Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1708.03968 · Physical Review Letters

Duality Games and Operational Duality Relations

E. Bagán, John Calsamiglia, János A. Bergou, Mark S. Hillery

Published Jan 30, 2018• 50 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We give operational meaning to wave-particle duality in terms of discrimination games. Duality arises as a constraint on the probability of winning these games. The games are played with the aid of an n-port interferometer, and involve 3 parties, Alice and Bob, who cooperate, and the House, who supervises the game. In one game called ways they attempt to determine the path of a particle in the interferometer. In another, called phases, they attempt to determine which set of known phases have been applied to the different paths. The House determines which game is to be played by flipping a coin. We find a tight wave-particle duality relation that allows us to relate the probabilities of winning these games, and use it to find an upper bound on the probability of winning the combined game. This procedure allows us to express wave-particle duality in terms of discrimination probabilities.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.120.050402

Related papers

Partial particle and wave information and weak duality games

Mark S. Hillery

Abstract Duality games are a way of looking at wave–particle duality. In these games. Alice and Bob together are playing against the house. The house specifies, at random, which of two sub-games Alice and Bob will play. One game, Ways, requires that they obtain path information about a particle going through an N -path interferometer and the other, Phases, requires that they obtain phase information. In general, because of wave–particle duality, Alice and Bob cannot always win the overall game. However, if the required amount of path and phase information is not too great, for example specifying a set of paths or phases, one of which is the right one, then they can always win. Here we study examples of duality games that can always be won, and develop a wave–particle duality relation expressed only in terms of mutual information to help analyze these games.

arXiv:2106.01514•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Nov 4, 2021•1 citation

Quantitative wave-particle duality as quantum state discrimination

Xin Lü

We consider the problem of quantitative wave-particle duality from the perspective of quantum state discrimination. Specifically, we obtain quantifiers of both the particle aspect and the wave aspect from state discrimination. We show that the familiar one-bet duality relation coincides with the relation obtained from considerations of ambiguous discrimination, and the quantifiers suggested by unambiguous discrimination provide us with additional duality relations. In contrast to earlier similar works, the path asymmetry of the interferometer provides the ensemble to be discriminated, and therefore there is no need to introduce which-path detectors.

Physical Review A•Aug 4, 2020•20 citations

A generalized wave-particle duality relation for finite groups

E. Bagán, John Calsamiglia, János A Bergou +1 more

Abstract Wave-particle duality relations express the fact that knowledge about the path a particle took suppresses information about its wave-like properties, in particular, its ability to generate an interference pattern. Recently, duality relations in which the wave-like properties are quantified by using measures of quantum coherence have been proposed. Quantum coherence can be generalized to a property called group asymmetry. Here we derive a generalized duality relation involving group asymmetry, which is closely related to the success probability of discriminating between the actions of the elements of a group. The second quantity in the duality relation, the one generalizing which path information, is related to information about the irreducible representations that make up the group representation.

arXiv:1803.04079•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Apr 3, 2018•6 citations

Wave-Particle Duality via Quantum Fisher Information

Chang Niu, Sixia Yu

Quantum Fisher information (QFI) plays an important role in quantum metrology, placing the ultimate limit to how precise we can estimate some unknown parameter and thus quantifying how much information we can extract. We observe that both the wave and particle properties within a Mach–Zehnder interferometer can naturally be quantified by QFI. Firstly, the particle property can be quantified by how well one can estimate the a priori probability of the path taken by the particle within the interferometer. Secondly, as the interference pattern is always related to some phase difference, the wave property can be quantified by how well one can estimate the phase parameter of the original state. With QFI as the unified figure of merit for both properties, we propose a more general and stronger wave-particle duality relation than the original one derived by Englert.

Chinese Physics Letters•Sep 25, 2023•6 citations

Unifying wave-particle duality with entropic uncertainty: Multi-path interferometers

Patrick J. Coles

An interferometer - no matter how clever the design - cannot allow the experimenter to see both the wave and particle behavior of a quantum system. This fundamental idea has been captured quantitatively by inequalities, so-called wave-particle duality relations (WPDRs), that upper bound the sum of the path distinguishability (particle behavior) and fringe visibility (wave behavior). Another fundamental quantum concept is Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, stating that some pairs of observables cannot be known simultaneously. The distinction between these two concepts has been debated in the literature. Here we provide closure to the debate by showing that WPDRs correspond to a modern formulation of the uncertainty principle, namely, the uncertainty relation for the min- and max-entropies, which is used in quantum cryptography. At the technical level, our unification relies on a novel operational meaning for the max-entropy in terms of the guessing probability. Furthermore, our unification provides a framework for solving an outstanding problem of how to rigorously prove WPDRs for interferometers with more than two paths, and we employ this framework to derive some novel WPDRs.

•Dec 30, 2015•1 citation

Duality relation between coherence and path information in the presence of quantum memory

Bu, K., Li, L., Wu, J. +1 more

Wave-particle duality demonstrates a competition relation between wave and particle behavior for a particle going through an interferometer. This duality can be formulated as an inequality, which upper bounds the sum of interference visibility and path information. However, if the particle is entangled with a quantum memory, then the bound may decrease. Here, we find the duality relation between coherence and path information for a particle going through a multipath interferometer in the presence of a quantum memory, offering an upper bound on the duality relation which is directly connected with the amount of entanglement between the particle and the quantum memory.

•Jan 1, 2018•12 citations
We give operational meaning to wave-particle duality in terms of discrimination games. Duality arises as a constraint on the probability of winning these games. The games are played with the aid of an n-port interferometer, and involve 3 parties, Alice and Bob, who cooperate, and the House, who supervises the game. In one game called ways they attempt to determine the path of a particle in the interferometer. In another, called phases, they attempt to determine which set of known phases have been applied to the different paths. The House determines which game is to be played by flipping a coin. We find a tight wave-particle duality relation that allows us to relate the probabilities of winning these games, and use it to find an upper bound on the probability of winning the combined game. This procedure allows us to express wave-particle duality in terms of discrimination probabilities.
Abstract Duality games are a way of looking at wave–particle duality. In these games. Alice and Bob together are playing against the house. The house specifies, at random, which of two sub-games Alice and Bob will play. One game, Ways, requires that they obtain path information about a particle going through an N -path interferometer and the other, Phases, requires that they obtain phase information. In general, because of wave–particle duality, Alice and Bob cannot always win the overall game. However, if the required amount of path and phase information is not too great, for example specifying a set of paths or phases, one of which is the right one, then they can always win. Here we study examples of duality games that can always be won, and develop a wave–particle duality relation expressed only in terms of mutual information to help analyze these games.
We consider the problem of quantitative wave-particle duality from the perspective of quantum state discrimination. Specifically, we obtain quantifiers of both the particle aspect and the wave aspect from state discrimination. We show that the familiar one-bet duality relation coincides with the relation obtained from considerations of ambiguous discrimination, and the quantifiers suggested by unambiguous discrimination provide us with additional duality relations. In contrast to earlier similar works, the path asymmetry of the interferometer provides the ensemble to be discriminated, and therefore there is no need to introduce which-path detectors.
Abstract Wave-particle duality relations express the fact that knowledge about the path a particle took suppresses information about its wave-like properties, in particular, its ability to generate an interference pattern. Recently, duality relations in which the wave-like properties are quantified by using measures of quantum coherence have been proposed. Quantum coherence can be generalized to a property called group asymmetry. Here we derive a generalized duality relation involving group asymmetry, which is closely related to the success probability of discriminating between the actions of the elements of a group. The second quantity in the duality relation, the one generalizing which path information, is related to information about the irreducible representations that make up the group representation.
Quantum Fisher information (QFI) plays an important role in quantum metrology, placing the ultimate limit to how precise we can estimate some unknown parameter and thus quantifying how much information we can extract. We observe that both the wave and particle properties within a Mach–Zehnder interferometer can naturally be quantified by QFI. Firstly, the particle property can be quantified by how well one can estimate the a priori probability of the path taken by the particle within the interferometer. Secondly, as the interference pattern is always related to some phase difference, the wave property can be quantified by how well one can estimate the phase parameter of the original state. With QFI as the unified figure of merit for both properties, we propose a more general and stronger wave-particle duality relation than the original one derived by Englert.
An interferometer - no matter how clever the design - cannot allow the experimenter to see both the wave and particle behavior of a quantum system. This fundamental idea has been captured quantitatively by inequalities, so-called wave-particle duality relations (WPDRs), that upper bound the sum of the path distinguishability (particle behavior) and fringe visibility (wave behavior). Another fundamental quantum concept is Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, stating that some pairs of observables cannot be known simultaneously. The distinction between these two concepts has been debated in the literature. Here we provide closure to the debate by showing that WPDRs correspond to a modern formulation of the uncertainty principle, namely, the uncertainty relation for the min- and max-entropies, which is used in quantum cryptography. At the technical level, our unification relies on a novel operational meaning for the max-entropy in terms of the guessing probability. Furthermore, our unification provides a framework for solving an outstanding problem of how to rigorously prove WPDRs for interferometers with more than two paths, and we employ this framework to derive some novel WPDRs.
Wave-particle duality demonstrates a competition relation between wave and particle behavior for a particle going through an interferometer. This duality can be formulated as an inequality, which upper bounds the sum of interference visibility and path information. However, if the particle is entangled with a quantum memory, then the bound may decrease. Here, we find the duality relation between coherence and path information for a particle going through a multipath interferometer in the presence of a quantum memory, offering an upper bound on the duality relation which is directly connected with the amount of entanglement between the particle and the quantum memory.