Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1605.09392 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Multi-triplet bound states and finite-temperature dynamics in highly frustrated quantum spin ladders

A. Honecker, Frédéric Mila, Bruce Normand

Published Sep 2, 2016• 13 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Low-dimensional quantum magnets at finite temperatures present a complex interplay of quantum and thermal fluctuation effects in a restricted phase space. While some information about dynamical response functions is available from theoretical studies of the one-triplet dispersion in unfrustrated chains and ladders, little is known about the finite-temperature dynamics of frustrated systems. Experimentally, inelastic neutron scattering studies of the highly frustrated two-dimensional material ${\mathrm{SrCu}}_{2}{({\mathrm{BO}}_{3})}_{2}$ show an almost complete destruction of the one-triplet excitation band at a temperature only 1/3 of its gap energy, accompanied by strong scattering intensities for apparent multi-triplet excitations. We investigate these questions in the frustrated spin ladder and present numerical results from exact diagonalization for the dynamical structure factor as a function of temperature. We find anomalously rapid transfer of spectral weight out of the one-triplet band and into both broad and sharp spectral features at a wide range of energies, including below the zero-temperature gap of this excitation. These features are multi-triplet bound states, which develop particularly strongly near the quantum phase transition, fall to particularly low energies there, and persist all the way to infinite temperature. Our results offer valuable insight into the physics of finite-temperature spectral functions in ${\mathrm{SrCu}}_{2}{({\mathrm{BO}}_{3})}_{2}$ and many other highly frustrated spin systems.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.94.094402

Related papers

Thermodynamic properties of highly frustrated quantum spin ladders: Influence of many-particle bound states

A. Honecker, Stefan Weßel, René John Kerkdyk +3 more

Quantum antiferromagnets have proven to be some of the cleanest realizations available for theoretical, numerical, and experimental studies of quantum fluctuation effects. At finite temperatures, however, the additional effects of thermal fluctuations in the restricted phase space of a low-dimensional system have received much less attention, particularly the situation in frustrated quantum magnets, where the excitations may be complex collective (bound or even fractionalized) modes. We investigate this problem by studying the thermodynamic properties of the frustrated two-leg $S=\frac{1}{2}$ spin ladder, with particular emphasis on the fully frustrated case. We present numerical results for the magnetic specific heat and susceptibility, obtained from exact diagonalization and quantum Monte Carlo studies, which we show can be rendered free of the sign problem even in a strongly frustrated system and which allow us to reach unprecedented sizes of $L=200$ ladder rungs. We find that frustration effects cause an unconventional evolution of the thermodynamic response across the full parameter regime of the model. However, close to the first-order transition they cause a highly anomalous reduction in temperature scales with no concomitant changes in the gap; the specific heat shows a very narrow peak at very low energies and the susceptibility rises abruptly at extremely low temperatures. Unusually, the two quantities have different gaps over an extended region of the parameter space. We demonstrate that these results reflect the presence of large numbers of multiparticle bound-state excitations, whose energies fall below the one-triplon gap in the transition region.

arXiv:1511.01501•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 8, 2016•48 citations

Neutron Scattering Measurements of Low-Dimensional Quantum Systems

Sara Haravifard

Low dimensional quantum magnets which display a collective singlet ground state and a gap in their magnetic excitation spectrum provide a framework for much exotic phase behavior in new materials, with high temperature superconductivity being the best appreciated example. Neutron scattering techniques can be applied to study a wide variety of problems in condensed matter physics. These techniques are particularly useful as applied to understanding the magnetic properties of quantum magnets that display exotic phases. SrCu2(BO3)2, is a rare example of a two-dimensional quantum magnet for which an exact theoretical solution describing its ground state is known to be a collective singlet. Previous high resolution neutron scattering measurements identified the most prominent features of the spin excitation spectrum in SrCu2(BO3)2, including the presence of one and two triplet excitations and weak dispersion characteristic of subleading terms in the spin Hamiltonian. The resemblance between the spin gap behavior in the Mott insulator SrCu2(BO3)2 and that associated with high temperature superconductors motivated the consideration of the significance of doping in order to understand the properties of this quantum magnetic system. For this reason, a series of neutron scattering studies on doped SrCu2(BO3)2 were initiated. These series of investigations began with the performance of neutron scattering measurements on a SrCu(2-x)Mgx(BO3)2 single crystal in order to introduce magnetic vacancies to the system. These results revealed the presence of new spin excitations within the singlet-triplet gap of this system. Application of a magnetic field induces Zeeman-split states associated with un-paired spins which exist as a consequence of doping with quenched non-magnetic impurities. Additional substantial broadening of both the one and two triplet excitations is observed in the doped system as compared to the pure system. Theoretical calculations are shown to qualitatively account for these features. These studies were extended to neutron scattering measurements on Sr(1-x)LaxCu2(BO3)2, with an aim of introducing charged carriers into this system. The broadening of the one and two triplet excitations is observed and compared to the thermally induced finite lifetime of the pure system. The temperature dependence of this broadening in Sr(1-x)LaxCu2(BO3)2 is different compared to that observed in both SrCu2(BO3)2 and SrCu(2-x)Mgx(BO3)2. It has also been suggested that there is a relation between the spin-lattice interaction in SrCu2(BO3)2 and the magnetic dynamics at low temperatures and high magnetic fields. For this reason there has been increased interest in the study of the crystalline structure and vibrational modes of SrCu2(BO3)2. In order to investigate the role of the lattice in the formation of the singlet ground state in SrCu2(BO3)2, a series of low and high energy neutron scattering measurements were carried out on this system to study both the crystalline structure as well as the normal modes of vibration of the lattice, the transverse acoustic and optical phonons. Transverse acoustic phonons with energies comparable to and higher than the onset of the two triplet continuum show substantially increased lifetimes on entering the singlet ground state below ~ 10 K. This may indicate the removal of the decay channel for the phonons due to the gapping of the spin excitation spectrum in SrCu2(BO3)2 at low temperatures. In high energy inelastic neutron scattering we observe broadening of optic phonons in the ~ 52 to 65 meV region on entering the low temperature singlet ground state. Additionally, the magnetic properties of CuMoO4, which is a triclinic quantum magnet system based on S=1/2 moments at the Cu2+ site, were studied using elastic and inelastic neutron scattering experiments. This material exhibits a first order structural phase transition at ~ 190 K as well as a magnetic phase transition at ~ 1.75 K. We were primarily interested in the low temperature magnetic properties of this material. Magnetization and heat capacity measurements as well as elastic and inelastic neutron scattering measurements were conducted on this system within the low temperature ordered phase. These studies confirm that this material has a magnetic phase transition at ~ 1.7 K. Neutron scattering results indicate that this magnetically ordered phase is characterized by a doubling of the a axis. Inelastic neutron scattering measurements revealed a gapped magnetic excitation spectrum in zero magnetic field, which could be filled in by the application of magnetic fields approaching 7 T.

•Jan 1, 2009•0 citations

Excitation spectrum of the S=1/2 quantum spin ladder with frustration: Elementary quasiparticles and many-particle bound states

Valeri N. Kotov, Oleg P. Sushkov, R. Eder

The excitation spectrum of the two-chain $S=1/2$ Heisenberg spin ladder with additional second neighbor frustrating interactions is studied by a variety of techniques. A description, based on a mapping of the model onto a Bose gas of hard-core triplets is used to determine the one- and two-particle excitation spectra. We find that low-lying singlet and triplet bound states are present and their binding energy increases with increasing frustration. In addition, many-particle bound states are found by exact diagonalization and variational methods. We prove that the larger the number of bound particles the larger the binding energy. Thus the excitation spectrum has a complex structure and consists of elementary triplets and composite many-particle singlet and triplet bound states. The composite excitations mix strongly with the elementary ones in the coupling regime where quantum fluctuations are strong. The quantum phase transition, known to take place in this model at critical frustration, is interpreted as a condensation process of (infinitely) large many-particle bound states.

arXiv:cond-mat/9808169•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Mar 1, 1999•65 citations

Finite-temperature dynamics of low-dimensional quantum systems with DMRG methods

Alexander C. Tiegel

This thesis is concerned with the numerical study of one-dimensional (1D) spin-1/2 quantum magnets and related method development. Its focus is on the calculation of dynamical spin correlation functions both at zero and finite temperature. This is motivated by the accessibility of dynamical quantities in experiments such as inelastic neutron scattering (INS) and electron spin resonance (ESR). The numerical methods used in this thesis are based on extensions of the density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG) and are formulated in the framework of matrix product states (MPS). While zero-temperature dynamical correlation functions are computed with existing MPS frequency-domain methods, an MPS frequency-domain approach for their calculation at finite temperature is developed in this thesis. The new method combines the Liouville-space formulation of the dynamics with a moment expansion of the dynamical correlation function. The majority of the results are obtained via MPS-based Chebyshev expansions. These numerical techniques are applied to two different model systems describing real materials. The first one is the material copper pyrimidine dinitrate (Cu-PM) which is modeled by a 1D spin-1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnet with Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interactions. The spin dynamics of this model is studied in an applied magnetic field and compared to ESR experiments. Zero-temperature calculations for momentum- and frequency-resolved dynamical quantities give direct access to the intensity of the elementary excitations and go beyond the low-energy description by the quantum sine-Gordon model. Thus, a deviation from the Lorentz invariant dispersion for the single-soliton resonance is found. The presence of the strongest boundary bound state previously predicted from a boundary sine-Gordon field theory is confirmed, while composite boundary-bulk excitations have too low intensities to be found in the numerical results. At finite temperature, there is a temperature-induced crossover of the soliton. Moreover, additional temperature effects such as interbreather transitions emerge, which is confirmed by accompanying ESR experiments on Cu-PM over a wide range of the applied field strength. The second system studied in this thesis is the compound BaCu$_2$V$_2$O$_8$. It is shown that the magnetic properties of this quasi-1D material can be described by a strongly alternating antiferromagnetic-ferromagnetic spin-1/2 Heisenberg chain. As found for other dimerized systems, the strong correlations in BaCu$_2$V$_2$O$_8$ persist even at elevated temperatures. Moreover, these correlations lead to an asymmetric lineshape broadening of the magnetic excitations at finite temperature. Upon raising the temperature, an increasingly asymmetric lineshape is observed in high-resolution INS experiments for BaCu$_2$V$_2$O$_8$. In this thesis, the lineshape is calculated by the MPS finite-temperature method developed as a part of this work. Comparing these results to the INS data and the lineshape obtained by a diagrammatic approach, excellent agreement is found over a broad temperature range. This demonstrates that coherent quantum behavior persists at elevated temperatures in BaCu$_2$V$_2$O$_8$ and that it can be predicted quantitatively.

•Jan 1, 2016•1 citation

Low-dimensional correlations under thermal fluctuations

Noam Kestin, Thierry Giamarchi

We study the correlation functions of quantum spin-$1/2$ two-leg ladders at finite temperature, under a magnetic field, in the gapless phase at various relevant temperatures $T\ensuremath{\ne}0$, momenta $q$, and frequencies $\ensuremath{\omega}$. We compute those quantities using the time-dependent density-matrix renormalization group (T-DMRG) in an optimal numerical scheme. We compare these correlations with the ones of dimerized quantum spin chains and simple spin chains, that we compute by a similar technique. We analyze the intermediate energy modes and show that the effect of temperature leads to the formation of an essentially dispersive mode corresponding to the propagation of a triplet mode in an incoherent background, with a dispersion quite different from the one occurring at very low temperatures. We compare the low-energy part of the spectrum with the predictions of the Tomonaga-Luttinger liquid field theory at finite temperature. We show that the field theory describes in a remarkably robust way the low-energy correlations for frequencies or temperatures up to the natural cutoff (the effective dispersion) of the system. We discuss how our results could be tested in, e.g., neutron-scattering experiments.

arXiv:1901.04339•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 13, 2019•3 citations

Finite-temperature dynamics and thermal intraband magnon scattering in Haldane spin-one chains

J. Becker, Thomas Köhler, Alexander C. Tiegel +3 more

The antiferromagnetic spin-one chain is considerably one of the most fundamental quantum many-body systems, with symmetry-protected topological order in the ground state. Here, we present results for its dynamical spin structure factor at finite temperatures, based on a combination of exact numerical diagonalization, matrix-product-state calculations, and quantum Monte Carlo simulations. Open finite chains exhibit a subgap band in the thermal spectral functions, indicative of localized edge states. Moreover, we observe the thermal activation of a distinct low-energy continuum contribution to the spin spectral function with an enhanced spectral weight at low momenta and its upper threshold. This emerging thermal spectral feature of the Haldane spin-one chain is shown to result from intraband magnon scattering due to the thermal population of the single-magnon branch, which features a large bandwidth-to-gap ratio. These findings are discussed with respect to possible future studies on spin-one chain compounds based on inelastic neutron scattering.

arXiv:1703.04652•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 3, 2017•24 citations
Low-dimensional quantum magnets at finite temperatures present a complex interplay of quantum and thermal fluctuation effects in a restricted phase space. While some information about dynamical response functions is available from theoretical studies of the one-triplet dispersion in unfrustrated chains and ladders, little is known about the finite-temperature dynamics of frustrated systems. Experimentally, inelastic neutron scattering studies of the highly frustrated two-dimensional material SrCu2(BO3)2{\mathrm{SrCu}}_{2}{({\mathrm{BO}}_{3})}_{2}SrCu2​(BO3​)2​ show an almost complete destruction of the one-triplet excitation band at a temperature only 1/3 of its gap energy, accompanied by strong scattering intensities for apparent multi-triplet excitations. We investigate these questions in the frustrated spin ladder and present numerical results from exact diagonalization for the dynamical structure factor as a function of temperature. We find anomalously rapid transfer of spectral weight out of the one-triplet band and into both broad and sharp spectral features at a wide range of energies, including below the zero-temperature gap of this excitation. These features are multi-triplet bound states, which develop particularly strongly near the quantum phase transition, fall to particularly low energies there, and persist all the way to infinite temperature. Our results offer valuable insight into the physics of finite-temperature spectral functions in SrCu2(BO3)2{\mathrm{SrCu}}_{2}{({\mathrm{BO}}_{3})}_{2}SrCu2​(BO3​)2​ and many other highly frustrated spin systems.
Quantum antiferromagnets have proven to be some of the cleanest realizations available for theoretical, numerical, and experimental studies of quantum fluctuation effects. At finite temperatures, however, the additional effects of thermal fluctuations in the restricted phase space of a low-dimensional system have received much less attention, particularly the situation in frustrated quantum magnets, where the excitations may be complex collective (bound or even fractionalized) modes. We investigate this problem by studying the thermodynamic properties of the frustrated two-leg S=12S=\frac{1}{2}S=21​ spin ladder, with particular emphasis on the fully frustrated case. We present numerical results for the magnetic specific heat and susceptibility, obtained from exact diagonalization and quantum Monte Carlo studies, which we show can be rendered free of the sign problem even in a strongly frustrated system and which allow us to reach unprecedented sizes of L=200L=200L=200 ladder rungs. We find that frustration effects cause an unconventional evolution of the thermodynamic response across the full parameter regime of the model. However, close to the first-order transition they cause a highly anomalous reduction in temperature scales with no concomitant changes in the gap; the specific heat shows a very narrow peak at very low energies and the susceptibility rises abruptly at extremely low temperatures. Unusually, the two quantities have different gaps over an extended region of the parameter space. We demonstrate that these results reflect the presence of large numbers of multiparticle bound-state excitations, whose energies fall below the one-triplon gap in the transition region.
Low dimensional quantum magnets which display a collective singlet ground state and a gap in their magnetic excitation spectrum provide a framework for much exotic phase behavior in new materials, with high temperature superconductivity being the best appreciated example. Neutron scattering techniques can be applied to study a wide variety of problems in condensed matter physics. These techniques are particularly useful as applied to understanding the magnetic properties of quantum magnets that display exotic phases. SrCu2(BO3)2, is a rare example of a two-dimensional quantum magnet for which an exact theoretical solution describing its ground state is known to be a collective singlet. Previous high resolution neutron scattering measurements identified the most prominent features of the spin excitation spectrum in SrCu2(BO3)2, including the presence of one and two triplet excitations and weak dispersion characteristic of subleading terms in the spin Hamiltonian. The resemblance between the spin gap behavior in the Mott insulator SrCu2(BO3)2 and that associated with high temperature superconductors motivated the consideration of the significance of doping in order to understand the properties of this quantum magnetic system. For this reason, a series of neutron scattering studies on doped SrCu2(BO3)2 were initiated. These series of investigations began with the performance of neutron scattering measurements on a SrCu(2-x)Mgx(BO3)2 single crystal in order to introduce magnetic vacancies to the system. These results revealed the presence of new spin excitations within the singlet-triplet gap of this system. Application of a magnetic field induces Zeeman-split states associated with un-paired spins which exist as a consequence of doping with quenched non-magnetic impurities. Additional substantial broadening of both the one and two triplet excitations is observed in the doped system as compared to the pure system. Theoretical calculations are shown to qualitatively account for these features. These studies were extended to neutron scattering measurements on Sr(1-x)LaxCu2(BO3)2, with an aim of introducing charged carriers into this system. The broadening of the one and two triplet excitations is observed and compared to the thermally induced finite lifetime of the pure system. The temperature dependence of this broadening in Sr(1-x)LaxCu2(BO3)2 is different compared to that observed in both SrCu2(BO3)2 and SrCu(2-x)Mgx(BO3)2. It has also been suggested that there is a relation between the spin-lattice interaction in SrCu2(BO3)2 and the magnetic dynamics at low temperatures and high magnetic fields. For this reason there has been increased interest in the study of the crystalline structure and vibrational modes of SrCu2(BO3)2. In order to investigate the role of the lattice in the formation of the singlet ground state in SrCu2(BO3)2, a series of low and high energy neutron scattering measurements were carried out on this system to study both the crystalline structure as well as the normal modes of vibration of the lattice, the transverse acoustic and optical phonons. Transverse acoustic phonons with energies comparable to and higher than the onset of the two triplet continuum show substantially increased lifetimes on entering the singlet ground state below ~ 10 K. This may indicate the removal of the decay channel for the phonons due to the gapping of the spin excitation spectrum in SrCu2(BO3)2 at low temperatures. In high energy inelastic neutron scattering we observe broadening of optic phonons in the ~ 52 to 65 meV region on entering the low temperature singlet ground state. Additionally, the magnetic properties of CuMoO4, which is a triclinic quantum magnet system based on S=1/2 moments at the Cu2+ site, were studied using elastic and inelastic neutron scattering experiments. This material exhibits a first order structural phase transition at ~ 190 K as well as a magnetic phase transition at ~ 1.75 K. We were primarily interested in the low temperature magnetic properties of this material. Magnetization and heat capacity measurements as well as elastic and inelastic neutron scattering measurements were conducted on this system within the low temperature ordered phase. These studies confirm that this material has a magnetic phase transition at ~ 1.7 K. Neutron scattering results indicate that this magnetically ordered phase is characterized by a doubling of the a axis. Inelastic neutron scattering measurements revealed a gapped magnetic excitation spectrum in zero magnetic field, which could be filled in by the application of magnetic fields approaching 7 T.
The excitation spectrum of the two-chain S=1/2S=1/2S=1/2 Heisenberg spin ladder with additional second neighbor frustrating interactions is studied by a variety of techniques. A description, based on a mapping of the model onto a Bose gas of hard-core triplets is used to determine the one- and two-particle excitation spectra. We find that low-lying singlet and triplet bound states are present and their binding energy increases with increasing frustration. In addition, many-particle bound states are found by exact diagonalization and variational methods. We prove that the larger the number of bound particles the larger the binding energy. Thus the excitation spectrum has a complex structure and consists of elementary triplets and composite many-particle singlet and triplet bound states. The composite excitations mix strongly with the elementary ones in the coupling regime where quantum fluctuations are strong. The quantum phase transition, known to take place in this model at critical frustration, is interpreted as a condensation process of (infinitely) large many-particle bound states.
This thesis is concerned with the numerical study of one-dimensional (1D) spin-1/2 quantum magnets and related method development. Its focus is on the calculation of dynamical spin correlation functions both at zero and finite temperature. This is motivated by the accessibility of dynamical quantities in experiments such as inelastic neutron scattering (INS) and electron spin resonance (ESR). The numerical methods used in this thesis are based on extensions of the density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG) and are formulated in the framework of matrix product states (MPS). While zero-temperature dynamical correlation functions are computed with existing MPS frequency-domain methods, an MPS frequency-domain approach for their calculation at finite temperature is developed in this thesis. The new method combines the Liouville-space formulation of the dynamics with a moment expansion of the dynamical correlation function. The majority of the results are obtained via MPS-based Chebyshev expansions. These numerical techniques are applied to two different model systems describing real materials. The first one is the material copper pyrimidine dinitrate (Cu-PM) which is modeled by a 1D spin-1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnet with Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interactions. The spin dynamics of this model is studied in an applied magnetic field and compared to ESR experiments. Zero-temperature calculations for momentum- and frequency-resolved dynamical quantities give direct access to the intensity of the elementary excitations and go beyond the low-energy description by the quantum sine-Gordon model. Thus, a deviation from the Lorentz invariant dispersion for the single-soliton resonance is found. The presence of the strongest boundary bound state previously predicted from a boundary sine-Gordon field theory is confirmed, while composite boundary-bulk excitations have too low intensities to be found in the numerical results. At finite temperature, there is a temperature-induced crossover of the soliton. Moreover, additional temperature effects such as interbreather transitions emerge, which is confirmed by accompanying ESR experiments on Cu-PM over a wide range of the applied field strength. The second system studied in this thesis is the compound BaCu2_22​V2_22​O8_88​. It is shown that the magnetic properties of this quasi-1D material can be described by a strongly alternating antiferromagnetic-ferromagnetic spin-1/2 Heisenberg chain. As found for other dimerized systems, the strong correlations in BaCu2_22​V2_22​O8_88​ persist even at elevated temperatures. Moreover, these correlations lead to an asymmetric lineshape broadening of the magnetic excitations at finite temperature. Upon raising the temperature, an increasingly asymmetric lineshape is observed in high-resolution INS experiments for BaCu2_22​V2_22​O8_88​. In this thesis, the lineshape is calculated by the MPS finite-temperature method developed as a part of this work. Comparing these results to the INS data and the lineshape obtained by a diagrammatic approach, excellent agreement is found over a broad temperature range. This demonstrates that coherent quantum behavior persists at elevated temperatures in BaCu2_22​V2_22​O8_88​ and that it can be predicted quantitatively.
We study the correlation functions of quantum spin-1/21/21/2 two-leg ladders at finite temperature, under a magnetic field, in the gapless phase at various relevant temperatures $T\ensuremath{\ne}0$, momenta qqq, and frequencies $\ensuremath{\omega}$. We compute those quantities using the time-dependent density-matrix renormalization group (T-DMRG) in an optimal numerical scheme. We compare these correlations with the ones of dimerized quantum spin chains and simple spin chains, that we compute by a similar technique. We analyze the intermediate energy modes and show that the effect of temperature leads to the formation of an essentially dispersive mode corresponding to the propagation of a triplet mode in an incoherent background, with a dispersion quite different from the one occurring at very low temperatures. We compare the low-energy part of the spectrum with the predictions of the Tomonaga-Luttinger liquid field theory at finite temperature. We show that the field theory describes in a remarkably robust way the low-energy correlations for frequencies or temperatures up to the natural cutoff (the effective dispersion) of the system. We discuss how our results could be tested in, e.g., neutron-scattering experiments.
The antiferromagnetic spin-one chain is considerably one of the most fundamental quantum many-body systems, with symmetry-protected topological order in the ground state. Here, we present results for its dynamical spin structure factor at finite temperatures, based on a combination of exact numerical diagonalization, matrix-product-state calculations, and quantum Monte Carlo simulations. Open finite chains exhibit a subgap band in the thermal spectral functions, indicative of localized edge states. Moreover, we observe the thermal activation of a distinct low-energy continuum contribution to the spin spectral function with an enhanced spectral weight at low momenta and its upper threshold. This emerging thermal spectral feature of the Haldane spin-one chain is shown to result from intraband magnon scattering due to the thermal population of the single-magnon branch, which features a large bandwidth-to-gap ratio. These findings are discussed with respect to possible future studies on spin-one chain compounds based on inelastic neutron scattering.