Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1610.04773 · Physical review. D/Physical review. D.

Evolution without evolution and without ambiguities

Chiara Marletto, Vlatko Vedral

Published Feb 13, 2017• 71 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In quantum theory it is possible to explain time, and dynamics, in terms of entanglement. This is the timeless approach to time, which assumes that the universe is in a stationary state, where two noninteracting subsystems, the ``clock'' and the ``rest,'' are entangled. As a consequence, by choosing a suitable observable of the clock, the relative state of the rest of the universe evolves unitarily with respect to the variable labeling the clock observable's eigenstates, which is then interpreted as time. This model for an ``evolution without evolution'' (Page and Wootters, 1983), albeit elegant, has never been developed further, because it was criticized for generating severe ambiguities in the dynamics of the rest of the universe. In this paper we show that there are no such ambiguities; we also update the model, making it amenable to possible new applications.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.95.043510

Related papers

Measuring time in a timeless universe

Samuel Kuypers, Simone Rijavec

Physical systems are usually assumed to evolve relative to an external time parameter, which is problematic because in quantum theory that parameter is not a physical observable. Page and Wootters (1984) solved this by proposing that the Universe is in a stationary state, eliminating the need for the external time parameter. Instead, their model contains an isolated subsystem, a clock, with which other subsystems are entangled, making the latter appear to evolve relative to different states of the clock. While this resolves the problem of the time parameter, the assumption that the clock is isolated prevents it from being measured, as this requires an interaction with another system. We prove that the clock can be measured while preserving the core features of the Page-Wootters construction. We also discuss clock synchronization.

arXiv:2406.14642•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Aug 24, 2025•6 citations

Quantum clock frames: Uncertainty relations, non-Hermitian dynamics and nonlocality in time

Eliahu Cohen

Abstract Dynamical evolution can be reconstructed within stationary, closed quantum systems by employing the Page-Wootters “timeless approach”. When conditioning upon the state of a “clock” subsystem, the rest of the system regains its time dependence. This mechanism, involving entanglement between the above subsystems has gained much attention during the last few years. After a brief introduction to the topic we will elaborate on a few recent results: The derivation of new time-energy uncertainty relations, emergence of non-Hermitian dynamics when utilizing non-inertial quantum clocks and dynamical nonlocality in quantum time.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2023•1 citation

Entanglement and the ticking of the clock

Andrea Valdés-Hernández, C. G. Maglione, A. P. Majtey +1 more

The concept of entanglement is at the heart of quantum physics.It plays a central role in all quantum phenomena involving composite systems.Interestingly, there is an intriguing idea that has attracted considerable attention recently, according to which quantum entanglement may also be essential for understanding the very emergence of time and dynamical evolution.Within this point of view, sometimes referred to as the timeless picture of quantum dynamics, the Universe is regarded as consisting of a clock and a system (or "rest of the Universe") that are jointly in a stationary quantum state, and time evolution arises as an emergent phenomenon rooted at the entanglement between the clock and the system.Here we provide a pedagogical and self-contained exposition, at the upper undergraduate level, of the role of entanglement in this timeless evolution approach to quantum mechanics.In particular, we give a detailed explanation of how the entanglement between the clock and the system is directly and quantitatively related to the average distinguishability between the states of the system at different times.

Revista Brasileira de Ensino de Física•Jan 1, 2020•1 citation

Emergent dynamics from entangled mixed states

Andrea Valdés-Hernández, C. G. Maglione, A. P. Majtey +1 more

Entanglement is at the core of quantum physics, playing a central role in quantum phenomena involving composite systems. According to the timeless picture of quantum dynamics, entanglement may also be essential for understanding the very origins of dynamical evolution and the flow of time. Within this point of view, the Universe is regarded as a bipartite entity comprising a clock $C$ and a system $R$ (or ``rest of the Universe'') jointly described by a global stationary state, and the dynamical evolution of $R$ is construed as an emergent phenomena arising from the entanglement between $C$ and $R$. In spite of substantial recent efforts, many aspects of this approach remain unexplored, particularly those involving mixed states. In the present contribution we investigate the timeless picture of quantum dynamics for mixed states of the clock-system composite, focusing on quantitative relations linking the clock-system entanglement with the emerging dynamical evolution experienced by the system.

arXiv:2009.12451•Physical Review A•Nov 20, 2020•3 citations

Conditions for unitarity in timeless quantum theory

Anonymous

Quantum timeless approaches solve the problem of time by recovering the usual unitary evolution of quantum theory relative to a clock in a stationary quantum universe. For some Hamiltonians of the universe, such as those including an interaction term with the clock, the dynamics is substantially altered and can be nonunitary. This work derives necessary and sufficient conditions for the relative dynamics to be unitary and finds the general form of the unitary evolution operator. A physical interpretation of these conditions is given in terms of the clock’s rate. Unitary dynamics is associated with rates that are constant in time and independent of the clock’s internal structure.

arXiv:2504.01579•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jun 18, 2026•0 citations

The clock ambiguity problem: extended or extinguished?

Ovidiu Cristinel Stoica

I show that the clock ambiguity cannot be solved by a purely relational condition like the noninteraction condition, and it is even stronger, extending to evolution laws. The ambiguity is solved by specifying the physical meaning of observables. Page and Wootters (1983) showed how time and dynamics can emerge from entanglement within a stationary quantum system containing a clock. The clock ambiguity problem is that, from a purely relational stance and without fixing a clock-world split, the emergence is ambiguous, resulting in any possible history (Albrecht 1995). I show that the ambiguity is stronger than previously recognized. Under the relational stance, it extends from histories to the evolution laws themselves. The spectrum of any ideal clock uniformizes the spectra of the world's evolution operators, leaving only the dimension of the Hilbert spaces as invariant information. Fixing the clock-world split can solve the ambiguity, but this would block spacetime symmetries. One might want to remove the ambiguity up to a unitary equivalence by imposing noninteraction, as in Marletto and Vedral (2017). But once the clock spectrum uniformizes the world spectrum, unitary equivalence becomes too coarse to distinguish any two possible world dynamics, which is the result proved here. Thus a purely relational condition such as noninteraction is insufficient. Nor can all different decompositions be regarded as equally valid perspectives, since then records would not be correlated with the events they record, and empirical knowledge would be impossible. The resolution is therefore not to embrace the ambiguity, but to recognize what a bare reading of the Page-Wootters structure omits: the physical meaning of the operators.

quant-pharXiv:2604.21805•Apr 24, 2026•0 citations
In quantum theory it is possible to explain time, and dynamics, in terms of entanglement. This is the timeless approach to time, which assumes that the universe is in a stationary state, where two noninteracting subsystems, the clock'' and the rest,'' are entangled. As a consequence, by choosing a suitable observable of the clock, the relative state of the rest of the universe evolves unitarily with respect to the variable labeling the clock observable's eigenstates, which is then interpreted as time. This model for an ``evolution without evolution'' (Page and Wootters, 1983), albeit elegant, has never been developed further, because it was criticized for generating severe ambiguities in the dynamics of the rest of the universe. In this paper we show that there are no such ambiguities; we also update the model, making it amenable to possible new applications.
Physical systems are usually assumed to evolve relative to an external time parameter, which is problematic because in quantum theory that parameter is not a physical observable. Page and Wootters (1984) solved this by proposing that the Universe is in a stationary state, eliminating the need for the external time parameter. Instead, their model contains an isolated subsystem, a clock, with which other subsystems are entangled, making the latter appear to evolve relative to different states of the clock. While this resolves the problem of the time parameter, the assumption that the clock is isolated prevents it from being measured, as this requires an interaction with another system. We prove that the clock can be measured while preserving the core features of the Page-Wootters construction. We also discuss clock synchronization.
Abstract Dynamical evolution can be reconstructed within stationary, closed quantum systems by employing the Page-Wootters “timeless approach”. When conditioning upon the state of a “clock” subsystem, the rest of the system regains its time dependence. This mechanism, involving entanglement between the above subsystems has gained much attention during the last few years. After a brief introduction to the topic we will elaborate on a few recent results: The derivation of new time-energy uncertainty relations, emergence of non-Hermitian dynamics when utilizing non-inertial quantum clocks and dynamical nonlocality in quantum time.
The concept of entanglement is at the heart of quantum physics.It plays a central role in all quantum phenomena involving composite systems.Interestingly, there is an intriguing idea that has attracted considerable attention recently, according to which quantum entanglement may also be essential for understanding the very emergence of time and dynamical evolution.Within this point of view, sometimes referred to as the timeless picture of quantum dynamics, the Universe is regarded as consisting of a clock and a system (or "rest of the Universe") that are jointly in a stationary quantum state, and time evolution arises as an emergent phenomenon rooted at the entanglement between the clock and the system.Here we provide a pedagogical and self-contained exposition, at the upper undergraduate level, of the role of entanglement in this timeless evolution approach to quantum mechanics.In particular, we give a detailed explanation of how the entanglement between the clock and the system is directly and quantitatively related to the average distinguishability between the states of the system at different times.
Entanglement is at the core of quantum physics, playing a central role in quantum phenomena involving composite systems. According to the timeless picture of quantum dynamics, entanglement may also be essential for understanding the very origins of dynamical evolution and the flow of time. Within this point of view, the Universe is regarded as a bipartite entity comprising a clock CCC and a system RRR (or ``rest of the Universe'') jointly described by a global stationary state, and the dynamical evolution of RRR is construed as an emergent phenomena arising from the entanglement between CCC and RRR. In spite of substantial recent efforts, many aspects of this approach remain unexplored, particularly those involving mixed states. In the present contribution we investigate the timeless picture of quantum dynamics for mixed states of the clock-system composite, focusing on quantitative relations linking the clock-system entanglement with the emerging dynamical evolution experienced by the system.
Quantum timeless approaches solve the problem of time by recovering the usual unitary evolution of quantum theory relative to a clock in a stationary quantum universe. For some Hamiltonians of the universe, such as those including an interaction term with the clock, the dynamics is substantially altered and can be nonunitary. This work derives necessary and sufficient conditions for the relative dynamics to be unitary and finds the general form of the unitary evolution operator. A physical interpretation of these conditions is given in terms of the clock’s rate. Unitary dynamics is associated with rates that are constant in time and independent of the clock’s internal structure.
I show that the clock ambiguity cannot be solved by a purely relational condition like the noninteraction condition, and it is even stronger, extending to evolution laws. The ambiguity is solved by specifying the physical meaning of observables. Page and Wootters (1983) showed how time and dynamics can emerge from entanglement within a stationary quantum system containing a clock. The clock ambiguity problem is that, from a purely relational stance and without fixing a clock-world split, the emergence is ambiguous, resulting in any possible history (Albrecht 1995). I show that the ambiguity is stronger than previously recognized. Under the relational stance, it extends from histories to the evolution laws themselves. The spectrum of any ideal clock uniformizes the spectra of the world's evolution operators, leaving only the dimension of the Hilbert spaces as invariant information. Fixing the clock-world split can solve the ambiguity, but this would block spacetime symmetries. One might want to remove the ambiguity up to a unitary equivalence by imposing noninteraction, as in Marletto and Vedral (2017). But once the clock spectrum uniformizes the world spectrum, unitary equivalence becomes too coarse to distinguish any two possible world dynamics, which is the result proved here. Thus a purely relational condition such as noninteraction is insufficient. Nor can all different decompositions be regarded as equally valid perspectives, since then records would not be correlated with the events they record, and empirical knowledge would be impossible. The resolution is therefore not to embrace the ambiguity, but to recognize what a bare reading of the Page-Wootters structure omits: the physical meaning of the operators.