arXiv:1506.07308 · Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields
Local-oscillator noise coupling in balanced homodyne readout for advanced gravitational wave detectors
S. Steinlechner, B. Barr, A. S. Bell, S. L. Danilishin, A. Glaefke, Christian A. Graf, J. Hennig, E. Alasdair Houston, Sabina H. Huttner, S. Leavey, D. Pascucci, B. Sorazu, A. P. Spencer, K. A. Strain, Jennifer L. Wright, S. Hild
The second generation of interferometric gravitational wave detectors are quickly approaching their design sensitivity. For the first time these detectors will become limited by quantum backaction noise. Several backaction evasion techniques have been proposed to further increase the detector sensitivity. Since most proposals rely on a flexible readout of the full amplitude- and phase-quadrature space of the output light field, balanced homodyne detection is generally expected to replace the currently used DC readout. Up to now, little investigation has been undertaken into how balanced homodyne detection can be successfully transferred from its ubiquitous application in tabletop quantum optics experiments to large-scale interferometers with suspended optics. Here we derive implementation requirements with respect to local-oscillator noise couplings and highlight potential issues with the example of the Glasgow Sagnac Speed Meter experiment, as well as for a future upgrade to the Advanced LIGO detectors.
The second generation of interferometric gravitational wave detectors are quickly approaching their design sensitivity. For the first time these detectors will become limited by quantum backaction noise. Several backaction evasion techniques have been proposed to further increase the detector sensitivity. Since most proposals rely on a flexible readout of the full amplitude- and phase-quadrature space of the output light field, balanced homodyne detection is generally expected to replace the currently used DC readout. Up to now, little investigation has been undertaken into how balanced homodyne detection can be successfully transferred from its ubiquitous application in tabletop quantum optics experiments to large-scale interferometers with suspended optics. Here we derive implementation requirements with respect to local-oscillator noise couplings and highlight potential issues with the example of the Glasgow Sagnac Speed Meter experiment, as well as for a future upgrade to the Advanced LIGO detectors.
In the context of the readout scheme for gravitational-wave detectors, the "double balanced homodyne detection" proposed in [K.~Nakamura and M.-K.~Fujimoto, arXiv:1709.01697.] is discussed in detail. This double balanced homodyne detection enables us to measure the expectation values of the photon creation and annihilation operators. Although it has been said that the operator b^θ:=cosθb^1+sinθb^2 can be measured through the homodyne detection in literature, we first show that the expectation value of the operator b^θ cannot be measured as the linear combination of the upper- and lower-sidebands from the output of the balanced homodyne detection. Here, the operators b^1 and b^2 are the amplitude and phase quadrature in the two-photon formulation, respectively. On the other hand, it is shown that the above double balanced homodyne detection enables us to measure the expectation value of the operator b^θ if we can appropriately prepare the complex amplitude of the coherent state from the local oscillator. It is also shown that the interferometer set up of the eight-port homodyne detection realizes our idea of the double balanced homodyne detection. We also evaluate the noise-spectral density of the gravitational-wave detectors when our double balanced homodyne detection is applied as their readout scheme. Some requirements for the coherent state from the local oscillator to realize the double balanced homodyne detection are also discussed.
Future generations of gravitational-wave detectors (GWD) are targeting an effective quantum noise reduction of 10 dB via the application of squeezed states of light. In the last joint observation run O3, the advanced large-scale GWDs LIGO and Virgo already used the squeezing technology, albeit with a moderate efficiency. Here, we report on the first successful 10 dB sensitivity enhancement of a shot-noise limited tabletop Michelson interferometer via squeezed light in the fundamental Gaussian laser mode, where we also implement the balanced homodyne detection scheme that is planned for the third GWD generation. In addition, we achieved a similarly strong quantum noise reduction when the interferometer was operated in higher-order Hermite-Gaussian modes, which are discussed for the GWD thermal noise mitigation. Our results are an important step toward the targeted quantum noise level in future GWDs and, moreover, represent significant progress in the application of nonclassical states in higher-order modes for interferometry, increased spatial resolution, and multichannel sensing.
Future interferometric gravitational wave detectors will make use of the coupling between shot noise and radiation pressure noise that produces a squeezed output for the quantum noise at the dark-port of the interferometer allowing these interferometers to operate with a sensitivity that exceeds the standard quantum limit at certain frequencies. The ability of the detector to take advantage of this squeezed output state depends in part on the readout system used. With the phase modulated laser input planned for these interferometers the quantum-noise limited sensitivity is slightly better when homodyne (rather than heterodyne) detection is used. We show that by modifying the laser input spectrum for these interferometers, readout with heterodyne detection can be made to have the same quantum-noise limited sensitivity as readout with homodyne detection.
Gravitational waves manifest as a time varying straining of space: they arise from the accelerating motions of large bodies of mass and propagate across the universe at the speed of light as ripples in the fabric of space-time, a fleetingly weak effect so far eluding direct detection. The detection of gravitation waves is expected to yield a rich vein to observational astronomy, complementing existing electromagnetic surveys and revealing a hitherto unexplored range of phenomena. First generation interferometric gravitational wave detectors, notably Enhanced LIGO, achieved strain sensitivities of one part in ten to power twenty-one per square-root-Hertz at 100 Hz with an expected detection rate of 2-3 events per year. Commissioning of a new generation of Advanced LIGO interferometric detectors has concluded recently with a resultant ten-fold sensitivity improvement. Overall their potential event detection space has increased by a factor of 1000. The quantum nature of light within these detectors now limits their sensitivity over most of their frequency range. This quantum noise limit is driven by the vacuum quadrature fluctuations propagated through their open detection ports and represents a fundamental noise floor to their strain sensitivity. This thesis addresses two distinct approaches to quantum noise improvement for future upgrades to advanced detectors. The first addresses the issue of quantum noise by adopting a quantum non-demolition approach to detector readout variables, the so-called `speed-meter’ design. Such a modified instrument samples test mass momentum, a quantity for which time separated measurements commute and are therefore not bound by Heisenberg-like limits. A novel polarisation-folded sloshing cavity type speed-meter is proposed where readout fields are stored and delayed in the orthogonal polarisation of the interferometer’s arms cavities. Here frequency dependence is selected to cancel position like measurements so that only test mass momentum information remains. A quantum noise propagation model is developed and a sensitivity performance is demonstrated that beats the standard quantum limit below 100 Hz over a broad range of frequencies. A second approach to achieve quantum noise enhancement in advanced detectors involves injection of quadrature-squeezed states in the place of vacuum. This dissertation details the development of a prototype squeezed vacuum source suitable to the demanding enhancement requirements for an Advanced LIGO squeezing installation. The construction of a doubly resonant, bow-tie cavity source is presented. This employs a novel monolithic all-glass cavity construction and is vacuum compatible. This design demonstrates the viability of building a cavity using optical contacting as a construction technique for attaching mounting prisms to highly polished fused-silica breadboards. Such a design can be expected to have excellent length noise stability, provide low intrinsic phase noise and would be suitable to mount on seismic isolation stages within the LIGO vacuum envelope. Further, the travelling wave cavity design should provide excellent 50 dB intrinsic backscatter isolation. We demonstrate the first operation of such a complex non-linear device under vacuum, producing 8.6 dB of measured vacuum squeezing down to 10 Hz across the advanced LIGO ‘audio-band’ detection range.
Balanced Homodyne Detection (BHD), introduced in the 1970s, enables highly sensitive detection of phase and amplitude variations in weak light. Initially developed as an advanced optical detection technique, it rapidly became essential in quantum optics for accurately quantifying quadrature components and detecting squeezed states at the shot-noise limit. Today, BHD plays a critical role in diverse fields such as high-precision quantum metrology, gigabit speed optical communications, gravitational wave detection, and large-scale quantum information systems. In this study, a BHD simulation was implemented with a 90 phase difference between the local oscillator and the signal, thus enabling the extraction of the phase quadratureP^component of the optical field.
Quantum noise is one of the limiting factors in laser-interferometric gravitational-wave (GW) detectors. The application of squeezed states in these interferometers allows the reduction of quantum noise in one quadrature. Due to opto-mechanical coupling in a GW detector the squeezed quadrature needs to be rotated within the spectrum to achieve a broadband noise reduction. So far, the implementation of additional filter cavities is considered that allow for the optimal, frequency-dependent rotation of the squeezed quadrature. However, these cavities need to have low loss, a length in the order of \unit[100]{m} and must be situated in the vacuum system, making them cost-intensive. In 2017, Ma and coworkers proposed a scheme for the broadband quantum-noise reduction without the need of additional filter cavities. It was shown by Brown et al. that a similar scheme can be used to broadband-enhance interferometers with a detuned signal-recycling cavity. Here, we performed a proof-of-principle experiment of the proposal on a table-top-scale. Squeezed states were produced detuned to the carrier field of a \unit[2.5]{m}-linear cavity and read out in a bichromatic homodyne detection. The frequencies of the lower and upper local oscillator were at entangled sidebands of the squeezed field. Depending on the relations between the involved frequencies, we can address both variants of the proposal. We show, that the frequency-dependences of the resulting noise spectra fit to a theoretical model we derived from the theory used by Ma et al. With this work we set the path towards an implementation of these schemes in a GW-detector prototype, where the compatibility of the approach with a low-frequency suspended interferometer can be tested. Moreover, we used the same setup to show nonclassical interferometer enhancement at low frequencies by high-frequency squeezed states. Here, a heterodyne readout scheme was implemented to avoid limiting noises at low frequencies. The application of squeezed states centered around the local oscillator frequency yielded an improvement in signal-to-noise ratio of $\unit[3.4]{dB}\pm\unit[0.3]{dB}$. Additionally, I designed, built and characterized a compact source of squeezed vacuum-states at \unit[1064]{nm} with a footprint of just $\unit[0.8]{m^2}$. I show measurements of squeezed states from this source with a reduction of quantum noise of $\unit[10.7]{dB}\pm\unit[0.2]{dB}$ below the vacuum noise and present a noise reduction in the frequency range from \unit[70]{kHz} to \unit[65]{MHz}.