Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1704.02270 · New Journal of Physics

General measure for macroscopic quantum states beyond ‘dead and alive’

Pavel Sekatski, Benjamin Yadin, Marc-Olivier Renou, Wolfgang Dür, Nicolas Gisin, Florian Fröwis

Published Jan 22, 2018• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider the characterization of quantum superposition states beyond the pattern ‘dead and alive’. We propose a measure that is applicable to superpositions of multiple macroscopically distinct states, superpositions with different weights as well as mixed states. The measure is based on the mutual information to characterize the distinguishability between the multiple branches of the superposition. This allows us to overcome limitations of previous proposals, and to bridge the gap between general measures for macroscopic quantumness and measures for Schrödinger-cat type superpositions. We discuss a number of relevant examples, provide an alternative definition using basis-dependent quantum discord and reveal connections to other proposals in the literature. Finally, we also show the connection between the size of quantum states as quantified by our measure and their vulnerability to noise.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/aa84de

Related papers

Bell Inequalities with Schrödinger Cats

M. D. Reid

Abstract In the Schrödinger cat gedanken experiment a “cat” is in a quantum superposition of two macroscopically distinct states. There is the apparent interpretation that the “cat” is not in one state or the other, “alive” or “dead”. Here this interpretation is proved objectively. I propose the following definition of macroscopic reality: first, that the “cat” is either dead or alive, the measurement revealing which; second, that measurements on other “cats” some distance away cannot induce the macroscopic change, “dead” to “alive” and vice versa, to the “cat”. The predictions of quantum mechanics are shown to be incompatible with this premise.

Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A•Feb 1, 2001•5 citations

Measurement- and comparison-based sizes of Schrödinger cat states of light

Tyler J. Volkoff, K. Birgitta Whaley

We extend several measurement-based definitions of effective superposition size to coherent state superpositions with branches composed of either single coherent states or tensor products of coherent states. These measures of superposition size depend on determining the maximal quantum distinguishability of certain states associated with the superposition state: e.g., in one measure, the maximal distinguishability of the branches of the superposition is considered as in quantum binary decision theory; in another measure, the maximal distinguishability of the initial superposition and its image after a one-parameter evolution generated by a local Hermitian operator is of interest. The scaling of the size of the superposition with the number of modes and mode intensity (i.e., photon number) is compared to the scaling of certain geometric properties of the Wigner function of the superposition and also to the superposition size estimated experimentally from decoherence. We also apply earlier comparison-based methods for determining macroscopic superposition size that require a reference Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) state. The case of a hierarchical Schr\"odinger cat state with branches composed of smaller superpositions is also analyzed from a measurement-based perspective.

arXiv:1310.6053•Physical Review A•Jan 23, 2014•21 citations

Proposal to test quantum mechanics against macroscopic realism using continuous variable entanglement: a definitive signature of a Schrödinger cat

M. D. Reid

In the Schrödinger-cat gedanken experiment a cat is in a quantum superposition of two macroscopically distinct states, alive and dead.The paradoxical interpretation of quantum mechanics is that the cat is not in one state or the other, alive or dead, immediately prior to its measurement. Because of this apparent defiance of macroscopic reality, quantum superpositions of states macroscopically distinct have generated much interest. Here we address the issue of proving a contradiction with macroscopic reality objectively, through the testable predictions of quantum mechanics. We consider the premises of macroscopic reality (that the ``cat'' is either ``dead'' or ``alive'', the measurement indicating which) and macroscopic locality (that simultaneous measurements some distance away cannot induce the macroscopic change, ``dead'' to ``alive'' and vice versa, to the ``cat''). The predictions of quantum mechanics for certain states, generated using states exhibiting continuous variable entanglement, are shown to be incompatible with the predictions of all theories based on this dual premise. Our proof is along the lines of Bell's theorem, but where all relevant measurements give macroscopically distinct results.

arXiv:quant-ph/0101052•Jan 12, 2001•7 citations

Review and suggested resolution of the problem of Schrodinger’s cat

Art Hobson

This paper reviews and suggests a resolution of the problem of definite outcomes of measurement. This problem, also known as ‘Schrodinger’s cat’, has long posed an apparent paradox because the state resulting from a measurement appears to be a quantum superposition in which the detector is in two macroscopically distinct states (alive and dead in the case of the cat) simultaneously. Many alternative interpretations of the quantum mathematical formalism, and several alternative modifications of the theory, have been proposed to resolve this problem, but no consensus has formed supporting any one of them. Applying standard quantum theory to the measurement state, together with the analysis and results of decades of nonlocality experiments with pairs of entangled systems, this paper shows the entangled measurement state is not a paradoxical macroscopic superposition of states. It is instead a phase-dependent superposition of correlations between states of the subsystems. Thus Schrodinger’s cat is a non-paradoxical ‘macroscopic correlation’ in which one of the two correlated systems happens to be a detector. This insight resolves the problem of definite outcomes but it does not entirely resolve the measurement problem because the entangled state is still reversible.

arXiv:1711.11082•Contemporary Physics•Nov 28, 2017•20 citations

Measurement-based measure of the size of macroscopic quantum superpositions

Jan Ivar Korsbakken, K. Birgitta Whaley, Jonathan L. DuBois +1 more

Recent experiments claiming the formation of quantum superposition states in near-macroscopic systems raise the question of how the sizes of general quantum superposition states in an interacting system are to be quantified. We propose here a measure of size for such superposition states that is based on what measurements can be performed to probe and distinguish the different branches of the state. The measure allows the comparison of the effective size for superposition states in very different physical systems. It can be applied to a very general class of superposition states and reproduces known results for near-ideal cases. Comparison with a prior measure based on analysis of coherence between branches indicates that significantly smaller effective superposition sizes result from our measurement-based measure. Application to a system of interacting bosons in a double-well trapping potential shows that the effective superposition size is strongly dependent on the relative magnitude of the barrier height and interparticle interaction.

arXiv:quant-ph/0611121•Physical Review A•Apr 13, 2007•96 citations

Entanglement of macroscopically distinct states of light

Demid Sychev, Valeriy A. Novikov, Khurram K. Pirov +2 more

Schrödinger's famous Gedankenexperiment has inspired multiple generations of physicists to think about apparent paradoxes that arise when the logic of quantum physics is applied to macroscopic objects. The development of quantum technologies enabled us to produce physical analogues of Schrödinger's cats, such as superpositions of macroscopically distinct states as well as entangled states of microscopic and macroscopic entities. Here we take one step further and prepare an optical state which, in Schrödinger's language, is equivalent to a superposition of two cats, one of which is dead and the other alive, but it is not known in which state each individual cat is. Specifically, the alive and dead states are, respectively, the displaced single photon and displaced vacuum (coherent state), with the magnitude of displacement being on a scale of $10^8$ photons. These two states have significantly different photon statistics and are therefore macroscopically distinguishable.

arXiv:1811.01041•Optica•Nov 8, 2019•10 citations
We consider the characterization of quantum superposition states beyond the pattern ‘dead and alive’. We propose a measure that is applicable to superpositions of multiple macroscopically distinct states, superpositions with different weights as well as mixed states. The measure is based on the mutual information to characterize the distinguishability between the multiple branches of the superposition. This allows us to overcome limitations of previous proposals, and to bridge the gap between general measures for macroscopic quantumness and measures for Schrödinger-cat type superpositions. We discuss a number of relevant examples, provide an alternative definition using basis-dependent quantum discord and reveal connections to other proposals in the literature. Finally, we also show the connection between the size of quantum states as quantified by our measure and their vulnerability to noise.
Abstract In the Schrödinger cat gedanken experiment a “cat” is in a quantum superposition of two macroscopically distinct states. There is the apparent interpretation that the “cat” is not in one state or the other, “alive” or “dead”. Here this interpretation is proved objectively. I propose the following definition of macroscopic reality: first, that the “cat” is either dead or alive, the measurement revealing which; second, that measurements on other “cats” some distance away cannot induce the macroscopic change, “dead” to “alive” and vice versa, to the “cat”. The predictions of quantum mechanics are shown to be incompatible with this premise.
We extend several measurement-based definitions of effective superposition size to coherent state superpositions with branches composed of either single coherent states or tensor products of coherent states. These measures of superposition size depend on determining the maximal quantum distinguishability of certain states associated with the superposition state: e.g., in one measure, the maximal distinguishability of the branches of the superposition is considered as in quantum binary decision theory; in another measure, the maximal distinguishability of the initial superposition and its image after a one-parameter evolution generated by a local Hermitian operator is of interest. The scaling of the size of the superposition with the number of modes and mode intensity (i.e., photon number) is compared to the scaling of certain geometric properties of the Wigner function of the superposition and also to the superposition size estimated experimentally from decoherence. We also apply earlier comparison-based methods for determining macroscopic superposition size that require a reference Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) state. The case of a hierarchical Schr\"odinger cat state with branches composed of smaller superpositions is also analyzed from a measurement-based perspective.
In the Schrödinger-cat gedanken experiment a cat is in a quantum superposition of two macroscopically distinct states, alive and dead.The paradoxical interpretation of quantum mechanics is that the cat is not in one state or the other, alive or dead, immediately prior to its measurement. Because of this apparent defiance of macroscopic reality, quantum superpositions of states macroscopically distinct have generated much interest. Here we address the issue of proving a contradiction with macroscopic reality objectively, through the testable predictions of quantum mechanics. We consider the premises of macroscopic reality (that the ``cat'' is either ``dead'' or ``alive'', the measurement indicating which) and macroscopic locality (that simultaneous measurements some distance away cannot induce the macroscopic change, ``dead'' to ``alive'' and vice versa, to the ``cat''). The predictions of quantum mechanics for certain states, generated using states exhibiting continuous variable entanglement, are shown to be incompatible with the predictions of all theories based on this dual premise. Our proof is along the lines of Bell's theorem, but where all relevant measurements give macroscopically distinct results.
This paper reviews and suggests a resolution of the problem of definite outcomes of measurement. This problem, also known as ‘Schrodinger’s cat’, has long posed an apparent paradox because the state resulting from a measurement appears to be a quantum superposition in which the detector is in two macroscopically distinct states (alive and dead in the case of the cat) simultaneously. Many alternative interpretations of the quantum mathematical formalism, and several alternative modifications of the theory, have been proposed to resolve this problem, but no consensus has formed supporting any one of them. Applying standard quantum theory to the measurement state, together with the analysis and results of decades of nonlocality experiments with pairs of entangled systems, this paper shows the entangled measurement state is not a paradoxical macroscopic superposition of states. It is instead a phase-dependent superposition of correlations between states of the subsystems. Thus Schrodinger’s cat is a non-paradoxical ‘macroscopic correlation’ in which one of the two correlated systems happens to be a detector. This insight resolves the problem of definite outcomes but it does not entirely resolve the measurement problem because the entangled state is still reversible.
Recent experiments claiming the formation of quantum superposition states in near-macroscopic systems raise the question of how the sizes of general quantum superposition states in an interacting system are to be quantified. We propose here a measure of size for such superposition states that is based on what measurements can be performed to probe and distinguish the different branches of the state. The measure allows the comparison of the effective size for superposition states in very different physical systems. It can be applied to a very general class of superposition states and reproduces known results for near-ideal cases. Comparison with a prior measure based on analysis of coherence between branches indicates that significantly smaller effective superposition sizes result from our measurement-based measure. Application to a system of interacting bosons in a double-well trapping potential shows that the effective superposition size is strongly dependent on the relative magnitude of the barrier height and interparticle interaction.
Schrödinger's famous Gedankenexperiment has inspired multiple generations of physicists to think about apparent paradoxes that arise when the logic of quantum physics is applied to macroscopic objects. The development of quantum technologies enabled us to produce physical analogues of Schrödinger's cats, such as superpositions of macroscopically distinct states as well as entangled states of microscopic and macroscopic entities. Here we take one step further and prepare an optical state which, in Schrödinger's language, is equivalent to a superposition of two cats, one of which is dead and the other alive, but it is not known in which state each individual cat is. Specifically, the alive and dead states are, respectively, the displaced single photon and displaced vacuum (coherent state), with the magnitude of displacement being on a scale of 10810^8108 photons. These two states have significantly different photon statistics and are therefore macroscopically distinguishable.