Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1702.01724

von Neumann's Formula, Measurements and the Lindblad Equation

Jacques Distler B, Sònia Paban

Published Feb 6, 2017• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We previously remarked that when an observable A has a continuous spectrum, then von Neumann's formula for the post-measurement state needs to be extended and the correct formula ineluctably involves the resolution of the detector used in the measurement. We generalize previous results to compute the uncertainties in successive measurements of more general pairs of observables. We also show that this extended von Neumann's formula for the post-measurement state is a completely positive map and, moreover, that there is a completely-positive interpolation between the pre- and post-measurement states. Weinberg has advocated that the time-evolution during the measurement process should be modeled as an open quantum system and governed by a Lindblad equation. We verify that this is indeed the case for an arbitrary observable, A, and a fairly general class of interpolations.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1702.01724

Related papers

Canonical approximate quantum measurements

Masanao Ozawa

In order to generalize the Wigner formula for the joint probability distribution of successive canonical measurements of discrete observables to continuous observables, a mathematical model is investigated of a canonical approximate measurement of an arbitrary observable, which generalizes von Neumann’s model of measuring interaction and Davies’s covariant instrument for approximate position measurement. Calculations of two types of root-mean-square errors show that this model clears certain requirements for good approximate measurements. A modified Wigner formula for successive canonical approximate measurements of arbitrary observables is established. It is also shown that the canonical approximate measurement of a discrete observable is reduced to the conventional measurement satisfying the von Neumann–Lüders collapse postulate by a minor modification in the process of measurement.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 1993•30 citations

The Uncertainty Principle Revisited

A. Mann, Pier A. Mello, M. Revzen

We study the quantum-mechanical uncertainty relation originating from the successive measurement of two observables $\hat{A}$ and $\hat{B}$, with eigenvalues $a_n$ and $b_m$, respectively, performed on the same system. We use an extension of the von Neumann model of measurement, in which two probes interact with the same system proper at two successive times, so we can exhibit how the disturbing effect of the first interaction affects the second measurement. Detecting the statistical properties of the second {\em probe} variable $Q_2$ conditioned on the first {\em probe} measurement yielding $Q_1$ we obtain information on the statistical distribution of the {\em system} variable $b_m$ conditioned on having found the system variable $a_n$ in the interval $δa$ around $a^{(n)}$. The width of this statistical distribution as function of $δa$ constitutes an {\em uncertainty relation}. We find a general connection of this uncertainty relation with the commutator of the two observables that have been measured successively. We illustrate this relation for the successive measurement of position and momentum in the discrete and in the continuous cases and, within a model, for the successive measurement of a more general class of observables.

arXiv:2006.00347•May 30, 2020•1 citation

Uncertainties in successive measurements

Jacques Distler B, Sònia Paban

When you measure an observable, $A$, in quantum mechanics, the state of the system changes. This, in turn, affects the quantum-mechanical uncertainty in some noncommuting observable, $B$. The standard uncertainty relation puts a lower bound on the uncertainty of $B$ in the initial state. What is relevant for a subsequent measurement of $B$, however, is the uncertainty of $B$ in the postmeasurement state. We re-examine this problem, both in the case where $A$ has a pure point spectrum and in the case where $A$ has a continuous spectrum. In the latter case, the need to include a finite detector resolution, as part of what it means to measure such an observable, has dramatic implications for the result of successive measurements. Ozawa, [Phys. Rev. A 67, 042105 (2003)] proposed an inequality satisfied in the case of successive measurements. Among our results, we show that his inequality is ineffective (can never come close to being saturated). For the cases of interest, we compute a sharper lower bound.

arXiv:1211.4169•Physical Review A•Jun 21, 2013•29 citations

Quantum measuring processes of continuous observables

Masanao Ozawa

The purpose of this paper is to provide a basis of theory of measurements of continuous observables. We generalize von Neumann’s description of measuring processes of discrete quantum observables in terms of interaction between the measured system and the apparatus to continuous observables, and show how every such measuring process determines the state change caused by the measurement. We establish a one-to-one correspondence between completely positive instruments in the sense of Davies and Lewis and the state changes determined by the measuring processes. We also prove that there are no weakly repeatable completely positive instruments of nondiscrete observables in the standard formulation of quantum mechanics, so that there are no measuring processes of nondiscrete observables whose state changes satisfy the repeatability hypothesis. A proof of the Wigner–Araki–Yanase theorem on the nonexistence of repeatable measurements of observables not commuting conserved quantities is given in our framework. We also discuss the implication of these results for the recent results due to Srinivas and due to Mercer on measurements of continuous observables.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jan 1, 1984•503 citations

The von Neumann model of measurement in quantum mechanics

Pier A. Mello

We describe how to obtain information on a quantum-mechanical system by coupling it to a probe and detecting some property of the latter, using a model introduced by von Neumann, which describes the interaction of the system proper with the probe in a dynamical way. We first discuss single measurements, where the system proper is coupled to one probe with arbitrary coupling strength. The goal is to obtain information on the system detecting the probe position. We find the reduced density operator of the system, and show how Lüders rule emerges as the limiting case of strong coupling. The von Neumann model is then generalized to two probes that interact successively with the system proper. Now we find information on the system by detecting the position-position and momentum-position correlations of the two probes. The so-called "Wigner's formula" emerges in the strong-coupling limit, while "Kirkwood's quasi-probability distribution" is found as the weak-coupling limit of the above formalism. We show that successive measurements can be used to develop a state-reconstruction scheme. Finally, we find a generalized transform of the state and the observables based on the notion of successive measurements.

arXiv:1311.7649•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2014•12 citations

Continuous time limit of repeated quantum observations

Bernhard Neukirchen

In this thesis we study the problem of continuous measurement on an open quantum system.The starting point of our analysis is the time-evolution of an open quantum system where the evolution of the environment is not explicitly described, i.e. traced out.More explicitly we restrict to time-evolutions having the structure of a semigroup or evolution system.That is, for time-points 0 ≤ r ≤ s ≤ t there exists a two-parameter family of completely-positive maps E * (t, s), such that E * (t, s)E * (s, r) = E * (t, r) and the systems state evolved according to ρ(tPhysically this means that in our Ansatz the interaction between system and environment is already fixed and can only be weak.The main goal of this thesis is now to describe, mathematically rigorous, all continuous measurements compatible with the given evolution.A measurement is compatible with the given time-evolution, if the evolution does not change when measurement results are ignored.In other words the measurement is indirect and does not further disturb the systems evolution.Our results can be interpreted as a rigorous construction of continuous matrix product states, and are related to the Hudson-Parthasarathy quantum stochastic calculus.The analysis in this thesis separates into two parts.In the first we study the class of quantum systems having an evolution system structure as described above.Precisely we study the theory of minimal solutions to a Cauchy equation with a generator of Gorini-Kossakowski-Sudarshan-Lindblad type.We do this for the case of time-dependent and unbounded generators.This analysis culminates in the description of a counterexample due to Holevo of a semigroup which is not the minimal solution to such a standard Lindblad equation.In the second part we construct a description of all measurements compatible with a given evolution and thus achieve our main goal.The analysis starts with the discrete-time version of the problem, i.e.where the time-points r, s, t in the above description of the evolution are chosen from a finite set.This discrete-time problem is completely solved by Stinespring dilation theory.We then construct our solution of the continuous-time case as a refinement limit over arbitrary discretizations of the evolution.Hence, our construction gives a continuous-time analogue of the Stinespring dilation for semigroups and evolution systems.It can be interpreted as a complete quantum description of the information the system radiates into the environment, i.e. it yields a quantum state of the environment.We complement the description of the state with a description of the observables for continuous measurements and the calculation expectation values.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations
We previously remarked that when an observable A has a continuous spectrum, then von Neumann's formula for the post-measurement state needs to be extended and the correct formula ineluctably involves the resolution of the detector used in the measurement. We generalize previous results to compute the uncertainties in successive measurements of more general pairs of observables. We also show that this extended von Neumann's formula for the post-measurement state is a completely positive map and, moreover, that there is a completely-positive interpolation between the pre- and post-measurement states. Weinberg has advocated that the time-evolution during the measurement process should be modeled as an open quantum system and governed by a Lindblad equation. We verify that this is indeed the case for an arbitrary observable, A, and a fairly general class of interpolations.
In order to generalize the Wigner formula for the joint probability distribution of successive canonical measurements of discrete observables to continuous observables, a mathematical model is investigated of a canonical approximate measurement of an arbitrary observable, which generalizes von Neumann’s model of measuring interaction and Davies’s covariant instrument for approximate position measurement. Calculations of two types of root-mean-square errors show that this model clears certain requirements for good approximate measurements. A modified Wigner formula for successive canonical approximate measurements of arbitrary observables is established. It is also shown that the canonical approximate measurement of a discrete observable is reduced to the conventional measurement satisfying the von Neumann–Lüders collapse postulate by a minor modification in the process of measurement.
We study the quantum-mechanical uncertainty relation originating from the successive measurement of two observables A^\hat{A}A^ and B^\hat{B}B^, with eigenvalues ana_nan​ and bmb_mbm​, respectively, performed on the same system. We use an extension of the von Neumann model of measurement, in which two probes interact with the same system proper at two successive times, so we can exhibit how the disturbing effect of the first interaction affects the second measurement. Detecting the statistical properties of the second {\em probe} variable Q2Q_2Q2​ conditioned on the first {\em probe} measurement yielding Q1Q_1Q1​ we obtain information on the statistical distribution of the {\em system} variable bmb_mbm​ conditioned on having found the system variable ana_nan​ in the interval δaδaδa around a(n)a^{(n)}a(n). The width of this statistical distribution as function of δaδaδa constitutes an {\em uncertainty relation}. We find a general connection of this uncertainty relation with the commutator of the two observables that have been measured successively. We illustrate this relation for the successive measurement of position and momentum in the discrete and in the continuous cases and, within a model, for the successive measurement of a more general class of observables.
When you measure an observable, AAA, in quantum mechanics, the state of the system changes. This, in turn, affects the quantum-mechanical uncertainty in some noncommuting observable, BBB. The standard uncertainty relation puts a lower bound on the uncertainty of BBB in the initial state. What is relevant for a subsequent measurement of BBB, however, is the uncertainty of BBB in the postmeasurement state. We re-examine this problem, both in the case where AAA has a pure point spectrum and in the case where AAA has a continuous spectrum. In the latter case, the need to include a finite detector resolution, as part of what it means to measure such an observable, has dramatic implications for the result of successive measurements. Ozawa, [Phys. Rev. A 67, 042105 (2003)] proposed an inequality satisfied in the case of successive measurements. Among our results, we show that his inequality is ineffective (can never come close to being saturated). For the cases of interest, we compute a sharper lower bound.
The purpose of this paper is to provide a basis of theory of measurements of continuous observables. We generalize von Neumann’s description of measuring processes of discrete quantum observables in terms of interaction between the measured system and the apparatus to continuous observables, and show how every such measuring process determines the state change caused by the measurement. We establish a one-to-one correspondence between completely positive instruments in the sense of Davies and Lewis and the state changes determined by the measuring processes. We also prove that there are no weakly repeatable completely positive instruments of nondiscrete observables in the standard formulation of quantum mechanics, so that there are no measuring processes of nondiscrete observables whose state changes satisfy the repeatability hypothesis. A proof of the Wigner–Araki–Yanase theorem on the nonexistence of repeatable measurements of observables not commuting conserved quantities is given in our framework. We also discuss the implication of these results for the recent results due to Srinivas and due to Mercer on measurements of continuous observables.
We describe how to obtain information on a quantum-mechanical system by coupling it to a probe and detecting some property of the latter, using a model introduced by von Neumann, which describes the interaction of the system proper with the probe in a dynamical way. We first discuss single measurements, where the system proper is coupled to one probe with arbitrary coupling strength. The goal is to obtain information on the system detecting the probe position. We find the reduced density operator of the system, and show how Lüders rule emerges as the limiting case of strong coupling. The von Neumann model is then generalized to two probes that interact successively with the system proper. Now we find information on the system by detecting the position-position and momentum-position correlations of the two probes. The so-called "Wigner's formula" emerges in the strong-coupling limit, while "Kirkwood's quasi-probability distribution" is found as the weak-coupling limit of the above formalism. We show that successive measurements can be used to develop a state-reconstruction scheme. Finally, we find a generalized transform of the state and the observables based on the notion of successive measurements.
In this thesis we study the problem of continuous measurement on an open quantum system.The starting point of our analysis is the time-evolution of an open quantum system where the evolution of the environment is not explicitly described, i.e. traced out.More explicitly we restrict to time-evolutions having the structure of a semigroup or evolution system.That is, for time-points 0 ≤ r ≤ s ≤ t there exists a two-parameter family of completely-positive maps E * (t, s), such that E * (t, s)E * (s, r) = E * (t, r) and the systems state evolved according to ρ(tPhysically this means that in our Ansatz the interaction between system and environment is already fixed and can only be weak.The main goal of this thesis is now to describe, mathematically rigorous, all continuous measurements compatible with the given evolution.A measurement is compatible with the given time-evolution, if the evolution does not change when measurement results are ignored.In other words the measurement is indirect and does not further disturb the systems evolution.Our results can be interpreted as a rigorous construction of continuous matrix product states, and are related to the Hudson-Parthasarathy quantum stochastic calculus.The analysis in this thesis separates into two parts.In the first we study the class of quantum systems having an evolution system structure as described above.Precisely we study the theory of minimal solutions to a Cauchy equation with a generator of Gorini-Kossakowski-Sudarshan-Lindblad type.We do this for the case of time-dependent and unbounded generators.This analysis culminates in the description of a counterexample due to Holevo of a semigroup which is not the minimal solution to such a standard Lindblad equation.In the second part we construct a description of all measurements compatible with a given evolution and thus achieve our main goal.The analysis starts with the discrete-time version of the problem, i.e.where the time-points r, s, t in the above description of the evolution are chosen from a finite set.This discrete-time problem is completely solved by Stinespring dilation theory.We then construct our solution of the continuous-time case as a refinement limit over arbitrary discretizations of the evolution.Hence, our construction gives a continuous-time analogue of the Stinespring dilation for semigroups and evolution systems.It can be interpreted as a complete quantum description of the information the system radiates into the environment, i.e. it yields a quantum state of the environment.We complement the description of the state with a description of the observables for continuous measurements and the calculation expectation values.