Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1709.04520 · Physical Review Letters

Photonic Counterparts of Cooper Pairs

André Saraiva, Filomeno Soares de Aguiar Júnior, Reinaldo de Melo e Souza, Arthur Patrocínio Pena, Carlos Henrique Monken, Marcelo França Santos, Belita Koiller, Ado Jório

Published Nov 9, 2017• 39 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The microscopic theory of superconductivity raised the disruptive idea that electrons couple through the elusive exchange of virtual phonons, overcoming the strong Coulomb repulsion to form Cooper pairs. Light is also known to interact with atomic vibrations, as, for example, in the Raman effect. We show that photon pairs exchange virtual vibrations in transparent media, leading to an effective photon-photon interaction identical to that for electrons in the BCS theory of superconductivity, in spite of the fact that photons are bosons. In this scenario, photons may exchange energy without matching a quantum of vibration of the medium. As a result, pair correlations for photons scattered away from the Raman resonances are expected to be enhanced. An experimental demonstration of this effect is provided here by time-correlated Raman measurements in different media. The experimental data confirm our theoretical interpretation of a photonic Cooper pairing, without the need for any fitting parameters.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.119.193603

Related papers

Photonic Cooper Pairs

André Saraiva, Filomeno Soares de Aguiar Júnior, Reinaldo de Melo e Souza +5 more

The microscopic theory of superconductivity raised the disruptive idea that electrons couple through the elusive exchange of virtual phonons, overcoming the strong Coulomb repulsion to form Cooper pairs. Light is also known to interact with atomic vibrations, as for example in the Raman effect. We show that photon pairs exchange virtual vibrations in transparent media, leading to an effective photon-photon interaction identical to that for electrons in BCS theory of supercondutivity, in spite of the fact that photons are bosons. In this scenario, photons may exchange energy without matching a quantum of vibration of the medium. As a result, pair correlations for photons scattered away from the Raman resonances are expected to be enhanced. Experimental demonstration of this effect is provided here by time correlated Raman measurements in different media. The experimental data confirm our theoretical interpretation of a photonic Cooper pairing, without the need for any fitting parameters.

•Sep 13, 2017•0 citations

Energy, momentum and production rate of photonic Cooper pairs

Filomeno Soares de Aguiar Júnior, André Saraiva, Marcelo França Santos +6 more

Photons interact with each other in condensed matter through the same mechanism that forms Cooper pairs in superconductors, the exchange of virtual vibrational quanta [PRL 119, 193603 (2017)]. It is however unclear which consequences of this pairing will be observable and potentially lead to further analogy with superconductivity. We investigate the energy, momentum and production rate of such a photon-photon collision in diamond and other transparent media, experiencing properties akin to those of traditional electronic Cooper pairs. The rate of pair production depends on the energy shifts of the pair, which in theory determines whether there should be an attractive or repulsive interaction between these massless and chargeless particles. We only observe pair formation in the case of attractive interactions. In contrast with traditional photon-phonon collisions, which scatter light in all directions, the photonic Cooper pairs follow the same path as the noninteracting laser. Due to the low interaction energy between photons, the observed light-by-light collision is extremely rare, approximately one event for every 10^15 incident photons. However, our model indicates paths to achieve the higher interaction energies needed to make the effect instrumental for applications.

•Oct 29, 2018•0 citations

Quantum correlations in the Stokes and anti-Stokes Raman scattering: the photonic counterparts of Cooper pairs

Filomeno Soares de Aguiar Júnior

The correlated Raman scattering, referred to here as the SaS process, occurs with the annihilation, within a material, of two photons of an excitation laser and the creation of a quantum correlated Stokes (S) and anti-Soktes (aS) photon pair where the phonon created in the S process is annihilated in the aS scattering. We found that, in addition to real SaS process where the energy exchange coincides with the energy of a vibrational state of the material, there is also the virtual SaS process, whose the exchange of energy and momentum between the photons of the laser, generating the S-aS photon pair, is mediated by a virtual vibrational excitation, setting up a photon-photon interaction similar to the electron-electron attraction responsible for the creation of Cooper pairs of the BCS theory of superconductivity. We observed the SaS process in transparent media in general, by measuring non-classical values of the normalized second-order cross-correlation function of the Stokes and anti-Stokes fields, 2(0). In diamond, we characterize the intensity of the virtual SaS scattering ( ) as a function of the virtual phonon energy, proving that the SaS process occurs only when the photon-photon interaction is attractive, as in the BCS theory for the Cooper pairs. We show that photons S and aS from the SaS process are scattered predominantly in the same polarization as the excitation laser of the sample and, with this, we implemented the pump-probe technique to study the lifetime of the real phonon (obtained in the diamond order 2.8 ps ) and the lifetime of the virtual excitation, which proved to be inferior to the temporal resolution of the measurement’s, characterizing one of the main differences between the two processes. We also observed that, due to the relations of energy and momentum conservation, have the same spatial intensity profile of the non-interacting laser that crosses the sample, different from the behavior observed for uncorrelated Raman scattering which spreads photons in all directions. We observed that the efficiency of the SaS scattering is proportional to the Raman scattering cross-section when we compare the process in different hydrocarbons and we generalize the observations made in the diamond to the sample of liquid decane. In water, the values of 2(0), predicted by the theoretical description of the process, corroborate the experimental data, validating the BCS theory for virtual SaS scattering, setting the pair of Stokes and anti-Stokes photons as counterparts of the Cooper pairs.

•Nov 25, 2020•0 citations

Quantum Correlations in the Stokes-anti-Stokes Raman Scattering: Photonic Cooper Pairs

Filomeno Soares de Aguiar Júnior, Ado Jório, Carlos Henrique Monken +4 more

Photons can interact with each other in condensed matter by exchanging virtual phonons, via instantaneous Stokes and anti-Stokes Raman scattering. We study this phenomenon and its analogy to the formation of Cooper pairs in superconductivity.

The Rochester Conferences on Coherence and Quantum Optics and the Quantum Information and Measurement meeting•Jan 1, 2019•1 citation

Generation of photonic Cooper pairs in nanoscale optomechanical waveguides

Yi Zhang, Lei Zhang, Yong‐yuan Zhu

In this paper we theoretically show that counterpart photonic Cooper pairs can be achieved in nanoscale waveguides with radiation pressure effect. We demonstrate that due to Brillouin scattering a Stokes photon and an anti-Stokes one can exchange virtual phonons, leading to an effective photon-photon interaction. The effective interaction Hamiltonian of the two photons is identical to that for electrons in the BCS theory, and the photonic counterpart of the superconducting energy gap can appear. Quite different from the conventional stimulated Brillouin scattering the number of photon pairs can be amplified. The result could be used as a photon-pair laser and might have a possible application in integrated optics and quantum information processing in the future.

Physical Review A•Jul 12, 2018•4 citations

Stokes–anti-Stokes correlated photon properties akin to photonic Cooper pairs

Filomeno Soares de Aguiar Júnior, André Saraiva, Marcelo França Santos +6 more

Photons interact in condensed matter through the same mechanism that forms Cooper pairs in superconductors. The production rate depends on the energy shifts, which in the BCS theory determines whether interaction is attractive or repulsive. Only correlated photons in the case of attractive interactions are observed. While traditional photon-phonon collisions scatter light in all directions, the correlated photons follow the same path as the noninteracting laser. The observed phenomenon is rare, but the authors indicate paths to achieve higher interaction energies.

arXiv:1810.12461•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 13, 2019•13 citations
The microscopic theory of superconductivity raised the disruptive idea that electrons couple through the elusive exchange of virtual phonons, overcoming the strong Coulomb repulsion to form Cooper pairs. Light is also known to interact with atomic vibrations, as, for example, in the Raman effect. We show that photon pairs exchange virtual vibrations in transparent media, leading to an effective photon-photon interaction identical to that for electrons in the BCS theory of superconductivity, in spite of the fact that photons are bosons. In this scenario, photons may exchange energy without matching a quantum of vibration of the medium. As a result, pair correlations for photons scattered away from the Raman resonances are expected to be enhanced. An experimental demonstration of this effect is provided here by time-correlated Raman measurements in different media. The experimental data confirm our theoretical interpretation of a photonic Cooper pairing, without the need for any fitting parameters.
The microscopic theory of superconductivity raised the disruptive idea that electrons couple through the elusive exchange of virtual phonons, overcoming the strong Coulomb repulsion to form Cooper pairs. Light is also known to interact with atomic vibrations, as for example in the Raman effect. We show that photon pairs exchange virtual vibrations in transparent media, leading to an effective photon-photon interaction identical to that for electrons in BCS theory of supercondutivity, in spite of the fact that photons are bosons. In this scenario, photons may exchange energy without matching a quantum of vibration of the medium. As a result, pair correlations for photons scattered away from the Raman resonances are expected to be enhanced. Experimental demonstration of this effect is provided here by time correlated Raman measurements in different media. The experimental data confirm our theoretical interpretation of a photonic Cooper pairing, without the need for any fitting parameters.
Photons interact with each other in condensed matter through the same mechanism that forms Cooper pairs in superconductors, the exchange of virtual vibrational quanta [PRL 119, 193603 (2017)]. It is however unclear which consequences of this pairing will be observable and potentially lead to further analogy with superconductivity. We investigate the energy, momentum and production rate of such a photon-photon collision in diamond and other transparent media, experiencing properties akin to those of traditional electronic Cooper pairs. The rate of pair production depends on the energy shifts of the pair, which in theory determines whether there should be an attractive or repulsive interaction between these massless and chargeless particles. We only observe pair formation in the case of attractive interactions. In contrast with traditional photon-phonon collisions, which scatter light in all directions, the photonic Cooper pairs follow the same path as the noninteracting laser. Due to the low interaction energy between photons, the observed light-by-light collision is extremely rare, approximately one event for every 10^15 incident photons. However, our model indicates paths to achieve the higher interaction energies needed to make the effect instrumental for applications.
The correlated Raman scattering, referred to here as the SaS process, occurs with the annihilation, within a material, of two photons of an excitation laser and the creation of a quantum correlated Stokes (S) and anti-Soktes (aS) photon pair where the phonon created in the S process is annihilated in the aS scattering. We found that, in addition to real SaS process where the energy exchange coincides with the energy of a vibrational state of the material, there is also the virtual SaS process, whose the exchange of energy and momentum between the photons of the laser, generating the S-aS photon pair, is mediated by a virtual vibrational excitation, setting up a photon-photon interaction similar to the electron-electron attraction responsible for the creation of Cooper pairs of the BCS theory of superconductivity. We observed the SaS process in transparent media in general, by measuring non-classical values of the normalized second-order cross-correlation function of the Stokes and anti-Stokes fields, 2(0). In diamond, we characterize the intensity of the virtual SaS scattering ( ) as a function of the virtual phonon energy, proving that the SaS process occurs only when the photon-photon interaction is attractive, as in the BCS theory for the Cooper pairs. We show that photons S and aS from the SaS process are scattered predominantly in the same polarization as the excitation laser of the sample and, with this, we implemented the pump-probe technique to study the lifetime of the real phonon (obtained in the diamond order 2.8 ps ) and the lifetime of the virtual excitation, which proved to be inferior to the temporal resolution of the measurement’s, characterizing one of the main differences between the two processes. We also observed that, due to the relations of energy and momentum conservation, have the same spatial intensity profile of the non-interacting laser that crosses the sample, different from the behavior observed for uncorrelated Raman scattering which spreads photons in all directions. We observed that the efficiency of the SaS scattering is proportional to the Raman scattering cross-section when we compare the process in different hydrocarbons and we generalize the observations made in the diamond to the sample of liquid decane. In water, the values of 2(0), predicted by the theoretical description of the process, corroborate the experimental data, validating the BCS theory for virtual SaS scattering, setting the pair of Stokes and anti-Stokes photons as counterparts of the Cooper pairs.
In this paper we theoretically show that counterpart photonic Cooper pairs can be achieved in nanoscale waveguides with radiation pressure effect. We demonstrate that due to Brillouin scattering a Stokes photon and an anti-Stokes one can exchange virtual phonons, leading to an effective photon-photon interaction. The effective interaction Hamiltonian of the two photons is identical to that for electrons in the BCS theory, and the photonic counterpart of the superconducting energy gap can appear. Quite different from the conventional stimulated Brillouin scattering the number of photon pairs can be amplified. The result could be used as a photon-pair laser and might have a possible application in integrated optics and quantum information processing in the future.
Photons interact in condensed matter through the same mechanism that forms Cooper pairs in superconductors. The production rate depends on the energy shifts, which in the BCS theory determines whether interaction is attractive or repulsive. Only correlated photons in the case of attractive interactions are observed. While traditional photon-phonon collisions scatter light in all directions, the correlated photons follow the same path as the noninteracting laser. The observed phenomenon is rare, but the authors indicate paths to achieve higher interaction energies.