Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1310.6053 · Physical Review A

Measurement- and comparison-based sizes of Schrödinger cat states of light

Tyler J. Volkoff, K. Birgitta Whaley

Published Jan 23, 2014• 17 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We extend several measurement-based definitions of effective superposition size to coherent state superpositions with branches composed of either single coherent states or tensor products of coherent states. These measures of superposition size depend on determining the maximal quantum distinguishability of certain states associated with the superposition state: e.g., in one measure, the maximal distinguishability of the branches of the superposition is considered as in quantum binary decision theory; in another measure, the maximal distinguishability of the initial superposition and its image after a one-parameter evolution generated by a local Hermitian operator is of interest. The scaling of the size of the superposition with the number of modes and mode intensity (i.e., photon number) is compared to the scaling of certain geometric properties of the Wigner function of the superposition and also to the superposition size estimated experimentally from decoherence. We also apply earlier comparison-based methods for determining macroscopic superposition size that require a reference Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) state. The case of a hierarchical Schr\"odinger cat state with branches composed of smaller superpositions is also analyzed from a measurement-based perspective.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.89.012122

Related papers

Macroscopicity of quantum superpositions on a one-parameter unitary path in Hilbert space

Tyler J. Volkoff, K. Birgitta Whaley

We analyze quantum states formed as superpositions of an initial pure product state and its image under local unitary evolution, using two measurement-based measures of superposition size: one based on the optimal quantum binary distinguishability of the branches of the superposition and another based on the ratio of the maximal quantum Fisher information of the superposition to that of its branches, i.e., the relative metrological usefulness of the superposition. A general formula for the effective sizes of these states according to the branch-distinguishability measure is obtained and applied to superposition states of $N$ quantum harmonic oscillators composed of Gaussian branches. Considering optimal distinguishability of pure states on a time-evolution path leads naturally to a notion of distinguishability time that generalizes the well-known orthogonalization times of Mandelstam and Tamm and Margolus and Levitin. We further show that the distinguishability time provides a compact operational expression for the superposition size measure based on the relative quantum Fisher information. By restricting the maximization procedure in the definition of this measure to an appropriate algebra of observables, we show that the superposition size of, e.g., NOON states and hierarchical cat states, can scale linearly with the number of elementary particles comprising the superposition state, implying precision scaling inversely with the total number of photons when these states are employed as probes in quantum parameter estimation of a 1-local Hamiltonian in this algebra.

arXiv:1407.3319•Physical Review A•Dec 18, 2014•9 citations

Measurement-based measure of the size of macroscopic quantum superpositions

Jan Ivar Korsbakken, K. Birgitta Whaley, Jonathan L. DuBois +1 more

Recent experiments claiming the formation of quantum superposition states in near-macroscopic systems raise the question of how the sizes of general quantum superposition states in an interacting system are to be quantified. We propose here a measure of size for such superposition states that is based on what measurements can be performed to probe and distinguish the different branches of the state. The measure allows the comparison of the effective size for superposition states in very different physical systems. It can be applied to a very general class of superposition states and reproduces known results for near-ideal cases. Comparison with a prior measure based on analysis of coherence between branches indicates that significantly smaller effective superposition sizes result from our measurement-based measure. Application to a system of interacting bosons in a double-well trapping potential shows that the effective superposition size is strongly dependent on the relative magnitude of the barrier height and interparticle interaction.

arXiv:quant-ph/0611121•Physical Review A•Apr 13, 2007•94 citations

Measuring the size of a quantum superposition of many-body states

Florian Marquardt, Benjamin Abel, Jan von Delft

We propose a measure for the ``size'' of a quantum superposition of two many-body states with (supposedly) macroscopically distinct properties by counting how many single-particle operations are needed to map one state onto the other. This definition gives sensible results for simple, analytically tractable cases and is consistent with a previous definition restricted to Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger-like states. We apply our measure to the experimentally relevant, nontrivial example of a superconducting three-junction flux qubit put into a superposition of left- and right-circulating supercurrent states, and we find the size of this superposition to be surprisingly small.

arXiv:quant-ph/0609007•Physical Review A•Jul 18, 2008•82 citations

Two-mode squeezed states as Schrödinger cat-like states

Enky Oudot, Pavel Sekatski, Florian Fröwis +2 more

In recent years, there has been an increased interest in the generation of superposition of coherent states with opposite phases, the so-called photonic Schrodinger-cat states. These experiments are very challenging and so far, cats involving small photon numbers only have been implemented. Here, we propose to consider two-mode squeezed states as examples of a Schrodinger-cat-like state. In particular, we are interested in several criteria aiming to identify quantum states that are macroscopic superpositions in a more general sense. We show how these criteria can be extended to continuous variable entangled states. We apply them to various squeezed states, argue that two-mode squeezed vacuum states belong to a class of general Schrodinger-cat states and compare the size of states obtained in several experiments. Our results not only promote two-mode squeezed states for exploring quantum effects at the macroscopic level but also provide direct measures to evaluate their usefulness for quantum metrology.

arXiv:1410.8421•Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Sep 24, 2015•30 citations

Schrödinger’s cat problem: Measurement, decoherence, macroscopic superposition, and definite outcomes

Sachin .

Schrödinger’s cat condenses the quantum measurement problem into an amplification chain: a microscopic alternative becomes correlated with distinguishable records, while linear quantum dynamics retains the records in an entangled state. The problem is not a puzzle about an animal with incompatible predicates. It concerns the relation between unitary dynamics, reduced-state classicality, and observing a outcome. This article develops the cat problem from the density-operator description of measurement, deriving the role of partial tracing and environmental decoherence, and distinguishing a decohered improper mixture from a proper classical ensemble. It examines pointer-state selection, Lindblad dynamics, quantum Darwinism, and responses to the outcome problem: Everettian branching, consistent histories, Bohmian mechanics, and objective-collapse models. Experimental realizations in trapped ions, cavity quantum electrodynamics, and mechanical resonators demonstrate superpositions of distinguishable alternatives. Bosonic cat codes show that macroscopic-superposition structure can be engineered as an information resource. The article identifies four weaknesses: conflating diagonal reduced states with collapse; treating non-equivalent “cat-size” measures as interchangeable; insufficient treatment of environmental noise in collapse tests; and an underdeveloped connection between measurement theory and error-corrected bosonic architectures.

International Journal of Physics and Mathematics•Jul 1, 2025•0 citations

Effective Size of Certain Macroscopic Quantum Superpositions

Wolfgang Dür, Christoph Simon, J. I. Cirac

Several experiments and experimental proposals for the production of macroscopic superpositions naturally lead to states of the general form /phi(1)>( multiply sign in circle N)+/phi 2 >( multiply sign in circle N), where the number of subsystems N is very large, but the states of the individual subsystems have large overlap, /<phi 1/phi 2 >/ 2=1-epsilon 2. We propose two different methods for assigning an effective particle number to such states, using ideal Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states of the form /0>( multiply sign in circle n)+/1>( multiply sign in circle n) as a standard of comparison. The two methods are based on decoherence and on a distillation protocol, respectively. Both lead to an effective size n of the order of N epsilon 2.

arXiv:quant-ph/0205099•Physical Review Letters•Oct 31, 2002•102 citations
We extend several measurement-based definitions of effective superposition size to coherent state superpositions with branches composed of either single coherent states or tensor products of coherent states. These measures of superposition size depend on determining the maximal quantum distinguishability of certain states associated with the superposition state: e.g., in one measure, the maximal distinguishability of the branches of the superposition is considered as in quantum binary decision theory; in another measure, the maximal distinguishability of the initial superposition and its image after a one-parameter evolution generated by a local Hermitian operator is of interest. The scaling of the size of the superposition with the number of modes and mode intensity (i.e., photon number) is compared to the scaling of certain geometric properties of the Wigner function of the superposition and also to the superposition size estimated experimentally from decoherence. We also apply earlier comparison-based methods for determining macroscopic superposition size that require a reference Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) state. The case of a hierarchical Schr"odinger cat state with branches composed of smaller superpositions is also analyzed from a measurement-based perspective.
We analyze quantum states formed as superpositions of an initial pure product state and its image under local unitary evolution, using two measurement-based measures of superposition size: one based on the optimal quantum binary distinguishability of the branches of the superposition and another based on the ratio of the maximal quantum Fisher information of the superposition to that of its branches, i.e., the relative metrological usefulness of the superposition. A general formula for the effective sizes of these states according to the branch-distinguishability measure is obtained and applied to superposition states of NNN quantum harmonic oscillators composed of Gaussian branches. Considering optimal distinguishability of pure states on a time-evolution path leads naturally to a notion of distinguishability time that generalizes the well-known orthogonalization times of Mandelstam and Tamm and Margolus and Levitin. We further show that the distinguishability time provides a compact operational expression for the superposition size measure based on the relative quantum Fisher information. By restricting the maximization procedure in the definition of this measure to an appropriate algebra of observables, we show that the superposition size of, e.g., NOON states and hierarchical cat states, can scale linearly with the number of elementary particles comprising the superposition state, implying precision scaling inversely with the total number of photons when these states are employed as probes in quantum parameter estimation of a 1-local Hamiltonian in this algebra.
Recent experiments claiming the formation of quantum superposition states in near-macroscopic systems raise the question of how the sizes of general quantum superposition states in an interacting system are to be quantified. We propose here a measure of size for such superposition states that is based on what measurements can be performed to probe and distinguish the different branches of the state. The measure allows the comparison of the effective size for superposition states in very different physical systems. It can be applied to a very general class of superposition states and reproduces known results for near-ideal cases. Comparison with a prior measure based on analysis of coherence between branches indicates that significantly smaller effective superposition sizes result from our measurement-based measure. Application to a system of interacting bosons in a double-well trapping potential shows that the effective superposition size is strongly dependent on the relative magnitude of the barrier height and interparticle interaction.
We propose a measure for the ``size'' of a quantum superposition of two many-body states with (supposedly) macroscopically distinct properties by counting how many single-particle operations are needed to map one state onto the other. This definition gives sensible results for simple, analytically tractable cases and is consistent with a previous definition restricted to Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger-like states. We apply our measure to the experimentally relevant, nontrivial example of a superconducting three-junction flux qubit put into a superposition of left- and right-circulating supercurrent states, and we find the size of this superposition to be surprisingly small.
In recent years, there has been an increased interest in the generation of superposition of coherent states with opposite phases, the so-called photonic Schrodinger-cat states. These experiments are very challenging and so far, cats involving small photon numbers only have been implemented. Here, we propose to consider two-mode squeezed states as examples of a Schrodinger-cat-like state. In particular, we are interested in several criteria aiming to identify quantum states that are macroscopic superpositions in a more general sense. We show how these criteria can be extended to continuous variable entangled states. We apply them to various squeezed states, argue that two-mode squeezed vacuum states belong to a class of general Schrodinger-cat states and compare the size of states obtained in several experiments. Our results not only promote two-mode squeezed states for exploring quantum effects at the macroscopic level but also provide direct measures to evaluate their usefulness for quantum metrology.
Schrödinger’s cat condenses the quantum measurement problem into an amplification chain: a microscopic alternative becomes correlated with distinguishable records, while linear quantum dynamics retains the records in an entangled state. The problem is not a puzzle about an animal with incompatible predicates. It concerns the relation between unitary dynamics, reduced-state classicality, and observing a outcome. This article develops the cat problem from the density-operator description of measurement, deriving the role of partial tracing and environmental decoherence, and distinguishing a decohered improper mixture from a proper classical ensemble. It examines pointer-state selection, Lindblad dynamics, quantum Darwinism, and responses to the outcome problem: Everettian branching, consistent histories, Bohmian mechanics, and objective-collapse models. Experimental realizations in trapped ions, cavity quantum electrodynamics, and mechanical resonators demonstrate superpositions of distinguishable alternatives. Bosonic cat codes show that macroscopic-superposition structure can be engineered as an information resource. The article identifies four weaknesses: conflating diagonal reduced states with collapse; treating non-equivalent “cat-size” measures as interchangeable; insufficient treatment of environmental noise in collapse tests; and an underdeveloped connection between measurement theory and error-corrected bosonic architectures.
Several experiments and experimental proposals for the production of macroscopic superpositions naturally lead to states of the general form /phi(1)>( multiply sign in circle N)+/phi 2 >( multiply sign in circle N), where the number of subsystems N is very large, but the states of the individual subsystems have large overlap, /<phi 1/phi 2 >/ 2=1-epsilon 2. We propose two different methods for assigning an effective particle number to such states, using ideal Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states of the form /0>( multiply sign in circle n)+/1>( multiply sign in circle n) as a standard of comparison. The two methods are based on decoherence and on a distillation protocol, respectively. Both lead to an effective size n of the order of N epsilon 2.