Tufarelli, Marco Piani, Gerardo Adesso

Published Oct 17, 2018• 36 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum Darwinism posits that information becomes objective whenever multiple observers indirectly probe a quantum system by each measuring a fraction of the environment. It was recently shown that objectivity of observables emerges generically from the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics, whenever the system of interest has finite dimensions and the number of environment fragments is large [F. G. S. L. Brandão, M. Piani, and P. Horodecki, Nat. Commun. 6, 7908 (2015)NCAOBW2041-172310.1038/ncomms8908]. Despite the importance of this result, it necessarily excludes many practical systems of interest that are infinite dimensional, including harmonic oscillators. Extending the study of quantum Darwinism to infinite dimensions is a nontrivial task: we tackle it here by using a modified diamond norm, suitable to quantify the distinguishability of channels in infinite dimensions. We prove two theorems that bound the emergence of objectivity, first for finite mean energy systems, and then for systems that can only be prepared in states with an exponential energy cutoff. We show that the latter class includes any bounded-energy subset of single-mode Gaussian states.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.121.160401

Related papers

Refined diamond norm bounds on the emergence of objectivity of observables

Eugenia Colafranceschi, Ludovico Lami, Gerardo Adesso +1 more

Abstract The theory of quantum Darwinism aims to explain how our objective classical reality arises from the quantum world, by analysing the distribution of information about a quantum system that is accessible to multiple observers, who probe the system by intercepting fragments of its environment. Previous work showed that, when the number of environmental fragments grows, the quantum channels modelling the information flow from system to observers become arbitrarily close—in terms of diamond norm distance—to ‘measure-and-prepare’ channels, ensuring objectivity of observables; the convergence is formalised by an upper bound on the diamond norm distance, which decreases with increasing number of fragments. Here, we derive tighter diamond norm bounds on the emergence of objectivity of observables for quantum systems of infinite dimension, providing an approach which can bridge between the finite- and the infinite-dimensional cases. Furthermore, we probe the tightness of our bounds by considering a specific model of a system-environment dynamics given by a pure loss channel. Finally, we generalise to infinite dimensions a result obtained by Brandão et al (2015 Nat. Commun. 6 7908), which provides an operational characterisation of quantum discord in terms of one-sided redistribution of correlations to many parties. Our results provide a unifying framework to benchmark quantitatively the rise of objectivity in the quantum-to-classical transition.

arXiv:2003.08153•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jul 10, 2020•8 citations

Generic emergence of classical features in quantum Darwinism

Fernando G. S. L. Brandão, Marco Piani, Paweł Horodecki

Quantum Darwinism posits that only specific information about a quantum system that is redundantly proliferated to many parts of its environment becomes accessible and objective, leading to the emergence of classical reality. However, it is not clear under what conditions this mechanism holds true. Here we prove that the emergence of classical features along the lines of quantum Darwinism is a general feature of any quantum dynamics: observers who acquire information indirectly through the environment have effective access at most to classical information about one and the same measurement of the quantum system. Our analysis does not rely on a strict conceptual splitting between a system-of-interest and its environment, and allows one to interpret any system as part of the environment of any other system. Finally, our approach leads to a full operational characterization of quantum discord in terms of local redistribution of correlations. Quantum Darwinism provides an explanation for the emergence of classical reality from the underlying quantum world, as information proliferates in the environment and becomes objective. Here, the authors show how some aspects of this mechanism is generic and classicality emerges for any quantum dynamics.

arXiv:1310.8640•Nature Communications•Aug 12, 2015•138 citations

Objectivity Emerges as the Center of the Observable Algebra: A Unifying Framework for Quantum Darwinism

Rolando P. Hong Enriquez

Quantum Darwinism tells us that some observable of a system becomes objective when the environment redundantly records it — but for a general, partly quantum system it does not say which observable that is. This paper proposes a precise structural answer: the objective observables are exactly the "center" of the system's algebra of observables — the quantities that are simultaneously compatible with everything else and that all observers can share. The proposal is given substance with three results, each proved in finite dimension and checked numerically. First, objectivity emerges as an algebraic order parameter: as broadcasting proceeds, the shared "consensus" center grows steadily from nothing to the full set of classical values, naming which observables have become objective at each stage — more information than any single number could give. Second, the abstract idea appears concretely in an ordinary lattice gauge model, where the center of a region's observables is exactly its boundary electric charge, with no gravity assumed. Third, the objective content is agreed by every observer but relative in degree: changing one's quantum reference frame never enlarges what is objective, though it can change how much microscopic detail is assigned. The paper connects this to the operator-algebra language of recent gravitational research, while being explicit that the gravitational completion is imported, not re-derived. In short: objectivity is not a vague notion but a sharp algebraic one — it is the center, the shared heart of what everyone can agree on.

•Jul 9, 2026•0 citations

Emergence of Noncontextuality under Quantum Darwinism

Roberto D. Baldijão, Rafael Wagner, Cristhiano Duarte +2 more

Quantum Darwinism proposes that the proliferation of redundant information plays a major role in the emergence of objectivity out of the quantum world.Is this kind of objectivity necessarily classical?We show that if one takes Spekkens's notion of noncontextuality as the notion of classicality and the approach of Brandão, Piani, and Horodecki to quantum Darwinism, the answer to the above question is "'yes," if the environment encodes the proliferated information sufficiently well.Moreover, we propose a threshold on this encoding, above which one can unambiguously say that classical objectivity has emerged under quantum Darwinism.

arXiv:2104.05734•PRX Quantum•Sep 27, 2021•31 citations

Emergence of quantum Darwinism and pointer states for noncommuting evolutions

Diana A. Chisholm, G. Massimo Palma, Luca Innocenti

Quantum systems achieve objectivity by redundantly encoding information about themselves into the surrounding environment, through a mechanism known as quantum Darwinism. When this happens, observers measure the environment and infer the system to be in one of its pointer states. We study the emergence of objectivity whenever the Hamiltonian of the system and the interaction Hamiltonian between system and environment do not commute, a condition where it becomes difficult to identify pointer states, and the use of methods such as the predictability sieve becomes necessary. We show in an explicit qubit model to what degree the noncommuting evolution allows for the emergence of objective states, and show that a definition of pointer states based on spectrum broadcast structure is more natural in this context, and coincides with the one based on the predictability sieve for commuting evolutions.

arXiv:2510.06867•APS Open Science•May 1, 2026•0 citations

Functional Information in Quantum Darwinism: An Operational Measure of Objectivity

Arda Batın Tank

Abstract Classical objectivity arises when many independent observers can retrieve the same information about a quantum system without disturbing it. Quantum Darwinism (QD) explains this by treating the environment as a communication channel that redundantly broadcasts information about pointer observables. We develop an operational framework for quantifying this redundancy through the lens of functional information. By introducing a one-sided adequacy criterion based on the Holevo bound, we measure the \emph{abundance} of environment fragments that individually contain nearly all classically accessible pointer information. Using a heterogeneous pure–dephasing model, we sample fragments to extract onset statistics and apply isotonic regression to obtain stable estimates of redundancy and its functional-information counterpart $FI_{QD}=\log_2 R_\delta$. The results reveal a generic onset–plateau structure: redundancy grows rapidly at early times, then saturates at a capacity-limited ceiling, universally across adequacy tolerances. We further connect $FI_{QD}$ to thermodynamic bounds, showing that each additional bit of redundancy implies exponentially increasing minimal heat costs for record stabilization. This approach provides a conservative, model-agnostic measure of emergent classicality, suitable for both theoretical analysis and experimental probing.

arXiv:2509.17775•Oct 7, 2025•0 citations
Quantum Darwinism posits that information becomes objective whenever multiple observers indirectly probe a quantum system by each measuring a fraction of the environment. It was recently shown that objectivity of observables emerges generically from the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics, whenever the system of interest has finite dimensions and the number of environment fragments is large [F. G. S. L. Brandão, M. Piani, and P. Horodecki, Nat. Commun. 6, 7908 (2015)NCAOBW2041-172310.1038/ncomms8908]. Despite the importance of this result, it necessarily excludes many practical systems of interest that are infinite dimensional, including harmonic oscillators. Extending the study of quantum Darwinism to infinite dimensions is a nontrivial task: we tackle it here by using a modified diamond norm, suitable to quantify the distinguishability of channels in infinite dimensions. We prove two theorems that bound the emergence of objectivity, first for finite mean energy systems, and then for systems that can only be prepared in states with an exponential energy cutoff. We show that the latter class includes any bounded-energy subset of single-mode Gaussian states.
Abstract The theory of quantum Darwinism aims to explain how our objective classical reality arises from the quantum world, by analysing the distribution of information about a quantum system that is accessible to multiple observers, who probe the system by intercepting fragments of its environment. Previous work showed that, when the number of environmental fragments grows, the quantum channels modelling the information flow from system to observers become arbitrarily close—in terms of diamond norm distance—to ‘measure-and-prepare’ channels, ensuring objectivity of observables; the convergence is formalised by an upper bound on the diamond norm distance, which decreases with increasing number of fragments. Here, we derive tighter diamond norm bounds on the emergence of objectivity of observables for quantum systems of infinite dimension, providing an approach which can bridge between the finite- and the infinite-dimensional cases. Furthermore, we probe the tightness of our bounds by considering a specific model of a system-environment dynamics given by a pure loss channel. Finally, we generalise to infinite dimensions a result obtained by Brandão et al (2015 Nat. Commun. 6 7908), which provides an operational characterisation of quantum discord in terms of one-sided redistribution of correlations to many parties. Our results provide a unifying framework to benchmark quantitatively the rise of objectivity in the quantum-to-classical transition.
Quantum Darwinism posits that only specific information about a quantum system that is redundantly proliferated to many parts of its environment becomes accessible and objective, leading to the emergence of classical reality. However, it is not clear under what conditions this mechanism holds true. Here we prove that the emergence of classical features along the lines of quantum Darwinism is a general feature of any quantum dynamics: observers who acquire information indirectly through the environment have effective access at most to classical information about one and the same measurement of the quantum system. Our analysis does not rely on a strict conceptual splitting between a system-of-interest and its environment, and allows one to interpret any system as part of the environment of any other system. Finally, our approach leads to a full operational characterization of quantum discord in terms of local redistribution of correlations. Quantum Darwinism provides an explanation for the emergence of classical reality from the underlying quantum world, as information proliferates in the environment and becomes objective. Here, the authors show how some aspects of this mechanism is generic and classicality emerges for any quantum dynamics.
Quantum Darwinism tells us that some observable of a system becomes objective when the environment redundantly records it — but for a general, partly quantum system it does not say which observable that is. This paper proposes a precise structural answer: the objective observables are exactly the "center" of the system's algebra of observables — the quantities that are simultaneously compatible with everything else and that all observers can share. The proposal is given substance with three results, each proved in finite dimension and checked numerically. First, objectivity emerges as an algebraic order parameter: as broadcasting proceeds, the shared "consensus" center grows steadily from nothing to the full set of classical values, naming which observables have become objective at each stage — more information than any single number could give. Second, the abstract idea appears concretely in an ordinary lattice gauge model, where the center of a region's observables is exactly its boundary electric charge, with no gravity assumed. Third, the objective content is agreed by every observer but relative in degree: changing one's quantum reference frame never enlarges what is objective, though it can change how much microscopic detail is assigned. The paper connects this to the operator-algebra language of recent gravitational research, while being explicit that the gravitational completion is imported, not re-derived. In short: objectivity is not a vague notion but a sharp algebraic one — it is the center, the shared heart of what everyone can agree on.
Quantum Darwinism proposes that the proliferation of redundant information plays a major role in the emergence of objectivity out of the quantum world.Is this kind of objectivity necessarily classical?We show that if one takes Spekkens's notion of noncontextuality as the notion of classicality and the approach of Brandão, Piani, and Horodecki to quantum Darwinism, the answer to the above question is "'yes," if the environment encodes the proliferated information sufficiently well.Moreover, we propose a threshold on this encoding, above which one can unambiguously say that classical objectivity has emerged under quantum Darwinism.
Quantum systems achieve objectivity by redundantly encoding information about themselves into the surrounding environment, through a mechanism known as quantum Darwinism. When this happens, observers measure the environment and infer the system to be in one of its pointer states. We study the emergence of objectivity whenever the Hamiltonian of the system and the interaction Hamiltonian between system and environment do not commute, a condition where it becomes difficult to identify pointer states, and the use of methods such as the predictability sieve becomes necessary. We show in an explicit qubit model to what degree the noncommuting evolution allows for the emergence of objective states, and show that a definition of pointer states based on spectrum broadcast structure is more natural in this context, and coincides with the one based on the predictability sieve for commuting evolutions.
Abstract Classical objectivity arises when many independent observers can retrieve the same information about a quantum system without disturbing it. Quantum Darwinism (QD) explains this by treating the environment as a communication channel that redundantly broadcasts information about pointer observables. We develop an operational framework for quantifying this redundancy through the lens of functional information. By introducing a one-sided adequacy criterion based on the Holevo bound, we measure the \emph{abundance} of environment fragments that individually contain nearly all classically accessible pointer information. Using a heterogeneous pure–dephasing model, we sample fragments to extract onset statistics and apply isotonic regression to obtain stable estimates of redundancy and its functional-information counterpart FIQD=log⁡2RδFI_{QD}=\log_2 R_\deltaFIQD​=log2​Rδ​. The results reveal a generic onset–plateau structure: redundancy grows rapidly at early times, then saturates at a capacity-limited ceiling, universally across adequacy tolerances. We further connect FIQDFI_{QD}FIQD​ to thermodynamic bounds, showing that each additional bit of redundancy implies exponentially increasing minimal heat costs for record stabilization. This approach provides a conservative, model-agnostic measure of emergent classicality, suitable for both theoretical analysis and experimental probing.