Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1508.00466 · Physical Review A

Discriminating the effects of collapse models from environmental diffusion with levitated nanospheres

Jie Li, Stefano Zippilli, Jing Zhang, David Vitali

Published May 13, 2016• 61 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Collapse models postulate the existence of intrinsic noise which modifies quantum mechanics and is responsible for the emergence of macroscopic classicality. Assessing the validity of these models is extremely challenging because it is nontrivial to discriminate unambiguously their presence in experiments where other hardly controllable sources of noise compete to the overall decoherence. Here we provide a simple procedure that is able to probe the hypothetical presence of the collapse noise with a levitated nanosphere in a Fabry-P\'erot cavity. We show that the stationary state of the system is particularly sensitive, under specific experimental conditions, to the interplay between the trapping frequency, the cavity size, and the momentum diffusion induced by the collapse models, allowing one to detect them even in the presence of standard environmental noises.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.93.050102

Related papers

Probing spontaneous wave-function collapse with entangled levitating nanospheres

Jing Zhang, Tiancai Zhang, Jie Li

Wave-function collapse models are considered to be the modified theories of standard quantum mechanics at the macroscopic level. By introducing nonlinear stochastic terms in the Schr\"odinger equation, these models (different from standard quantum mechanics) predict that it is fundamentally impossible to prepare macroscopic systems in macroscopic superpositions. The validity of these models can only be examined by experiments, and hence efficient protocols for these kinds of experiments are greatly needed. Here we provide a protocol that is able to probe the postulated collapse effect by means of the entanglement of the center-of-mass motion of two nanospheres optically trapped in a Fabry-P\'erot cavity. We show that the collapse noise results in a large reduction of the steady-state entanglement, and the entanglement, with and without the collapse effect, shows distinguishable scalings with certain system parameters, which can be used to determine unambiguously the effect of these models.

arXiv:1611.09989•Physical Review A•Jan 30, 2017•22 citations

Experimental Blueprint for Distinguishing Decoherence from Objective Collapse

Ridha Horchani

The transition from the quantum to the classical realm remains one of the most profound open questions in physics. While quantum theory predicts the existence of macroscopic superpositions, their apparent absence in the everyday world is attributed either to environmental decoherence or to an intrinsic mechanism for wave-function collapse. This work presents a quantitative and experimentally grounded framework for distinguishing these possibilities. We propose a levitated optomechanical platform capable of generating controllable Schrodinger-cat states in the center of mass motion of a dielectric nanosphere. A comprehensive master equation incorporates gas collisions, black-body radiation, and photon-recoil noise, establishing a calibrated environmental baseline. The Continuous Spontaneous Localization (CSL) model is embedded within the same framework, predicting a characteristic saturation of the decoherence rate with superposition size and a quadratic scaling with mass. A Bayesian inference protocol is outlined to discriminate collapse induced excess decoherence from environmental noise. Together these elements provide a concrete experimental blueprint for a decisive test of quantum linearity, either revealing new physics beyond standard quantum mechanics or setting the most stringent bounds to date on objective-collapse parameters.

quant-pharXiv:2512.02838•Dec 3, 2025•0 citations

Proposing new experiments to test the quantum-to-classical transition

M Bahrami, Angelo Bassi

An open problem in modern physics is why microscopic quantum objects can be at two places at once (i.e. a superposed quantum state) while macroscpoic classical object never show such a behaviour. Collapse models provides a quantitative answer for this problem and explain how macroscopic classical world emerges out of microscopic quantum world. A universal noise field is postulated in collapse models, inducing appropriate Brownian- motion corrections to standard quantum dynamics. The strength of collapse-driven Brownian fluctuations depend on: (i) the parameters characterizing the system (e.g., mass, size, density), and (ii) two phenomenological parameters defining the statistical properties of the collapse noise. The collapse-driven Brownian motion works such that microscopic systems behave quantum mechanically, while macroscopic objects are classical. At the intermediate mesocopic scale, collapse models predict deviations from standard quantum predictions. This issue has been subject of experimental tests. All experiments to date have been at the scales where collapse effects are negligible for all practical purposes. However, recent experimental progress in revealing quantum features of larger objects, increases the hope for testing at unprecedented scales where collapse models can be falsified. Current experiments are mainly focused on the preparation of macroscopic systems in a spatial quantum superposition state. The collapse effects would then manifest as loss of visibility in the observed inference pattern. However, one needs a quantum interference with single particles of mass ∼ 10 10 amu for a decisive test of collapse models. Creating such massive superpositionsis quite challenging, and beyond currectstate-of-the-art. Quite recently, an alternative approach has been proposed where the collapse manifests in the fluctuating properties of light interacting with the quantum system. The great advantage of this new approach is that here there is no need for the preparation of a quantum superposed state. It has been discussed that promising results can be revealed in the spectrum of light interacting with a radiation pressure-driven mechanical oscillator in a cavity optomechanics setting. Here, we review the theoretical modelling of the above optomechenical proposal. We discuss how collapse-driven Brownian motion modifies the spectrum. We quantify the collapse effect and explain how it depends on the parameters of the mechanical oscillator (e.g., mass, density, geometry).

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jul 3, 2015•2 citations

Philosophical, theoretical and experimental propositions on wavefunction collapse

Goldwater, Daniel

Collapse models are posited as a resolution to the measurement problem. On one level, they offer a clear, simple and testable resolution to an age-old problem. Yet at the same time, they raise many new questions of their own - what is the origin of the putative noise field? What are its properties, and why ought it couple to wavefunctions in this particular way, inducing collapse in some analogue of the position basis? How might these models be extended to the realm of relativity without incurring catastrophe? What sort of image of the world do they deliver? In this thesis we begin with a philosophical exploration of collapse theories. We examine, in detail, the relationship between stochastic noise fields and the evolution of the wavefunction - shedding light both on the solutions offered by collapse models and the new issues which they raise. We discuss the possibilities for constructing an ontology based on these theories, and look at possible implications for the arrow of time and the meaning of causation. This in turn motivates the development of protocols for experiments which might be capable of probing these models; to new degrees in some senses, and in new forms in others. We develop a comprehensive theoretical model of a levitated nanosphere held in an electric quadrupole trap, and find the limits to which this can probe the characteristic collapse rate $\lambda$ and correlation length $r$ of collapse models. Further, we develop a novel treatment of this scenario in the style of open quantum systems, and show that such an apparatus can constitute a general quantum spectrometer, capable of characterising arbitrary correlation functions for a noise source coupled to the oscillator - whether that noise be invoked by collapse models or other, more mundane sources. Finally, we utilise numerical simulations of trap dynamics to demonstrate the capabilities of electronic feedback cooling - showing that quantum states ought to be achievable without the use of optics. This work is motivated by a desire to understand the world, and specifically to address some of the paradoxes which arise when we try to use quantum mechanics to do so. We have aimed to follow what we see as best practice in physics - from a motivation within philosophy, to the development of theory capable of meeting that philosophy, to the design of experiments which would be able to speak to the relationship between that theory and the world.

•Sep 1, 2018•0 citations

Optomechanical Sensing of Spontaneous Wave-Function Collapse

Stefan Nimmrichter, Klaus Hornberger, Klemens Hammerer

Quantum experiments with nanomechanical oscillators are regarded as a test bed for hypothetical modifications of the Schrödinger equation, which predict a breakdown of the superposition principle and induce classical behavior at the macroscale. It is generally believed that the sensitivity to these unconventional effects grows with the mass of the mechanical quantum system. Here we show that the opposite is the case for optomechanical systems in the presence of generic noise sources, such as thermal and measurement noise. We determine conditions for distinguishing these decoherence processes from possible collapse-induced decoherence in continuous optomechanical force measurements.

arXiv:1405.2868•Physical Review Letters•Jul 10, 2014•131 citations

Investigating the foundations of quantum physics with optomechanical setups

Marta Maria Marchese

The extraordinary success of quantum mechanics and its formalism has been established thanks to countless experiments with microscopic systems. Nevertheless, it is still not clear whether and when the quantum world ends, allowing for the emergence of classical phenomena. The extension of quantum properties to macroscopic system gives rise to paradoxes, as the well-known Schrödinger’s cat example. Among the alternatives to quantum mechanics, collapse models propose an objective modification of standard quantum theory to restore macrorealism at large scale. They predict a loss of coherence when scaling towards macroscopic systems, due to a spontaneous collapse mechanism included into the dynamics through non-linear stochastic modifications of the Schrödinger equation. Assessing and characterizing these models is a noteworthy endeavour in the exploration of the quantum-to-classical transition. The overarching goal of this Thesis is to address some of these fundamental issues, by exploring the concept of macrorealism and probing collapse models, making use of optomechanical setups. To answer the question whether a system has a quantum or classical dynamics, we will propose a theoretical test of Leggett-Garg inequalities, as tool to probe the macrorealism of an optomechanical system. We will investigate collapse models through the study of the dynamics of an optomechanical cavity, looking for signatures in the noise spectrum. Further, we will use the hypothesis testing framework and quantum metrology tools to distinguish dynamical channels encoding the presence or the lack of the collapse. Our findings show a violation of Leggett-Garg inequalities, suggesting that the demarcation line of the quantum domain can be pushed further to include larger systems. Our approaches for testing collapse models provide novel methodologies to better discriminate these effects and the results represent another step forward in the attempt of gaining a better understanding of the foundations of physics.

•Oct 1, 2026•0 citations
Collapse models postulate the existence of intrinsic noise which modifies quantum mechanics and is responsible for the emergence of macroscopic classicality. Assessing the validity of these models is extremely challenging because it is nontrivial to discriminate unambiguously their presence in experiments where other hardly controllable sources of noise compete to the overall decoherence. Here we provide a simple procedure that is able to probe the hypothetical presence of the collapse noise with a levitated nanosphere in a Fabry-P'erot cavity. We show that the stationary state of the system is particularly sensitive, under specific experimental conditions, to the interplay between the trapping frequency, the cavity size, and the momentum diffusion induced by the collapse models, allowing one to detect them even in the presence of standard environmental noises.
Wave-function collapse models are considered to be the modified theories of standard quantum mechanics at the macroscopic level. By introducing nonlinear stochastic terms in the Schr\"odinger equation, these models (different from standard quantum mechanics) predict that it is fundamentally impossible to prepare macroscopic systems in macroscopic superpositions. The validity of these models can only be examined by experiments, and hence efficient protocols for these kinds of experiments are greatly needed. Here we provide a protocol that is able to probe the postulated collapse effect by means of the entanglement of the center-of-mass motion of two nanospheres optically trapped in a Fabry-P\'erot cavity. We show that the collapse noise results in a large reduction of the steady-state entanglement, and the entanglement, with and without the collapse effect, shows distinguishable scalings with certain system parameters, which can be used to determine unambiguously the effect of these models.
The transition from the quantum to the classical realm remains one of the most profound open questions in physics. While quantum theory predicts the existence of macroscopic superpositions, their apparent absence in the everyday world is attributed either to environmental decoherence or to an intrinsic mechanism for wave-function collapse. This work presents a quantitative and experimentally grounded framework for distinguishing these possibilities. We propose a levitated optomechanical platform capable of generating controllable Schrodinger-cat states in the center of mass motion of a dielectric nanosphere. A comprehensive master equation incorporates gas collisions, black-body radiation, and photon-recoil noise, establishing a calibrated environmental baseline. The Continuous Spontaneous Localization (CSL) model is embedded within the same framework, predicting a characteristic saturation of the decoherence rate with superposition size and a quadratic scaling with mass. A Bayesian inference protocol is outlined to discriminate collapse induced excess decoherence from environmental noise. Together these elements provide a concrete experimental blueprint for a decisive test of quantum linearity, either revealing new physics beyond standard quantum mechanics or setting the most stringent bounds to date on objective-collapse parameters.
An open problem in modern physics is why microscopic quantum objects can be at two places at once (i.e. a superposed quantum state) while macroscpoic classical object never show such a behaviour. Collapse models provides a quantitative answer for this problem and explain how macroscopic classical world emerges out of microscopic quantum world. A universal noise field is postulated in collapse models, inducing appropriate Brownian- motion corrections to standard quantum dynamics. The strength of collapse-driven Brownian fluctuations depend on: (i) the parameters characterizing the system (e.g., mass, size, density), and (ii) two phenomenological parameters defining the statistical properties of the collapse noise. The collapse-driven Brownian motion works such that microscopic systems behave quantum mechanically, while macroscopic objects are classical. At the intermediate mesocopic scale, collapse models predict deviations from standard quantum predictions. This issue has been subject of experimental tests. All experiments to date have been at the scales where collapse effects are negligible for all practical purposes. However, recent experimental progress in revealing quantum features of larger objects, increases the hope for testing at unprecedented scales where collapse models can be falsified. Current experiments are mainly focused on the preparation of macroscopic systems in a spatial quantum superposition state. The collapse effects would then manifest as loss of visibility in the observed inference pattern. However, one needs a quantum interference with single particles of mass ∼ 10 10 amu for a decisive test of collapse models. Creating such massive superpositionsis quite challenging, and beyond currectstate-of-the-art. Quite recently, an alternative approach has been proposed where the collapse manifests in the fluctuating properties of light interacting with the quantum system. The great advantage of this new approach is that here there is no need for the preparation of a quantum superposed state. It has been discussed that promising results can be revealed in the spectrum of light interacting with a radiation pressure-driven mechanical oscillator in a cavity optomechanics setting. Here, we review the theoretical modelling of the above optomechenical proposal. We discuss how collapse-driven Brownian motion modifies the spectrum. We quantify the collapse effect and explain how it depends on the parameters of the mechanical oscillator (e.g., mass, density, geometry).
Collapse models are posited as a resolution to the measurement problem. On one level, they offer a clear, simple and testable resolution to an age-old problem. Yet at the same time, they raise many new questions of their own - what is the origin of the putative noise field? What are its properties, and why ought it couple to wavefunctions in this particular way, inducing collapse in some analogue of the position basis? How might these models be extended to the realm of relativity without incurring catastrophe? What sort of image of the world do they deliver? In this thesis we begin with a philosophical exploration of collapse theories. We examine, in detail, the relationship between stochastic noise fields and the evolution of the wavefunction - shedding light both on the solutions offered by collapse models and the new issues which they raise. We discuss the possibilities for constructing an ontology based on these theories, and look at possible implications for the arrow of time and the meaning of causation. This in turn motivates the development of protocols for experiments which might be capable of probing these models; to new degrees in some senses, and in new forms in others. We develop a comprehensive theoretical model of a levitated nanosphere held in an electric quadrupole trap, and find the limits to which this can probe the characteristic collapse rate λ\lambdaλ and correlation length rrr of collapse models. Further, we develop a novel treatment of this scenario in the style of open quantum systems, and show that such an apparatus can constitute a general quantum spectrometer, capable of characterising arbitrary correlation functions for a noise source coupled to the oscillator - whether that noise be invoked by collapse models or other, more mundane sources. Finally, we utilise numerical simulations of trap dynamics to demonstrate the capabilities of electronic feedback cooling - showing that quantum states ought to be achievable without the use of optics. This work is motivated by a desire to understand the world, and specifically to address some of the paradoxes which arise when we try to use quantum mechanics to do so. We have aimed to follow what we see as best practice in physics - from a motivation within philosophy, to the development of theory capable of meeting that philosophy, to the design of experiments which would be able to speak to the relationship between that theory and the world.
Quantum experiments with nanomechanical oscillators are regarded as a test bed for hypothetical modifications of the Schrödinger equation, which predict a breakdown of the superposition principle and induce classical behavior at the macroscale. It is generally believed that the sensitivity to these unconventional effects grows with the mass of the mechanical quantum system. Here we show that the opposite is the case for optomechanical systems in the presence of generic noise sources, such as thermal and measurement noise. We determine conditions for distinguishing these decoherence processes from possible collapse-induced decoherence in continuous optomechanical force measurements.
The extraordinary success of quantum mechanics and its formalism has been established thanks to countless experiments with microscopic systems. Nevertheless, it is still not clear whether and when the quantum world ends, allowing for the emergence of classical phenomena. The extension of quantum properties to macroscopic system gives rise to paradoxes, as the well-known Schrödinger’s cat example. Among the alternatives to quantum mechanics, collapse models propose an objective modification of standard quantum theory to restore macrorealism at large scale. They predict a loss of coherence when scaling towards macroscopic systems, due to a spontaneous collapse mechanism included into the dynamics through non-linear stochastic modifications of the Schrödinger equation. Assessing and characterizing these models is a noteworthy endeavour in the exploration of the quantum-to-classical transition. The overarching goal of this Thesis is to address some of these fundamental issues, by exploring the concept of macrorealism and probing collapse models, making use of optomechanical setups. To answer the question whether a system has a quantum or classical dynamics, we will propose a theoretical test of Leggett-Garg inequalities, as tool to probe the macrorealism of an optomechanical system. We will investigate collapse models through the study of the dynamics of an optomechanical cavity, looking for signatures in the noise spectrum. Further, we will use the hypothesis testing framework and quantum metrology tools to distinguish dynamical channels encoding the presence or the lack of the collapse. Our findings show a violation of Leggett-Garg inequalities, suggesting that the demarcation line of the quantum domain can be pushed further to include larger systems. Our approaches for testing collapse models provide novel methodologies to better discriminate these effects and the results represent another step forward in the attempt of gaining a better understanding of the foundations of physics.